State Of Haryana v. Chander Bhan & ANR

IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH

RFA-5780-2015 and connected cases* Date of Decision: November 10, 2016 State of Haryana and another ...Appellants

Versus

Chander Bhan and another

...Respondents

CORAM:

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ARUN PALLI

Present:

For the State of Haryana:

Ms. Safia Gupta, AAG, Haryana For Claimant(s)/Land owners: Mr. Anoop Kumar, Advocate, Mr. Amandeep Rana, Advocate, Mr. Harsh Bunger, Advocate, Mr. H.S. Lalli, Advocate, Mr. K.K. Saini, Advocate, Ms. Meenakshi Sharma, Advocate, for Mr. M.L. Sharma, Advocate, Mr. Mukesh Yadav, Advocate, Mr. P.R. Yadav, Advocate, Mr. Sanjeev Sharma, Advocate, Mr. S.S. Khurana, Advocate, Mr. Sudhir Aggarwal, Advocate, and Mr. Ved Parkash, Advocate.

ARUN PALLI, J. (ORAL) This order shall disposed of a bunch of 84* Regular First Appeals.

Learned counsel for the parties are ad idem that the matter in issue is squarely covered by the judgment rendered by this Court in the case of Pushpender Kumar and others v. State of Haryana and another [RFA No. 5316 of 2014 (O&M), dated 27.05.2016], vide which in the appeals arising out of the same acquisition, this Court had enhanced the

compensation awarded to the land-owners. The requisite details as regards the compensation awarded (village-wise) and enhanced by this Court are tabulated here-in-below:

Sr.

No.

Name of the Village Compensation awarded by Land Acquisition Collector (in Rs. per acre) Compensation awarded by Learned Additional District Judge, Gurgaon (in Rs. per acre) Compensation awarded by this Court in the case of Pushpender Kumar (supra) (in Rs.

per acre) Badha 60,00,000/- 1,81,01,217/- 3,75,70,419/- Bhangrola 50,00,000/- 88,25,208/- 1,81,44,000/- Dhorka 60,00,000/- 1,39,87,202/- 2,92,98,240/- Hayatpur 60,00,000/- 1,77,71,110/- 3,52,00,000/- Kankrola 60,00,000/- 1,06,48,000/- 2,24,97,003/- Mewka 60,00,000/- 1,23,95,226/- 2,54,06,080/- Naharpur Kasan 38,00,000/- 1,09,43,525/- 2,30,83,872/- Nakhrola 60,00,000/- 1,47,03,212/- 2,88,14,349/- Nawada Fatehpur 60,00,000/- 1,48,86,729/- 2,48,64,000/- Shikhopur 60,00,000/- 12,10,70,693/- 16,89,35,120/- Sihi 60,00,000/- 3,33,78,186/- 7,02,70,659/- Sikanderpur Badha 60,00,000/- 1,29,21,393/- 2,06,97,600/- Wazirpur 45,00,000/- 1,18,25,000/- 2,55,89,760/- For, concededly the matter is covered, all these appeals are disposed of in terms of the decision rendered by this Court in the case of Pushpender Kumar (supra).

And, as a necessary consequence, the appeals preferred by the State of Haryana are dismissed.

YES / NO Whether Reportable:

YES / NO ...contd...

* Detail of Bunch:

Sr.

No.

Case No.

Title 1.

RFA-1072-2015 M/S MARIABELLA BUILDERS AND DEVELOPMENTS PVT LTD V/S STATE OF HARYANA & ORS 2.

RFA-2142-2015 RAM KANWAR AND ANR V/S STATE OF 3.

RFA-2345-2015 SAMAY SINGH AND ORS V/S STATE OF 4.

RFA-2411-2015 RAM NARAIN (DECEASED) THROUGH LRS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 5.

RFA-2412-2015 SATPAL AND ORS V/S STATE OF 6.

RFA-2413-2015 HOSHIAR AND ORS V/S STATE OF HARYANA & ORS 7.

RFA-2414-2015 RATI RAM (DECEASED) AND ORS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 8.

RFA-2415-2015 JAI NARAIN AND ORS V/S STATE OF 9.

RFA-2416-2015 PARTAP SINGH AND ORS V/S STATE OF HARYANA & ORS 10.

RFA-2417-2015 LALLI AND ORS V/S STATE OF HARYANA & ORS 11.

RFA-2418-2015 SATDEV AND ORS V/S STATE OF 12.

RFA-2419-2015 BHOORI AND ORS V/S STATE OF 13.

RFA-2420-2015 BAHADUR SINGH DECEASED AND ORS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 14.

RFA-2421-2015 INDRAJ DECEASED AND ORS V/S STATE OF HARYANA & ORS 15.

RFA-2422-2015 MAHABIR AND ORS V/S STATE OF HARYANA & ORS 16.

RFA-2423-2015 SULTAN AND ORS V/S STATE OF 17.

RFA-2424-2015 HANS RAJ AND ORS V/S STATE OF 18.

RFA-2425-2015 DAYA RAM AND ORS V/S STATE OF

19.

RFA-2426-2015 SARLA AND ANR V/S STATE OF HARYANA & ORS 20.

RFA-2427-2015 SHANTI AND ORS V/S STATE OF 21.

RFA-2428-2015 SHEO NARAIN AND ORS V/S STATE OF 22.

RFA-2429-2015 LEELAWATI AND ORS V/S STATE OF 23.

RFA-2430-2015 DAYA RAM AND ANR V/S STATE OF 24.

RFA-2431-2015 BRAHAM PAL V/S STATE OF HARYANA & 25.

RFA-2471-2015 BIKRAM SINGH V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 26.

RFA-2472-2015 BIKRAM SINGH V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 27.

RFA-2550-2015 DALIP AND ORS V/S STATE OF HARYANA & ORS 28.

RFA-2552-2015 SURENDER YADAV AND ANR V/S STATE OF HARYANA & ORS 29.

RFA-3648-2015 STATE OF HARYANA TH ITS COLLECTOR GURGAON AND ANR V/S RAM SINGH AND ANR 30.

RFA-3649-2015 STATE OF HARYANA TH ITS COLLECTOR GURGAON AND ANR V/S MOTI RAM AND 31.

RFA-3650-2015 STATE OF HARYANA TH ITS COLLECTOR GURGAON AND ANR V/S SATBIR AND ANR 32.

RFA-3651-2015 STATE OF HARYANA TH ITS COLLECTOR GURGAON AND ANR V/S M/S KAMDHENU PROJECTS AND ANR 33.

RFA-3652-2015 STATE OF HARYANA TH ITS COLLECTOR GURGAON AND ANR V/S RAM SINGH AND ANR 34.

RFA-3653-2015 STATE OF HARYANA TH ITS COLLECTOR GURGAON AND ANR V/S M/S MONARCH BUILDCON AND ANR 35.

RFA-3654-2015 STATE OF HARYANA TH ITS COLLECTOR GURGAON AND ANR V/S M/S CAPEX

PROJECTS AND ORS 36.

RFA-3655-2015 STATE OF HARYANA TH ITS COLLECTOR GURGAON AND ANR V/S SAMEY SINGH AND ORS 37.

RFA-3656-2015 STATE OF HARYANA TH ITS COLLECTOR GURGAON AND ANR V/S MAHABIR AND 38.

RFA-3657-2015 STATE OF HARYANA TH ITS COLLECTOR GURGAON AND ANR V/S NANAK CHAND AND ANR 39.

RFA-3658-2015 STATE OF HARYANA TH ITS COLLECTOR GURGAON AND ANR V/S RAM SINGH AND ANR 40.

RFA-3659-2015 STATE OF HARYANA TH ITS COLLECTOR GURGAON AND ANR V/S MEENA DEVI AND ORS 41.

RFA-3660-2015 STATE OF HARYANA TH ITS COLLECTOR GURGAON AND ANR V/S RAM KHILARI AND ANR 42.

RFA-3661-2015 STATE OF HARYANA TH ITS COLLECTOR GURGAON AND ANR V/S BHOOP SINGH AND ANR 43.

RFA-3662-2015 STATE OF HARYANATH ITS COLLECTOR GURGAON AND ANR V/S VED PARKASH AND ORS 44.

RFA-3663-2015 STATE OF HARYANA TH ITS COLLECTOR GURGAON AND ANR V/S LILU RAM AND 45.

RFA-3664-2015 STATE OF HARYANA TH ITS COLLECTOR GURGAON AND ANR V/S JANAK RAJ AND 46.

RFA-3665-2015 STATE OF HARYANA TH ITS COLLECTOR GURGAON AND ANR V/S M/S GENTRY PROPBUILD AND ANR 47.

RFA-3666-2015 STATE OF HARYANA TH ITS COLLECTOR GURGAON AND ANR V/S DHARAM SINGH AND ANR 48.

RFA-3667-2015 STATE OF HARYANA TH ITS COLLECTOR GURGAON AND ANR V/S CHANDER BHAN AND ANR 49.

RFA-3668-2015 STATE OF HARYANA TH ITS COLLECTOR GURGAON AND ANR V/S JASWANT AND

ANR 50.

RFA-4522-2015 SATBIR V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND 51.

RFA-4560-2015 HARDWARI V/S STATE OF HARYANA & 52.

RFA-5622-2015 MOTI RAM ORS V/S STATE OF HARYANA & ORS 53.

RFA-5780-2015 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANR V/S CHANDER BHAN & ANR 54.

RFA-5954-2015 RAM MEHAR AND ANR V/S STATE OF 55.

RFA-5955-2015 RAM CHANDER V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 56.

RFA-5956-2015 LAKHPATI AND ORS V/S STATE OF 57.

RFA-5957-2015 RAJ KUMAR AND ORS V/S STATE OF 58.

RFA-5958-2015 RAM KANWAR V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 59.

RFA-5959-2015 BANWARI LAL V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 60.

RFA-5960-2015 PARTAP SINGH AND ORS V/S STATE OF 61.

RFA-5961-2015 PUSHPA YADAV AND ORS V/S STATE OF 62.

RFA-5962-2015 DAYA RAM AND ORS V/S STATE OF 63.

RFA-5963-2015 KRISHAN AND ORS V/S STATE OF 64.

RFA-5964-2015 SHER SINGH AND ANR V/S STATE OF 65.

RFA-5965-2015 LAKSHAY AND ANR V/S STATE OF 66.

RFA-5966-2015 SARBATI AND ORS V/S STATE OF 67.

RFA-5967-2015 SHRI CHAND V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 68.

RFA-6094-2015 INDRAJ AND ORS V/S STATE OF HARYANA TH COLLECTOR GURGAON AND ANR

69.

RFA-6095-2015 RANBIR AND ORS V/S STATE OF HARYANA & ANR 70.

RFA-6096-2015 SARDARO DEVI & ORS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ANR 71.

RFA-6097-2015 PRATAP SINGH & ORS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ANR 72.

RFA-6098-2015 MAM CHAND AND ORS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ANR 73.

RFA-6099-2015 MAHENDER SINGH & ORS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ANR 74.

RFA-6460-2015 JITENDER AND ORS. V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS.

75.

RFA-6467-2015 ANIL & ANR V/S STATE OF HARYANA & 76.

RFA-7329-2015 BRAHAM PARKASH V/S STATE OF 77.

RFA-80-2016 RAM SINGH V/S STATE OF HARYANA & 78.

RFA-991-2016 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S SAVITA W/O SURESH KUMAR 79.

RFA-992-2016 THE LAND ACQUISITION COLLECTOR, SECTOR 14, HUDA GURGAON AND ANR V/S SMT. ASHA AND OTHERS 80.

RFA-993-2016 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S BALBIR SINGH S/O MAM CHAND AND ANOTHER 81.

RFA-1061-2016 M/S HALIBUT DEVELOPERS PVT LTD V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ANR 82.

RFA-1062-2016 M/S GLIMPSE BUILDWELL PVT LTD V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ANR 83.

RFA-1063-2016 M/S PROSPEROUS BUILDCON PVT LTD V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ANR 84.

RFA-1064-2016 M/S GALLIUM PROPBUILD PVT. LTD. V/S STATE OF HARYANA & ANR (ARUN PALLI) JUDGE November 10, 2016 Pkapoor