High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO-M/324/2017allowed

Sumit Joshi v. Aditi Sharma

2023-04-17Ms. Justice Ritu Bahri,Mrs. Justice Manisha Batra16 pages

!"""#"" " " "

&) *

'( %

"$ +,$- !

- " +,$- !

- $"-"""

! " !

! " !

# ! " !

# $$$ $"-"""

.!

% &

" # '

#

(

# #" #"

%) *%+* (+# & "

!%,--* #

.

"

/+#

!0"'! '"' #

1 # 2 3 '#" "!

# "

#

( ) 4"

(

#2,%%25%5"" &

" #

4

#

# !

# 4 #

" "

#

# "

#

"

! #

"6

4

0"'# 4 #

'

" #

& "

#

"" "

' "

'

"

# 7 #"25%%!

8## "

9

" 3

!

#

!

#

"#

4

6 " 94

#

"'!

'

:

25%2 " #

# '

# " " "' 25%)# "

5;5<25%) #

" # 1 &

!

0"'!

# !

# " #

# =

# '

##

>

=! "

'

# # "

7 # # #

4

" #

!" # ! #

#

? 4 #

'

"

7

#

# :

4

"" #"

"1

8## "

1

8## "

7 '#1 7

# # <"

#" &1

"

4 ##

# 4

# ""

2@5?255,!## A ' '

#

( ( "

! # '

"" "

#

# &

( ( " # "

A

?5 # '

#

7

%

#

7

"

! #!

" 6

" #

& # " " 4

"#

" "

=B1

# ' " #

25%)!

:

# 4 #

6

#

=!

4

" '"" "

""

&

& # "

=#

"6 # # & " = #

" "

" "'

0"' (

4

#

# "

=

# 8 5;5)25%-! " =

#

"

"

#

0 4

#"

"# ## "

7 ' "

"

# >

" # "

# #

"

"

- C # 8

1 # #

5@5<25%- ( .% >

# D800 2 >

" # " #"

D80 ) #/ @ 4

" " "

"

4

# 0>(%:

0>(2 : # >(%

"= >(2 ; C

"" < 8

# ""

1 " #

(

"

#

, 3 ! (

#

%5

#

" #

/

" 22%%25%; # 1

#

&

"

"

" #

## 4 #

: # #"

# # # "

! "

" " # "

"

2?# "

'

#

4 1 # " #"

#"

# "

&#

# 4 #

"7 # " # #

#

" B # # # "

! "

" # "

## " # :"

"&#

# 1

25%,

6

" "

! "" ## # # -5"

#

&#

#

< B

!

(

' " " > ""

!" # ! # "" "#

#

4 #

#

! " # " "

"

0 123 12!

*%,,?+%11));E -4 *13 !5 *1!*255;+?11-%%E 3 6 1 3 6 1 !*255@+?11--<F - 715

3 65 45 !%,,?* +211-<< %% 0" !

" #

# 1 #

&

#

"

"

" #

#& "

# 1 ' # "

"

" 1&"!

%2 7

#"

#

1 #

1 !##

###"

4

#

F1"

1 #

1

# #

8

%) 4 (

#

" 4:

." / # "

7

! !

" " " 1 "

#

# #

#

# ""

"""

" #!

! !

# "7"

!5)1 73 "

6!*255-+ 21122! &A:1 6

# " " # #

" "

"

! "

" 1 ! " " ! " #

# 7## ""

G #""

"

"

# !

#!

""

" 70 12+*" *+! :1

" ""

" #

" ## '

#

!

# "

"

:"

"

!"

#

"

7

* 3 - * !*%,;-+211)2@! &A:1

" # #"

%)*%+* (+

' ! " "

#

## "

"

# #

#

H ' " # "" ! "

## "

"

"4

"

# #" # #"

"

"

" " 4# #

!

#

" ""

""

#"

"

"

" "

# #

4 #" #

#"

"

"

" '"

7

" ! #

#

" #" ##"

( # # ! # (

# "

""

""

" " 4

" '

6

" #"

#

# # "

'

" #

#4 1 # " " " ""

"

"

" " " " ""

" " 7

#

"

" #

'

# # "

' " # "&""B:0(2

# # "

#

C !# # "

# ## "

"

"

"

# " & ! #"!

# " "" " " # " #

## "

"

4

" "

""

## & ! " #

" !

" # 6 # #

6

' "

& # " 25%,

1

#

"" #" "' &

' " "# "

# #"

# ##

'

"

#

" %? C 6

#"

#

" 7 - *1- 1 3 2!7255<1)5,)! &A:1

''

#

#

'

"

" " "

" # " # "

# " 7 -4

*1+* " *+! &A 1 #

" # "

" # "

" # . " /" "

" 6 # #"

!

# "" 7 " !

# # %@ 7 " #

#

!

"" ! "

# E " !

" # #

" ' "

" 4&A:1 #

"" 7 3 6 1 +* " *+!

# %5 1

"

"

" 4&A :1 "

"

# ## #

#

# "!

" ' 7 # 1

!

' ""

! #

#

'

! "

7

'

" 6" #

# ' " " ##"

"#

#

7- 715

+*" *+! &A :1

# "

#"

"' "

#

) '

' 1

"# " %- 7

" ! "

"" ' #

# ' # 6 "

# (

# 6 ' "

!

"

6 ""

G

#" ' "

" "

"

" 7

!

&A:1 "

!5)1 7+* " *+

#"

6 # # "

"' #"

#

!"

6 # #

" ' #

""

7 9$* :$1 3 .$ 3 0 3 $ !*25%?+;11@?5!

6

"

#(

"" ' "

7- 3* ; 3 - 1 4 !

252%1189 1;52! 1

# 6

" ""

" #" & ! &A:1

'

6 "

"

" "

" " "

:

# "

7 "

#

# # " "

#

" 1

"

'

"

7

# #

"

"

# " #

"

#

4""

#

#

# 7 " "

# #"

#

' # #" "" #

6 #"

# #"# " # #

7

# '

#

6

#"

"#

"

# 25%;!

1 25%,

'

0 ("( "

"

" "252% 4 "":(% "# 9 ' 0# # "

#

" 4 (

# # " ##

# 1

# # # #

1

" 4

""25%- # #< 4

'%

"'### #

#

4##

1 #

1 #

1 #

4

"

#

< 4

#

# "

'

"

#

# "

#" - *1- 1 +*" *+C !

' #

#

# '

# & !

# '

#

" "! " 1 #

7 1 7; 37 9-4 :3 - 37 !*%,,)+?112)2!

"# " ' " "

" "

"8 #"!

" #"

#""

>" " #

""

#

3 "

" !

" 4'

"

#"

# #

# 1

1 # " :

"

9

"

# 7

"

#

#

"# 7 " #"

"

"

" " !

"

'

"' # 4

'

"

C #

#

&"! #

'

1

:" "# "&"!

4

1

"# " #

#

%@ =#"" ! ! ! " (

# 1

7

# "#

" #

525,2522! ( ##

# -5"

# 6 5,5,2522!## ## #

4 ## ""

'

17

##

1 5@52252)!

:

7 !

"

# #1# ?

# < & #"

" #

"

#

" ##

"

( * + 4 (

# @5"

# #

## #

'/

1

""

1 "

"#

*

+ H "# "" 1 !

' # #3 C

I=' # (

#

#

4""'

1

*

+ 4 (

#

6

""

"

# * + # #

#

! "" "

#

# "

# %;

" "

* +! #!

# 9 ":

9$"-""":

!

!

'( % > '

G GC > GC