← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaITA/558/2017dismissed

Pr.Commissioner Of Income Tax -2 Chandigarh v. Sh.Shivpal Singh Chaudhary H.No.3121 28d Chd

2018-07-05Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta,Lok Adalat Bench - 39 pages

GURBAX SINGH 2018.09.11 15:55 

    

 !"#"$%&%'(

)**%&&%'")'$*"+ ,+-. '#%/ ). 0011"22 '! 3& 4.4.%51 24%'/.. 6#. )7-8-4"$!)+-. '#%/ ). 0 "&1'#"'!   ( 9:

 4;

 :   9:

 434   

        



          !

      < 7;6* ) %!! 2- "

#       $%& '(# ) "*%"+, -.    $% &/ $&"0 )

1   23  '( # )   #2     +  , #2 -.  '

#

 4 $$566$&"0  

(3 $&"$"1 ( 2  7  ,8  (     9:2'# #  

*/1"$0%6( 5&+".+ . # 3(( ;2  23   5&+ .+ .  

  2  

 ( 3           5&+ .+ .     &"

&5 $&"1 23 9:2 !  9      #(  < = '#+'# 4 $0>$&"5.?- $

  

 3  

       ( 3 2    #      ( (3 $&"$"11& &* $&"$  (

"$/*%*$&6 ( ("51+1. $0 &$ $&"/ ( $5/5">5&623(

   +. "*&%$%623    51@'

# "*%"A +.    */1"$0%6   5&+ .+ .   # 3(( ;2  A +.    /5&5/6   5&+ .+ .     #           <3 A + .    1500516   $"1"16   5&+ .+ .     )      6 BC# D B(  6# D BA + .   "0*>5$&6     A + .      "/&&6 2  3    )

 23   2((  '( # ) + . E'#+ .F     )  (    4  + .

 =    "& ""

$&"% )

$ 

'#+ . 3   23  # (

 4 +. 2     (  4 +. +.+ . ( 4          2  #2       (  4 +. 2 = $% &/ $&"0 )

1  #2  (    23     9   

23     8

    # 23 2#2    3 5&+ .+ . #    ,               3     )          G=''@ 3(2(2    2+".$&" 2  2( 

    )(  (23 3    - 2 +.+ . +2.5&+ . 2 +.23 D +4 $. $&&5 ("

$&&/ #   5&+ .+ .     23 D   $&"$   ( "  $&"1            2        )          G='' @    2   (  2 

 ( 2+". $&"  , 2(  

   )(  (236 3   - / ' 2) $&"+".     ('H3$&"$ '   

      

       

    

  

 





 

 



 

 

  

  

    



     

          

   

             !"





#            "





 

 

           " $ 

          

    



       %& % # $&"+".   2    '           )     (         (   2(2

           )      ("1*  



((((   ) ( 23(( 

23 (  37() G='' @  )     7   3 )  ((2  

2$&" 9  

 $&"+".  ('H3 $&"$ )   2                2;(         4     2 

   5&+ .+ .   (&"

$&"1 #  2 23   

  (  )     2( 

    )(  (236 3 >  D(   3 $&"+".   5&+ .+ . 2 2    36 (  3( 23

223    ) (     2    2       (  

  2 * 4   7    7        5&+ .+ .  ('

$&"1  3 (3 $&"$"12 "& (   5&+ .+ .

    ( 2        

         +$&"/. 100 '#  %1/+.

 # 9       

 @'# #'# 4  6$&"1

  

 !    5&+ .+ .

    3          2     (' $&&/  "1   ' %( 

  

$ )  *($( + , -  $   % $*(   

    

 

   

#





   .   /0

 

 $

  

 

 



        %*   

 #      !

        1 2          , 

     

  

            



        

   

#       

  

   



  

  %.  

        

         

       



           % (   

       3     



   

 

              

      #     

  

 

3  

   

     % (      



  

   % 4   3    

          





      

         

 %

    

 ,           /0

 



 

    

 

   ,

 6

   

     



 7 8 4  7    

 

             

    

  

 

    6     

        



     

         





  %(   .   /0



     

 

     

       



  

 

               

    

   

 

     

  %*        

 

 

        

        

      

   

 

   %( 

 



       

  .   9:

   /0

  

  %(  .   /0

 

         

       

  

  

  # 

 

   

          

  8



      



  6 %;

 

 

  

   

        







 

 

      

 

    

  



    

    6    

     

  

       

    

                         

     

  

         % *    

      



            

  

 

   

  

 

    6    

         



      

        

   

     

%(

         

  

  

   % $    

            .    /0

   



 

  

 

 

            $ 900<   

 

        

      /0

   

=

  ;%9 $ 900/% ""

8   (      9   

       "  + .   

   @'# # 23  2  5&+ .+ .   (3   3        2  3   (' $&&/ "$  

3   ) (   ( )  '        3   7 2*>**"5"6 ;2   */1"$0%6    6 H   ( 3     )  #

I      3(

2(  3     )          

     :  )   I   3(75&+ .+ . #

  2'#+ .         5&+ .+ .     3(   

 2    #'#+ . 2(                  (  (   3     3( (  23 (  # $

 %  & 2( # '#+ . 3     

       2 23#2 "1 '    2              !  9     

 %

  % '())%+$&"5.1%5'# %>*    *     +$&"/. 1$  + . /&%  2  5&+ .+ .   ( &"

$&"1        8

   222   3  ! 9     "5 '   2  32  7 (            

    73  ( 

< 7;6* ) %!! 2 6#/" 627-  5'""&..%'/ ' =/&9  6#/" 8

6  "& 8 2 "&