The Pr Commissioner Of Income Tax -3 Ludhiana v. The Ludhiana Central Co- Op Bank Ltd Near Sadar Police Station Civil Lines Ludhiana
GURBAX SINGH 2018.10.29 14:22
!"#"$%&&' ( )"$!"* +,,"##"$ ) $!, -./01("
&&&&** ++ & )#0# ( /01("
+ *& $3/ 1&./01("
&&&
#*$1 &
4%5)&
#(7
!(.4)&4
$1"$80$# + ) ** ++ . "$& 5)&2"9 34
(".4)&4
$1"$80$# + ) ** ++ . "$#&:. $1: & 5)&2 )0$5"
+.19!
) 5)&2"3 #5( $0*
.19!
) #*$1 . "$& 5)&,
".19!
$1 5)&50$"#(7 *"+ .19!
) #*$1 . "$#&:. $1: & ;;;
& ("#)1 )#( ++1"#*# <0$!( 0) **
+#<
)"$8 #&.:. $1: !!)1"$8 +
)$ 1!0$# + ) #.#","+ )"##0 "$9+9 "$& & ( #<
$*)
)) 1<= $0 0$1 )4 "$ > $!, -!
.>?"$#() @ AB "$# )1
1 && ?$$ -0) B * 1 <= $!, - ** ++
)"<0$ +. "9"#"$ $!(. ( $1"8 )( ?(
) )
)) # @ )"<0$ +AB "$ & :>CC. ) ##, =
) . !+ ","$8 ++D"$8#0<#
+E0 "$# + D% ?"B F(
)$ $1"$ !")!0,#
#
!
. $G<+ .( $1"8 )("#60# " "
"$1
"$8 11"
"$ ..'.C, <=
$ "$
!!)0 1 $ $$ ) ),"$8
# <= "8$)"$8 1 !"#"$ $G<+ 40*) 0) "$ !
*)
1"$?'>B:' H ?""B F(
)$ $1"$ !")!0,#
#
!
. $G<+ )) 1 "$ **+="$8 "$ !*
"9 #!"
= "& &
D("!( "# $ #* !" "!
++= , "$ 1 "$ "$H """B F(
)$ $1"$ !")!0,#
#
!
. $I<+ ( )) 1"$ ++D"$8
1 !"#"$ "$ !
## ##, =
)# '.') *)
1"$:?(1B
**+="$8 4 "$ . 0$6 < 4
*
"9 $3 /","
1 "# 4!( 10+ 1 $3 D(
/01("
+ *
"9 $3 /","
1"#$ #!( 10+ 1 $3&HA 40<# E0 +=.9"1 )1 )1
1&&* 1"$5&> . ++D"$8 $1 1 #0<#
+ E0 "$# + D D
$ $ !)1% @"BF(
)$ $1"$ !")!0,#
!
. $I<+ . ( $1"8 )( "# 60# " "
1"$1
"$8 11"
"$ ..'.C <= ## ##"$8 "!
) $
!!)0 1 $ $$ * ) ),"$8
# <= "8$)"$8 1 !"#"$ $I<+ 40*) 0) "$ !
) *)
1"$?'>B :' H
""BF(
)$ $1"$ !")!0,#
#
!
. $I<+ .( $1"8 )("#60# " "
"$1
"$8 11"
"$ ..'.C, <=
## ##"$8 "!
) $ "$
!!)0 1 $ $$ * ) ),"$8
# "8$)"$8 "$1"$8 ## ##"$8 "!
D( "# ++D"$8 , )!
"+ #=#
,
"$8.( #(D"$!, C) "* #$ !!)0 + < #"# <0 ) !8$"
"$ "$
$ ?$ ) ),"$8##
#B #$) "* #"#<=
#(D#
(=<)"1#=#
, "$8"# < "$8 ++D 1<=
D("!("#$+$8 ),"##"<+ D"
(
),&&H & $#&:. $1: . ++D"$8#0<#
+ E0 "$# + D(
$) "# 1% ?"B F(
)$ $1"$ !")!0,#
#
!
D #!)) "$"8$)"$8
4 "$ $!, - !
. > D0+1$ **+= *
"9 $3H ?""B F(
)$ $1"$ !")!0,#
#
!
D #60# " "
1"$+ D"$(+1"$8
4 "$:J !
."# **+"!
<+ "$
!
.D( $4 "$:
!
. -!+01 # "
**+"!
"$ !*
"9 $3#H ?"""B F(
)$ $1"$ !")!0,#
#
!
( )) 1"$+ D"$!$ "),"$8
1 !"#"$ /1&?BD(( 1D)$8+=) +"
0*$ "$1"$8 $G<+ +(""8(0) "$ !
5C#2 #"# (( =2= )/ 1&K #&::.:>: :.& . #& . >>. : ' $1 & ' 1
1 !"#"$&&LD("!("# $ $3"$8 $!"
+ )*)
"$. D(
0$1 ) !$#"1
"$ "# *
"9
4!"
=H ?"9B F(
)$ $1"$ !")!0,#
#
!
. ( )) 1 "$ !$ "),"$8 !"#"$ /1&?BD(1
11"
"$ ..>.'C , <= $
!!)0 1 $ $$* ) ),"$8
# <= "8$)"$8 1 !"#"$ $G<+ 40*) 0) "$ !
4
$3 ) $!) ?:' BH D )."
, =< $ "!
E0 0, 11"
"$#"$& $1 &: "# 1"
"& & ..>.:>C $1 .:.:>.'C) #* "9 +=& &
)<) 9"
=. "$8
1 ),& :& D #$ )= ) 1601"!
"$ "$#
**
+ ))
"$, =< $ "!
1&(
"+ 1"
#)
0)$ "$!, $ && 1 !+ )"$8 $ "$!, .:..:C& ( ##, D !,*+
10$1 ) 4 "$ ?B !
<= ## ##"$8 "!
)9"1 )1 )1
1&&?$$ -0) B
$"$!, '..:'.'CD"
(
11"
"$ ..'.C$ "$
10 $$
) ),"$8 ##
# ? B&
+"$8 88)"
1.
"+ **
+ < ,,"##"$ ) $!, - ?**
+#B K ) <) 9"
= @ ?BAL& ( ?B 9"1 )1 ) 1
1 '&& ?$$ -0) B 1
11"
"$ <= ## ##"$8 "!
)& 8 "$# )1 ). $$ -0) . $0 "+ **
+< )"<0$ +D(9"1 )1 )1
1&& ?$$ -0) B1"#,"## **
+ $0 0*(+1"$8 1
"$ <= ?B $ 11"
"$ ..'.C ) )1"$8
!!)0 1$ & . *) **
+#<= $0 & >& /
)$ 1 !0$# + ) ) $0 "$
+"
#0<,"
"$8 *
"9 $31 #$ ++0$1 $= !
8)"
!
#* !" "
10$1 )4 "$ D("!(*)9"1 # )* =,
- $"$
$< 11 < #)10< 0+1 < #$+="$ =
) ) "* $1.
."#$ 4 "$ & D
)80
"$9"
D *)9"#"$# 4 "$: .
"# +"
<+ * =
-$ "$
"$!, !!)0 "
0$1 , )!
"+ #=#
, "$8.D(
))$ "
( #<
++=) "9 1& 0) ). D # 0)8
D( + 8"#+
0) ( # , #* !" "! *)9"#"$ ) #* !" "! #. # D0+1 !9 ) $+= (# $1. . "$ D0+1$
1"$ *) !
&F( #* !" "!*)9"#"$"$ $
0) 4 "$ ( #<
$,
#+"3
-!+01 1 ), *0)9"
D .
$$ "$1") +=!+ ",< D("!(D0+1 ,0$ #","+
0$1 )4 "$ &
+"
D #*+ 10*$ 6018, * - 0) "$ "#$%&'( &)%("*"+,&- ,.,$&/ 0 ",($
"..,--,"(&'
"1 ()".&23
",.42$"'& 5 !
& )( $1.+
)$ 1!0$# + )
#0<,"
"$!, !!)0
"# -"8"<+
- "$!, D("!( !!)0 ##(0+1<
+"$!, $1$ (=*
"!
+"$!, &F(
"#
# . "# ( )1+= $= +"3 +"(1 ) "*
$& D # 0) ) #0<,"
, )!
"+ #=#
,
"$8 !
$ < ) $+= 1
),"$ *"$ ",
D("!(
<"+"
= "#
$1 !
$$ < ) +"
1 0*$ 1
),"$ D(
"$!, ( # "$ ) #0+
1 ) ,
)"
+"M 1 "$ 90)
& !!)1"$8 +
)$ 1!0$# +. #* *)9"#"$# 4 "$:J
)9 $3 $1"
.?"$#() @ !
AB *)9"#"$# (
)( $9 ))"1"$8
9 *)9"#"$# ++ )+ D#
80"1 +"$ # ( 9"$8 <
$ "##0 1 0$1 # "1 (
).
7
D0+1 *) "+ 9 *)9"#"$# $!, - !
&
+"
D *+ 1$ 6018, +(""8(0) "$ "..,--,"(&'
"1 ()".&
23 0
2-,-$%
%28
8292'
$/ 5
. D( "$ "
D +1
D( "$
D #$ "9 1$ ."
!0+1$
!!)0 1"$ 90)
)
+"$!, "$ ( $1#
& 40**) D +# 1) D$ ), 1 !"#"$# 06
"8( 0) "$ ! "
#"$ " ?B: $1,< ="8(0) "$
" % & #' ( & )& " % & ?:B & 0) ).
)$ 1 !0$# + #0**)
)1 ) * 1 <= ?B 1
"$8
11"
"$, <= ## ##"$8 "!
)$ "$
10 $
"), 1<= )"<0$ +& = ) )1"#,"## + **
+#D #, & '&
<0
"$8 )80, #)
"$8 *)9"#"$# !
") "$#C) 80+
"$# ),0+
1C"##0 0$1 ). "
D # !$
$1 1 <=
)$ 1!0$# + ) $0
1") "$#0$1 !
*)01 + $),#. <0 ( $ ("$8 1 D"
( !,*0
"$ )
<"+"
= *)9"#"$ 0$1 ) !
& (08( 1") "$# 1 9"
), "$8 *) "!
# *)9"1 1 <= ,* $"
#!
.:><0 =1$ 9 ))"1 *)9"#"$#
= *
"$8"$1"
"
+1#&/ +=."
D #*"$
10
)$ 1)"<0$ +08( ( ( +1
!*
"9 $31 #
"# = !$1"
"$# !")!0+ )& &C'C'C
1 &&' !0+1 $ "+ < # "1 !")!0+ )& $ < #"# "1 #0<,"##"$#. +
)$ !0$# + 0) ) 0)8
#0<#
+ "##0 "$9+9 1 "$ <9
**
+#< 1 !"1 1"$ 90) $0 )1 )* 1<=
## ##"$8 "!
) 0$1 ) # "$ ?B $!, - !
< !$ "), 1& &
)(
)"$8+
)$ 1!0$# + ) * #.D 1$ "$1 $= )"
"$ **
+#& & ( !) "##0
)"# # )!$#"1
"$"$ **
+#"# D(
) "$
$ $$* ) ),"$8
# "$ ( $1#
*
"9 $3#"#
<+ $ !!)0 +< #"#)$ .3
*"$8"$9"
D 80"1 +"$ #
)9 $3 $1"
& & *)!
,"$ 9 )"0# ) #
)= *)9"#"$#
+ )
"9 1601"!
"$ *) !$ )9 )#=& & ( + 8"#+
"9 ("# )= 4 "$ !
, = < "!
1& 4 "$ !
D # "$#
1 D& & && <= ?&B!
& *)9"1 # )* =,
-$"$
$< 11 < #) 10< 0+1 < #$+="$ =
) ) "* &
1# (0#%
" !
:
#$ % %
& ' ()*+ #(
()*+$,
%
%
# $ #$
-+,
#$ % %
-
&+ " '
()*( #+- ()*($,
#$ % %
.
+(/
' ()*+ #( ()*+$
0 1
' . 0 #$ -+ 2
(-
3 ' +4(
() 5 ())(
60
@
7 3
8 '
: 8 ' & 3
;
2
;<
= 2 3
44 (
>
44 4 ?
3
&-5
;<
= 2 3
>
5 3
44 - 3
())4
())40)-
>
2
&
!
.
"9 ), && #0<#
)"8"$ ++=
14 "$ D"
( ++D"$8% ;
!
#$
,
8
" !
#$
% 8
% 8
8
()9/ #*- ()9/$,
% % !
# $
' ()*+ #( ()*+$,
# $
1
0
,
# $
8
"
' #8 5 ()9)
-@
-( 8
()9/ #*-
()9/$,
#$
% %
& ' ()*+ #(
()*+$,
#$
%
%
# $ $ 0 #($
-+,
#$
% %
-
&+ " '
()*( #+- ()*($,
#$
% %
.
+(/
' ()*+ #( ()*+$
0 1 2
:& = 9") #0<# "$. #!* ,<"
4 "$ D #D"1 1D("!(( #<
-*+ 1"$ 1
+ ")!0+ )&1
1 (4
,< ) #0$1 )%
*+! ,
-.( " " &
/ :& $1 -"# "$8 *)9"#"$# 4 "$ $!, -!
."$ !
*0<+"! "$ $!"
+"$# "$) #!( 10+ 1 < $3 ) 4
$!"
+ )*)
"$ ) 4
$10# )"
+$9 )*)
"$."$!, <=D = "$
"$
"$ #0!(!
8)"
# < 1)10< 0+1 < #. #, =< *) #!)"< 1( 9"$8) )1 80"1 +"$ #"##0 1<=
)9 $3 $1"
."#!( )8
<+
-"$ *) 9"0#=
)"$D("!( "#!) 1"
*) "
$1+## ) !
, = < ."$D("!("
"# ++=) "9 1.D("!( )"#
)+"
)& :&&F"
( 9"
D ",*)9 9"
<"+"
= (0#"$8 "$ !,* $"
*)9"1 <# (0#"$8 # ).
!
. $1# 4 "$ #
$1 "
*)9"#"$# *0<+"!!,* $=D(# , "$<6 "#!
))="$8 <0#"$ ## *)9"1"$8+$8
), "$ )!$# )0!
"$ ) *0)!( (0# # "$ $1"
) ) #"1 + *0)*# D("!( "# ) 8"#
1 "$ !!)1 D"
( 0#"$8 ,* $"
#?B") "$#.'.8"9 $0$1 )# "$ "$
"$ + 0#"$8 $3 !
. '& (
.*)9"1
"$ !
#0!( !,* $=.
"$!, <=D = "$
"$)
"$ #0!(!
8)"
# < 1)10< 0+1 < #. =< *) #!)"< 1( 9"$8) )1 80"1 +"$ #"##0 1<=
"$ +0#"$8 $3"$)
"$ #0!( 1 < #. #( ++ < !( )8
<+
- "$ *) 9"0# =
) "$ D("!( "
"# !) 1"
1 <= !,* $= "
# *) "
$1 +##
) !
, =< "$D("!("
"# ++=) "9 1<=
!,* $=.D("!( )"#
)+"
)& :&&("# $1, D"++
), # 1 = *)"+ $1D"++ !!)1"$8+= **+="$)
"$ ##, =
) $1#0<# E0 =
)#&?4 "$'B&A >&
0+ > $!, - 0+ #.>?"$#() .@ 0+ #AB
#* !"
+*)9"#"$#) )1"$8"$
$< $110< 0+1 < # $!"
+$# "$#.< $3#
!& D #"$#
1"$ 0+ #<= $!,
- ? ( , $1, B 0+ #. D"
(
), && *) #!)"<"$8 $3#C "$ $!"
+"$# "$#C!)*)
"$# D("!(*)9"#"$# 4 "$ D0+1< **+"!
<+ & "#E0
1< +D% @
+A 3 &-5
6!
#$ #$ 0
0 #$
!
#($
,
#4$
> >
>
,
#-$
,
#&$
0
,
#*$
>
0
>
,
#+$
,
#/$
,
#9$
>
>
0
> ,
#)$
>
,
#(@$
0 1
0
>
0 ,
#(($
>
0
,
#(4$
,
#(-$
#(&$
#$ 3
0 #$
!
#($
#4$
0
,
#-$
(@B (*B
#$
#$
0
5
#$
5
#$ $ 2
& "$ #"$#
1<= ?&B!
D& & && $1#0<#
1<= .D& & &&* $# D"
( !+ 0# . $ +=. @ D"
(#
$1"$8 $= ("$8 !$ )=!$
1"$ $= )*)9"#"$# ("#!
A (0#.9 ))"1"$8 *)9"#"$# &4 "$ *)9"1
"$ !
0<+"! $!"
+ $# "$ ) 4!( 10+ 1 $3 ) 4
$!"
+ )*)
"$) 4
$10# )"
+$9 )*)
"$. "$!, <=D = "$
"$ )
"$ !
"$ !
8)"
# < 1 ) 10< 0+ 1 < *) #!)"< 10$1 0+ > 0+ #.#( ++< !( )8
<+
-"$ *) 9"0#=
)"$D("!("
"#!) 1"
1<= 0<+"! $!"
+$# "$) 4!( 10+ 1 $3 ) 4
$!"
+ )*)
"$ ) 4
$10# )"
+ $9 )*)
"$ "
#*) "
$1+## )
=
)) , =< "$D("!("
"# ++=) "9 1<=
"$# "$)< $3) )*)
"$D("!( )"#
)+"
)&$ )D)1#.4 "$ "#
!
3"$ 4 "$ !
& ( 40*) 0) "$ "
" & 0 ?B :?4B <)
#!* $1 )
#$ ) "$8 # "1*)9"#"$& D #( +1
"$
),< $110< 0+1 < #"$ !
< $3 $1 "$ $!"
+"$# "$#"# 1" "!0+ $1 $ )0# ) !9
-"$8 #0!( "$!, $ !!)0 + < #"# 10!
+"E0"1"
= $3C "$ $!"
+"$# "$D"
(0 8
"$
$="$!, &(0#.4 "$ D #"$#
1D"
( # "1*0)*#
,"
"8
!")!0,#
#
-"$8 "$!, !!)0 1 ), < 10< 0+ 1 < -!
"$ =
) ) "* ) "$ =
) "$ D("!( "
"# !) 1"
*) "
$1+## .D("!( )"#
)+"
)& '& ."
D0+1< +
*)9"#"$# !
&
%29$&'
;
<'"0,-,"(- '&*2$,(+ $"
"(2(=,(+
(-$,$#$,"(- &)&,0,(+ /&9"-,$- 2(/ >,(2(),2* (-$,$#$,"(-
"$: !
++"$8"$(
) # "*0+
*)9"#"$# ("# (
) #( ++ $ **+= 4
$3 $1 9 )"0# $3"$8,* $"
#)
8"$ + 0) + $3) *
"9 $3) *)", )= 8)"!0+ 0) + !) 1"
#!"
= ) *)", )= !) 1"
#!"
=& "# "$ ++D"$8
),#% &)$,"( !
@!& (
) $ **+= "$ !
"$ !
#& ( *)9"#"$# ("# (
) #( ++ $ **+= 4
$3) $3"$8!,* $= #1 1"$4 "$: $3"$8
80+
"$ !
. ) !)) #*$1"$8 $ D < $3 #1 1"$!+ 0# ?1 B 4 "$:
)
#0<#"1"
)=< $3 #1 1"$ 4
$3 $1"
?40<#"1"
)= $3#B!
.:)
8"$ + 0) + $3 !*
"9 < $3 ) *)", )= 8)"!0+ 0) + !) 1"
#!"
=) *)", )=!) 1"
#!"
=%
)9"1
) *0)*# # ("#(
).
7
,"+ 10 $10# )"
+ $9 )*)
"$ /","
#( ++$ 1
$3"$8!,* $=&A "$:)
1 "$"
"$#"$) #* -*) ##"$#0# 1"$9 )"0# *)9"#"$#0$1 )(
) &4 "$: ,*D )#
1
),"$ *+"!= $1"##0 1") "$#&
1# (0#%
<
#($
0
1 0
0
>
0
0
0
0
0
#4$ ? 1
#($
0
0
0
#$
0
,
#$
0
0
0
2
"$:J*# 0+
(
) #( ++( 9 ))"1"$8
9 )+ D#"$ ++D"$8
),#% @!?(
) 9 ))"1 )+ D#( *)9"#"$#
("# (
) #( ++ (
$ D"
(#
$1"$8 $= ("$8 "$!$#"#
D"
(!$
1"$ $= )+ D ) ", < "$8"$ )!
) $="$# )0, ( 9"$8
<=9") $= #0!(+ D&A
)9 $3 $1"
( # !+ ##" "
++
# $ D("!( "#
0+ "$* =, "$
)"$) =, *)"$!"* +#0, ),)
#* !" "
1* )"1 # & & ( 06
"8(0) "$"
#"$"
1!
?#0*) B.1 +9"$8"$ #!* 4 "$:J !
$ "!
#0$1 )% @() &*C
6 ;&*0C '
!3 '
2
4@ &*C '
3 '
>
D
0 3
:
& ( (
1
0
#<$
3
0
3
. 0
3
.
< 3
2
4@
&*F
()-&
5"' (()G5.#<3$0)9
-( F ())9
<
0
" ' # "'$ 3
% "'
<
$ 5 ())9%#
5 ())9$
& 4!* **+"!
<"+"
= ") "$#'"##0 10$1 "$: !
E0") #!$#"1
"$& ") "$#'. +=1"#!+#0) $),#)$),#) )1"$8*)
"$ *)9"#"$# "$ #(
$ & $1 )4 "$:.*D )"#8"9
) 80+
)= ) D)3 "$9+9"$8 *) #!)"* "$ *)01 + $),# ) #D("!(
3"$81 *#"
$#0)
# 0$!
"$
$#0$1 $1(
(=+"$ #&( *)", )=<6 # "1'") "$#"# *)01 . $#* $!= $1 1"#!+#0)
&*F!, # 0$1 ) (
D("!( 1
+# D"
( *)9"#"$# )
"$8 $!"
+ $# "$#. $$< $3"$8$# "$#) "9"$81 *#"
# ), *0<+"!&( # "1' ") "$# 0!( 9 )"0# #* # #0!( # "$!, ) !8$"
"$N
!+ ##" "!
"$N *)9"#"$"$8.
!& ( < #"# ' ") "$# "#
"!"*
1+## #,0#
$"$ <0 -*
1"$!, $
1$ <
$ $
& ( . ") "$# $#0) !
#( +"E0"1"
= ) # D("!( $D ) E0") #
)0 $1 !)) *) "
#. D"
(0 *)6 "$8"$ +
1*) "
#&( ."$0)9"
D. ") "$#'1
+ $+=D"
(*)
"$ *)9"#"$#"$ 4(
$ & ( #$ ("$8 1D"
( !,*0
"$)
<"+"
= *)9"#"$# ) 0$1 & "# !+ )" "
") ()0# ") "$# '"#$*)
"$ *)9"#"$"$ 4(
$ &
"$C1"#!+#0) "# 1"
),!,*0
"$C
<"+"
= *)9"#"$ ) & ( $
0) -* $1"
0) 0$1 !
!
$$ < !$!+0#"9 +=1
),"$ 1<= , $$ )"$D("!( *)
1"$
),# ' ") "$#&
$ 3
*# !$!
# "$ ,"$1. "
"# 9 )= !+
") "$#' , +=*)01 +$),#&( =!
+# < !
++ # 1"#!+#0) $),# ) $),# ) )1"$8 *)
"$
)9"#"$# "$ 4(
& ( = 1 $ 0!( 0*$ $
0) "$!, ) -* $# D("!("# 1 !"1 1<= ## ##"$8 "!
)"$
##, *)!
1"$8#& & (
#$# )"##0"$8 1") "$#'$
1# 1 +9 & $ &&'. ") "$# ' "$ )10!
$ D ) 80+
)= D)3"$9+9"$8*) #!)"* "$ "#!+#0) $),# ) # $#0)
# 0$!
"$ $ #0$1 $1 (
(=+"$ #&
80+
)=
#0* )9"#)=
"$ D # !0## 1 $ 1 *#"
3"$8 # #
<+ 1"#!( )8 "
#) #*$#"<"+"
*)
"$
*#"
)#&( # #0<6
*)01 +) 80+
"$#$9 )"0#
#* # #0!( # "$!, ) !8$"
"$N
!+ ##" "!
"$ $1 *)9"#"$"$8.
!&( #"# )=<0#"$ ##"#
"!"*
1+## #,0#
$"$
<0 -*
1"$!, $
1$
$$
&("#"# #"#
") "9 ' # "
"# !+# )
+"
= !
#( +"E0"1"
=
*) # ), !++ *# & ( ") "$# ' 1
+ D"
(
"$ *)9"#"$ "$ 4(
$ & '. 4(
/!!0$ $ D E0") *) 1 "$ !!)1 D"
(
# $1 4!( 10+ 2 # *)9"1 4(( ,* $"
# !
. :> +"3 $= ) !,* $=& 4!( 10+ 2
,* $"
# !
. :>#* !" "!
++= *)9"1
)9"#"$ ) 10< 0+ 1 < # #(0+1 < ) 10!
1 ), 8)## ,0$ < )# #& # D ++D"$8 # *) "!
1"#!+#0) "$ ") 01"
1 "$ $!"
+ #
# 1$ <= ,* $=& 2"1
. #$ "!
1"$ " " & 1!
?#0*) B.
( #, $1
)= #( ++1"#!+# "$"
# 4(
)9"#"$ D"
(0 $
"$8 , ), $!, ) ), 9 +0
*)9"#"$#( ++< 1"# "$!
+="$1"!
10$1 #
1# #% ?"B*)9"#"$# ) < $110< 0+1 < #. $1 ?""B *)9"#"$# ) 1 *) !"
"$ "$ "$9 # "$ 4(
0$1 O0)) /"
<"+"
)9"#"$#O
#0!(*)9"#"$ )
!( =
#( ++< 1 <"
/!!0$ #
)0 $1!)) "80) O
) "
O8
#)
1"$ "$ $!"
+ # !,* $=&(
#0!("#!+#0) "# "$!)
!0)) +"
<"+"
#<=#(D"$8 *)9"#"$
"$# *##"<+ /##$
#!+ ##" "
# &#* )#0<*
.O *)9"#"$##( ++< 1"# "$!
+="$1"!
10$1 )#
(
1#
#O $ /"
<"+"
= #"1 < #(
0$1 !
"$ O!0)) +"
<"+"
$1*)9"#"$#O& & - ,"$"$8 **+"!
<"+"
= 4 "$ : !
.
. D , = #
"$ ") "$# ' )01 +C
)9"#"$"$8 ),# "##0 1 <= 0$1 ) (
) !
& ( ),# 1
+ ++= D"
( $!,
!8$"
"$& ( = )!
# 1"#!+# ,0$ "$ ") "$ $!"
+ #& ( = )!
# O )0 $1!)) O*) "
#&=9") &*C
()-&
5 ())9
00 % % ' :>&( ") "$#!$#
!1 <="
+ &D ). ") "$#'
"$1"
#&( '") "$#( $ ("$8 1 D"
(!,*0
"$
<+ "$!, &( ") "$#!
$$ 9 ))0+ O* ),"##"<+ 1 10!
"$#O ) O ") -!+0#"$O 0$1 !
& ( "$!$#"#
$!= <
") "$#
' "# $+= "$
) $!,
!8$"
"$ $1*)
"$ $!"
+4
#&( !!0$ "$8 +"!"
1*
1 <= $ !
$$ 1
),"$
<+ "$!, & "# D ++ #
!!0$ "$8 +"!"
# ++D 1 <= !,* $=!
$< !( $8 10$+ ## !, !$!+0#"$
#0!( !( $8 D0+1) #0+ "$0$1 )#
*) "
#&D )."$ *) . ## ##"$8 "!
)( ++D ") "$#'"$9"
D "$ :J !
& . # $!,
!8$"
"$ "# !$!
)$ 1. (&* !
( #$)+ *+ ="$ *) 1"#*0
&
4&
3 '
#$
60
;*/
5
())9
)01 +C )9"#"$"$8),#"##0 1<= 0$1 (
) !
. & ( ),# 1
+
++=D"
($!,
!8$"
"$&( = )!
# 1"#!+# ,0$ "$ ") "$ $!"
+ #& ( = )!
# O )0 $1!)) O*) "
#&=9") 4 "$:J. $9 ))"1"$8
"#8"9 ") "$# ' 9"# 9"# O"$!, ) !8$"
"$O *)"$!"*+ # "$ ,* $"
# !
. :>& ( ") "$# !$#
!1 <= + &D ). ") "$#' !
*
"$ 1"
#&( ") "$#'( $ ("$8 1D"
( !,*0
"$
<+ "$!, & ( ") "$# !
$$ ))0+ O* ),"##"<+ 1 10!
"$#O)O ") -!+0#"$O0$1
!
& ( "$!$#"#
$!= <
") "$# ,* $"
#!
"#$+="$ ,
) $!,
!8$"
"$ *)
"$ $!"
+4
#&( !!0$ "$8 +"!"
1*
1<= $ !
$$ 1
),"$
<+ "$!, & "# ++ #
!!0$ "$8 +"!"
# ++D 1 <= !,* $= !
$ < !( $8 1 0$+ ## !, !$!+0#"$
#0!(!( $8 D0+1) #0+ "$0$1 )#
*) "
#&D ).( "# !
D( ( ++D
") "$#'"$9"
D 4 "$:J !
& . #$!,
!8$"
"$"#!$!
)$ 1.4 "$: !
( #$)+ *+ ="$ *) 1"#*0
&A :& D #!$!+01 1<= * -0) "$"#$%&'( &)%("*"+,&-
,.,$&/- )2-& 5-#9'26
1") "$#( $ ("$8 1D"
(
"$8
)
<"+"
= "$!, 0$1 D.9"M&
!
") "$#. ' *
"$ 1"
"
+1#& ( 40*) 0) ( 1!+
)+=) !8$"M )= )
+"$!, $1( +1
$ D"
(#
$1"$8
, = < ++D"$8 , )!
"+ #=#
, "$8."
!
$<
1$)
+"$!, $1$ !!)0 1"$
D("!("#(=*
"!
+"$!, &
>&
$1 . !( )8 "#$*) "
$18 "$#.$ $8)## "* #?D("!((D ).( #*) "
,< 1"$"
B&( .#0<6
E0") # .*) "
10$1 ( 8 < )
+ *) "
# D("!( ( < !,*0
1 $ )1"$ )= *)"$!"*+ # !,, )!"
+ "$8& $ ) D)1#. *) "
# ( 8 < !,*0
) 1 10!
"$8 +## #C -* $# # "$!0)) 1 ) <0#"$ ##. (08( #0!( +## #C -* $# #, =$ 1,"##"<+ 0$1 )# "$# 0$+ ###0!( +## #C -* $# -*) ##+=)<=$ )=",*+"!
"$1"# ++D 1<= !
& & ( +(" "8( 0) "$ 2-,-$%
%28
8292'
$/- )2-&
5-#9'26( #"$ !$
#","+ )"##0 )"#"$8"$ !
$$ < $3"$8 "$ $!"
+!,* $=( #( +1
D( 0$!
=*) "+ 1"$#
#) !9 )= "$
*)"$!"* + ,0$ + $D #!$!
)$ 1."
# + 8"
",
"$
"$
$ *)"$!"* + ,0$ ( 1 $ @ !!)0 1A&( <# )9
"$#)
#0$1 )% @& $ ("##!
)".D ( ,"$ # $8 ("$
#0<,"##"$ +
)$ 1 !0$# + )
$0
D(
) "
!
$ # "++ < ( +1
"$!, "$ ),
(08( $ ) "9 1 ( 1 # "++ !!)0
0$1 *)9"#"$# 3
$1D #.
. -"8"<+
-& 0) $#D )"#"$ $
"9
$1D 8"9 ++D"$8)
#$#"$#0**) % ?B
")# ++D D0+11"#!0## ,
)"$ +"8( *)9"#"$#
3 ,"$ D(
)"$ 8"9 $!")!0,#
#."$
"$!, (
!!)0
& "# #
!#
"$
1,"
1*#"
"$"#
( ) "9 $= "$
$ # "1 *+ 1 D"
( 4( DF ++!
#"$!
##, =
)> #"
( < !, # "$ !!)1 D"
( )01 + $),#
D("!(D
1"$ <3# #&(
# 0) ) #0!!
## 0++= 1 ,$#
$ "$ #0!!
1"$8 ##, =
)#. $ "$
D # ) "9
*#"
"$) # 0$ "+ ##, =
)# >&
#$
)# $!"
+ !")!0,#
"$ $!"
+ !)0$!( 1 <= 4( D ++ &4,0!(#."
D !"$8D"$1"$80**
"$# D("!(D "+ 1<=, $=!) 1"
)#&( !")!0,#
#. $0$!
="$# #) !9 )= "$
D !$!
)$ 1. #0+ "1*) )"0# "$ $!"
+ *#"
"$ 4( DF ++ &F(
+3 "$
.
*)"$!"* + ,0$ "
+ ( 1 < !, 10< 0+ !9 )&$ ("##!
)""
D #+ 8"
",
,9 "$
"$
"$!, 0*$( #$ O !!)0 1O&F "$ 8)
D"
( #0<,"##"$ 5)&2() $ ("# !0$ . #0**)
1 <= 9 )"0# 1 !"#"$# 1"
"8( 0) # "$!+01"$8 ("# !0) D("!( ( +)
1= <
)) <9 & ?B $ "$#
!
.
!,* $= < "$8 "#89 )$ 1<= *)9"#"$# !
& $ #0!( !
. "$
"$!, !
$$ < # "1 !!)0
( 9"$8 ) )1 *)9"#"$# # "$ :J )01 + ),# "##0 1 <= "$ )!"# "
# #
)= *D )#&#* $),#. ( 1< !,
$1$#0!( D( "$
D #$ "9 *##"<"+"
= ) !9 )= D +,# $"+. "
!0+1 $ <
(
!!)0 1"$ 90)
&
1
'
3
8
'
!
1
H
0) .
1 <"
1 '.>'.:> # *)9"#"$
"$# "$ *) "
$1 +## . D("!( D
-+#($ #$
3
<
-+#$#9""B !
& ( ##"$8 "!
). (D ). 1"1 $ <)"$8
- ..>: # "$!, ?< "$8 "$!, !!)0 1 0$1 , )!
"+ #=#
,
"$8B&( 1"#*0
* -!0) !
)0$1 1 10!
"<"+"
= *)9"#"$ ) &
+=M"$8 *)9"#"$# !
. ")/)1#("*# * - 0) <# )9
"$ # ),"##"<+ 1 10!
"$# ) -!+0#"$# 0$1 !
!$!
)$ 1. # 1,"##"<+ $+= " #0!( 10!
"$#C -!+0#"$# #
"# = ) !$1"
"$# "*0+
) 0$1 !
&
."
D <# )9
)01 + ),# 1 $ 9 ))"1 *)9"#"$# &D ). * -0) , 1"# "$!
"$D"
() )1 O$!,
!8$"
"$O $1( +1
"$!, ( < ) !8$"M 1 "$
),#
)01 + ),#. (08( # 1 9"
1 ), )!
"+ #=#
, "$8 $1C) (&* $!, -!
& !
$< # "1. .
* - 0) **)9 @)
+ "$!, )= D("!( "#
$8) 1 "$ )01 + ),# ) ) !8$"
"$ $0 <= &A ( # "11 !"#"$D "), 1<= 40*) 0) "$&&&:' 1"#,"## 1$&&&
7
'&
"# $D , 6018,
1 2
3 $ < #"# D("!( $ #0<#
+ E0 "$ + D ( # <
$ !+ ", 1 <= ) $0 & $ $2$& 2(= "1
'202()"'&@- )2-& 5-#9'26
#0<#"1"
)= 4
$3 $1"
. 0# ,
"$ # $ , )!
"+ #=#
, , 3"$8 )"
# $
!!)0 + < #"#& (
1*
!
$1 ) =
# "
#*) 9"0# =
!
$1 )=
)#>.>: $1>>D #* "9 += *) 9"0# =
)# ) ## ##,
)# >:>>. >>> $1 >>' D("!( E0 "$)
1&$ !0)# "
#< $3"$8<0#"$ ##
!( )8 1 "$
$ # !$#"1 1 10< 0+ ) !9 )= )D"# ++ 1 # "!3= # <= 1 <"
"$8 !$!
)$ 1 * # <0 "$#
1 ))="$8"
"
#@ ) "
$1/##!!0$ A!) 1"
# #
# =+ 1P$
@#0#* $# A *)"$!"* + ,0$ # "!3= ,# +9 # ( 1 < !, . $ < 1 ) ")) !9 <+ <0
+= 10< 0+ ) !9 )=& D ). "$ "
# )
0)$#
1"#!+# 1#0!("$
#
+= $1!+ ",
# D #$
<+ "$ "
# ( $1# # "$!, ) !$!
)$ 1 =
)#& ( !$
"$
D # )
++ + +# *)"$!"* ++= $ D 8)0$1# ?
B #"$!
1,"
1+=
D # ++D"$8 , )!
"+ #=#
, "$8 #0!("$
( !!)0 "
$1
!( "$8=
$1?<B
( 1"
+ #(D$ !!)0 + #0!("$
<=!( )8"$8 #
!$!
)$ 1 * # <= , 3"$8 1 <"
)"
# "$ ") #& ( 40*) 0) ( +1
!$!
)
+"
= "$!,
+"
= #"
"$ )#D("!(8 , 3"$80*
!!)0 + "$!, <0 $!
!!)0 +
#*+ $1"$!, !!)0 #. !
$$ 1
1<= $= )= )
+"$!, &( !0) <# )9
D"
( *)<+ ,+"3 *) $ ."
"#<
1( #"!
0$1
+# + DD"
(!+ )"
= $1!$#"#
$!= !
))"
= <=!,,$!+"!(Q#&( !$!
)
+"$!, !
"$+="#D ++ !!
$1,0# **+"
1"$ **)*)"
!
#<0 D"
(!")!0,#* "$ ,0# $ < !
++ 1 "$ "1 1
0$1
+ *)"$!"*+ # + D "$!,
- #1 +* 1& & 40<# E0 +=.
3"$8
")!0+ & &C'C'C1
1&&'. 40*) 0) "$ 2(=
2*)#$$2 0
6
:: 5
-*+ 1"
)+"
)1 !"#"$"$
1!
?#0*) B&$451!
?#0*) B. 40*) 0) D #!
++ 10*$ !$#"1 )D(
)"$
$ + $D(# !9 )="#10< 0+ $1D("!(( #$
$) !9 1<=
< $3 + ()
=
)# <0 ( # <
$ 3 "$ #0#* $# . !
$ < "$!+01 1"$ "$!,
) ##, =
)''&( 0) <# )9
% @& ( E0 "$D(
)"$
)$ 1.$D(
( !, 3$D$ #@# "!3=A+ $#.!
$< !$#"1 "$!, )$ 0$ "+ +)
+"M
"$."# E0 "$D("!( = )"# # +$!, - "!
)# )!"#"$8 60)"#1"!
"$ "$ 1"
* # !0$ )=& $1
"$8 *) "!
. "$
D("!( "# $# )) #0#* $# $1$ <)08( *) "
$1+##
!,* $= "# $
# "$!, & ( E0 "$ D(
) "$ 8"9 $ !
#0!( @ !!)0 +A
"# 10< 0+ ) $ . , = +# < *)<+
"!& .
. )1 ( # !$#"1 1 "
$ )= + = 1D$ 8 +
)1 !"1"$8D(
"# 10< 0+1 < .
$1 1")
++ $!, - "!
)# #(0+1
#0!( ,0$ # $ ),"$8 * "$!,
0$ "+)
+"M 1. ("#1") "$<=D = !")!0+ $$ !$#"1 ++"$8< =$1 *D )#
:
)10$1 )4 "$ $!, -!
&40!(
!")!0+ )"#<"$1"$80$1 )4 "$&( !")!0+ ) '. . *)9"1
) ) !8$"#"$8 D(
!+ ", )"$
!
$<
10< 0+ !+ ",0$+"3 += !9 1)$ &(
*)9"1 <= # "1!")!0+ )"# #
D(
$1 ()
=
)#. ,0$ "$
( #."$ .<
$) !9 <= $3)$ & "
"#$ !9 1 ) * )"1
()
=
)#. $"$ 0) (=
$1$D )1# !+ ", ) "$
( <
10< 0+ !+ ", D("!(
1$ "$!+01 1"$ "$!,
0$ "+"
"# ++=) !9 1& RR RR RR &( .(D ). D1 !"#"$# ("#0) D("!(
$# )$8+=) +"
10*$<= #*$1 #"$ *) !
&( ")# 1 !"#"$"# , 6)"
=6018, "$$2$& 2(= "1 '202()"'& 0
1 !"1 1<= $!( ()
018 # ("#0) <= , 6)"
= D $ & ("# 6018, 1") += 1
+# D"
( "$
$ @# "!3=
#AD("!((
$1 <"
!0# )<0
"$
#0#* $# <= < $3"$8 !,* $=& ( , 6)"
= 6018, ( # )
)) !")!0+ ) >: $1 "
# D"
(1) + <= # !$1 !")!0+ ) >'& ( , 6)"
= **
)# ( *)!
1$ #"#
<= # !$1!")!0+ ) >' + )1( 11")
"$
"$ #0#* $# $ @# "!3=A # #(0+1 < "$!+01"<+ "$
<+ "$!,
++ $1"$8 !
# #(0+1 < 1"#*# 1 3
*"$8 "$# )0!
"$# "$ 9"
D& ( #0<# E0 !")!0+ ) ' <= D("!(. ), ## ##,
) ' < $3"$8!,* $"
#D 8"9 ),')#*2'
"1
: 1 #$ **
(
$*"$
10
0) &F(
D ##0<,"
1< 0) D #.
#"$!
#0!("$
( 1<
++D ,*
),) $( + !
0)=. *) "!
( $# ), + "$ + D ("# *#"
"$ #(0+1 $ ( <
9"
1 ),&
"9"$8 ("#!$
"$. 0) # "1
E0 "$ (D !$!
)
+"$!,
)# "$ E0 "$
<"+"
= "$ !")!0,#
# !
. $1(D D(
!$!
)
+ "$!, #(0+1 "$
),"$8+ D"
(
!!)0 + "$!, .D"++( 6018 1@"$ +"8(
*)9"#"$# . *)"$!"*+ #
$!= !8$"# $1 ++D
#"<"+"
=A&( 0) "1
)+"
)!")!0+ )#< "$8 !0 "9 "$!(
$$
*)9"#"$# &( D "$
0) !$!
##"$# D("!( !0+1
+D =# < *)#* "9 += D"
(1) D$& ( 0) +# <# )9
!")!0+ )#!
$$ 1
), &( 1 !"#"$
$# "$ $!( ("# 0) "$ 20(,$ 2*
20&', 0
&( 7!6 !7
:) #0<# E0 !"#"$ "$ <
2'+%&-& 0 :
+#1$ **
(
$*"$
10 0) & 4"$!
+
)!")!0+ ) 'D #$ *"$
10
0) . 0) $
0) ++= *)!
1 $
##0,* "$
< 8)
1 0$1
)+"
!")!0+ )D #$+$8 "+ <+
(# !")!0+ )# !0+1 $ < ) #)
) *0)*# )!,"$8 *)9"#"$# !
& $
"$8+=. !$!0))"$8 6018, # !$1 018 ( # $ 1
D"
( ("#E0 "$
++<0 ( #1 !"1 ,
)$ < #"# )*)9"#"$# + D& :& RR RR RR >& $ *) ,"# , 6)"
=1 !"#"$"$4
$3 ) $!) 9& !
$$ < +3 1 0*$ # + ="$8 1D$
!")!0+ ) D("!( "# *)* )+= "##0 1 0$1 "$ $!, - !
) *)*
1,"$"#
"$ $1 )) +"
9"$8 )"80)
+"
+ !$# )0!
"$ + D )
"$!
"$#"
"$#D0+1$ <"$1"$8$
+ ()"
#& ("# D0+1 < !$ )=
"+ "11D$<= $!( "9 018 #"$ 9$"
/ + & )"9&7&7&4 $&A & $ ++ ")$ ## +
)$ 1!0$# + ) $0 . !$
"$
4 "$ "
+ ) !8$"#
<"+"
= #0!("$
D( #* !" "!*)9"#"$"$ $
0) # "$ ( <
$ , . # +"3
-!+01 1 ), *0)9"
D
.
!
$$ "$1") +=!+ ",< D("!(D0+1 ,0$
< #","+
0$1 ) # "$ !
. ) E0") < 1"#!0## 1&$ ("#) )1."
, =< $
!+ ", 1<=
"#$ 0$1 $=*)9"#"$ &(
"$8<0$1<=
0"1 +"$ #D("!( "##0 10$1 *)9"#"$# !
#$ #(D$ "$
$ #"$!, &=9") *)9"#"$# "$:J !
. *)9"#"$# (
) ( ))"1"$8
9 )+ D#&( .$ D"
(#
$1"$8 *)9"#"$# # "$ .#"$!
*)9"#"$# # "$:J !
( $9 ))"1"$8
9"#S9"#"$!, !8$"
"$*)"$!"*+ #"$ ,* $"
#!
. ## ##"$8 "!
)"#<0$1 ++D ") "$# # # "$!, ) !8$"
"$ "# !$!
)$ 1& ( "$
$ *)"$!"* + +
,0$ D("!(( #<
$!+ ##" "
# !
$$ ( +1 ( @ !!)0 1A #
- , 0$1 !
& ( !$
"$
!
$$ "$1") +=!+ ", D("!(D0+1 ,0$ #","+
0$1 )# "$ . .1 #$ , )"
!!
&
& ( #","+ ) "##0 D # !$#"1 1 "$ "
#" $ " 12
3 "$ !
*
"9 $3#<= 06
"8(0) D( "##0 D #1 !"1 1"$ 90)
()08( 1
"+ 1 6018, & 8 "$# 6018, 06
"8( 0) . * - 0) **)9"$8 # "1 1 !"#"$ 1"#,"## &&&' "+ 1<= $0 $&&& , = 0) )< "!
)+"
( $1 14 "$ <= !
.
"9 ), &&' D( <= #* !" "!
++= "$!+01"$8 @ !*
"9 < $3 *)", )= 8)"!0+ 0) + !) 1"
#!"
= ) *)", )= !*
"9 8)"!0+ 0) + $1 )0) + 1 +*, < $3A "$ # "1 *)9"#"$& & 19 "$8 + ,
)"-. "
, = < $ "!
)"<0$ + D("+ ) +="$8 0*$ 9 )"0# *)$0$!
# ( 1 1 !"1 "##0 )1"$8
<"+"
= "$
$ G#"$ 90)
< "$8
<+ "$ =
) ) "* &( )"<0$ +( 10*( +1 1
"$ <= ?B $ 11"
"$ ..'.C ) )1"$8
!!)0 1$ & "++ +"
= ) * )9 )#"
= !0+1 < 1 ,$#
<=+
)$ 1!0$# + ) $0 "$ "1 "$1"$8#) !)1 1<= )"<0$ +& & (0#. #0<#
+ E0 "$# + D # !+ ", $#D
!!)1"$8+= **
+# 1"#,"## 1& 5
6
A
&9$&.4&'
: 5 6
8<#C8# A
B%&$%&'
9&2=,(+C&2-"(&/
&-
B%&$%&'
&9"'$24*&
&-