Malti Gupta Prop Caliber Institute For Further Education v. Commissioner Of Income Tax Jalandhar Punjab

 

     
 

 !"# #$%&%'( ) *

*
 

      

   

 +#,&-&      ! "#  $  %$ & '%()*+$ ,


-., $

+  ,/  '%()*+$ ,
 0(
' '(

(  ,/  & / 12
1  

 0 13
 
 
 4

 51  +. 
/0

  

 
  789    

 :;8:!)

)#4  



   * !) )#    4 

 2 11 799;5:9 7

 

 < 4  =  <     &

>  

  <   1 4      ) 4   )  ?  7;    4   1     
    @A!:#  < 
    B9 !7#!#    <     ?

  <  /


 ?:;B'

      3

"  ?:BC   

      "

     <     

)     

4 ?C  

 :;8:D

 >  

  

 < 4    ?@A!:#   

       

        <   4  2  <    <        < 

       1  4

  41  
  $  (    

 

 

 /1 E +  1    !:;A;#  ::F   $  78:  !
#    1    .1E $!:;89#
A@F ,)>  *<2 +1*

!:;:B#8 @;;!'+# 1 +1 $!:;C:#
7AFD


     >  

  <   4) 4 )    )   )   2

2 2 13 4)      )D @



   44 4 

     4  
 4 4

    

   $      2  799;5:9    7;9;799;    4      $;8 9@9?5/  412 

    $:

AF :A A@7?52 4   $F:

@9 999?5<     <  

 <3

  2 

 
    :B@!7#     

    =     <      7A9F79:9    7C9B79::     4  %   !

%#      



2   24 <    <

 2 4 3

    4    1          %  <  

1   <C9G      2   

 

         %           $B9 8C 999?51 78:779:: B

44 1 

<      !

#H) !

#I

 C  

  4 1  4<

    

  <       

  2  7:         B@    <

 <     !

# 2<

1 9B9F79:B  < C9G 

 <

 1  

!

#  

<& ))%      1      2  1

     221  (B7?:@

 

 

 1   4   <  21 <3    1 2  4<  

      1 

  22

      2

    <     <  1  1  221       1   <1  4  1(  1       <1          1        <      1             2<   12

       4  214 1   2     = 2  4%     1     <  1    < 41    2    

          

  

  << 2  4% 1   1   

 << 2        2                  4<< 1    =  <  = < <

   21 D

1

  =       <  1    4      

  4( 4 2   

1 4      2

   52 2   2 2 <  

   

       1 2     

     

     2 21        1 <   

  

    2  1 

   1  221            1     2 1    <   " 2

1   1        1 <  1  1 22



  3<2       1               <  

1 "

< 1     4 % 1 <  4%  3   2    1 < 4 



 <1)) 8  

<   1  7B9879:8  

$1     = <& ))F>1 1  14 4     >     

  

   

1  1      4   <  2$79 999?5   2    2  2                

        <      1        <   <  
     2  1 4 

 

    

 

2       <   1        $A 999?5 < <           @C     <  

  J $79 999?5         <    

    

   4        1          2                 

 1 

       4 

           

   1      4    $79 999?5  $:9 999?5           4           



  $A 999?5 $A C9 999?5$:9 999?5

4 1    2 

 2J$79 999?5   1      1   <         <     2

    

     

   4     <    2  4       =   2                  <                   1   4   2  4

= 

  2  

  ')  ' 4      4 1  77A $FB8 2  

     1 2<              4  1  3    

    2    4    1 4< 3 2  1  >1  4  !

#        4        1            4     <<    <     2    $B     2 1 47B / 2  
 2  $C 999?5   .  2 1 4:@:5

(<  <  (4   
 2        $@ 999?5  

 2 1 47C  2 5 / (4      $@ 999?5           .  2   1 4    ' (B7@? 
(:9 (
 4
1 
    $:A 999?5  
 2 1 4 1  +   

2 ;   

 1  

  

    <<)) A '  

2

5 F + 

       4

<  

 2 ' 4     

2   1    %           1   4           1   4   =  <     ;

  2 

  <  :9

  

                    4    < < 4   

  (

< 

   < 43  <

   <      2<

  <  22 

   

1 2 !

#< 

27:

 B@<  1    



   <

   4 <4 1  1 4 < 2

  

  /
 22 =   <          4    

   <  1   5     

     < 1          4

      << 

 < 

 <44  4  ::   <     

                  

                     4  %   <2C9G       :7

  

       1    1        



%   1 1  3 ) 

 <   %1

32

1    :@

   <1     4   < C9G    

 <2   2   4   

 1 1 2  2 <   :C (  =  <   

 :8



 2     3
/    +. 
 ) *

*    > 3 4? -?( >$ & -?(