← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2145/2013allowed

Darshan Singh v. Balbir Singh And ANR

2016-09-23Mr. Justice Arun Monga12 pages

   

       

    !"#$"%&"' () *'+,*-.-/, 0##"11*-$ 2"'+3+ *1&.'.-/,*-4*-$,"'  0 "+#-4"-$+



  !"#$"%&"' ()

*5,,#*16*3'*-4*-$,"' 0##"11*-$+ 2"'+3+ *'+,*-.-/,*-4$,"'+  0 "+#-4"-$+  !7 89   :9

'"+"-$! '3%""$*,*;*-("-.'425*$"<.$, '%.$6,*'(425*$"'$,"*##"11*-$ .-   *-4'$,"'"+#-4"-$ .-

  '6#*'*.(425*$"'$,"*##"11*-$

.-  *-4'$,"'"+#-4"-$+

.-   :9( %%- =3"+$.-+  1*< *-4 *5$ *'" .-212"4 .- $,"+"$<*##"*1+*-4$,">*'"&".-/4.+#+"4&>$,.+

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

*14($,"+5'.&"*-4,*'*$,3+,*-($,"%*'/.-*1<.$-"++ ,"4""-4*-$+,*4(.-$,"<'.$$"-+$*$"%"-$($'."4$5,*-/" $,"$"'%+*-45-4.$.-+$,"*/'""%"-$&>$"'%.-/.$$&" ' $," #3'#+"  +"53'.$> .- '"+#"5$  $," 1*-4 /.2"- ' ,*1.<*1'*4"'+*/*.-+$<,.5,$,"#1*.-$.,*4.1"4*+3.$' '"52"'>-$,"&*+.+*,."-$'."+.-*-3*'>@@@$,$,"

7 3'$+ &"1< 4"51.-"4 $ /'*-$ $," 4.+5'"$.-*'> '"1." *-4 /'*-$"4 $," *1$"'-*$.2" '"1." ' +(A(C7 *1-/ <.$, .-$"'"+$"+3&%.$+$,*$3-4"'$,"#'2.+.-++"5$.-+@ *-4@$,"2.4"-5"5$(DA.-5*+"$,"*/'""%"-$$+"11 .+*<'.$$"-*/'""%"-$($,"-$,"#*'$."+*'"&3-4$11<$," $"'%+ *-4 5-4.$.-+  $,*$ */'""%"-$  "1.*-5" ,*+ &""- #1*5"4-$,"#*'*A$,";34/%"-$'"-4"'"4.-*%.1*43 1"5$'.5.$> *'4 *-4 *-$,"' 2  *;3 "44.*' *-4 *-$,"'

@@) 3#'"%"3'$*+"+<,.5,'"*4+*+3-4"'! E      



                                   

                      

           !  

            "                          #         

                   " 

        

  ""  "     

  $  "   

77      "   

       

   "     

 "            "                %        & 



  

 "   "               "      "   "

     

     !   "   "  '  "           

    "           " ("  $      )  *                 ""       * "            +     "      !   "

  "          

       *       *          "

  " ,  "  $     "    ",        "  %          ""   "

77

  "            

      



         "  % "

  " ,            -  ( (       "  " "                        "              

        %   "  

    ((      "        -  "         "  ((  "  '  "   "           " *      "     " "        

) .(   

         * "   

"  

   - % -    &  (   "  /        ""    ( (   "      "                 "       "      $       

7)7        -        ""&                "           ) .("    "" 

    * " %      "  '   " (" "      " %                     "   " ("   

                   "    F "+3&%.$+$,*$$,"5-$"-$+$,"*/'""%"-$$+"115*--$ '"%$"1>&"+*.4$,*$$,"#*'$."+,*4.-$"-4"4$"-$"'.-$*- */'""%"-$'$,"#3'#+"+"53'.$>('*$,"'*11$,".-/'"4."-$+ $,"+*1"*'"#'"+"-$ - $," 5-$'*'>( '6#*'*.( 1"*'-"4 53-+"1 *##"*'.-/-&",*1$,"4""-4*-$7'"+#-4"-$++3&%.$+$,*$ 2.+7G72.+ $," /'*-$  *1$"'-*$.2" '"1."( $," "/31*' "5-4 ##"*1    ,*+ &""- .1"4( $,3/, .$ .+ *55%#*-."4&>*##1.5*$.-+'+""B.-/5-4-*$.-4"1*> )

4*>+.-.1.-/$,"*##"*1*-44*>+.-'".1.-/$,"*##"*1( $,"4"1*><*+-$.-$"-$.-*1*-4'*$,"'&-*.4""+3&%.$+ $,*$ $," 4""-4*-$+ ,*4 -$ "?"53$"4 *-> */'""%"-$ $ +"11 4*$"4@@@.-'"+#"5$$,"+3.$1*-4%"*+3'.-/AB*-*1+

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

-   $," 3-;*& 3'$+ 5$(@D<314*##1>'$,"*##"*1." <314&".1"4 3-4"' "5$.-   4"  .2.1 '5"43'"( + $,"'" .+ -""4 $ '*%" $," +3&+$*-$.*1 =3"+$.-+ 1*<' -$ ," -+$.$3$.-*1"-5,-8&1"3#'"%"3'$,"14$,*$$," 4"5.+.-.-E631<*-$6*3'*-4$,"'+H+3'4.*1.

4"*4 &>9 +*-4$,"'+  )(-*##1.5*&.1.$> "5$.-@A   .+-$*5''"5$1*<(.-"++"-5"($," #'2.+.-+"5$.-$," 3-;*&3'$+5$(@D,*4 &""-'"+$'"4&*5B

7D7 

'$,"+*B"&'"2.$>($,"'"1"2*-$#'$.-$," ;34/%"-$  .2" 1"*'-"4 34/"+  $," -8&1" 3#'"%" 3'$.- *-B*;*B+,.8+5*+" +3#'* '"*4+$,3+!7 E.-5""5$.-$," 3-;*&5$.+"?#'"++1>.- 5-1.5$ <.$, $," *%"-4.-/ 1*<( 2.I( "5$.-  *+ *%"-4"4( .$ <314 &" 4""%"4 $ ,*2" &""- '"#"*1"4,3+<",*2"-,"+.$*$.-$,14$,*$ $," 1*< 4"51*'"4 &> $," 311 "-5,  $," ./, 3'$.-$,"5*+"*-#*$J @AD

 A! D 3-; 9  

 K 5*--$ &" +3+$*.-"4 *-4 .+ $,3+2"''31"4LJ*$#*'*+A7@KF A 2"- $," '""'"-5" $ '$.51"   $," -+$.$3$.-<*+-$5''"5$1>%*4"&>$,.+3'$ .- $," +*.4 4"5.+.- "5$.-   $," 3-;*& 3'$+ 5$ .+  @D 2.-$*/" &2.3+1>( $,"'"'"(.$.+-$*1*<%*4"&>$,"9"/.+1*$3'" *$*$"*$"'$,"-+$.$3$.--4.*,*+5%" .-$ '5" $ .+ * 1*< %*4" &> * '2.-5.*1 9"/.+1*$3'"3-4"'"5$.-D$,"2"'-%"-$  -4.* 5$( @( <,.5, 1*< <*+ 5-$.-3"4( &".-/ *1*<.- '5".- '.$.+, -4.*(.%%"4.*$"1> &"'" $," 5%%"-5"%"-$  $," 2"'-%"-$  -4.*5$(@ (&>"5$.-@$,"'"-$3'-( *$"'$,"-+$.$3$.--4.*5*%".-$'5"*-4( &>'$.51" @('"#"*1"4$,"2"'-%"-$-4.

* 5$( @ ( $," 3-;*& 3'$+ 5$ <*+ 5-$.-3"4 &".-/ * 1*< .- '5" .- $," $"''.$'>  -4.* .%%"4.*$"1> &"'" $," 5%%"-5"%"-$  $," -+$.$3$.--4.*&>2.'$3"'$.51" A   $," -+$.$3$.-  -4.* ,.+ &".-/ $," 5*+"( '$.51"$,"-+$.$3$.--4.

7@7 -*##1.5*$.-$+35,*1*<'$,"+.%#1"'"*+- $,*$ .$ .+ -$ * 1*< %*4" &> $," 9"/.+1*$3'"  * $*$"&3$.+*-"?.+$.-/1*<5-$.-3"4&>2.'$3" '$.51" A$,"-+$.$3$.--4.**$*11(.$ .+ '$.51" A   *1-" $,*$ <314 *##1> $ +35, 1*< <,.5, .+ $ 5-$.-3" .- '5" 3-$.1 *1$"'"4 ' '"#"*1"4 ' *%"-4"4 &> * 5%#"$"-$ 9"/.+1*$3'" ' $,"' 5%#"$"-$ *3$,'.$> :" ,*2" *1'"*4> 3-4$,*$+.-5""5$.-@A  $,"4".2.1

'5"43'"

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

77 ,"*5$+-$.5"4*&2"(*$"'$,""?#.'>$,"4*$" 5-$'*5$(<.$,.-#*++.-/$,"1.$$1"4*>+*$"'$,"-"%-$,( $,"+3.$<*+.1"4($,3+(.-%>2."<($,"*##"11*-$7#1*.-$.,*+ &""-*1<*>+'"*4>*-4<.11.-/$#"''%,.+#*'$5-$'*5$.- 2."<  $," 1*< 1*.4 4<- .- .$* *% *-4 $,"'+ 2 *4,"> ,>*% A    .2.1  

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

77 -2."<$,"*'"+*.44.+53++.-($,"     .+ *11<"4( <,"'"*+( $,"     .+ 4.+%.++"4.-5"$,"%*.-*##"*1&"*'.-/  .+4.+%.++"4(.-4-'"*+-$5-4-"$,"4"1*>.-.1.-/*-4 '".1.-/$,"*##"*1*-4*55'4.-/1>.$.+4.+%.++"4 "#$"%&"' ()    :9  6