High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/6135/2019dismissed

Laxmi Devi And Others v. Kuldeep Singh

2023-10-11Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal3 pages

!"#$%#&'('$)*++ ,-./'#0'!)1$"2#3( 4#"'"'$)#3( 0#3(-( 5-61##78')92 4+#(7$)1#)"

$3!/*

3#(#)"* 3+8!):'05-/!3!1!0;10$&!"#%$3"2#7#"'"'$)#3(+ 3+!"#28!')';10$&!"#%$3"2#3#(7$)1#)"+ <<<

2'( 3#0'('$) 7#"'"'$) 2!( =##) %'6#1 => "2# 1#%#)1!)"( "$ &2!66#)9#"2#&$33#&")#(($%$31#31!"#1?+ + 7!((#1=>"2#"3'!6

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

; 2# &$)"#)1( "2!" (-&2 !/#)1/#)"&$-61)$"=#!66$@#1=>"2#"3'!6 $-3"+

2'( $-3"2!(&$)('1#3#1"2#(-=/'(('$)+ E 2#&!7"'$)$%"2#-)!/#)1#1(-'"3#!1(!(-)1#3* F

" "

# $ "

%&'$!( "

%&)$$'

*+,( ) *+,( '

*+,( -( .&-& %&/( 0 1 2 3 4

( ,+ ,)+,, 1 '++,,( 4 3 %

$ 5

$ -( 0 1 2 3 #

4 ( 6 1 &7&& 8

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

76!')"'%% @!( &!66#1 -7$) "$ 7!> $-3" %##; @2'&2 @!( 1#7$('"#1=>2'/')"2#>#!3+$@=>@!>$%!/#)1/#)"$)6>! %$3/!"$%"2#(-'"2!(=##)&2!)9#1($!("$!0$'1!)>"#&2)'&!6$=:#&"'$) @2#3#!( ') (-=("!)&#; "2# 73!>#3 @!( !63#!1> #.'("#1+ 2# :-19/#)" 3#6'#1-7$)=>"2#6#!3)#1&$-)(#63#73#(#)"')9"2#7#"'"'$)#3(')C

;"2#8-73#/# $-3"2#61"2!""2#!/#)1/#)"$% 76!')" &!))$" =# !66$@#1 !%"#3 "2# #.7'3> $% "23## >#!3(+ $@#0#3; !( !63#!1>)$"'&#1')"2'(&!(#;(-=("!)"'0#73!>#3"$"2!"#%%#&"2!(!63#!1> =##)/!1#+ 5##7')9')0'#@"2#!%$3#(!'1%!&"(;)$93$-)1("$')"#3%#3# ')"2#73#(#)"3#0'('$)7#"'"'$)'(/!1#$-"+ ? $@#0#3; "2# 1#%#)1!)"( (2!66 2!0# 6'=#3"> "$ 73!> %$3 %3!/')9$%!)'((-#$)"2'(!(7#&";@2'&2(2!66=#%')!66>1#&'1#1=>"2#

$-3"$)!773#&'!"'$)$%#0'1#)&#+ G B'"2 "2# !=$0# (!'1 $=(#30!"'$)(; "2# 3#0'('$) 7#"'"'$) '( 1'(/'((#1+ 66"2#7#)1')9/'(&#66!)#$-(!776'&!"'$) ( ;'%!)>;!3#!6($ 1'(7$(#1$%+

++ : ;

< $ = >$% ;

3 = >$%