← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2609/2013dismissed

Shashi Kant v. Amarjit Dutta & ORS

2019-12-02Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan11 pages

  

     

      

 !! "#$ %#&$  #$'

!'! # #

        (#

# #$)*#+,

# %)*+#  !!

# -#$ #%*+# #   .&&*+ ## /

# - "

 0 !*+ ## / 1 

 

 

3#

4# #%  !* % !!,!'! ## /

5$!,'

  % #/   !#6#$'

###   $#   !!7 %%% #8 ##



 !  " #$ .#!7* #  !   )'##$ 6#$'

$' 6# # %#&  $*  %##  #  5  % (#+  .!*  % %

"*% $% #8'!#  ,# !%$#' 98! 1%#!$!!7#6

  !$+!!':

8!*- ! #;$# $# # 6%$/

9 #'#'% (#8 +,,

)'##$# ##$*  !!'!*  $!!    +*  <$!7  !     

    #     !  %$#'    8!    +$#   3#6 &'

 / 1 ! 

#'#' !%$#'18! =%#!+$# /

>$67%#&$/  !!'!*$!!+# #+$#6  !+$#/ 1

 # +#  !*)'##% :

, #'!,# $!?  >$ +!@!!1 = 1A+$# ,(#8 +,  ## # (#8 +*  # # #  ,$!'   ?)'## 9 1A %$/  9 6@!!,+$# (#8 +?(#8 + 

  #

  @!!>$67)'##*# (#8 +*  ! 6% 6!$,# $ # #7?/ =

+#'

*!## $ # #76$ 7!!$ , #+$' %$ #  #+$# #'  ! %$,#' 6'$  %? / 1 !%  7

  $#   !  %$#'    8!  +  !     

?    /

 !%        !     

#'#'18! =%#! #'  !  !#$!,$!*+* #+' #'

   !? 6 !*  # #'  !8  $! #% %*'+'#$  !6#' $

*/ 9 # 7 ,#  #  '  > #  -   #%'    #    / A    =  !    &  ,#  %* , #/ 1 %$ ,  #&,# %

B &,#%!67 #%#* 7   6@!!1 = 1A*(#8 + 6% 6!$,#  $!#   # $6)'##%$/ A 9,

9  #+$#?# (#8 +* #+!+$  !! !'! #67,7$#!$ B  #&,#%!6 ! / 1 7 %$/

9, +$#!'! #(#8 +# #

$   $#  !%$#' 8! 1  8!  =  %#!   #$'

 +!  !    #  +!$6! #, $# $# ' !* 7 + %  #* ,7 7#  $# #  !

!!  #7#%! $

-   !    !  # !  #+#'   !!'       ,#  %  , #  ##'   +#%  !

  !'  #*!!,'$,# #%

@  #  !!!# #7#C

((

@  # %$/

9!

 !!'!*$!!+C ((

@  # $6#>:$#C (

@  #  ! '$C (

!

A B  ##    #+    *     !    '   %##(@ 6#'#$%

      #  *         >% 

3#6 &'

@ 

$!,'

@

# #'!#$!#  #* #!

:$#$/ 9'  ! $!!7*$   !,%,  - ,+ &$'%#= =  4!'''#+67 &$'%#* !    !     !       :$#    #  )$'* ;$# $#*,  ,'!#!#)$'*   4-#8:$#*;$# $#*, +&$'%# 

 % %

.', &$'%#  67 :$#6!,*  ! 88 #  :$#67,7!'#'$!# ! #7'  % 6 * % $'&$'%# 67 :$#6!,6$  !6#

  ''      #'$!#     !*   # D/

1  + # #$'

$!

B + #!#$!#  !!6 '' #$'

##

 . :$#6!,!7 $!!'!

 +% !$ # # 6<$6%6!$ '7,!!  # B ,6#+ )'##  $  # #7 #@!!+!+$ (#8 + 6!$!7 B 6@!!  #(#8 +*

#+!+$ !! #!'! #67$#!$    %$  ,  #'

!7         6     $#!

$(#8 ++$# #!'! #$! 6$, % 4$# #%#* 6  %$,#'

.$'

#$'

!E> (

3#6 &'

*3# '

*$ '

#$ '

 #$'

!E> (9  $# # # $ !* ##* 7#  $# ### , $*$  #$#!,! # +$#6!#6!!'!*$!!+

- 4# !!:$# !, %# !%#8 '+,!!   *  %' !$  ',,#', %$ +  ,    #    (#8  +    '  67  $#!

$  !+  #    $  #  #7  ##   # #$$# 

 

                

= 

 

   

      

   



  

  

             !

  

  

 " 

     



   

  

  

   

  

 

 

 

#        !

 $

   



%

&

 & 

   

' 

   

   (  



   

 



   #

 

 

   

   

# 

   

 

  )       

 #

%

  

#   # *+  



 ,-,%./0,

  

  * 

       

        & 

    

 



 



     

   #* 

 

    

1   )  

)(   

   %

 ! 







 

   #

2 )%

 +  3 41   



   





 

      



 

     !

            



   

   









 1  





    !

   #





    



   (   5 3  6 4 



 *    

   







      

  

         #   

        !

            

  

#  



    6

  

 

#   #

  

    !

 



   6

   

      "78,7-  

  

       *

 

     



   

  

 "78,7-

 

    !

 

 

# 



   6

 &

 &

 

    

  

  

  

     



  

(            

  

   #

   

               #  

   

 

     5  



 

            9     

    

  

    "78,7-  

            



         

      

*

  

%



 #

    :( 2 ) %



 2*.,8"  %

;/,

    

  %

  1       

    

 

# # 





  <1          

        

 

    <          0#  $!  #      !!    ###   $ # 



         !""

# $%& ' (   

    ) '    *  $!  ""

#   ++,  -  #

.(  '* /" ' '  +%""

#  !

   0        "        ""

# ,%&  -   &$'%      !      !!   +' $##$% >,  $ 6#+ 6%

@ #!#$!## / 1   ###$ #  0  1'

2'

   ""

# ,,   /30  #       

3  2'      '      %&,  45"  $!&  1 ' 2'        2 6

        '   

%$%""

#  %  '  '

   ' 1'

  '  %&7&45" +*,  $ # # +#

B7##, +,867    :$#  6!,     #      #  

)'##*   6#7% (#8 +, # 6!$ ,#!%,# - ,!!6# # % % (#8 +,&$!%,#+ , $!!,#  #'

 - #  $7## # >#',#  #'

  # #7 #67 #+ ,!!

 # ,#%8!$ % 6!$  ,#  -   ,!!    6  # #    %   

  % (#8 +,6###%>#'#'

,#  7%# - ##* # #'' #!'!

#67$#!$6&$ - %$, #'

!7+$#!! !'! #% (#8 + 67$#!$ - 7$!!,  # #7 # #%% (#8 +7%# 7!!8*# '* %8'! - !6#% !!'!+#7$ # - &$'% 67 :$#6!,#6 $   # #   #!     #    + ## # #!,

/$6!<$!,#  !

- ##*B7%#  # !

        7 #    $#6     !'!*  +!    ,!!

#&$'%# 67 :$#6!,

-  !%#'!7

  "$ .#&   %&'(&'))'*+,-'./+0'*12-3 '+/, %&'(&'))'0,)(*45'

'+/,