High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2195/2013dismissed

Karnail Singh v. Gurdev Kaur And ORS

2015-10-12Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal12 pages

!"##$%&%'( )!*'!%+%',- .#!. "-*/,-0 & 11#++!'"

2& /*.#3)!/*!'."-#*& #&1'.#'"& (

! "#

$% &'%(!)* + # % )* ,

&'%(!) '

%#%-).-( *

/

!

"

#

&'%(

#%

# &'%(

*

+ ,,-

## .'% /. "# 0 % #)

#%

#

2 +- 3+

#

( #&'# ) #%

3!

#

( #&'#

#

&# # # ' )#% % # ##

# # &# # # " 6 ##

( ##% # 7# # ) %'

*!

" # ' #' #' %#

# #

283*92

#( :'# #

'%

(' '# #' ## # # #

#

## ' /') '

'

( ##% ##0 <

((##

#

')(# #

##%

%

# # (# "#(#

# 9!

##% # # #

( #% #'6

!

"

#

=!

$

##

$

76

'

'

##6 #

'( '

)#% $ $#%

# $ >: 6

:

##

# # '

#

$

# :

6 4'# $

?!

' # $ '

( #6 6# #'

## %

#)

#' '()

# 76

$

)#% # '

4'

# ##

'## #

#(# '% #( 76

')'

% #

4'

#(# # &'%(

*

+ ,,-

2!

%%# &'%(

#

'

#

#

:

# &'%(

+* 3 3+ $')4'

# #% #%

# :

&'%(

#

# +- + 3+

)

$

&'%(

+* 3 3++3

#

(#

-!

"'#%

# ' @

'

# 6 '

##

## # ## 3+

3 +* ,,=8+ +* ,,= #

-

,,2

# ( +, +

,,?

'

'

'

+-

,,2

A#(# 3, +* ,,= ##

## .'% /$ "# 0 % #) ,!

'(

#(

(##)

'# '(

#( #% ## ) #

'(

#( '##

(## #

#

## )#% ) #% #

# ' @

'

) %

#% ##

4'

&

+!

> # ##%

:'#

#(

#% )#% :'# # ' #

,,=

# (

(# '( ##% # #(

'

'

' #

## 3+ +* ,,= #

' ( #&'#

#

#(#

-

,,2 5#

'% '

## ( @

'

#

#(#

#'

## % # %

!

" ' ## (

'( &# # #

#

# )#% % # ' 6 # :

#% ' '

# (

#

'%

(#%

# ' @

'

#

&

# #%

3!

7# ##%

(' ') # 4'#

?

%'

#% 6 &'

(

)

& * +

,

%(

,

,

( -'

,

.

) )

( , (

(

.

( (

,

*'

) )

& *

(

(

$

. ,

( +

. (

'

) )

& *

(

(

.

(

(

#

*!

;

%'( ) #

' #

#

# ) ' #

9!

< '

%' ' @ ##

6'

'

76

' 5#

#(#

' #

6 4'# $ $# ' #

) )## ##

#(#

% > #

$

)

#

' )'

' # %

' #%

#(#

#%

=!

#

)'

&# #% @ &##% #% ##

# ' @

'

'#%

## ## # #' ##% # ##

3+ +* ,,=

' ( #&'#

#

& <

##

#(#

-

,,2

#% :'# # ' #

,,=

?!

# '

(##

# ( # # #% &

(

## ' @

'

'(

#'

## %

' ## ( ##

'( &# # #

'

2!

$# ) # ' '

' # #'

## % )'

#% #

%#'' ' #%

28 83*92

##%

# (

-!

< '

# '

! $% 0

)%($% 1. %2#"

)% )/+3+1,2 1-02,, #

) ' # # #

# #' ) # '(#

4'# # < ' ' # ' & )& 0

')- % )/445152

1-025,6 6##%

# ( # # ##

' &'%( '

&'%( # :

# #

# (

$

# ' #

( #

&'%(

,!

< '

# ' $ -)(0

. " )% )% /+331+27 89:

'(# #

' )#%

' '

'# # # #

B

# ' ; % )0

)-) )%- /+3391+2

1-0255:

( ) ' ( :

# #

# ( #( ' #%

) ' # % 3+!

@ ' # ' +331+2<' ') 59, #

) 6:

(#

#

# # ' < ' ' # ' +351,2,,+ 1. --('2

#%

# ):

#

#

# #( 6 :

(# # '(#

#

#( !

< ' ' # ' '

) !! 0

" ) -/ 44,1,2

96+ &'### $#

# ( '( ##% #

(# )'

#

#

## (#

:'# # #

) )

# #

# 33!

'

'

"

##%

# ( 5#

#(# % )'%

#% #

6 : '

#% ##

# % #

$

3*!

) # )#% #'

## % '(

) # ' # # ' # #

&#

'(

'

#' )#%

; 4'# ('

' #

# ' # : 6#% ( 76

'

' $#

## # &'### '( ' ## #%

% C'#

#( # #

&'## '(#%

) )## ( ) '

## % # % 5

' # #

39!

C'#

"

#( # #

)#%

' #( ) '

$

##%

# (

(' '(# # ' ##

( # ) (

)## % $# #

' % ( ) '

$ # ' ) ' ## #% &#

## %

'(

'

#'

' 3=!

#

# 4'#

('

:#

# ') # 4'#

# #

#%

'

)

#%

3?!

#' #' #

=,296

3+ *

#' += 3+ *

'() # )' # #

# > # += +- 3+ * :'#%

#

&' ) #:

# ( # '#

32!

5 #

=3 ##%

# '# # %

'#% ( # 4'# (#( ## #

:' 6

5 # )'

# ; #

##

(# ## # # $#

# ' (# # 3-!

#% ) #

) #

#

;('% &'%(

#

# $'# # #(#

#'

@)

3 3+ =

&%