← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/6535/2018allowed

Niranjan v. Raj Kumar And ORS

2025-11-18Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma10 pages

      

     

 !"# $% &

'

' 

() $* !$%$+%,-%)&

'

'  ./$(## $%&

'

'   

      & 0 1 2'

2 2  2     

 

    

   !"

 ##### 2  2

'





$     

 

%&'(%   

 )%   * 

   

 %  & * 

)



  +

 ,-&&.,&-  





 

&//!&',

  



&011)%

  

  *)

$)  2  

 3 *) 34   

   

 



 

 !

   & ,- /,,!5 + 

 

-(6

 

    )%



 

 !

             



 

    ,.,..,&( . 

 

  

  

7  

 + )%

 *)





   

   



8

 

8 )

% 2 222  1

21   2 9 *

  

 

 !

 

5 4 * 

 + )%

 *)   +  

 ) 

 4 * 

 !

 

    )% :

   ;

 : ,.,..,&( ,/,..,&(

4 *  +  +  <



 +   * 



) 

+  

  +   

 !

 ) 

 



+ '   

   

      5"

 % +

%   +

%)

    

   )%

 *)



%)



* 

 %  

( "

 

  

  

 

+



   +  )

 

 21

13  2 ( :=)

   

 +  



 + 

 ) %*

>    (4 5+-(!

6 '

4(7 5+-(!

(%# %$)8!



2+.!- $+!) ( 9 

 5         !"# 

           ! "#$" 

     "! %# "& ! !'" &       !

#$ !(!

(  (! "!  " (!    & !    # !

'" # 

"#"         !

(  #$&  !  %"!  

!   &  "      &   "(   $"    "! #& !

'" # &#  !  & $"&#"  

 "!  "" $"&

    #  !  #& ! "   #&$&    

  "!    $&! #"      $"  !    #&   "   "! "!

   !

 )  * +  )"#   ,&  

+" " - ,./0)" *"1/2.

4  ( ! *,! 5!

  )**

 !6  7"( #&/0*82/

 !"!     !!

 $"&    (9 $ "#%  &' (  )   :%   (         ; 

!      " (  !  !

 "%!"

 5 ( ! (    $"!

"!  ! ! #$"! (9  5 (!"( !  < #  5    ""   (    "    ! #&

 ="" ! % ->" &!

( ? 3 (

   3 (       "(  !   "

   '" $"

  5       !@        

 (

 5%  ( (&

," $"&    # !!&"!  !    !

,& " $"&   !  !# ( !      #( !"! &  !

#    !  ("" ( " ! #&"" ! %   !@  (

!% 

%%% %%% %%% %%%

* #+ "   ,  %

"

% -./  $" ! # (

$" !" (  &



 ( ! #&    #!&  # "

!#  ( (  &  " !&  ( (  &      ( ! #& %     #"  #  !"!  ( (   &             (      ! #&



!  ! $"!>    % !  "#'"&  %   ! #& (!&( ! %       ! #&

       (   &  (   # !#&

#"    !&



  ! #& &"!  (         (    &    !   !!(  "      "     " $# (!"  !  

  0,  

  1  

 1  1"

"    

2%-++ ,1   ,1+

"

 339

$"!     (!10 &  ! (. 1000@>      !      3   !       ! #&  #  '" $"&  20A ! '"  ! #&     '" !    10A

       (

   &   !#& #"   A # !# "   "!

  &  #"  ( ! * "    #  9

 "      #     !  9  .

12000@>

# 5"" ( "

 A  "  9 . 800@>

"  #   (9/ !

5"" (9 800%/ 9.

00@>

"

 3439

$"!  ! (!10&   (. 1000@> 

4 ! " ! !

 ! #& ! 20A 4    ! $#  "!(! 4 (( &  &  #  !

 ( &$#   & &#  

  #"      !       ""   (    &    /  * "      #  9

 "             !  9  .

12000@>

# 5"" ( "

/ A  "  9. B/000@>

"  #   (9/ !

5"" (9B/000%/ 9.

8 000@>

"

 339

$"! B &  !   & :(("!  "  !                 (   !  

" !  !      !

    ! #   ! /0A  $"!     !""    !  '"!      "( "  "" (  &   !  /0A

   "           #    9

 "

 "   "!

( !# &!   :( 9. 20000@> # 5"" ( "

/0A %! "  9. 8B000@> "  #B &  9 !

5"" (98B000% 9. / 2000@> C-9

(" !!"   !6  

&  

("," *   # !

  "    !!+"

 "

/ :=)

        "  #5 %6 $#' ,7 :

;

2 <

 

+ 

&// &/95 &/1   



&011

 

+

5 2 4 ?





   >

  





@ 2A4





 

 @ 24  

 )

%

@ 2?4  )

  

   

%   

           >

  +

@ 2B4 $  



 

      +  

  )@  

%     >   % * 

    



 5

   &%  #"

 ,      "       #  ("     

 ! & "

 !

"  %  "! # .  000  . 80000 !

.  000&  

(  !  !   # 6"   "!# >'" "

> 7   "!#!(  "    '" ! "!# ! (#  & &  !    "!#   0A   &  7 !!

!# "  #(&    !

 - :=)

      8"%,#$#6 '

 82

05 % 9  :

 5 F/

      '"!# % !#&"9 &) ,  1 " 13 ;3

%13 3<

  !  ""(  #  (    B1& &( $"!(     -    ,"   *  &  5 !  

  &)  !G B0/*HB/00)*

,  82        !  $"!(      *"  6 &  ! "  !#"! 

!  #  )   )

!G  3   *  !  B00*HB)* ,  ((" >B &  " #   (   ( %! #&

  ! &!"!#& ! " !) *  ! "           "        "    # !      #   !

/

&-)  5

 1      #  1  ,    + ,   % - #1  < ,          !           !    !# !

"H (!   IG B0 *H0)*  !) !+ "$  "3 !I    B0/  *H  /  )*

 7  %   #   " H (! "   9 J  ,  (          & #   ! !  # #   !

    "          & ! #& !#&  !!   !      

  !      "    (       ( 9 

 "( ! "

"(

 !< 

5 "!("" < 

 #&   !  (    < 

! %"!(    &  #  '"!    "!    ""< ! 

5%  J

 C  "!D

  !  #  ;!

  $"!(   ) !+ "$   " (  "  ! ( & "! !( &  # !'" &        "    !        ! #& "!  !

,  " "    %      ! #&            !

@  ;             " "

# ! & K &   "(" B0  H " &B01

 "$" !#"  "!9 J "1!"#9 

"! "  "

" 

 "# #  

"! "# #(   

 "1!8 I    (  ! 

"#  "(  " 

 "  " 

 "# #( 7  "!  (   %!   ( " &     "(  !#& !" !) *      !  " 6   &      !  "$"    % ="  #!   1) !+ "$  "    &(     "   !  ""     !   !   #  !  7  ""'" &    

     !   !

  ( !"" " # !      (   ! #& 1 A

'"     #  $"!( -  ," * 5!

  "   &  2 !( (    "!# 0A  "   &    & )0, ,%% ,

 

 , 



 %  < ,          !         !  !           !"(     "  

 (A  $"! "  "!( H (! L "

G  

   (   "!" !#&  !" !     !A     !#& *"

5='

 

"   ! &( !

      "         #&     "    & "!

# !!  9 >%

+%% 5     (    . 828%B%1 @00 . /@> ="" 0 !!

. 80@> !   %  "!(   ( "



. 8228@> 5    .

00000@> 5         

 !   (& .  0000@>   !"( . B00000@>

  . 821@>

     "!   "  #  !      . 821@>   ! (                A    "

      !      !  & 

1

  ++  

 !

 +.0 %   



   



%  "

       )

2B>&,4



 *) 

%+   +  :+

   )

+  +



       

    



  



 



   +/, ,,,!5  

)

  %+ )%

 *) 0 " + )





+ * + 

,-&&.,&-   >

  )

 &,  

  

  

)%:=)

  (',?(,4!6 ',# ',6  =  ;@6% , 6'0 %"'

 0 

 

   2+.!- $+!) (

;>



 !

  

 

D06

 

  

 







  ;  && *   95"

 %

 





  

  + 

+  *)

+ 

 +  



 %   * *) 

 ) 

 



  + 

 

 

 !

 *

 !

 

 )8

 

  

*)  &.  

 %     

2  2 

 

 E    F



8!5

8 

8 F



 )

G !