High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2370/2013dismissed

Deepika Sharma v. Paramjit Singh

2015-10-12Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih7 pages

!"# $#%&'&()

* +"&,&-!.!/+! 0,,#11!(" 2#/'3'

!/!+4&"&(5. 0#',($#(" ) 6 7 77

/#'#(") / !'8&/&(5.9$:%!"#9 /".#!,,#11!(" / !';!19$:%!"# /".#/#',($#(" <<<

=.#".#/ /#,/"#/' 1%!1 ,!,#/' +!> 8# !11;#$ " '##".#43$5+#("? 8#/# #//#$"".#/#,/"#/'/("? =.#".#/ ".# 43$5+#(" '.31$ 8# /#,/"#$ &( ".# $&5#'"? <<< 77 /!1 3&" &1#$ 8> ".# ,1!&("&

;!' $#%/##$ 8> ".# "/&!1 %3/":&$#43$5+#("!($$#%/##$!"#$

'#:#(".# !,,#!1 ,/# #//#$ !5!&('" ".# '!&$ $#%/## !&1#$ !($ ;!' $&'+&''#$ :&$# 43$5+#(" $!"#$ @

9 $# #($!(" &' 8# /#".&'%3/":&$#".&'/#531!/'#%($!,,#!1 !/"&#'"".# 1&'9.#/#&(!

"#/9;31$8#/# #//#$"8>".#&//&5&(!1,'&"&(' &(".#'3&" (!'3&" &1#$8>".#,1!&("&

9.#,/!>#$ /!$#%/##

/,''#''&(8>;!> ',#%& &%,#/ /+!(%# ".#!5/##+#(" $!"#$ A

A9!'/#5!/$'".#'3&",/,#/">+#!'3/&(5 B +!/1!'

6CA@66 ' $# #($!(" .!,,#(#$ " 8# ".# ;(#/ &(

,''#''&(9:&$#!5/##+#("&(D3#'"&(9'.#.!$!5/##$"'#11 ".#'!+# /!""!1%('&$#/!"&( 9

E'3+

E ;!',!&$ 8> ;!> #!/(#'" +(#> !"".# "&+# #F#%3"&( !5/##+#(".#'!1#$##$;!'"8##F#%3"#$(

G A

*9(/#%#&," 8!1!(%#'!1#%('&$#/!"&( 1!&("&

.!$!1;!>'8##(/#!$>!($;&11&(5",#/ /+.&',!/" ".# %("/!%" ' G A

* ;!' ! .1&$!>9 ,1!&("&

!,,#!/#$ 8# /#".#38#5&'"/!/9!%..&;!/!( H A

*983";!' &( /+#$ ".!" &" ;!' (" ".# $!> &F#$ / /#5&'"/!"&( ".# $%3+#("' 1!&("&

!5!&(;#(""".#

&%# 38#5&'"/!/ ( ".# 11;&(5 $!> &# A

* !($ ;!' 311> #D3&,,#$ ;&". ".# 8!1!(%# '!1# %('&$#/!"&( !($ ".# 3($' " $# /!> ".#+&'%#11!(#3'#F,#('#'#/#+!&(#$,/#'#("&(".#

&%# "&11A)A*,+!($5".&',/#'#(%#+!/-#$ 3"".#$# #($!("

!&1#$""3/(3,($!'".#$# #($!(""./#!"#(#$"!1&#(!"# ".#'3&"1!($"'+#(##1'#9".3'9".#'3&" ( $# #(%#9 &" ;!' ,1#!$#$9 &("#/ !1&!9 ".!" ".# ,1!&("&

.!,,#(#$ " 8# ! +(#> 1#($#/ /+ ;.+ ".# $# #($!(".!$8"!&(#$1!( *

E 1!&("&

8"!&(#$ '&5(!"3/#' ".#$# #($!("(%#/"!&(81!(-,!,#/'"'#%3/# ".# 1!(9 ;&". !( !''3/!(%# ".!" .# ;31$ /#"3/( ".'# ( %1#!/!(%# ".#1!(!+3("";!'!5/##$".!"".#$# #($!(" ;31$,!>&("#/#'"I J,#/+(".!($'.#.!$'&(%#8##( ,!>&(5".#&("#/#'"#:#/>+(". 1!&("&

;!'!11#5#$".!:#

,1!>#$ ! /!3$ 3,( ".# $# #($!(" 5/##+#(" $!"#$

A;!''!&$"8#!'.!+"/!('!%"&( ( ! $3# !($ %+,/#.#('&:# %('&$#/!"&( ".# +!""#/ &( &''3#9!($ ".##:&$#(%# ( /#%/$98".".#%3/"' %(%3//#("1> %(%13$#$ ".!" %(%#$#$1> $# #($!(" .!,,#(#$ " 8# ".# ;(#/ ".# '3&" ,/,#/"> ,/:# ".# $3# !($ :!1&$ #F#%3"&( ".# !5/##+#("9 $!"#$ A

A F

9 ,1!&("&

#F!+&(#$.&+'#1 !' = 9!'!1'(# ".#!""#'"&(5 ;&"(#''#'9(!+#1>93-.;&($#/&(5.!' = .35.9.!( 7!1= 9!(".#/!""#'"&(5;&"(#'' ".#!5/##+#("9"/&#$" '3,,/" ".# :#/'&( ".# $# #($!(" &( .&' #F!+&(!"&(&( %.&# 983"%(%#$#$&(.&'%/''#F!+&(!"&(".!" &/'".#.!$ ,3" .&' '&5(!"3/#' ( ".# !5/##+#(" !($ ".#/#! "#/ ".# ,1!&("&

!' !1' ".# $# #($!(" .!$ '&5(#$ ".# !5/##+#(" # #($!(" !$+&""#$ .#/ '&5(!"3/#' ( ".# !5/##+#(" F

$3/&(5 .#/ %/''#F!+&(!"&(#!(&(5 ".#/#8>9 (" (1> ".# ,!/"&#'"".#1&'83"#:#(".#!""#'"&(5;&"(#''#';#/#,/#'#(" !" ".# "&+# #F#%3"&( ".# !5/##+#(" +3%. '9 $# #($!("#:#( !&1#$"'355#'"" = " = 9".!"'.#.!$ (" #F#%3"#$ ".# !5/##+#(" $!"#$ A

A .# .!$ !1' ("$&',3"#$".!"".#,1!&("&

.!$,!&$!'3+

E " .#/ !" ".!" "&+# #!(&(5 ".#/#8>9 ".# :#/'&( ".# ,1!&("&

/#+!&(#$ 3(%("/:#/"#$ 8> ".# $# #($!(" ".&(5 ;!'8/35."(/#%/$91#!'"!(>%5#("/%/#$&81##:&$#(%#9 " ,/:# ".!" ".# !5/##+#(" $!"#$ A

A ;!' &($##$ !

A /#'31" /!3$/;!'! !8/&%!"#$$%3+#("# #($!("= %(%#$#$&(.#/%/''#F!+&(!"&(".!"'.#(#:#/'#/:#$!(> ("&%# 3,( ".# ,1!&("&

" $&',3"# ".# !5/##+#(" !($ +!&("!&(#$".!"'.#.!$+#/#1>8"!&(#$!1!( *

E +3%.'9'.# !1' !$+&""#$ ".!" ".#'"!+,,!,#/'93,( ;.&%. ".# !5/##+#(" ;!' '%/&8#$9 ;#/# ,3/%.!'#$ 8> .#/ .3'8!($ .# &' 1&"#/!"# !' '.# .!$ '&5(#$ ".# !5/##+#(" F

&( (51&'. ".35. &" ;!' '%/&8#$ &( 3(4!8& #'"&+(&#' ".# ,1!&("&

9 !""#'"&(5 ;&"(#''#'9 (!+#1>9 3-.;&($#/ &(5. = !($ .!( 7!1 = 311> ,/:#$ ".# $3# !($ :!1&$ #F#%3"&( ".# !5/##+#(" :&$#(%# ( /#%/$ /#:#!1#$ ".!" ".# ,1!&("&

.!$ &($##$ 8##( /#!$> !($ ;&11&(5 " ,#/ /+ .&' ,!/" ".# %("/!%" ("#/#'"&(51>9 ( '355#'"&(;!'#:#(,3""".#,1!&("&

&(".&'/#5!/$91#!'".# ;!' %/''#F!+&(#$ D3! 8#&(5 /#!$> !($ ;&11&(5 " ,#/ /+ .&' ,!/" ".# %("/!%" .!" 8#&(5 '9 ".# (1> !($ ".# &(#:&"!81# %(%13'&( 8". ".# %3/"' %31$ !//&:# !" ;!' " $#%/##".#'3&"9!',/!>#$ /'&($&%!"#$!8:#9(".&(5;!' 8/35." ( /#%/$9 1#!'" !(> %5#(" / %/#$&81# #:&$#(%#9 " '.; ".!" ".# !5/##+#(" &( D3#'"&( ;!' &($##$ ! /5#$ $%3+#(" (%#$#$1>9 $# #($!(" (#:#/ +!$# !(> %+,1!&(" / &(&"&!"#$ !(> !%"&( !5!&('" ".# ,1!&("&

".35. ".# !5/##+#(" ;!' ,3/,/"#$ " 8# ! /#'31" /!3$ # #($!(" ,3/,/"' " .!:# 8//;#$ (1> ! '3+ *

E9 83" (".&(5 ;!'#:#( /#+"#1> '355#'"#$ !' " / ;.!",3/,'#

* ".# !11#5#$ 1!( ;!' 8"!&(#$ .# %1!&+#$ " .!:# 8##( /#531!/1>,!>&(5&("#/#'"(".#1!(!+3("I J,#/+(".9 83" (".&(5 ;!' 8/35." ( /#%/$ " '38'"!("&!"# ".# '!&$ ,1#! 7#!/(#$ %3('#1 / ".# !,,#11!(" %31$ (" ,&(" 3" !' " .; ".# %(%13'&(' ".!" .!$ %(%3//#("1> 8##( !//&:#$ !" 8> 8". ".# %3/"' ;#/# #&".#/ %("/!/> " ".# ,'&"&( ( /#%/$9 / '3

#/#$ /+ !(> +!"#/&!1 &11#5!1&"> .# (1> '38+&''&( ".!" .!' 8##( !$:!(%#$ 8> 1#!/(#$ %3('#1 /".#!,,#11!("&'K".!"!5/##+#("&(D3#'"&(;!'!

/5#$ $%3+#(" !($ 8". ".# %3/"' !&1#$ " %('&$#/ ".# ,/:&'&(' #%"&( ".# ,#%& &% #1&# %"9 H@ / './"9L".#%"6(".#;!-# ".#,/:&'&(' #%"&( ".#%"9&"&'%("#($#$9".!",1!&("&

35."("".!:#8##( 5/!("#$ ! $#%/## / ',#%& &% ,#/ /+!(%# ".# %("/!%" #1&!(%# &' ,1!%#$ ( 7!-.8&/ &(5. : .!( &(5. !($ !(".#/9

!($!+&(5.:35.!/ &(5.9

F !%&#9 ".# !/53+#(" ".!" &' 8#&(5 !$:!(%#$ 8> ".# 1#!/(#$ %3('#1 &' +&'%(%#&:#$ !($ %!((" 8# %3("#(!(%#$ ".&(5 %31$ 8# ,&("#$ 3" ;.#".#/!(>,1#!9&("#/+' ".#,/:&'&(' #%"&( ".# %"9 ;!' #:#( /#+"#1> '#" 3" &( ".# ;/&""#( '"!"#+#("

&1#$ 8> $# #($!(" / !(> #:&$#(%# ;!' 1#$ &( ".&' /#5!/$ ".&(5 ;!' 3/5#$ #&".#/9 &( ".&' /#',#%"9 8# /# 8". ".# %3/"'"43'"".!"9&(".#+!""#/&(.!($9$# #($!("$#(&#$

@ ".!:##("#/#$&("!(>!5/##+#("9!($/!".#/".#'!+#;!' !11#5#$"8#! /5#$$%3+#(".#(681#3,/#+#3/" &( /!-!'. .!($/! : !/!>!(9 9 &( ,!/!5/!,. *.!$8'#/:#$K

!"#$

'( )

* %

+, .!" 8#&(5 '9 $#%&'&(' 8#&(5 /#1&#$ 3,( 8> ".# 1#!/(#$ %3('#1 $ (" .!:# !(> 8#!/&(5 ( ".# +!""#/ &( &''3# ( ".# ;!-# ".# ,'&"&( !' '#" !8:#9 ".#/# .!/$1> #F&'"' !(> 5/3($9 1#!'" ,1!3'&81# &( 1!;9 " &("#/ #/# ;&".".#$#%/##8#&(5!''!&1#$D3#'"&( 1!;9+3%.1#''

!(> '38'"!("&!1 D3#'"&( 1!;9 !/&'#' / %('&$#/!"&( ,,#!18#&(5$#:&$ +#/&"&'!%%/$&(51>$&'+&''#$ %"8#/ 9

* !4!( /3( !11& 3$5#