High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2647/2013dismissed

Maghar Singh v. Darshna Devi

2015-02-04Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih8 pages

!" ! #$$%% &"

( # $

)" " *( "+ "(,! ")" $!"-+( "!$$%% "."/!, %+( "!" $ 000 1!!" "$""

%% $$"

-2 / %%,

!*' - 3 ./" ""!"$""

" 345 1!!" ! *' - !'% / "$" 3 000

"% ' % /2 ! $%

, " /2 ! "% '" ( *' - " 6 $$% $" ""

! " % ,

.! !,+ / " ! '"+ ! " '%" $$% )" ! % + !" "+ ,'%/" ""/2!"" %$

' !"+ ' %/2!$%

+!$"2 " " ""("2 +

+!! ( % +

89 ! 7

!" + $"-

"$ , :'/2! ('" !$%

+!,

"//2 !'$ !'-/-";/2

$" "/ ,%% $" ! " ! -<% "2 ! " ", % - !" " "/ "% !-'

% (" "$ /2 ! ! %%2 " '

$2!% -'

.!'

+! ' + , $%+ " %+ ! ! %% $"-

"$," " /" 7, - ! -'

89 (" ( /2 ! $%

! + " (":' 2$"-

"$7

+ ! /- --/" --/" -- +

89+ ! 2"

+ ! , / "'

/2 ! $%

+ !" "+ ! " $2

7 -/"+

+!$ "!-- - 2 '"! -'

+$"-

"$," :'/2!$%

"-! /2 ,2 '"2 ='"!"+ $%

'" ! ! ,! ! ,'% -$% %% !

+!'- :'/2! ,'% / "'"

7 , - ! ! $ %% !

- "

- ! " "," " %2- !"("

!$!$2 $" "$.!'

+! "$2- +

89 -!$%

, ("( /2 ! $%

! + $'"

' ! %%

$"-

"$+ '%%2, ! ! $%

" " " %2+ $"2

% '

! -"

' ( ""+ /! ! '" '"" %2 '

! !$%

!'%2$"(!:' !$"-

5:) "$5:)!$$" '$$" !" %- $"( !" !'$ + 1"" )1+ ,! ! "/ ! '- 5:) 5:)+ % ! ' (% :' ! $"-

!"$>% $"( "2 "% ! - ! " " ! " "<;, +( - <%+ ! ,

5:) 5:)+ % $ -%" % %!' !+ !" !+ ,!% $$" ,

! :' ! $" "$ 5:) 5:) >,("+ ! - ! !'-/ -$"

! $! "$!!, '%2

: !$"-

! "$ .! $% ! ! ! '- 5:) 5:) ," :' /2 ! $%

'" !---'

89+!-'

!, '%2$/2! + -' "-!'- 5:+"- '

$"( ""! , /"' ! "" !, ! '! -- , (""'

" - /2 ! $%

='"!"+ %2

5:+ , / "( ! !' !+ ! :$" :- /2 ! ($ ?'$ ! ! " "" 5:," !! !$%

+ /' %% ! '- " % % %- '

/, ! $" 1" 5: , !"

/2!$%

", ,

/2 2 $ ,

%% '"!"+ !" , "% ! '- 5:+ ,!! '% 2 ! %- '

" "$2- /2 ! ! -- -'

! $'"$" !( / / /2 !

+ :$ ," ! "("

$!$2 $"-

"$ ='"!"+ ' /2 ! + ! "

- " " ,"'%2- !/; !$!$2 $"-

"$ 5:+ , -$%%2 (+ $" "$ ," -%2 :' /2 !

! 5: "(% !

" " !---'

," !, !( / -

+ @

+ 6

( $"" ! :' $" "$ .!'

+ , %' ! '! "

- ! /; $!$2 ! $" ," 9 ," " .!' !+ ! "

- ," $' ! $%

+/' ! !( - '! "

.!' !+ ! "$" '/- /2 :$" ($ ?'$ 1 !, ! ! ," ! /; $!$2 !$" "$%%,!!

"," +/' / "(/2!'" /%,+$ ! :$" , %'

( " %2+ , %' ! '% / - ! $" "$ ," :' /2 ! -"%2 /2 ,2

'"2 .! / + , %' ! , :$ $"' $"

: ! !'-/ -$"

'$ /% ;'- 5:))!," "//2! ,"" " '% ,!! -'

89 , / ( ! .! /

+ , / "( ! ! $" "$ ," '%2 :' /2 ! !'

+ ! - "" $" '-$ " " ! $

+ '

" @ ! /% 7

"'- '% %2+ ! ', " !$$%$" ""

! " % ,

7 !( !" %"

% " ! $" % ! $"'

!$$"/; <"

% "!$$%%

-$%2 ;

""! '/-

!,"( / " ! '" /%, "* " ' -$"!

(

!" " '- , (

)" "+ %"

% " ! " $ $%

'/- ! /! ! '" /%, !( '"" %2 "" ! ! $"-

5:) "$ 5:) ," '%2 :' /2 ! .! '/2! !!!"$ '- +

89 "- '

'/ "" '- 5:!, ' !/"%'$ /2! ! " " ,

" "*+ ! " "" !" $" ! $" ( $"" ! :' !$"-

5:) ' !' ! '%

'+7- !

"(,!!

$$% ( -" !'

+%/%/

" ! "

! " / "" !" " %

"+ "$%

'+ !, "A'"$"(! !$"-

5:) "$5:),"'%2 (%%2 :' /2 ! )%

:- !

"/ !$"-

5:) !'$+ 1"")1+,! !' (%:' > '"!" $"( ! "2 " " '%2- ! " " "% 5:)- <%)1+ ! ,

+% $"( ! %- ! $%

- !!'- A' ""! !'-/ -$"

% ! $! "$!.!$% '/2!

+!! ,'- ," :' %2 /2 ,2 '"2 '" ! -- -'

+ "- '

'/ "" ( + % + , /"' ! "" $"( ! '! -- ,"/ "'

"- /2!$%

)% ! !!!"$!---'

89 /2 ,2

- " " ," '%2 - ! /; $!$2 $"-

+ ( -'

, $'"$" !( / $

+ " @

+ ! 6

+ !

( $"" ! :' $" "$

5: +! "

- ," 9 , "

+ !,! '%"$2!

A' -'

89 ! , $'"$" !( / ( -/"+

+, B'

%% '"!"+ ! , ("" !," - ,! !,! -'

, $/2! !$%

C %2+'- 5:, /2!$%

='"!"+ "

- " ""$2- ,"- %2!/; $!$2 .! " % '- 5:) 5:) ""2

'! "

- 5(

'- " ! ; " '- ! ! $"-

"$ 5:)

! 5:) ," :' "- ! %2 /2 ,2

'"2+ ! , /"' ! "" !, ! "$2- -'

+ / !" % $"-

"$ "-!$%

! , /"' ! "" !,!!'- A' ," %% $2- !---'

5:' ! '- $

!( / $"(+ ! / 2 ( "$2- -'

89!, ( ! +$%

, " !%2!% %!" $"2 " <"

" '

% " ! $$%% '%

$ ' !,! %'

!," '"" %2 ""/2/!!'" /%,,"!" ""2! $ """ '

" "- 2-"%%% %2 !,; !$ + '/(+!" !"%2 : 2 "'

+ % $%'

/% %,+ "

" ,! ! " /

% ! $" $$% A' %,+ -'! %

'/ % A' %,+ " "

$$% / ( -" + " %2+

February 4, 2015 Rajan ( Arun Palli ) Judge