High Court of Punjab and HaryanaITA/239/2017dismissed

Pr. Commissioner Of Income Tax, Faridabad v. M/S Nhpc Ltd

2017-07-13Mr. Justice Ajay Kumar Mittal,Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal14 pages

Gurbax Singh 2017.08.19 11:45

!"#"$%&%'(

)%'$%* +,,%&&%'")'$," -.

)%# / # 00**"++ '! 1&

2& 3%,%!"#45"$.4 ,*+"-4 )%# / # 0 "&*'#"'! ( 63

3 63

5375

8 97:, ) %!! +4

#$ !%&!%' !()!) *

+, - . /"

#$ !%'!) * % "

# $ !%' !) * - -

!0)#" /

.# '0 12 # 34 )& )!

!) 0 #. "5 - " /

. # $, 6 1 2 34 "

# $ (%%76897!) % / !))( ): / ,- ; ,

142< / , +=- "

# , , !%(> / 76,52,089/- !%(>, ; ? 14< / , +=- "

# , , !%(6 /3,11,509/-

, , !((# / 10,78,208/- , ; ,? ( # ,

# $ !%' !) * / - /$ /- !))( 124,66,88,768/- , was processed under Section 143(1) of the Act, on 13.12.2004 at the declared book profit of 284,21,60,970/-. Subsequently, the assessee revised its return of income on 23.12.2005, declaring a loss of 173,16,33,768/- and the book profit of 374,06,15,970/-.

, - :(# / (%1%4 # , / !'

!))* / -@ 483,33,60,110/- - //" /

.1# 4A"

1#4B - 109,27,44,140/- -@ , / 374,06,15,970/-.

:> # , / - C # !))'

// , / , # !))

" , // /-@

/ #D :(

# :

% !)

, , !% !)

5 !% !)

/ -- # / - - / 28,28,14,257/- , - E"5 1F #/ D8.4 D 28,28,14,257/-, 7 19,51,55,078/- - /8,76,59,179/- was -@ / . ,

# - !%(>!%(6 # , , !((##

1#4 5 !!

) !) ! "

1#4 , $ , / , -

5 )& )!

!) 0 #. # "5 / - ,-

", @-# D , -"

1#4 , " , # D , /, @ :(# /

- "

1#4 :( 1 #4 # !%(6# , , !((## , ; ", - - !%(># - - //

:># Hence, the instant appeals by the appellantrevenue.

/ .

:> # C / !))( ): -

/ &*0:' *'7 / --

/ , - - @ - # D

/ !&7!'

!))0 1#. #

4 / -@,@-@ .

:># - @ 1 48. 1 4

:># # - / "

1#4 , - - - C # !))'

// /

( !)) 14 8.

:># 2 / / /

3 -

, /

- 1!4 G-@ = < # D :(# / -@ - - -- 148.

:># / /

/.7 ; - # , "

1#4 :(# ,

1#4 # D , , // , ,

- , "

1#4 , / - @

1 4 8.

:> # , , - - 14 8.

:># D - - 1 #4 :(#

C / ,

, !%(> !%(6# - ;

- - * /- ; , ; %-, ,; - 4 < / - # D , @, :(# , , - / - "

1#4 :(# , - , // / -C # !))' 148.

:># /

( !)) ? 1-4 < / !%(> !%(6# -

? & 8.

/;1 4 - ,-. - 1 4 1 #4 :(# , , -

" ;<= "$!%%$ !%',%&! >" 4< , / @ / /

0 /

4 / - # H 1-4 / / -- 1 4 (% / - - #4< / - -, - 1 4 / , , /- / - / / , - 3 '

- - 1 4 :(# / @ / I / /, / @ / - # +, , / - - , - 1 #4 :(# :(1 #4# - ,- / , - - - ", /, / - 2 / / , - 3

- , - /

) # - / . / - - --, / , , - "

1#4 " ,

:(1 #4# 7 , 2/ @ / 3, - - / - 7

:(# - @- #D " / - - 7 , ,/ "

1#4 - # D / , - - - - , ,@ -@

:># - -"

1#4 " - - "

1#4, /

/ :( # @-#D , :(1 #4#

,,-

2 , - - - - - - // " /

1# 4 ;-/ - //" /

.1# 4 - #D / , - - - - , ,@ -@

:># - - "

1#4 #/ :(

- @-#D , /

///

:># -

/ @ / -, ,#D

, //.- -@ "

1#4 "

1#4 , / /

:(# '

" " "

9/1 '&*4

00 "

J (:( 9 @ +

/ - 1 #4 :( / , - -, / - /- . , :(1 9

/ / - , ,- - / , - /

/ / - " /

. D / // / -// / , / / - / / // 8

/ / - // / @

/, , - / , - // - -" /

.D 3

@ 1-4 - ; , C @, :(# , ; , - - !%(> !%(6 # , #D /, @ :( # / - "

1#4 :(1 #4 #

!%(> !%(6 # , ; 5,/ !%(> # /

- / , -

. !)&# - . ,

. ')K .

.- ,

, .,

- - - ,

/ -; , / , /

- , !%(> # , - >/- + 1!) :4%*'"

J%0 !%(> #

,,-

2!!

8 /

D !%(> #

:># + ->/- + 1!) :4 0) ./ / %)% 1>/- 4 // " /

. /- < 8 9/ !%(>#

- , - - // # + - +

/ ; $ ! ; -- +-/ ,

, , !%(> "

# - /

- , /-@ / .

:> "

# . -- -@ , / " # !))

+, @

!%(>"

# -/ /

" / / / , -

. !)& .,

. ')K

, - ,

. / @ //" /

# , --; < / /# , -!))& /

. / !))0 )* / /- ,

., , , ,

, .,

- # / - , / , , -; /

% @

148. 1

G14 /

( ---C # !))& , /"#!))

/ G( - - , , G / =

,,2 -3-C # !))&,

( !))

3 - 2" / 1 414- -L=

/ " ,

/+=- += / -. + , /

, +, !%(>

!%(# /- - -

!)* !)& "

# , / - !

# $

, % !))

/ - - /

. , ,

;

-/ % D -!)) ,/.- , , / -@-

$ //

:> - # !))! , , + / /"# !))

* " , / / -@ 8. 14

:>,-- C # !))&, /"# !))

-- - / @ /

., , - ,

14 , -

- , - - C # !))&

. / - !))0 )* - - - / !%(>" /

# '0

& " " 14 9/ 8 1!))04 !&)"

J%!

./ !&+=-/ 2- 3, / .

- , / 0!)) -C # !))

- / @ / . - // ,

/ , -// " /

. 1# 4 C # !)) , / - C # !))!

// , / @

- / - -

/ = -//, -/ - // / - //, +,

, - - /, , ; - !))! // // , - , ; !%(> / " +=-/ 2* " /

; - -, .-, -- , // C # ,

", - ,/- / /- , /

, ; - M -

< / / @ , - /.

, - - , ,

- - / & - ,

; / - / / , 3 !) / - , ; / - / / , " , - ,, ,- + " - +, - - / < @ - - / !%(> . , - , - - C # !))& , - / , -

- / /

. / - / 1 4

< - ,; / , @ ; - ,

3 !% , +=->/- +, - - !%(># - -

:># 3

9 - - -

, - - ; , ; /

8 97:, ) %!! + :#?" :+94 '%+7&@"! )* + A?&6 :#?" < @7 "& < - "&