High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/294/2013allowed

Shamsher Singh And ORS v. Bahal Singh And ORS

2017-05-16Mr. Justice Gurmit Ram11 pages

!"#"$% & '

(

)%*+)

, ! "

# #$

%"

&'(')'() #$

* +"

,

%"

-

&(&)''. #$

/ +"

0 *

*# "

%"

2 #$

$2

3" "

"

.# &'# 2 $

"

" "

2 # # !" $2 "$ #$+2

2

((4(.5(

6'''

2

! 2"# " "

" #" 2

! $

" +2

"

+2

)'((..&

" 2

"

+2

(.6(..& , " 2 "

2

2 %

$#$

+2

" ((4(.5(

$

2 +2

" #

" " $(..&! +2

# 72 2

2

# #$

" 2 2 2 #

2

2

2 ! $ #%

" $ !

#

!/ / "

" 8( 9 "

" +2

((45(

6 '''- :; ) 9

:; & 9" 2 :;* < 9

" #$

:;* = > !" 2 "

$ 2 #

3"

"

.#

(5# 2 *

2

-

-

-

"#

?

" $

#$%"

- &(&)''. #$ / - / " 2

* +"

#$ -

2 2

%"

#$ / "2" %"

&'(')'()

#$%"

#$# / "# # #$

#$

"

@

"#

#$# "# 2

#

# # !

? "

2

7

A

2 2

? ! $2 2 2? 9)

?

B

2 @

"#

$

2 2 "#%

#"

2

2

2

/ " 7 #

"

2 #@

"# " 2# "

&<

#"

# B

@

"#

#$# "# 2 "

2

#

3" "

2

$ $ 2 2

@

" %"

) - .- $/

#0#+ 1 23"//"43

$/- .#,)''60)1/0/ 14)5 $35 $0#6"7 8"$9-, (:;

:"0"1;'

, $9 - .

$/ $- .0#.

<"#-. $/

$/- .#,

(:;:"0"1;

, 523 / #-"0 == > .0# .8 > - $

1 2- .>. ,

&:; '(, # ## - $ 1 .$ $/ ? :/ /; 28 +# 0# # ) ."8 $ .$ $/ ?,

:

; :"0"1; (,- 5 $/ $- . 0# 3. #- $/ - .#,

:

; :"0"1; @'

.8 $ .2 $

0 1=5 $3-."8 $/ $- .0# = 13= ,

&:

; :"0"1; '

" @

"# %"

#$ / " 2 @ 2/ "2

#

!

' # / "# 2

2

#$# "@

"# +2

2 $

"

#

#

" 2 2 , $ 22 +2

#"" 2

"

2 #$# "# 2

"22

2 " $!

"

2 2$$

"

" +2

@

" %"

5 #- 3 $/- .#0# 3$7 2 $/- .#,

:

'; ,)A $?"$9 1 $/- .#0#)"1 + >-"

$/- .#,

:

;:"0"1;(&&,3.3$ -) $- .

#> . $/- .#0# 9 #-"// == 193$/ $/- .#,

@ :

;:"0"1;'&,- $"2 " $/- .#0#-1"2 " $/- .#,

( :';:"0"1; ,)-"$/ ."$9-0#<."#- $+ 1 $/- .#,

:;:"0"1;& ,"

$< 3.0# 9-32"."$9-,

:

;'&(, 5 ."$9-0#) $-1, :

;''(,+ 1"$9-0#7""$9-

$/ $- .,

@:;:"0"1;&'

$/ 5B .$< $ $/

$- .0#5 .- $/ 5.

$/- .#,)'((0)1@&'5 "

" %"

# "# 22

&

# $

"

%"

3" "

"

.# &'# 2

"

<'&62

"

# # !$ %"

" $ " $2 $

#$+2

2 ((4(.5(

6'''-

2 ! #

#$2$ 2

""

" #" 2

$

" +2

"

+2

)'((..& !"

2

"

(.6(..& 2 " #$

#$

2

"2 #$+2

2

*

+2

$ 2

$#

72 2 +2

" #

"

2

" # !

#

# #$

" 2

( 2 2 #

+2

!" 2 "#$

3"

"

.# (5# 2

$ "

<'&6

+2

"

2

#

"

2

?

" $

*

%"

/ "2 2

%"

#$ / "2"

#$ %"

#$# / "# # #$

2

%"

#$# "# 2#

# "# 2 ? "

2 7

A

(56)

B " 2#

&<

2 " !2

2

B (5

$

# "" ;

"

#

#$

2

" 2 +2

" 2

" !

@

? $(5$

# $ "" $

"

B 2 "

+2

$ !" 2 +2

$," 2 2 2 +

"! (('4(.5(2

$# 3" #$A $

2 2

.6 (.'.(.65#$@

3" / A

"

2

#$ / 77 , &<<5

'4'<(.6.

#$

$

3"

2

" 2

#$

" $ ! " 2 2 "

? $#" "

$2

2 " C

"

2 =52 $

"

" ? "

"

<= "

%#@

" "

$ "

# "

2 2" 2 #

*9(

2B

# +2

2

" $

7 #

" "

$ $ *9)"

"

2

"

3"" $#

"$ " $!$2 "

"

B

+2

*9&

+2

2

"

)''((..& *

+2

2 ? # *9(-

" "

+2

+2

? " "

$ " $ 7 2

$

# $ "

2 #

#$2$

$

# "

2 ?

7

#

#$

2 2 ?

#" 2

#$ "# 2

2 "B

" 2

$

2 # 2

2

/ "

2

? #

#

$

2 "

?

? "

$ "

$

"

# 2 2# ?

? "

! "#

$

$

2 # $

#$ 2 2 # #$ "

# $

7

$

2 2

$

2

2 2

2 $ 7# %"

"

$

# # "

#

%" # * "

"

#"

7

A

(56)! 2# B %"

/ " = 1 "$9- 6#-"#- 1 $/- .#,

&:; "0"1 ( $/ )3> #-<35 .C) 6# .8 $ ,

:

;"0"1&(' ! %"

/ " 2

$

2 # $ #$ 2 2

2 " 2

# #

$ / "

2

#$2$

$

!

$

"

$# 2

2 " # "#

$ B

"

B "

!

$

"

"

2

# $ #$ #$2 #

"

# 2 #

#

2

$

2

2 2 $ !

#

#$2$

# 2 2 ""

4=

7

A

! 2

$ #" 2

$

"

#

$

!

# 2

$

" # 2

"

%"

B

2

$

# 2 B

$

2 "

"

! 2 # %"

D# ?/ " 5

#-/- 6#<-2- $",. =. / #

( :

; : $; && 2 #-> 31" - $/ 6# ) / - 1 32 8 $/ $- ., (':

;&& 2

2 " # # %"

! / "2E / "

#

2

#

$ 2

%"

@ 2/ " &'(')'()#$ ) 8 &,

( : ;

=$ A- - .#= >"$9D.

#$ /

# A- - .. =.

#