High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/701/2018allowed

Rajinder Kumar Sharma v. Suresh Kumar & ORS

2019-01-18Mr Justice Rajiv Sharma6 pages

!!""# $% %

&#%

%!&#%

!"#

$%&'( #'#$(# &() (&

%#'

() % *+&,#-&#!!""#) ()!$ *+&,#-&#%!&#%) ...

'#$(# &() (&$ *+

*&/&-#+,"0 %#&% -"#%##!!"%%"1#/#2)3)4567!%%89# ()))*

!1) --,#% 98&#,##& #%#)," !##&/% -" ,#& 6:: &- # (&#& $,"% ,#* 6233 %;1 ,& !%#&#&## &- %)35";%&,,& #&-#&-#%

&#&+,",,####&&;!",&4<)=)456<)" #% /#!#%*%%#8&#&-#,%)#," !##&# /% %%# ## & 4<)=)456< #%

>%, ,%? /% !&,1 -& 1 #& " & % &#&,9," 81 1%##& &) 64 7:@7) # 8& # 2)=5 )( # ,; 81 1%##&&) :@ 64<=, -& #8,;%>

!1%? 81+%1"1# *%# ,;/## &#&,9," &,,& #&-/,#%

-""&/%/%, %

##9&-## ,;)#%

%%###&+##%!&#)

&)46#4:)=)456<, #&8"&1# &", ##&*

1&#%## #&- ,"&-#,% #%A#%

) ," !##&, #&8,&#%#89#+ &/&-#&--1+,"# %&--"1%!#/##%## #%) -,#

&-,,#/%#/%- #% #####

0 %#& &% &# -",# # 1%##&

8 &- # +," %#&) %!&#&)= % ,& !9-"/##%## # #;1 !" 9 &8,#& ## # % , !&",9 8

"#89#&/B!%#!!""###&!&",9,&+1# !&6<)=)456<#&6@)=)456:+8%% 899&--,"&-# % ,& !9) #/%- #%####+,& !"## 3):)456:8"&1/##!&",1%##&/&-#+," % ,1) # !"1% &- #!#%* #-&""&/1 %% % / - 89#8 "'

! ! ! " !

#$%&'%

! ( !)*$$ "

()*$$

)*$+ ' ! " )*$+ , "-

%"&-# 1/+"%###8 "% !",",&#%## #%&- C 6/"

#% A#%

*/&," #&89/#%%%#&#,,#%"%& #!&# ,#&67=) )##8!%#1%##

, +&-#+,"0 %#& % #%,& -1/#1#&+&"+ #&-#&--1# ,;0 %#&# ,,#/,% "###&-#%

) %&-% #

&-,& !%#&%,&,*,& &-#,%%8 #;% %)4<*555B ! &#*1%8,,!#%4=9%## # &-,,#*<5D ,#&%8 #&/%!%&""+1 E!%% &- # ,%

"#!" &- 63 % 8 !!" #& ,", "##,& !%#& & #&- %)47";%)#&" & # &- %)45*555B #&/%- "E!%%%"%&8/)9#;1 &#, &- # %## # ,& &- # &/B!%# !!""#* /& !!% C 6 ####%+,"/%&#% ### &-,,#*% ,& !9%88%&"+&-#8 &-# ,& !%#&) & %"!%#1#!!""#B&/&-#+,"1 % ###%,%&- %1 %!!,#&&-+,) 8"&11%# ;&/+ ;&/+,")1 % ###/%,",%&-# ,&+#+,"%8 #& ,/#+/#&," ,& !%#&)

,&#*,& %"!%#1#,+#&%B%!&#%&)6 #&@% !!&#%#/) #%% #####+&-#&--1 +,"/%,""#-#%-,1#"&#,1&-% 1"1#+1)

#1 ###,,#/%/#%%89#/& 9/#%%%/&8 "9E #/& "8& &,,%&#&%8"+#% )

#,&####0 #

&- ,& !%#&/%%!! #%"&/89#!E& # ,%&-

# $ %! && '!# & %"* % % ,* !9% -& % %%"&-#!!") & %"-&#!#%+8#"1#) ,&%&- #8 "8%

&#% +"%&8! %) #,&%+/&-#%& #*# 1/# 2)3)4567!%%89#8 ",&#% %#) #&&-# %

* C =) C" !!1#/#%%8&E C =%####/%-&""&/1,% #%

&%&/%,&&#/#,,#&,, #

8&-#&--1# ,;) - #%#### /#%% # ,,# "&1 /# & /

) C = - # !&%##%###&#!&",###,,##&&;!",/#

;&/+,"81+89 ;&/+8 #% 8%0 #"9 !& ,&- 18& ##1%##&

8*%,"&%#% #&# !&",-#!&&-7 39%)%!&%#&#%1/%#&# -&""&/1--,#'

F. !

" ( " "

! .

" /%0 ( . !

" /%0 ( 1 . 22- #%# &9&- C 6/"

/& ""%&8 "+#) C 6/"

%!&%##/%-&""&/1#%

&%%,&&#) !&,,#+1&,, * C 6%%#### #1%##&

8&-## ,;)!&%##/% #&"99/#%%&-#%&,, ,## ,"&-#,%

,##%!&#-##,,#

- "9#;!",###&"

8& ## &--1+,"+1%# ,;1%## &#&,9,"+1, % #,,#)#%1!&%#&&- C 6/%,#1&,#&#--,# ## ,"&-#,%

, ##%!&#-## ,,# 9!%,&4<)=)456<) C 6%- #!&%### # ,;-#, %1#,,#%#&!!#+"1# !&#& 1/9)+1G,%&-#,, %B+-"" &/-& #!&,;#!,; !#% &+# % #&#!&",) C 6%%## #%"%&!&%##8"&1% #&#% +""1%##&-#,%##/%+1+%#1 # %/##- "9&-#,%) !&%#&##,""9 1%%##%!#&- C 6

C =+1!&%###9#1%##&

8&-# &--1 # ,;*9#*# 8 1%# 1%# ;&/ +,"81+89 ;&/!%&)#%#1 1##+ #& 1* C 6%##%###+1G,%&-#+&-#&--1 +,"-""& #&-#!&,;#&-#+#% 8 !,; !&+#&#!&",*%#""*!#, "%&-#+ &#- #&# )

# &*&#& C 6% !&%##/%#%&"#9/#%%#&#,,### #%A #%

* C =,#-####&" 8& # #&--1# ,;+1%# ,;# &#&,9,"* #%A#%

," % %"-#&8-&""&/1#,%+1/#%% #,,# %"-) +#&%#!&%#&&- C 6 C =,&#8 &+"&&;)9/& "1&#&#&&#&-# ##)

,&,"9%#" ,"&-#,%) +/"

%%#&-#% +""1%#,% % ##%!&%#&##/%&+%#1# %/##- "9 &-#,%)("#&%!&81,0 #,,&#8# %&"1& #&%,##%# &9&-&#/%"8"/#%%8 # #!, "-,#%,,

%#,%&-#,%89&#,1#1"1 ,&#,#&%*#%& #/& "&#%###&,&## C 6 C = +8!"#%/#%%%%&%#&#& ,#&--1+,") #%%##"!&!&%#&&-"/##,%%"#1#& &#& ,,#," %*#," #%&#0 #&!&+#,%%#% 0 #&8&, "#")%#&-!&&-))89& %&8"& 8#%&##&8!!"% ,,%%)," #%#& %#8"%#,%&##& ,%#&&-!!&,&-!&88"#9) #!%#,%+1&189#!,!"&-!!&,&-!&88"#9 89E 1#!&%#&&- C 6 C =*#%& #/& " ,&,"

###&--1# ,;/%&#+&"+#,,#) #",&#,#&%#%## #%&-##/&""1 9/#%%% C 6 C =+8&+"&&;89#8 ")

& 8#"9*#!&",%-",""1%##+8 ##% %&"#&/& "&#8,&,"

%+/#1#&+&"+ #&-# &--1# ,;#!, "-,#%,,

%#,%&-#,%)(9 # #!&",!

#%#,""&#8%%&-#%## #%/#& # 1##1#&## #- "%%&-% ,%## #%) +/ &- # %&% ,& 8&+* !%# !!" % ,,!## 1/#2)3)4567*!%%89#8 "% %#%) !!"%""&/)

'#$(# &() (& $%)# "

,;9 C#%!;1B%&'

%B& C# !&#8"'

%B&