High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/1121/2017dismissed

State Of Haryana And ORS v. Om Parkash Uda

2018-01-19Mr. Justice Rajesh Bindal,Mr. Justice B.S. Walia8 pages

!"# $ %&' (')* +#, -&%&' %./% %% (&0'.* 122'33% &* 4'.*5* 6%.7%*0(% 1'*2 (' &

.'*' &+

.%85&&-0%.6%9 9 %./% %

:; .%/'. &0* &.%<)5.& %22'%3 * . *'&& = %*(' >5(=6' & (%&'( "?@ 2%**'( A/ &0' 3'%. '( - =3' 5(='9 B0'.'A/ &0' %22'33% &*<.'*2 (' &* B'.' (.')&'( & 2%** % .'*0 .('. 2.6& = &0' 2'&& '.&&0'2*& &.')&.% (.'3'%*'%33) *'C5' &%3A' ' &* & 06 B&0 %2'.( ' 6 &0 .6 &0' (%&' .')'2& )'.& '( )2/ &0'.('. :; .'

%)&* &0')%*'3'%( =&&0' 3 = &0' &.%< 5.&%22'%3 %.'&0%&&0'2'&& '.B%**'3')&'(% (%22 &'(%**&.)&5A3)'3%& *

)'. $$## 0'.'% &'.90'B%*2.6&'(%*'25&/.')&. $@$'D&2.6& %32*&*&0%& &.')&.&A' 33'(52

.6%6 =*&2'.* * 33 =&0' 33B =C5%3 )%& * &'.6*

%./% %5A3)'3%& *'2%.&6' &%3 .52<-'.8)'53'*9#,+< E5. /'%.* 'D2'.' )' %* '25&/ .')&.9 %( % ( .'** %*

)'.9.8* %3 %62%=

)'.F :$;

.'8% )' &0' B.& 2'&& '. B%* &0%& ('*2&' &0' 2*& & .')&.0%8 =A')6'%8%3%A3' &0'('2%.&6' & 90'B%*

"# & 2.6&'( &0' ).)56*&% )'*9 &0' B.& 2'&& '. 68'( .'2.'*' &%& . 2.6& & &0' 2*& & .')&. ? 'D5.'"B0'.'52 0*)%*'B%* .B%.('(A/&0'.')&. ' '.%39 .6%& 9 5A3) '3%& % ( 53&5.%3

%.* '2%.&6' & & &0'

8'. 6' &.'*2 (' &$8('3'&&'.(%&'( 'D5.' .'*2 *'&0'.'&9&0' 8'. 6' &8('3'&&'.(%&'( 'D5.' ,(.')&'(&0'.')&. ' '.%39 .6%& 95A3)'3%& % ( 53&5.%3

%.* '2%.&6' & .'*2 (' & $ & *' ( 2.6& %=' (% & &0'

8'. 6' & B&0 &B (%/* . ) 8' = '2%.&6' &%3 .6&

66&&''0'.' % &'..'

'..'(&%*<G H .'*2 *'&0'.'&9.')&.

' '.%39 .6%& 9 5A3) '3%& % ( 53&5.%3

%.* '2%.&6' & .'*2 (' &$*' &&0'2.6& %=' (%&&0' 8'. 6' &8('3'&&'. (%&'(# 'D5.'#A5& %)& B%*&%7' &0'*%6'% ( &0'6'% &6'9&0'B.&2'&& '..'&.'( $ :?; &0'% .'6' & '(A%)7=.5 (9&0'2'&& '. 3'(%B.&2'&& *''7 =(.')& *&&0'%22'33% &*<.'*2 (' &*&2.6&'06 &0'2*& & .')&. B&0 '

')& .6 % ( & =.% & 06 %33 ) *'C5' &%3A' '

&* &0'=.5 (&0%&%*2'. 8'. 6' & *&.5)& H* (%&'( " 'D5.' @9 2% '3 % &)2%&'( 8%)% )'* 2.6& C5&% 52& $*& ')'6A'. 'D& /'%. B%* & A' 2.'2%.'( A/ 8'6A'.'8'.//'%.% ( 5.&0'.&0%& B%*.'C5.'(&6''&B&0 &0'

.*&C5%.&'. '%)0)%3' (%./'%.&2.'2%.'%3*& %332'.* *'3=A3' 2.6& %=% *&8%)% )'*37'3/&%.*'(5. =&0')5.*' &0'/'%.* &0%& 2.6& )53( A' 6%(' B&05& % / 3** &6' &0' 8%)% )/ %.* = B'8'.9(5'& %)& &0'%22'33% &*<.'*2 (' &*&2.'2%.' &0'2% '3A/) 8' = %)).(% )'B&0&0' *&.5)& *9&0'B.& 2'&& '.B%*25&&2.'>5()'%* &0'6'% &6'90'.'&.'( $

"$# '*53&% &3/0'*5

'.'(3** % )%3A' '

&*9A'*('*9.')5.. =3** 2' * 0' B.& 2'&& '. 6%(' .'2.'*' &%& * (%&'( $ % ( #@ 'D5.')3%6 =2.6& &&0'2*& &.')&. % ( .'*2 *'&0'.'&B%* .6'(&0%&0')53( &A'2.6&'(2..& &0'(%&' 0*.'&.'6' &%*6''& = &0' )53( &A') 8' '( %))5 & )'.&% %(6 *&.%&8'.'%* * :";

.'8% )' &0' B.& 2'&& '. 5.&0'. * &0%& % &'. 0' .'&.'( $9 B%* 0'3( 'D5.' ? B0)0 ' *07 I56%.9 '25&/ .')&. B%* .')66' ('( .

)%& = %* & .')&.('*2&'0*A' =&B*&'2*3B'.&0% &0'2'&& '. &0'*' .&/ 3*& '25&/.')&.*-%(*07I56%.B%*=8'

)%& =)0%.='%* & .')&. %* ' -%&*0 I56%. *0 B%* %) = (*)23 %./ 2.)''( =* B'8'.9-%&*0I56%.*0B%*'D '.%&'( &0')0%.='* 8('.('.(%&'(#@ 'D5.'"B0'.'52 B%*) 8' '( 66'(%&'3/ % ( 0' B%* 2.6&'( %* & .')&. 8(' .('. (%&'( @J, 'D5.'@'$(%/*2..&&0'(%&' 0*.'&.'6' & $-63%.3/9 '%60%=%&-0%.6%9'25&/.')&.B%* 2.6&'( %* & .')&. 8(' .('. (%&'( $$ 'D5.' # 2..&&0'(%&' 0*.'&.'6' & $$$-63%.3/9 'I%&0 B%*=8' &0'A' '

& 52=.%( = &0'2*& (6 *&.%&8'

)'.& &0'2*& '25&/.')&.(6 8('.('.(%&'(?@, 'D5.' % (B0A5& .&0'52=.%(%& B53(0%8'.'&.'(%*(6 *&.%&8'

)'. -63%.3/ ' 0%3 - =09 .>')& .')&. B%* =8' 2.6& %* ((& %3 .')&. .&9 % =5%=' 53&5.%3

%.* A/ 52=.%( =0*2*&%*%6'%*5.'2'.* %3&06% (B&05&) 8' = 8(' .('. (%&'( @# 'D5.' &0' % .'6' & '( A%)7=.5 (9& B%* ) &' ('( A'

.'&0'B.& 5.&&0%& &0'%)&

"%# ('2%.&6' & & 2.6& = &0' B.& 2'&& '. A' .' &0' (%&' 0* .'&.'6' &&&0'2*& &.')&.9%33'='(3/ %))5 & %A3&/& ) 8' ' %))5 & %(6 *&.%&8'.'%* *B%*5 >5*& '( :@; %)&5%32*& %*.'

'..'(&%A8'B%* &(' '(A/&0'%22'33% &*< .'*2 (' &*% (&0' 3/23'%B%*&0%&&0'2'&& '.)53( &A'2.6&'( 2..&0*.'&.'6' & %))5 & %A3&/&) 8' '&0'6''& = 2..&$ :; '

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

B%**' & #A5&&0' )53( &A' ) *&&5&'( (5' & *0.&%=' &6' & B%* 5.&0'. ) &' ('( &0%& &0' 2'&& '. )53( & )3%6 2.6& %* % 6%&&'. .=0& A5& )53( 3/ )3%6) *('.%& :#; !' 0%8' ) *('.'( &0' *5A6** * 6%(' A/ &0' 3'%. '( -&%&' )5 *'3% (%.' &0') *('.'(8'B&0%& .&0'.'%* *%*%.'.').('( 0'.'5 ('.9&0'%22'%3*A'.'

& 6'.&9&0'.'

.'*3%A3'&A'(*6**'( 36 '

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

'33 8%)% & 9 &0' %22'33% &*<.'*2 (' &* B'.' .'C5.'( & &%7' %)& %)).(% )' B&0 &0' *&.5)& * & 33 52 &0' 8%)% )'* %& &0' '%.3'*& 2**A3' B&05& B%*&%=' % / &6' %)& %* 2'. &0' *&.5)& * 'D5.'@%*.'

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

"'# B&05&% /3** &6' &0'8%)% )/%.* =' 05*9 &0' %22'33% &*<.'*2 (' &* ('

%53&'( & %(0'. = & &0' *&.5)& * 'D5.' @A/ &2.'2%. = %2% '3 8'6A'. .8%)% )'* B0)0 B'.' & %.*' 52& ')'6A'.9 A'*('* A/ & ) 8' = &0' 6''& = &0' &0' .*&C5%.&'. &0'/'%. 33 =52&0' 8%)% )'*&%.*'(5. =&0')5.*' &0'/'%.%*&0'8%)% )/ &0*)%*' B%*&%.*' *&'%(9&0'%22'33% &*<.'*2 (' &*'.')&.

' '.%39 .6%& 9 5A3) '3%& % ( 53&5.%3

%.* '2%.&6' & & &0' 8'. 6' &.'*2 (' &$ .B%.('(&0')%*' &0'2'&& '. 2.6& & &0' 2*& & .')&. 'D5.' 9 .'*2 *'&B0)0&0' 8'. 6' &8('3'&&'.(%&'( 'D5.' ,(.')&'(&0'.')&. ' '.%39 .6%& 95A3)'3%& % ( 53&5.%3

%.* '2%.&6' & .'*2 (' & $ & *' ( 2.6& %=' (% & &0'

8'. 6' &B&0 &B(%/* .) 8' = 0'%=' (%B%**' & &0'8'./ 'D&(%/' # 'D5.'#A5&6''& =B%* & ) 8' '( :$; 0' %)&* &0')%*'=&*0BA'/ (% &% (5A&&0%& %)& ) *('. =&0')3%6 &0'B.&2'&& '. .2.6& &&0'2*& & .')&. &6' %* 2'. &0' *&.5)& * %223)%A3' * 'D)35*8'3/ %&&.A5&%A3'&&0'%22'33% &*<.'*2 (' &* 0' *&.5)& * 'D5.'@ %*%223)%A3'% (%*.'

'..'(&%A8'B'.' 35&'(B&0625 &/% ( &0' ' ( &0' *&% ( &%7' 52 B%* &0%& %3&05=0 &0' %=' (% 0%( A'' *' & 2.6& &0'2'&& '.&&0'2*& &.')&.9/'&&0'2'&& '. )53( &A'2.6&'((5'& %A3&/&) 8' '&0'6''& = (5' &*0.&%=' &6'%*&0'2*&0%( %33' 8%)% & % (%=' (% B%* *' & # 'D5.' # B03' &0' 2'&& '. .'&.'( $

# :?; %(&0'%22'33% &*<.'*2 (' &*%(0'.'(&&0' *&.5)& * 'D5.' @**5'(A/&0' 8'. 6' &9 (

)53&/B0%&*'8'.B53(0%8'%.*' * )'&0'2% '3B53(0%8'A'' 2.'2%.'( .8%)% )'*B0)0B'.'&%.*' 52& $ 8'6A'. % ( 6''& = &0' B53( 0%8' A'' ) 8' '( &0' .*&C5%.&'.'52&$$ .2.'2%. =%2% '3 )% ((%&'* .2.6& B0)0B'.'& %338%)% &(5. =&0'/'%. 0'%22'33% &*<.'*2 (' &*0%8'%3* &A'' %A3'&) &.8'.&&0'23'% &0'2'&& '.9 2.6& *J52=.%(%& *%*.'

'..'(&%A8' 2%.%=.%20 *" %A8'0%8 =A'' 6%('

)'.*% 'B(%/*2..&&0'. .'&.'6' &)).( =3/9B' ( 6'.& &0'%22'%3 :"; 3 =B&0)0%33' ='&>5(=6' &(%&'("?@9 &0* &.%)5.& %22'%39%223)%& 0%*%3*A'' 3'(2.%/ = .) ( %& $?(%/* 3%&' 3 = &0'%22'%32'.5*%3 &0'%223)%& .'8'%3*&0%&25.*5% & & .')'2& 625= '( >5(=6' & "?@9 .'C5'*& B%*6%(' &&0'

)' &0'(8)%&' ' '.%39 %./% %%*B'33%** %./% %8('3'&&'. (%&'(#"@ &*''7 3'=%3 2 %* & B0'&0'. &0' )%*' B%* &

3 = 0' (8)%&' ' '.%39 %./% %9 8(' 6'6 (%&'( #@ .6'( 3 = &0' 6%&&'. %./% % %3* ) )5..'(B&0&0'8'B &0'(8)%&' ' '.%39 %./% %% (%)).( =3/ **5'((.')& *&&0'(8)%&' ' '.%39 %./% %& 3'&0' &0' 6%&&'.8('6'6(%&'($#@ 0'.'% &'.9&0'%22'33% &*.'6% '( )..'*2 (' )'B&0&0'

)' &0'(8)%&' ' '.%3 3 =% ( &0'*%6'B%* 3'( "% (% &'..'68%3 A>')& *&0'*%6' B%* .'

33'( ," -&% ( %3* * &0%& &0' ('%3 = %***&% & 0%( 2.)''('( 3'%8' % ( &0' )%*' B%* A' = 0% (3'( A/ % &0'. -' . ***&% &% ((5'&('3%/ 3 = &0' *&% &9) )'. '('%3 = ***&% & &0'

)' .'*2 (' & $ 0%* A'' *&%&'( & 0%8' A''

"(# )0%.='*0''&'(5 ('.53' %./% % 83-'.8)'*5 *06' &% ( 22'%3 53'* #,9 8(' 6'6 (%&'( ,? )).( =3/9 . &0' .'%* *%*=8' &0'%223)%& .) ( %& ('3%/9('3%/ $? (%/* 3%&' 3 = &0'%22'%3*) ( '( :@; B'8'.9 &0'3=0& &0'2*& %* &'(%A8'9B'%.' ) *('.'(8'B&0%& )%*'B0%&*'8'.*6%('5& . &'.

'. =B&0&0' B'33<.'%* '(.('.(%&'("?@92%**'(A/&0'3'%. '(B.& 5.& :; )).( =3/9 ( = 6'.& &0'%22'%39&0'*%6'*(*6**'( 36 ' )*+,- ./0)1!

)1.)! 203+ 203+ #, %6& !0'&0'.&0'.('.*.'%* '(J*2'%7 = + '*J !0'&0'.&0'.('.*.'2.&%A3' + '*J