Jyoti Chatrath And Another v. State Of Punjab And Another
! " #$
%&
!"#$%&'()$ %$' "
* %
'
()
!*+&,- " ) () .
& !/!& +)))+ #$) ()!&
%!*+&,- "
%& )0) %$' "
* %% +, % $
"2 & & !
- 340 ) %/"5 /"-*%2-
) 67687)9:)098360:)9;)098;
!
-<=8>=?>"!6!= "-
>- &@
- 07;
+<0<+3;0+<;3+;9A 2- !+,2B
+ * &22
%-
&/ "*
-*%*
= ?
<>) *%25
@ /"2 &$-*%2
%& )0 & %-
&/ -** & ) @ + @
, "
-$2
+"22
, &
&
2, &
& % + @- %% "*
-*%*
= ?
<>) * +
,./ %@ " $%/- "
%-
&/ @ 2&$ " 2 ?
-
&$
"%-
& + 5
&22
%-
&/
"**$ 5 &
"# - ) ,& & & &88)0)0909& - &
%% $ " 225 (/ 62 " -&/
+ - &$ " +& 225(/ 62 @ 2 & - &
& %) % - * + 2 &(+*
%& &09)<)0909 )C % 2 ?
& /2 "-*%2/& !/+(#D & && -& &87)<)0909) +2 &(+* --2 & &
%%%
, &-*%*
,2 2& --
& %
-
& --
&, $
& -2 & -2* & ""
) , &2 &-
2"
+%
& -& & %
$2 &(+* ) $ 2" %, " 340) ))@ 2&
@ / **.
-& + *$ -
/, ""
-& & & % $
%-
" @
- "# - )!
-<09) 5 22 ,"- & +@-%
-$
%- & " -*% &/" ""
& &
2& )
%/, @ """
22 / &2-** & & "-$
, *-$2
& & % +
- "-*2%
- @ 2&$ " 2 ?
-
) E$2
! % *$ "-
-2 &/
!" !!#B.S.Joshi and others , State of Haryana -.+
'/0+1/+ "22@ &$ 22 --
"2/,3-+'4.- .+5'6/78-.+9
, & 2 @ %% ,2, & %
-
&
& 2@) " +E$2 ! % Gian Singh :State of Punjab and another '/0+1/+
" & 2 @
& 2 2@
&$ ! % "5 / State of Haryana :Bhajan Lal9
'/00'
)
A8" # &/* & & '
!
"
#
$
%&'
(
"
)*+ , #
- +
,
(
!("
( - "
-
(
(
.- -
(-
(
/
(
$
(
(-(
.0
1
(
.
(- *
(
2 ( 3
(
-
(
- -
-
-
.
(
(-
(
(
( -
(
-
-
(
.
# "
#
(
-
(
#
#
-
+ ,
-
#
4 %%2/ 2@
& $ E$2 ! % %2 "# &/* & / + %% @
%
, & -*%*
+ - "
%-
&/ @ 2&$ * 2$
"%-
&$ 22@/&-- %/ % " $5 /
@ 2&$
- / "# - +@- %*2 $# -"
/ 2 -/ & !
-340)
2+ "& -
& 5 2"22
@ *$&%*
&$# &-2% - & & + -*%2-
) 67687)9:)098360:)9;)098; & !
-<=8>=?>"
!6!= "-
>- &@
- 07;
+<0<+3;0+ <;3+;9A 2- !+,2B
+* &22
%-
&/ "* 5 &5
-*%*
= ?
<>)
&2
22 *$ &$ * &-& -*%*
&
-& &$ " - $ 2@)
& 22@ &) %$' "
* % %&;$
2 -. C ./6 &'
6 C
%$2 '
6