Naresh Kumar Pathania v. Shiv Dev Singh Pathania
!"# $ "!
$$&& '
!) )!"# $ "!
$ * +,-&./'+.+0 $
"% '!
1##
134)5 3
"% 777 !
#(1
5"4
1
%
"% 5") "!
%!
!"#
4%
!#!"
16 !%!"!"% 5!)!1 (!% (# % !
1! 55:6 "!
42!% 661!5 %!" ;;
*
5"4"
%!" <
< !" !1!"#%
13<
45("
1
4":
!% (!% 6 !" 61%34 4!"% !"%32
4 !461%! 6
% "4!"9 % 39 %"! ;=
;> !%( 4!")!11 ("
3 !1
3! % !5% 0( 6(
**
5% 3
!"%3
!"# 5* 2"
)!"# ?
!"% "43:
- "4 2"!"
4 51( !" % !% 61 "3 %% 4 % % 61 !"%3 4 % (!%
4" !# %3%!%1 5"5
"2!% % "438(% 4!11 11<
5!81<38<% 9!"# 4)
:%
)!11 3%96 !" "4 "4! 6
% "4!"
% 39 %"! ;= "49
;> !%( 4!"
)!11 ("
3 !1
3! % !5%0( 6( 3 "42
4!"%
@ "4! <
>>*>
A(
"%%
4:!% ! 51 !: "4%) 6 !" (!%6 6
%<
:) 1 8(%%
4
/6""%!5
42 !%% " % "%6
:
9!"#6
1!:!"
<8@ 5%!" 3!%2 % !% 42!% %
!"%2 !"5
5% 6
"%! "%6
% 9
;> %2 %
62 !%( 4"% "48
!"#9
?39 % = "4% !41 "4! 2"
48<% #
"4*
"%3"
1< "@4 !"# %2
62
:
<
5% !5!%<:
!"% !4 62
1 !" % %:
"=<
61!5 %!"2 48<%
15(
112!"#! ( *
! 5*2"
"4C$$
! "%!%1 4%%
6 !"
< C$$
**
"15( % "4!%
(!%C$
"5 5%!"%
"% (!%C$
!% %% 42!% % !"%! !"5
5%C $ ; 1!
"
%6 ! 51 !:3%
:!"
4$B "0(6% 3 !
"#!"
3
+ !% "D$
"4 ! !#"
%(
"% "@4 !"# 2 :!"
$B
!:
6 $B
"%3!"
%
8(%% 51 !:
:!"
4
!"4
!"# 3
% :
"3 B
!"# 4
!"#
B "4B3
5%!) 1<6!
@ "4!
"49
#!
!2
4(5 D$= "4D$>
4 % 1 5( %3
5" !4
!"# %
5% "4 %
)!4 4(5 434 5!4 4! ( "4 !" %%
(
"4 2
5!4 4!"
)(
"% ( 2 1 5!4 4!"
)(
"% "
(1%2 %)!4 @(4#:
"44
;
>3% 4! :!
## 4
!4@(4#:
"44
1
%3
5!
%!"#%
5% )!4 3
"4:4!
!"4!"#
5( %"! ( "4 ( 3 "4 2
4 5!4 4 !" %%
* *
"%
1 2 112 4 )!4 @(4#:
"% "4 4
4
(1% "%1<3%
6 !" "4 +
"% #(1
5"466
18<%
"% "%
13% 112!"# !) (8 % "%!
1A( %!"
2
4 ! B
1
5(14
112
!"# ! (!%2 "!%! 2 11 81!
6 !" ! 6 !" ! "% !%( 4 )
% 1 "4 %
!! B
!%5 "8 14%
! !"6 !"
6 !%( 4)
"4
!"%
"<4
%!"8<%
"( (% !%!
!!!B
% 1
4 5( % 8 12 :!
4 :! 5" % )!4 "
5 4C !)B
?
6"4 "5"%
4!5% <
!"% (!% "4% (!%4
%8 4! :!
4"
%# ("4 1"
) B
!:6(#"
4 @(4#:
"% "4 4
6
4 8< %
45( % 8 12! ( % !"
!"% < 2C %% %!:
#(:
"% 31
45("
1"1<5"% !"5
4%6
"%2 "
! 61
, 1 "43! 9
;>3%
3!" (5 5!
5(: %
4!" 112!"#%
1
%
! ( 2
4
#( %2(148
%!"
"%%"%
1!
1 3% !
48
"!"4! 6(% % 5:
"
5 43 !# %1<
1!
4(6"
8<%
%3% %!"% 5
4!"# ("4
(8!)! !"
1 #! %
5! !"#% 62
11 5% 3
"3 ("4
5%!" "4 % $(81!5 $
:!
)!5%!"
/"
(% 455(6 "% 5%3 > 3!"% F!:"!
>
> DG3!%2 :
"%!"
4("
(% !F 4 6
"42"
48<% $("@ 8$B- 51 !:
!"% % ! 6! "%"% "48
!"#9
;>38(% ! "1 "48
!"#9
?32 !5 ! 2"
48< ! #
"4*
"@4 !"# !4 "@4 !"# 4 6 $B+ %
4! 6(% 4
"5" % (5% 4!"% "42"
48<%
"4%
5*
+
6 !4
5" % (5% 48<:
9!"# 5 :
"%+ "!
"%! !
"4* " !
4% !:!" "<:
""
%! !:6 "%%"% %% ! %
! "4! 6(%
%2
"%
"4 "@4 !"# 2!%
4%% 8("4
5%!) 61%
! "4! 6(%
4!"#% 2"
!6 9
;> ?
"4$B "@4 !"# 6
"5" % (5% 4!"% "48
!"#9
;>
"4!%! 8<2 < 5 :
"%
"%8 !5 11<
1!
4(6"%
*;*
5% !5!%<8!11 % 2% 2 )!"# 5% !55""
5%!"!" !
%=<
15(
)!1<
1!
4(6"%
5% !5!%<8!11 %4! :! % (!%8< 14!"#% %!%2 "%6 48<%
! "% "43
5% !5!%<8!11 6 2
%=<
15(
4!"
1<!"#(6"% 5% !5!%<8!11 38 !# %1< 148<%
%3% 5% !5!%<8!11 #!) "
!1% 2%
! 5" % (5% 4"1
11!"#!"
5% "#1 ?
"%8 !5 11<
% ! 2 "
"4@!"%1<2"
48< !: "4 ! #
"4*
"@4 !"#
2"
!6 "@4 !"# 2!%
4%% "4!"
5% "#1 ?
"%8
"4! 6(% 4 "@4 !"# 2 !1
!"# $B 6 5!
!5 11< "!
)!"# "<
%!"2!% %
"%
"%9
6"
"#!"# ! %
:%!:
%%!:
!:
(# %"
5
5
4!"# % !" % !: 5 :
"%(6"% 0)
":
"%1 "4
"%5
%8 51 !5 :61 2
8<% 9!"#% 5 "!5 1
)!4!"#
:) 1
! "% 41 "42 <8 59
:% <
>>>
44(1<6 42"
!6 ! 1 "48
!"#
;>+! 4 6 !%!" 1"#2!% % % "% $B "@4 !"# 51
1< 81! %
4(6"% "4
" (5 5!
5(: % 3"
(1%5 "8 ("4!"% @(4#:
"44
48<%
%
** ( !"#%
!"#31
45("
1 5(14"%6!"%(% "<!11 1!%<
!%<!"% !:6(#"
4@(4#:
4 8< %
4 % % + 5(14 "%
% "< A( %!" 2:(5 1 (8 % "%!
1A( %!" 22 !5 ! !"
A( ""
% ! 5( %%
5!
!% 62
("4
5%!"
$ %
#(:
"%2
" !4
!"# %
5% "4 5!
5(: % % 5
"%
8) 3 5(61 4 2!% %
"
*:
"%!"
43 % ! ( % ! %
5" !4
4)!
2%
1! 8
% :
!% "42!% (% "< (8 % 3% ( !%:( %
!1 (1% "%1<3% !" % 5"4
1! 4! :!
43 2
2!% "
%5 % !" # $ %& "4@