High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/5401/2015disposed of

Om Lata v. State Of Haryana And ORS.

2019-04-03Mr. Justice A.B. Chaudhari15 pages

"#$%&% '( )**#$&%

$ +,- . -.. /,

! "

#$ %

"& ' ()"*

( ' (( ( ! ++,- .. /,0 '1 #.$ *"(&%

( / 0123.43.1524.2 43.6#$ (

-%"7 .43143.1*"

% !( 12"

!8%((( !.9:2"

(

(!(;- ( "

(

< 7" %4= 7" "(!" 7 (> ) "

!8%((( -

! ( "( .<3943.3 #4$ *"

-% " "% (> "

7 ? <3

7" 6 7" "(!"")

!!%

(( 4:9333@; %!% "(!" ! ((

"(!" !8%( %(

.47 4 (% (

"%A

%,("7*"

%) (!

% !8%((( ! %!( B B7+ %( C "7 "

((!( % !( 2 (% .<..433: .27 6

#<$ *"

) "

-% "

" !

" "

( 8% (

0( "( "

! "

"%A

%")

(> ? 4=<3333@;

! *"

A( -((

% (!( - ( "7 ,

% -

!"7#C>6$ "

A( -((

( ! !( C 8%((!

! "

( 8% (

8% ("-

! "

( 8% (

23 7"

! ( 43.4+ %"

C>.1 ( " )

(

" "

<3 7" "

)%(

0( ( "

7 43 7"

! + (!

( 8% ( !

"7!(

( "% 7) % #C>:$ "

( .;.DE (

"% 7) % "

"% A

% )

( ( &(

( 8% ( *"

! "

( !8%(((

<3 7"

C>.< "

(

( 8% ( ( 4=<3333@; % 7

(

>-% % " !8%((( -

! #433<$ .4 -- 624 "

( "

" "

)%(

0( ( "

!" (!

" (

( ( #2$ / % (

6 7" !!%

(

" % !

% #<$ #2$ !( 4<#.$ !!%

( %(

) 7

( ( !""

( &%(% ! "

( "

! "(!" () 7

( ( + (!

" !!% !8%((( 47

.2 )

) "( ( !

029E(

0.4@4 .:@. *"

( ( "

: 7 !(

0;.3

" )%1<7 "(!"

(

(" ! !( ()( ( "(

(

6 7" !!%

)

( !( 4<#4$

(

% ,( ((

!" &%

( .('( *2' ! '3 24' .*#52 %6& '(#'

& *"

%!% !!% "

!""

%( "(!"")

?.6=31<@; "(

(

()

() (% %

04. <33<43.4 ( " )!! %

!&%("

%!% % "

( #C>1 6$

#1$ -%

;

" (

(!( ( % 6 %

.= (" !( .1. --

(!( % !( .9"

.9:2 !

,((!A%

"7#-;.3312;-+;43.9( / ;

123.;43.1-;.3.9:;-+;43.9+0/ ;24.2;43.6$

(

"(! (7 "

" (

(!( % !( .9 .4 7 4 " )

(

.2 7 6 (( (

((!( %@2

0< 43.3;43..

<.3943.3*"

(""

(

" "

.47 4 ( (%!%

(

(!( ")

- ( ) (

" "

!% " )

(()

-% ) "(-% %!" "(! (7 !% )

) ! ! "

(

(!(

!!(

((

#6$ (( -;<13;-+;43.: +0 / ;123.;43.1 -;<21; -+;43.:+0/ ;24.2;43.6"

(

% 2.%

4=--

) (

>% .$ % " )

! " !( "

"(!" ( % " ) !8%( *"

(!(

) "

(""

( ! )% " )

(

) "

- ( !!(

)

( ! (""

(

!C> 1 #=$ -%

"!!(

" "

7 "% ) ? 23 7"

( #C>9$ "

%)( " "

% !

( ()

)

" + ( %"

%)( " !!%

%!" (>

%6 7"

! "% "

)(

7 ")

( .3(*#"7' 5!.('( ' 8'#'%%% , 6% "

-%( ()

) (( " >

#9$ ( ( ( ! ++,- "

" %)( " "

7 " )

! ! (> ) "

!8%((( -

!!% -

! -%

&%(( (

" !(

4= 7"

! <3

! + ( %)( " "

" )

) !% ) %

#:$ /( !(

(% !

;

%"(( "!8%( %(

.47 4 "

((

0.: !

) <.3943.3 .2 7 6 !8%( (

"% A

% ) 0:< !

% (

2946413@; (

% (%?<3F.22=9=1@;

%(( !"

26.<9:@;

6=<11.2@; ("

#.3$ (

.:.343.. " )

(% ) "

,((!

#C>.3$ " "

)%(

0( ( "

0.3

.4.443..#C>..$"

((!( (% "( )%(

0( ( "

G0H (7

!!(

% (% #C>.4$ "(!"

(

" "

(

" )

(

"% 7) %(

"%A

%*"

(

!" )

( ( %!" ) "

-% + ( )

413243.4"

#C>=$" )

%.6=31<@; "

( 8% (

("*"

(

#C>1$ " "

(""

#C>6$"

!""

)% 2( "%!" "(!"")

% )

>% "(!""

(!(

(( ! ("C>1

"(!" " " "

( &(

! "

% &( -"

(! +(!

(! ! %!""

" (

( (% ( < 7 "

% (!( (( "7

(

"% A

" (

"% 7) % *"

! ( " % ("

" (

! %!( %!"

%!" ! (! "

) "

% ! %!( %!" (

()

) ( (""

( - ( #..$ *"

( ("

( 8% ( "% % (( "( )%(

( "

"(!" ) !

(

C>1

>% %!

! (( "

( %(!(

( " " "

%"(( "

" )% ""

"( "

%"(( ""

)%(

"( "

% " )

(% C>.4 *"

H "%)

" ( =7-""%-" 7"7 "

(

"% ""

( 8% ( )

% (!% % % "

!8%( + 4E % (!( (( %% )!( "

!% ) ! !( ( % !!(

(4!

! ")

%+ !;

>( ( "

")"(

(( %)( " "

( 8% ( ( )% = 7 -""% -" 7 "7

( " "

(( !! (""

("( 0- (( #.4$ *"

- ( " %!

B.0

E% (

+ %( ++,- " " )% " ! "

((!( "

( ""

)% "

0( ( "

"(!" "7( )% ) )%

! %! ( #.<$ ((

433=43.3C>41%!"" )

)%"

!( %!"

(

((

)

(! )"

( "

( !

(

" )% " !"

(

%!"" !( "

(

#.2$

(

!%% ( (!%( ) ( )

-%"

% -

" !

#.1$ *"

>-% ( ,'1 2'#" ! % .69%

( "%!"" ""

!(!

(

( )"

% C>

;

( ;

(

;

( *"

( % ;

! "#! $ % %! & ! ! % '( % !)

! "#! $ * ! + ! , - % . % & ) #! !!

* ! ! * / ! ! 0 * / ! 2 3 ! ) 2 3 ! '( %! ! ! - !!

#! ! ! ! 4 ! #! * #! #! / ! ! ! ! ! ! - ! !!

"#! $ ! ! 0 1 2 !

- ! ! ), 5, !! !

! ! 6 #.6$ % 7

(

)

"(!" ")

(!(

0( ( "

(> ?<3 7"!

) % ("(

(#C>9$%!"!

)

% # %!"

) )( (>(

7 *"

)

(>(

7 "

)(

((

"(!""

)(

>)( !

(4! /"

( ((

(

>-%( '3 ""8!,'#"):7**(*# *) 0 8"

';'" %% . &!

% *"

( % ;

* / / ! 5 / ! ! ! % 80 1 &))! ! / !! ! / ! ! ! / !

! ! ! ! !

! % 1 &) ) ! / % 80 1 / !! / ! / ! ! ! / ! ! ! ! !

# ! / ! ! ! ! ! 6 #.

( !(

" "

% 7 (

+("

)(

! %(!(

"(!" (

%)("

%!"

( (

(

.< )*'1 ,'#" ):7**(*# *) ! =' *54"' .6>*"

( % ;

- , ! ! ! / ) 5 %

9 ) $ / ! ! % 7: ! ! 2

! / % 78 ) ! ! % 7:78 )! ! $ / * ! ! # 2 / ! ; ! ) ! ! ! !

!!2 ! / * ! ! !! ! ! !

%$$>87? $ #! !! !! 4! ! ! 3 !! ! ! ! ! $ !! ! ! ! $ ! *!! $ ' @+ ! ) <07AAB1B%$$

8? $ C

D) $ & )/ 4 / * % 2 D * ! ! #! ! % ! * $ ! !! % " # $ #! ( ! ! 6 #.9$ % "

% % %)(" 7 ( ()

)

" )(

#.:$ -(

( ( ( %

%!""

.47 4 "

((

" (

!8%( "

(%!"( ""

.27 6 *"%"

47 .2 "(!"") ! %

" (

% ! ()

+ %!" !(!%

( *#"7' 5+! #% $(&%(( "

(" " (

"(!" (

()

% (!% % ! !( "

( H" %!"")

!8%( I !

% #<$#2$ !( 4<#.$"

("%)

(

! " "

" !% " )

(! "

("%

(( 0"(

%!" )% " !)"

! "(

! #43$ + (( !(!% "

,( ((

!"( .('( 7#?'; ! <'1 .*#52 , >& ! "

! %( " "

!% !!

( !!% "

," )" )

)%( % 13F"

7 "

% !8%( !!% "

( % ;

= ! 2 $

)+E F : =9: ! >AG ! / / ! / $ ! 2

$ ) + E &)/ $ ! !2 $ 2

H 2 / 2 !!

! $ )+E ! * ! 2 ! ! ) ! / ! ! $ ! % )+ E 6 #4.$ !!(

(

) "( -% ( "

( ""

)

(

?13F 7 "(!"")

! ! ?3 7"

! "

% !8%( ( "

% "

( " (

; #($ *"

7 "

( ?<3 7"

! #(($ !!%

% !8%( ( %(

47 4 "

7 ) ) ?13F"

<3 7"

#((($ *"

%!% ?4:9333@; (% "

%!% "

) "

% )

( % !( 4<#. $ !( 4<#4$ *"

( )

(

) )

7 "

"(!"")

(

( .('( 7#?';!3' ?*(.*#52# 0 .,-9 #44$ ,( ( ) &% ..'#"2'4'1*'

7"5