High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2449/2013dismissed

Shamsher Singh & ANR v. Sohan Lal & ORS

2019-04-23Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan12 pages

""## $ % &#

" '

$() #* +,

' -(.#*+ ""##

' !

*+ "

//// ) #-* "#) + ,,

0%(!

#!# " + 1 %!

% !2

* 1 !

3-' +! ! #%" "1, " *, "2 ' 4$ 5 * . # ,## 2 '

6# (! %%1%! 1" "#* " -!

% "% "# " ""%

" "#

0%( 5 *

%1 ) +"# " " 7 58 % ) 9* . #* % 3),

0 ) !, #- *,

2" " 5% : ";%,"% 1-2

' ( 3): "##

' ( #-#:

, -!

1%0#, ,( "1% 1%," +!1" 1#* < " 1%, "% -#2' 4$5 ,

: " ! %"1, " * ", # " ##-"4$ " - 1% ! -# %#1, ##" :

% , , !" : % , 1 , 1(1%!!1-- " : %

,%#1! #- !% " # *, , 1 "#%" : =#2 " ,1% 2 +1-

, = #2" ,1% 2 +1-7

: ! %"*" ! #+* %#: %# % ##-1- " ## " , #1# ## : >", 1" #-% " --* ,11 1- " , " :

#% * "%,1#1- %%#" ",1 +

* %1 "#: 1% , %#- - ##

0%(

: "# ) +, <" " ", >% *+, ,! 1- "#,%#1### #1# # -#%!" # 1%

0,+ * * >#% "# !

" ## ":

1 !2'

6# , % "#: , "#;% * !+- " : "#( + # #+ * % + " " 1%+*!+! % "## %;%

* "" # , !+ %#!#1< ##!!1#- %*% ! % "#1 ! % 4 % "# %"" % ##!<% 5% - % ! * %1 "##-

##! #1 , "* ,+ *,: + ?*2 7 + , * ",%#1 *2" ,- ,%#1 ?2" *

0%( 5 * "# (! %" 8 * ,+ *, (, "# , , "

' ( ,, ";%* -"""-! !+% @*2

' ( " #

: ","% 1-

? 7

' ( + ! #7 2 ?

: 2' 4$5 ,#+

# ,#4>% * + # "# "! ( " # -1<% !

+ -#- *%, # "-,## " #%! "#1- (! #%

*% 8*2 "*, "# %1 +, !%##-,%, "#1% "- + !! #%: " #- 7 A !

# " " " 2 ' 6# *, "%

' (

! * " - # %

"#! " *##,!%,

"# # - <% ! ! " "C ''

"## % ;%#%" "1, " C

"## + - %* , % 1 "- 1- ! C ''

" " 1, " , #+

%1, "

+1#C '

% "#1#C '

"# 5% , #

C '

"# % # " %C '

%" " #-+#% "% " 5% <% C '

@ #

E " + *#!# " + "##- &#! 'B + "#,# !

* 7 !

! B 1>!

)11 *0, !F! ' 6>" B

.% *.B

! # %# " * #

D 5% %7 +% "#*% 7

! * % 7 D ! %##- % , , " " 2' 4$5 ,#+ "! <%!" # - %,"+% "# , % + +" " "# # %

F#!!! +1- <%! * 7 #""# 5% 3%!*. #*, ,!# # 3%!*. #*, +<%!@ ""#%"

#! <%! "1- #5% )!, <%! " 1- 5% 1#,* 7 # " !%# ""#1 5% *, ,% ""#"" %!

E + # %# " 1!!

E- ""#

" " " ;% 1 "

0%( 5 *

%1"# ) + E"% ;% ",1!"1-

@ * , ) + A "#

! %1;%#- "

,, " , " " +

' ( * % - """-! ) + "% @*2

' ( " #

* ","% 1-7

' ( + ! #7 2 ?

%# ! 1 , , <%% %* , ;% 1 + 8 E6+ # , 6""# 4: & ' ' E# #-" + +1#" " -* " #! %!

% * ##*% ! % -*1" - ## %

* 1!! -*#% +1# " " -:" , %"-+1#" " -1- # " " * ##1" - % " #% " , % #,!+ G % , "";% #

"# ";% 4 -%#"1#-""- "#1!!+!

' (

" *

# "## 1!1,

' ( 4 *1( 1" " # %

* , ) + , # # , #* #!# " +

> !1 ! # ?

>% 1-

' ( +% 7

6+(1* %#,%#1 7 ;% , " !

" ;%1% %##- - !

0%( #%" "* " ", 1#+ ) +*, %##-;% #!# " +*, ""

" %# " "6> ' + - %# E ! , 1!- * , 1, 2

0%( 5 * !

* 1 !

3-' % % -# 2' 4 $ 5 * 7, < * . # % 1%# " !##( 4 $ " 5#% ?* #% - " 1%#!,##1 +

4 1#%#-1!%- ! & %# ""## 1%#%" !% 7 "% " ;% ,

' ( *% 1 #% " " " "

1#+ , 0,+ *E! ,

# %# ""## " "##- #% * ", 1 #+

0%( 5 * "% " 1- 7 A !

' ( ! " , ! #+ - " #%

0%( 5 1 %1%1- , "

4 %!

(%" ""# " "#+

1% -#%1 1-#!

!+!+ 4 - +#" + #%+ 4 -%#1# ##! "- ?*2

4 >-# #4> , 1!

1-* #>%1 ,##1- FE 1#!1-1-+!""# 6> 'H - , " ,

2' 4$5 *, ! , % ,>## 5% 1#, + !

#- #% "# #1# ->%1, 2' 4$5 2' 6# , # 1 *% * "#,# % #% " " 2 ' 6# "# ,

%##-#- 2' 4$ 5 , 1#+ "! <%!" # - %, "+% "#% !

+ +" " "# #%

& %# ""## %

! " #$ %

( ) *

! " #+ ' "

, )

-+.

/(0 #11 2 3 4 4& 2 # ! "!!

.. 5* 4

! " -$

* 6 !

! " 1- , $ !

! "

1% ""# " % % >, % 1 + 1

7%1#;%#, ""#

<%! "1-1 5% 1#, ,## * 1 %" " " "" # "" + " #, 4 ##!#- -

F! " ""#* ,

) <

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#