High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2223/2013allowed

Gurmukh Singh And ORS v. Harbans Lal And ORS

2016-09-28Mr. Justice Arun Monga9 pages

!"# $%&%!'()*+*,

( -. * /.

!!" # $ !%

" #& " # $

'() *! "*" + " # $

',- ....

0* .

# $1

$&2"& +

!" !"#

$%&%'# %$&('# $(%&('# ($&'# ( !"$(&)'# *!" $ &%' ()% % $&'# % $%&('# %+ $+&'#%+( $+&'#%+( $+&'#%+* ($ &'# %+ ($&'#%$%&%'#% *!$&+'#%( ( $&'# ($ &'#%$&'#%( ($&*'#($+&'#(*%$*&)'#

! !# $*&%'#

% *!$ &+'#*!$&+'

! (!# (** %!$&'#*!$+&+'

! %!# ( !$*& +'# (** %# $%&'

! #

( $+&('# ( $+&'

! $&# *$+&+'# )$&+'# *$&'

! # $+&%'#* $+&*'# %*$+&%'# !$&'# ($&'# *$& '#( $+&'#(%$+&'( $+&'

! # ()+ *($ &'#+)$)&')%$+&'

! # ($&('#(($)&('# (%$(& '#%+$&' ,

-./ #01 )#2 3# 4 3 $

'# 5 .

.$*'&

6 4#4 #

6 .(!

& .7 78&.7 # 3 !39 ! 37 #. . *

6 # : :7 !39! 3; 3 7 < /.

! 3 ! 3; 0=7 < ! ( 6 6 < . 9 . 6 # 6 #

.# 6 #.

# .

# . 6 7 +&2 !!"

$ & 2&

&0 1

$ 2"& +

$ $& /&2$

#+ & " $"

# 1 # $ ,30$ 1 2

",45, $6,45,6/ & $ +0

'35 /

" "

" "$+

"& $ &$ & /&2$ .

# $ ,45,7$ &

$ +"

# +

# & $ $ /$ 8)$ 1

# ",99: $6,99:6 #+ 7 + " $ & $

/&2$ #

$$ +

'35 +"

+" 7 $ $$

# + $

"# +& $# /# + ;<*0,;<*03+$&

+2 2

= ",948

$6,9486"& + $

= "

# +

$$ $ & & +

2 # %

2$$ $ = $& &

! %

" 2 + "

'() +$ "

$$ + $ "& +$ $ +

" # $ 8) $,99:&$+ 7 $ "

" 1

+ 2

!!" "

# $ %% & '(

& &#

# #"$"" # &$ # $> 9)2 2"#

$$# ,-,$7

;# "& $<

,-($;# " &+

$$& $ "& +"

# $ 7 "

$ " & 2 # $

/= $ & #

$ 2&$"

1 $

+&2 $ ,30 $,45,& &+

& ()-03-- $

2 ? @2

$# " = "$

/# & $

',3(?3: + /

$$&$ $$ $ 6@ & 6&& $

$# "& $

$1' & 1" $ # ()-+

$ " $ 1

= 6@ & 6 +&

+$# /

+ $

" $" &A 0 #

# / + $# # $

$ #

/ $ $$

B +

$ 7 $

+,45,"& $ +$

',83(

, # $ $

#" 2 >$$ 1

/$ & > $ # "# +

& $ & 1$

" &>

$ $*C>"

$$ #

'3)

,( @ ( @ &" ! ')8

() @ ,4 @ &

$ $$!'(:,03):

9:& ' "

' 2"" 2 $ $$

7# $

$# &

$ $ !!"$" 2$<

# ;<*0,;<*03 $ $1

3--:(--) 22'8)9$(--3"8)4$(--3

85,$ (--3 +

* %

" "& + & $

= + $ $ "& + 0

# "" + & / $$ $ " & # (3,,(--) ;<*08 /

$$ $ 1$ $

"&&

$$# :)-@ $

$$2

""! " &"

$ 7 $" $$

! " &

$& $#$ +0

'35& 7 #+# # $$ +

# / ,30$,45,# 2 # 2

& # 1 C$ # +"# $ ,30$,45, 0 ) *+ , ) $'< 4 # >.86# 1 3 6 . 4 ?

#8 @ 4 ?

A 8 >6.

. #

..6 6 . 6 6 4 < #. 9 # ..6 . ..6 #

6 6 4 < # : :

9 ..6 B 46

..6 # 9 .

8 < =

9 $'2 &8 $'

. : :6 4 # )+*$( )+*'7

) $"# $#$

$ ,4-)/ $$#$ # + + $ # /& 2

+ &

& +

* %

" &

,9$,948/&2

= $$

&" #

" +# &"1

$&2

+ " #/

$$#$

,-,$;# & #

7 +# &" $$ # # $ $&$ $ ++"# $# 7 $ #

$$ $

7 $1

$2 # 2& " &2< 1

" 7 +# &" $

# +&2 34$

# 7 1 / ;<*D "& $

$ "& & 7 # &$# $,45,"7 $# & 2

+ 7 & $

$$ # # + & & ' " 2 $

+ = $&&

" # &$ +$ # %

$ 2 -.. ,

+% .

/"%

#& &

# &$# $ 4: ,2 2"&# $ 8,$ 1 2",4,9& + & $

,--$2 $2 # / 2 @ $ 2

0,'10, +2, '

# 3

%%" +$ 4: ,$2 2&

&" "# $ 8,$ 1

2",4,9

$"7

$ = $ & &

$ C$

$& 2 +$&

+" +

$ 2 /

F $ # " & /.

)*+*, + F

A &3 !

F &3 !