High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/1048/2017allowed

Securities And Exchange Board Of India v. Jagjit Singh And ORS.

2019-09-09Mr. Justice Krishna Murari,Mr. Justice Arun Palli6 pages

"#$!%$&'(')*+ + +

* , -.-/ - , -/

! " #$ % & '& "

! ( #"& ') ! * & '& !

! + * & '& ,!-& .& /& 0& 1 23 24!

! 5* ,& '& ,!42!

000 .-/

1"2 7 % 8 5 20!3/!4320 9( & " "

( 9 -.3 %! !%! $ $ !-3&333:7!

$ " 9( " 9( * " $ ' 4'(),52$61#7"85$92$"($%#&"22!1 #4$$)#'1$1$&1%!#4$&"($

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

''' !1'((6")&$!"99191'"#$:1'#/%'1$&#')')#4$ )"#61$!7")%"76(#1$(9)%$)#) A' $ - # #"@$"&#')"<"')(#1$(9)%$)#&79")8#'%$)#'!8 #4$1 (6&4 &79")'$( 9$1"#')< ') #4$ (#"#$/ !1 9$1"#')<

') &)#1"?$)#'):'#4(#"#6#18<6'%$2')$(1$<62"#')(

))$B61$ ")% #4$1$58 %'1$&# #4$ 1$(9)%$)# &79")8#'77$%'"#$28(#9(6&4(&4$7$(1$!6)% #4$"76)#(&22$&#$%!1"6%62$)#28!17#4$9652'& "#2"1<$')&26%')<9$#'#')$1(4$1$')

'? 1 '((6")&$ !1 "99191'"#$ %'1$&#') # #1")(!$1;$)#16(# #4$ ')?$(#'<"#')( "1'(')< 6# ! #4$ &1'7')"2 &"($(;(/ "( %$#"'2$% ') 9"1" ) ! #4$ ')(#")#9$#'#')')&26%')<")8!6#61$&792"')#!2'@$ )"#61$/ # ")8 ')%$9$)%$)# "<$)&8 2'@$ $)#1"2

61$"6 ! )?$(#'<"#')( C D 1 ")8 (6&4 ')%$9$)%$)#"<$)&8')?'$:!')#$1(#"#$9$1"#')! (6&4 (&4$7$( 58 #4$ 1$(9)%$)# &79")8 :4'&4 &"11'$( ')#$1$(# ! 9652'& "# 2"1<$ ') 1%$1 # % &792$#$=6(#'&$")%$)!1&$#4$!6)%"7$)#"21'<4#(/ :'#4"!61#4$1%'1$&#')#1$(9)%$)#) EF915$ ')#")<2$!)#$1)"#')"27)$82"6)%$1')<

? #"528/'((6")&$!(6&4%'1$&#')'(%$('1"52$ # ')(#'22 &)!'%$)&$ ! 9652'& "# 2"1<$ 91?'%$ &1$%'5'2'#8#(6&4')?$(#'<"#')

?' G'#4"!61#4$191"8$1#4"##4'(),52$61# 5$ 92$"($% # 9"(( ") "99191'"#$ %'1$&#') # #4$ 1$(9)%$)#(#"#$#91#$&##4$2'!$2'5$1#'$(!#4$ 9$1()(:47$1$28"&#$%"(H&77'((')"<$)#(,! #4$1$(9)%$)#&79")811$&$'?$%("2"1'$(#4$1$!/ :'#46# 5$')< 1$"2 5$)$!'&'"1'$( ! ")8 "(($#( ! &79")8I:'#4"!61#4$1%'1$&#')#1$(9)%$)#(#"#$ # )# 1$<'(#$1 ")8 &1'7')"2 &"($ "<"')(# ")8 (6&4 9$1():'#46#%6$')>6'18(6&4'%$)#'!'&"#')

?'' 61#4$1 91"8$1 #4"# #4'( ),52$ 61# 7"8 7)'#1(6&4')?$(#'<"#')(;')>6'18"($)6)&'"#$%58 #4$),52$-691$7$61#/')#$1"2'"/')

!""#$#

%&"' " " ( ' -2!31!432; 9( $* " 9' 3"?')<4$"1%#4$2$"1)$%&6)($2!1#4$9$#'#')$1( ")%:'#46#$B91$((')<")89')'))7$1'#(!#4$ &"($/2$(#'#(462%91$=6%'&$#4$1'<4#(!$'#4$1!#4$ 9"1#'$(/ 91$($)# :1'# 9$#'#') '( %'(9($% !/ :'#4 " %'1$&#') # #4$ 4"'17")/ -$&61'#'$( ")% B&4")<$

"1%!)%'" - J1$(9)%$)# A#2@')# #4$ 7"##$1/ &)('%$1 #4$ <1'$?")&$ 1"'($% 58 #4$ 9$#'#')$1(/ :4'&4 91'7" !"&'$ ($$7( # 5$ <$)6')$ ")%%$&'%$#4$("7$589"((')<")"99191'"#$1%$1 #4$1$)/ (#1'&#28 ') "&&1%")&$ :'#4 2":/ "# ") $"128 %"#$")%')")8&"($:'#4')"9$1'%!!617)#4( !17 #4$ %"#$ ! 1$&$'9# ! &$1#'!'$% &98 ! #4'( 1%$1 K

<"'& 9=( $ 9( % $& (

( 9 > 6$ $9 " 9 $ * & " $ ' 3-!34!4320 9( 9 ?> 6$ $9@ ?% $@!

3-!34!4320& > 6$ $9 9$ " $! 9=(& 31!3/!4320 " $ 9( > 6$ $9 $ $& 9 * ' '$ $ 22 & 2AA4 9( 7 * (

( ' ' 22 & 2AA4! " 7 '& 9 $ % (& +'! 9 " ( 5' % %$$ B 9C& & % & ' 34!3/!4320!

'$ $ " * 9( 9 '' % ( ( $ " 9 > 6$ $9& 9 " -.3 %!

!%! !-3&333:7 " $!

5 ' $( ' -.3 %!

!%! $

' ( 9 '* ( B9C 2 2A/ 9 $$ & %! 2A/ %!

!%! $ " ( 9 '& 9

$ ' '! & ( 9( ' * 9( % " 9 !

> $ " $ ' 9( " 2A/ ' -.3 %!

!%! D ' * $ 9( % 9( $ 9 $$ & ( ( %! , ' 9 9 $ ' ' %! 6 & '"& 2A/ " ' -.3 %!

!%!& $$ $ " -.3 %!

!%!

$ " $! > ( " 9 9( > 6$ $9 ( 9( %! 6 " * 9 9 *& ( * $ 9( $ 9 $ %& & $ " ( ' $!

> -.3 9 9 " ( $ "

9 "& "

' $

!-3&333:7!

5 ,!-& .& /& 0& 1 23 24 '" * 9( > 6$ $9 " ' 22 22 & 2AA4 ( !

$(& 9 $ 9 ( $ 20!3/!4320 9( & -.3 %! !%!& $ $ !

'" 9' & $ 20!3/!4320 9( 9 9 9( ! 6 ( "!

$ 9 & = 9 % 7444175 74320 '!

.1'(4)"61"1' 4'$!6(#'&$ + + + "=") 16)"22' 6%<$ > * : > 9 ,F