Pr. Commissioner Of Income Tax, Gurgaon v. M/S Comverse Network Systems India Pvt Ltd.

 

    




 ! !"#$#%& 



  
    

     !"



 $# %  # &'

()
 *
'

()
+)
 ,,,  & 
' #() !!

 

   ! *  #   ! * # 

! %  (#    # ,,,  *
-./ +
 

# #

 #  
 
 , -.

/0123  * ##4+5625+7 

"25+51++ 
%  

# 

8

  &1
 

  

 

           

      

   !

"

  # $%  &'"

(     "

!) "

* "+) 

% $' $  , 

)()  (   " 

   "& 

 



% &-

    

%

%.

 %   '         '

 

  /0

 1  



      %  

% 

 

   %              %/      %&-%

%   '

  /2 2
%  # 



     !"





 

$#

 " #

"      !"



  9!




 #

 

   # 1   

 #    

 #

 

  

#:



-.:

/0 4 ; 

"25+51++%  # 

 #

  

 +4+525+5#



 % +<4772+5
   

 #  

" #  "  # 

+<2-+0 #+<4-20  
+=>+-./0 # # 8

  

#    

     

      

   

 ##

 #

 

 

#

#

  

# ,"

    #



=2-0-+0  # 




? -.
?/0

  *      #

  

      

     

 

 



  # 

  ,"   

  #

  

  "  255=1+5  

" #

#

 < 3 $#
?

 # #  

 #% +5*  
% # #  # $#
? , #   

 #   # 

   

 

  



 

# 

-.:/0& +  $

#   

 

 #

  

+44675<4=

2    9!  

 

 # 

22@5=4++

4  $

#   

   



+=6+=4>==

<  $

#   

 



254466=+

 0 6  $

#   

  ! !

2@=+==5>

>    "$#   %

, 

-%#0 +56=>=27  7 

"

!#3#

"

%

, 

-%#0 24<7<5@  @  $

#  %

, 

- #0 :

+5<7@4<  =    9! %

, 

- #0 :

64=54@2  +5   ( 9( %

, 

- #0 :

+44<6<+  ++     " $

# %

, 

- #0 :

+=7=2+  6?

,

 

   " #!  *     

    

  -

A

   

 0 ! # 

 

 - ,  

0!    

 





,   #



     !  # "

 

##

.

 /B? ? $
? ? " # +5C=CB7C  "  4  

? ?  +@ =+4C
 



 # , /

  !

   # : # 

 ?  " #2>@=C

?   66@C
"#   ##

! # ! ! !   : # 

 ? ? " #7C

? ?  >6@C

 1
  



 # , / $  >

?  #  ###275+25+<#

# #'  % 67@>>>52  #& ! *  ! % 4<6<=5+> ,


! ! ! % 244+76@>
-D,0 % 67@>>>52 1 7
 ##' 

  #,"

?  -.?/0

#

 #

#

 #

 #  ,'

, *

% 

 -.*%/0
 *% # # 

##+@+225+< ##'  #,"


?

? @

   #'  $ # #," *%?

#;



 # # 

+<<# 



+<4-40  2<5225+6 =  #," 



 ###2<5225+6

# , E /,


E /,

#

 

  ,"
?

"#

 # , ,'# #  # ##4+5625+7 +5 3

 #,"

 # ###4+5625+7  /,

%  #  

#

 ++ ?

"    8

   ,    #  ,"    %    

       '#  ,"  
 ,   ,"  "A

   

 "      #                ,

 #,  F   #   8 "  #& )* +() :1    3  $

# +2
 
?  #  # #  :1         

      ,



 " #

#   ## 

    #
 ,# 

? #   " 
 #
:! 

# "      

  %   #       "       "  
:!   ,

  #," "
*%#'#

 

 



3 





#:1    



"#

    



 :1      #

##

 #



 #    "     

 
 



   #  
  ,#  ;  

#," 

  # "#

   

  

 # "   




  

 #& G34/ -  

 '

       

   %  

 556  7     

       

* /89:8448;5 /$ < '  7    

 =      * /9<59;;5:< ) 

% * /36:<;9<8 3</     %

 

.

    

    '       

  

>    /       

     '        '     '    /  

  

  

. 

  '      '   ($   '   



 '  '  / 3;/ 

    

   %     '   ( /?      

    

             

   '  '  /  

       %



 

/

 2        %  

 /2 +4
 

     #

#,"
? #

 #  

# , 

  ,"


?


 #

#     " ,  A#  , #

#    

  8      #  

#   
 ,#  


  #

 

  

  ,



 
,#

  #  # 

#, 

 

#  

  ! #

  ,



"#

 ,  , ,"%    ,  ", ##,"



*!"



 $

# +<
 
?   #  

  ,      

      "



 " 
   # #  ,    


 #

 #,"*%3 





#

*!"



 

"#

 



 # " # 

 

   #

    ##

" 

#,"



*!"



# "   ;'

!

$

#


 #

 # ,  , #  #& G45/ '       %    '  % 

    % 7  

    '      

 %           



 

 



   

94  7/

        

 ' >  '  

    '   /0  '  %

        

    



    / %       

 7

  %   / %

   

 

   

 %     / 

 '  

 

   / 



     7



      (

  /   ' 

 ' 

% 



 

   ( 

'  7 %  

'  %   7 >    /

    

 %  

 7/    ' 

%       '

                  '

   7  %  



/ 4@/- 

 '

      

%     /2 +6
 

     #

#,"
? #

 #  

# , 

  ,"


?3

  ##,"

 ,  ,  #  

,  

#

 "  , 

 # 

 ,  

,#  )() ))())) :

  $

# +>

? # # , ,



"     


 #

  #,"*% 3 



  ##:

  $

#-.:$/0 

"#

    



   # "  ##    ' 



 A



#





 #



 

    8    

   #   

 3 

 

  

     # 

   #  

 #   

 # " #

 E  

#,"

 # "  #  #



  # # # "  

      ##  


 # 



  , #

 #& G<</   '        '

  



'

%  /  ' 

 '

   (  

  %(/ !       

     %   %

    

 



  

% '  

  

  /    % 7      % 

  ' A'   %/  

 %       %   /2 +7
  #  

           , 

 

"

 ,  , ,"%  # 

  " ## # ,  ,## 3 :



 #

 "$# +@
 # ,  ,"
? ,



"

,    

   #,"*% 3 

 

#,"

3  

"



    ##

 #



 

 

# " 

#,"



 # "  ## #   # #





  4*  #

2* 





 



   '  

   #  






 # 



 3 

,



" ,    

 #

 4  #& G;:/     '                



'

%  

"/)  

%  ''      1 B    7%    /  $  

'

         

   7       '       %

  / %

/0

 

%  '  %   

    

 7  7    

 /   '  %

%

 %  

  /2 +=
 

 ##," 

 ,  ,   #  

,  

#

 "  , 

 # 

 ,  

,#  %
:!$

# 25
 
?  #  

  ,     

    "  

 "   , 

## 

  

   ##,"


 #

  #,"

*%3 

 

#,"

 ,  #

 

  



 " #

  



   #   "  

    #    

 



  ##       

  ##     ,'###

" 

#,"

      #   " #  ,   

A#      

     #      

         #  

    #   

 

#

   


 # 



  , #  #& G '   

 '

%             

      /           %

 

C) 

%     2     %  

 

%&- '   

 

/       '      %            

  

  

   

  %

/     % D'/   E  7  '       7% 1 /  

    

      *($  "/    

    '

            %  7     / + ,

/)'/)D (   +&,"/F@:58G 58<#8;;

F@:59G593  / 935+ /, +,#%/)'/ ))  +&,"/F@:5@G39$-@6:

+E*-, @3  / 3@:+#, + ,H*  +  ,+&,"/'/-F@:58G8;

 / 9;8+#, +,??7   +&,"/'//)IF@:58G88  / @4+#/, )  



  '    1            '               %     /2 2+
 #

  ,



"#

  ,  , ,"%  #  ", ##,"


:



:

 $# 22

? #

 ,  

 "

 #

   '



 



 

 #  ,    


 #

  #,"*%3 

 

# ,"

 # "  ,'#

 

  #







 "

  #



      

   # 



  #  #





  #  

  #  

         

 

#,"

 # "#, #     , ,'#


 # 



# , #  #& G '   

 '

%       

  / %  '' 

' %     / 

 

'   

          /  

  

  '

'  '

( /' 

       %      1

'      

  1   

 



              

 '  /0     

   

  ) %  '    %      /  ' 

 

      





 )$) 

  %/2 24
 

     #

#,"
?

##

 #  

# , 

 ,"
?


 ##,"

 ,  ,   #  

,  

#

 "  , 

 # 

 ,  

,# 

"

 2<
, 

 ,"

#



   # #  #     "

 
8

 

#

  #

  

!

 ,   ,"

E /, 

   
567% )/7 #%$
%8#5 ( 8-
 <+= 25+>03 ,"

 

  
5$) 9.!-4=6
%+7>0 #

 .#%"#:/;;#$$#%!. 
%";!<+$ ."/=$!">%/?=!% .!

%8#5 ( 8-<5=
%+5@0 #,"(  E  

.#%"#:/ ;;#$$#%!. 
%";!<5$) @.%8$
%8#5 ( 8-<5>
%6+40

 

26
  #

 # 

, 

 2>   !



  , # ##

 

  

 

  "  #

 #    *
   +)
  



1   F 



# H

F% ,& H