High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/23771/2022disposed of

M/S Thind Brothers Rice Mills v. Fci And ORS.

2022-10-31Ms. Justice Jaishree Thakur12 pages

!" # " !"! $

!" # " #

# %

!" # " !&'(&)*+,-$.-#!,$'#-(,,('/.

'2 3 0 34-

51'2 0 -

51'2 - %/1'2 "

!6 )77 % 1'2 "

!6 )898 ! 1-'2 3 / 3

1'2 2 4051'2 "

!6 ):: //0"1'2 !# -;< -

5'41''01

;< $ %

& '(

)) '( !"!

) '(#

# '""

3 '

4 *'(*+,+ "

3 "

< " )>4 "

!6 )77 3 % !#1

" 3 "

5 !6 ) 771 898 ::

22 <

5 % % !6 )77

3 " < '

?7 !

5 %"5 8 7

<A " )?3

-"" !

%% % "A

5/ 4

5- 13 @ '

;/ "< %%

% : " %

" < 55

5"A ""A

!#53

" A 1 < #""

;< !

A / <

'% !%%

" % 5 A " (321 "

!%% " % " % 5 A1

< "% "A %

5 ""

<A !# !%% > ! 0/

2 % 1'2 ""

5 " 3 <% " % "" % "A13 !# 3

4" 53

34 13

3 + " % 3 4 " +

$A 1 3

% "

A #

<% " % 3

%<+<" 1AA

6 4

1 !#

!%%

5% "A A" + #

4" A

5 3 2 B2 B %

1 3 2""A +3 " "%

"% "

<% " 2A" +13 < !#

"A ? +

2 3 <% % 4 A<

<A" %

!# A

" 1

% 3 "

A13

33% +

: " % +

" 1A3< % 3

53 !# 7 +

5 !#3 <%

2 <3 "

!# 3< 2 % A 3 #

<% " 2 < < <

< 0CD A! E1 5 &

1! 5C< 3%" " % "" " E + < " #

% % "

3 " 3

% 2 <

3 % 3

!#3

!! 5 <

33 A <5

" A

5 + -% < 53 3 F

!"#!$"$$

%!"#!$"$$ &!'()%*'()$%*'

()%"*$+()")!,-

/ 0 !, 1"

2)"#" /3 !"#!$"$$

%) 2%)'$ /3

%!"#!$"$$- /- !4#

5 % 3

43 -5 +

!#3 A " < 2 < % "5? A"

" 2 % ,0-&' + " #

!#3

<% +3 2" 5

> <

% 1 1 " % "A 9 +

5 < " - 3 <% % <A

'% !%%

% '

= "A

! A 8 &

5< 1

% 1

5 " % 1 321

5 " !# 3 A " ! 7 C=

E 3

5 ,2 ! 1 !

A / ! 7C=

E G- --

5 65

7 8 29.03

: 5

: ; - 5 23-

!H# %

+3 " 3

%1" '

1 ! 0/

2 3 "

A " "

5 5

!# 3

5 "

1 3

3 2 2" % <

A3 "

-5 + 3 " ""2 #

<% " A" 1 32 < 9

!! 5 53 "

5 9 :9

2 <1 1 A

3 % <

5 %

? 2 << A

% "

22 #

<% '

51 6 5 5 &" <5 3 2 % %

< @ A

-5 +#

<% 3

5 A ""

< A 3

5 "

" ;

1 "

% "A %

5 4

5 "A 1 %

% "

A 3 @

5 < " " ;5% <A ( I< -"% !

!"## ;5% <A

! ( 5!

$% &

(

")* +, *# < " " ;5% <A$4 ( 5!

( $ $- (

")*+"", +,..! % " A 3 " 2 A

< % 5

! 5 5"

" 4 "

<A0CD!E15 &

1 ! 53<A A 5

5 ""

7 % "2+3 " 1 %

% "" <

! 3 < 3 3 "

"A % 3 "

<A !# @

5 5

% %% % "A

5/-

J'% A1

!# 4

%" 1 3 3 + "

3 4 <A !# " %

<A "

A 4 " +'

" A" " <A !#1

5 4" 3

3 + < " < %< -5 +3 " ""2 !#

5 +

3 ""21

3@ 3 "

2 3 !#

% A" 32 3

3 "

3 A 5 3<"

A< 3 " % <A

2A ! 2

A 0 CD!E1 5 &

1 ! 5 5

22% A" +13

0CD!E 3 "

<A!4"

A " C3

% % 3 A

9 % 3 < +<A!#E% % 3 3

% < % < " #

< 45 1

! 3 % " "" " 2

% 2

< <

A : ! 7CEC

E !

A / "2 % <

% 623 - < - -

: - ""=

* - - / 5 5 23

: -

- - / 5* - : -

!8 > (321

5 ! 7CEC2

E ! / 3 % <

%<BB%

A " % 5 A

' ! <

< 4

<A "% !#

"% % 5 A 53

2 AC E

1 %A<

% 3 ";

% %

# < "

13 "2

)&! %

8 " % 5

# "

!1 ! 7 CE C2

1 3

3 "% % "

% @ 2 % 5 53

<" "

3<%"

5 A "

% #

1" %

A " !# @ 3 %"A 1 " 2 < 2 3

A %

5 A %

1 2 5 0 CD!E1 5 &

1! 5 A"

5 ""

% ? '

" - 3

<% 3

" 5

% %

5 /- % #

% ! 4 1 %A ""

2 < ! :CE1C<E C E 7 #

! 3 "" % ;5% <A( I<-"%!

"E3 % " %" A 3 %

< < 4

" A <

< 4

3 2 " %" A5 "

5< 5 < < 4

5 3

" ;

5 < "

" " %" A3 4( 5

!2 ;5%

3 " 13

<A( I<-"%!

5 6+! ,- -

- /

- - /

/ * 5 -

7 ! ,- - / * < - -

-- / -

* - >/-

/- !8 9 - % A1 $4 ( 5 !

( $ +/ ,0 %" A 3 " 2 A

< % 5

5 ! ( 5!

$% &

(

C "E 3 B % 3<A3

3 5'

" 1 3 "

5 # 5

1 < %% A 3

3 2( 5!

3 "

" ;

32 % 5 5 '

8CEC5E !

# 13

# A

3 3 @ <

# 8 #

1 <

%"5 <A !#

'% !%%

" %

3 A 5 " A 13

5 '

8CE

C5E !

# A<A !#1 <

%"5 %%

13 " % A5

3 " ""2 5 ) 3

" %

""A + % <A !#3 <; % A3 ,2 " <% <A 0CD!E

< %%A""

% '

<% <A

2 ""

5 " 15 % 3 <% <A" % 1A3 5 A""

A <

%A1 < ;

<3 " 1

!1 "

A4"

2 3

5 5

" % K<

"<3 " 5

5+2

5< " 1 "3 % "A % 4 3 A 2 " 3 <

3 % 1

4 ! 7CEC2

A / 1" % %2 ""

< %" A !#1

2 + 3

% &

1 %" A

% "

5 3

" 3A #3<="

A !# 4

%14"

" <

2 3 !#

1 1

2 <

" 2 <5 ""

5< !# %

2 3 !#

2 " + %<A%-

13 " 2

23 !#

1 " +1 3 < =" <A !# A

513

5< =" A "

<1" <A

= % <A 5

5 ""

5 " % #

" 2

2 !#

2 " +1 A 3 < "

" % '

'% !%% A"

5% 13

512 5 3 "

5 " 3 " 1 " 2 %A2 <% ! :C E /

A A '

A "" <A "

3 <

<A %" A3

" 3 A

< 4 <A !# < 2

1 3 "

$ -./,0 1

4;L 6 "4

5 M ) 6"< M )