High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/5592/2015disposed of

Randhir Singh & ORS v. Union Of India & ORS

2025-11-12Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja2 pages

RFA No.5592 of 201 5 (O&M)

+B "!+/ "!+/ "!+/ "!+/ BB?9 BB?9 BB?9 BB?9+/ +/ +/ +/9B 9B 9B 9B7 H8 7 H8 7 H8 7 H8 ,%%+ ,%%+ ,%%+ ,%%+ 9 9 9 999 99 99 99B 00##" !

00##" !

00##" !78 0+ ) !

0+ ) !

4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 "D''"

@"()*+,"!/+ "#$"

% &'()*+,"!/+ !'

"00##" ! %#'"-#"( " #+. #( !' 0+ ) !1 %+ +/ )%" 2'% "'"% (("

" EEEE ( ( ( (7 "#8 "#8 "#8 "#8 56 3 -"3 +/ 0 ! "00"#78( ,'"# ## & '" 2 #"%) !+ !' - -"

) )"!)9 :0")23!'#"

)))# %!

%,!.)&(+ 0"!7'

% "

!+2 /

!';

/ ,+.

!<8(-'

23 / , !%!%+ /%#).

) ,!%+ = +/ !'

' " ) ,>.%%!%+ ,!( =?:

: 7/+ '+ ! ;!' =?: ,!<8 "! !' % !" , +/ !' "00##" !1#" )+- -" 0"

!#3 "##+-) -'%# & " !% & !'

'@ 2 /%!+/ '"

,)@"

$!*"#.A 9(=( 1I0 ", >."!'",>.% )#"

" ) 2%)"-"

)% &+!'

!"!.!+ 32 /%!1% !

!% !'% /"*+.

"0 +*%)).

) !'=?:,! 596

) ,+. # /+ !' 0"

!% "

") %)@ !'"! !' @"!!

- -%!'

0,!!+!') !

@% "!%+ +/@"

$!*"#.!"

" )")D.)%,"!).0+ 23!'%+ +.

! *%)%!),%%+ )"!)F99F0")%

+?J ?J ?J ?J+/ +/ +/ +/9:

9:!%!#)"K4"

4"!"

% &'" )+!'

*!"!+/"

3" "" )+!'

*!"!+/"

3" "" )+!'

*!"!+/"

3" "" )+!'

*!"!+/"

3" "" )+!'

L-'

23!'%@%#"

#3%!."

"!) #" )+- 0 !

!"% % &!+!'"@",>.%%!%+ 0 +,)% &'"*2 '#) !%!

!#) /+ !' '" , ) "@+. ! +/ ,+@0 "!%+ A A 9:(:B(:FB1I 0 ", 2% %) )"@"&"&"% !

!* " ,+/#" )A BC +/!'@"

$!*"#."") )23 !' +.

!( "#+ + & -%!' "## !"!.!+ 3 2 / /%! #*" ! 0+ !%+ / +@ !' "/+ @ !%+ ) D.)&@ !%G!

",!)'

. )

I MOHMED ATIK 2025.11.13 17:12 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment

RFA No.5592 of 201 5 (O&M) K+ %) % &!'0,.#%"

/",! " ),% ,.@!" ,+/!'," +!

+!) "2+ +*( ,+.0#) -%!' !' "+ "/ "/+ @ !%+ )( !'% +.

! % +/ / !' ,+ %) )*%-!'"!"##!'"00"#/ /%#)23!'#" )+- ) *!+ +2 0"

!#3 ",,0!) " ) !' "@ "

23 "##+-) !+ !' G! ! % )%,"

"!) "2+ +* ' #" ) +- % !' "00 0"# "

%% & +.! +/ ",>.%%!%+ )"

)"!) = 9? " -## " !' #" ) +-

% !' "00"# "

%% & +.! +/ / !' ",> >.%%!%+ )"!)=F9?("

'#) #) !%!#)!+ ,%*!',+@0 "!

"!%+ /+ !'% ",>.% )#" )("!!'. %/+ @ @ "!+/ 9:(:B(:FB1I0 ", (/

/ +@ !' )"! +/ +!%/%,"!%+ . ) ,!%+ + : +/ !' ,! '3 "

"#+ '

'#) !% !%!#) !+ ,%* BC +/ !' "2+ +*"%) @"

$! *"#. + ",,+. !

! +/ * * " ,,'"

&%)!'%(!'#"

" )+- (% 2+!'!'",>.%%!%+ %+ ( '"

"##2 !%!#)/+ "##!'!"!.!+ 3 2 /%!"*"%#"2#!+!'@(. )

# *" !0 +*%%+ +/!',!L 56 * *%-+/!'!" )!"$ 232+!' !'%)+ /",!" )"00#3% & !' % ,%0#+/0"

% %!3" )/+ & " !+/D.!" )/"% , ,+@0 "!%+ (!'0 !"00"

"#% 0"

!#3"##+-)% !

@+/!'"/+ @ !%+ )) ),%%+ %4"!"

% &'" )+!'

4"!"

% &'" )+!'

4"!"

% &'" )+!'

4"!"

% &'" )+!'

* !"! +/ "

3" " " ) +!'

< "

3" " " ) +!'

< "

3" " " ) +!'

< "

3" " " ) +!'

< ," 7.0 "8 " ) !' "00##" !1#" )+- "

'#) !%!#)/+

%@%#"

"@+. !+/@"

$!*"#.

A 9:(:B(:FB1I0 ", 2% %) )"@"&"&"% !

!* " ,+/#" )A BC +/!'@"

$!*"#."") )23 !'+.

!("'"

"2 "-"

))!++!'

%@%#"

#3%!."!)#" )+- N"#+ &- -%!' "##!"!.!+ 32 /%!" )% !

!"*"%#"2#. )

!'"@ ))0 +*%%+ +/ "

" ) ,>.%%!%+ ,!

(=?:""00#%,"2#!+!'0 !",>.%%!%+ 5:6 )% &"00#%,"!%+ 78(%/" 3'"## "#+!" ))%0+)+/ +*@2

+*@2

+*@2 9 9 9 9(9 (9 (9 (9 !%$ 99 99 99 99B 7 4 8 7 4 8 7 4 8 7 4 8 M'

'!'

0"$% &1 "+ ) '!'

0+ !"2# 1+ 1+ MOHMED ATIK 2025.11.13 17:12 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment