← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/1122/2017dismissed

St Of Hry Fc-Cum-Ps To Govt Of Hry Town & Country Palnning Deptt Hry Cs Chd & ORS v. Somvir Singh

2018-01-19Mr. Justice Rajesh Bindal,Mr. Justice B.S. Walia5 pages

  

           ! "# $  %&' (') * !+, -&%&' %./%!%%!(&0'.* 122'33%!&* 4'.*5* -67 .- !80 1'*2!('!&

+

9 - 

 - 

9 - 

-" .'*'!&+ .%7 5&&-0%.6%: : %./%!% ;;;     <= .%/'. ! &0' >. & 2'& & ! >%* . 8.%!&   -')!( **5.'(

%.''. .8.'** !   2%/ *)%3' 5!('. &0' 7 3 -'.7 )'* **5.'( %.''..8.'** !53'*:0'.' !% &'..'

'..'(&%*?@&0' 53'*9:%*%3* .('* 8!%& !8&0'2'& & !'.%*(( & !%3-5A 7 * !%3

!8 !''.0'.' !% &'..'

'..'(&%*?@- 95!('.-)0'(53'%.& % .'*% (53'* <= 0' .*&2.%/'.>%*8 7'!52A/&0'>. &2'& & !'.%*.'3 '  ! .'*2')& &0'.'& >%* 8.%!&'( A/ &0' %22'33%!&*B.'*2!('!&* (5. !8 &0' 2'!('!)/ &0'>. &2'& & ! <C= 0'*')!(2.%/'.:!%6'3/ .8.%!& ('* 8!%& ! : >%* %33>'( A/ &0' 3'%.!'( >. & 5.& ! &0' 3 80&   53'* %* >'33 %* -)0'(53'&&0'53'*A/03( !8&0%&%(6 &&'(3/&0'>. &2'& & !'.0%(25&

 !/'%.* *%& * %)&./*'.7 )'%*5! . !8 !''. !&0''2%.&6'!& >!%!( 5!&./3%!! !8: 7'.!6'!& %./%!%%!( !7 '>&0'.'  ! %)).(%!)' > &0 3%5*'    %.&    -)0'(53'  & &0' 53'*: &0' >. & 2'& & !'. >%* '!& &3'( & A' ('* 8!%&'( %* -   "0 3' 03( !8 *: &0' 3'%.!'(>. & 5.&.'D')&'(&0'23'%&0%&&0'.'>%*!2*& 5!('. &0'-'.7 )'53'*:&0'.'

.': 5.&0'.2.6& ! &0'2'& & !'.&&0'2*&  3%!! !8 ** *&%!& )53( !& A' )!* ('.'(  0' 3'%.!'( >. & )5.& .'D')&'( &0' % .'6'!& !'( *&%!(   &0' %22'33%!&*B.'*2!('!&* A/ A*'.7 !8&0%&&0'>. &2'& & !'.>%*!3/*''E !8('* 8!%& !&&0'2*& - %!(&0%&'7'!% &'.A' !8('* 8!%&'(%*- :0'>53()!& !5'& *5A*&%!& 7'3/03(&0'2*& 5! . !8 !''.%!(&0'!3/A'!'

&>0 )0&0' >. & 2'& & !'. >53( ('. 7' >53( A'   )!* ('.%& !   0 * )3% 6 . 2.6& ! 5!('. &0' %223 )%A3' -'.7 )' 53'* . &0' 2*&   3%!! !8 ** *&%!&%!(&0%&('* 8!%& ! &0'>. &2'& & !'.%*- >53(!' &0'. !737' %!/ !%!) %3 A'!'

&* !. >53( '!&% 3 8.%!&   %!/ 2.6& !%3 *&%&5*  0' 3'%.!'( ". & 5.& &E &0' %A7'6'!& !'( 7 '> ! &0' .'%*! !8&0%&%))'2&%!)' &0'23'% &0'-&%&'>53(.'!('.&0'F5&'( 53'*>0 )00%(A''! .%6'(5!('..& )3'C, !*& &5& ! !( %: !58%&./ <$= ! &0' % .'6'!& !'( A%)E8.5!(: &0' 3'%.!'( ". & 5.& ( .')&'(&0'%22'33%!&*B.'*2!('!&*&('* 8!%&'&0'>. &2'& & !'.%*- > &05& 8.%!&   %!/ !%!) %3 A'!'

&* . 2.6& !%3 *&%&5* ! .('. & '!%A3'0 6&)3% 62.6& !&&0'!'G&0 80'.2*& 3%!! !8** *&%!& &A')!* ('.'(%*2'.%223 )%A3'-'.7 )'53'*!&0'*5A*&%!& 7'2*&0'3( A/0 6%*5! . !8 !''. <H= 0' *3' 8.5!( ! >0 )0 )0%33'!8' 0%* A''! .% *'( & &0' ( .')& !* **5'(A/&0'3'%.!'(". & 5.& *&0%&&0'.' *!*%!)& !'(2*&

  !&0''2%.&6'!&  >!%!( 5!&./3%!! !8%!(&0%& !&0' %A*'!)' %*%!)& !'(2*&:&0'2'& & !'.)%!!&A'('* 8!%&'(%*- . (( & !%3 >!3%!!'.!)623'& ! /'%.* *'.7 )'%3&0580&0' >. &2'& & !'.0%*)623'&'(/'%.* *'.7 )'%!(&0'2%/*)%3'* 5! .

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

%./%!%-'.7 )'  >!3%!!'.-&%&'-'.7 )' .52B%6'!('(53'*: ,:%3%!! !8** *&%!&> &0H/'%.*'G2'. '!)' !&0''2%.&6'!& *& A')!* ('.'( .2.6& !&&0'2*& ** *&%!& >!3%!!'.!&0' % .'6'!& !'( A%)E8.5!(: *&%!( ! 2%.%8.%20 $   &0' 8.5!(*  %22'%3 *&0%&&0'>. &2'& & !'.>0>%*>.E !8%*5! . !8 !''.)53( !& A' 23%)'( ! &0' .'B('* 8!%&'( 2*&   -  . 'F5 7%3'!& 2*&  ** *&%!& >!3%!!'. < = "'0%7')!* ('.'(&0'*5A6 ** !*6%('%!(%.' &0'7 '> &0%& %(6 &&'(3/ &0' >. & 2'& & !'. >%* 8.%!&'( B  ,C B C$: J H > &0'

')& .6#!%))5!& )623'& ! /'%.* .'853%.*%& * %)&./*'.7 )'7 ('.('.HC!!'G5.'B **5'(A/ &0' .')&. '!'.%3: >!%!( 5!&./3%!! !8: 0%!( 8%.0 ! %)).(%!)'> &0&0'53'*%.& -)0'(53'&&0'53'*)%&'8. )%33/

 2.7 ('*&0%&5! . !8 !''. !&0'&0.''> !8* ":%!)0%/%& %D %!( >!%!( 5!&./3%!! !8'2%.&6'!&%.''!& &3'(&&0'2%/*)%3'  ,CBC$:BH!)623'& ! /'%.*.'853%.*%& * %)&./ *'.7 )'*> &0)0%!8'(('* 8!%& !  <=

3% 6   &0' >. & 2'& & !'. * A%*'( ! &0' 53'* %!( &0' -)0'(53'%*%3*!0 * 33 !8&0')!( & !**& 253%&'(&0'.' ! .8.%!& &0'A'!'

&)3% 6'(!&0') .)56*&%!)'*:3'%.!'(-&%&')5!*'30%*!& A''!%A3'&5.8'%!/8.5!(>%..%!& !8 !&'. '.'!)'A/&0 * 5.&> &0&0' .('.2%**'(A/&0'3'%.!'(>. & 5.&03( !8&0%&('! %3 &0'('* 8!%& ! )3% 6'(%*2'.&0'53'*%223 )%A3'>53(&%!&%65!&&.'!('. !8&0'53'*

.%6'(5!('..& )3'C, !*& &5& ! !( %!58%&./'* ('*:%* 0%*A''!0'3(A/&0'3'%.!'(". & 5.&:&0'>. &2'& & !'.>53(!3/A' '!& &3'(&&0'8.%!& ('* 8!%& ! > &05&%!/ !%!) %3A'!'

&* !.'*2')&&0'.'&:*3'3/&'!& &3'0 *)3% 6 .2.6& !&&0'!'G&0 80'. 2*&&A')!* ('.'( !%)).(%!)'> &0&0'53'*%223 )%A3' <,= 3!8 > &0 )0%33'!8' & D5(86'!& (%&'( # ! &0 * !&.%B)5.&%22'%3:%223 )%& !0%*%3*A''!67'(2.%/ !8 .)!(!%& ! $#(%/*9('3%/ !3%&' 3 !8 &0'%22'%3 <=  2'.5*%3 &0'%223 )%& !.'7'%3*&0%&)2/ &0' 6258!'( D5(86'!& (%&'( # >%* .')' 7'( A/ &0' %22'33%!&* ! $# >0 3' &0' 

)'   &0' (7)%&' '!'.%3: %./%!%: 7 (' 3'&&'. (%&'( $#%(7 *'(&0')%*'&A' & . 3 !8  >'7'.: ..'%*!* A'*& E!>! & &0' %22'33%!&*:  >%* 3'( !3/ ! H 

G23%!%& !8 7'!&0%&!.')' 2& %(7 )':)..'*2!('!)'>%*8 !8! > &0&0'

)' (7)%&' '!'.%3: . 3 !8 %22'%3:&0'.'A/ ('3%/ ))%* !'(: ! 5. 7 '> ('* !& )!*& &5&' *5

) '!& )%5*' . )!(!%& ! $#(%/*9('3%/ !3%&' 3 !8 &0'%22'%3)).( !83/: .

  &0' .'%*!* %* 6'!& !'( %A7': ! )%*' * 6%(' 5& . )!(!%& !  ('3%/ $#(%/* !3%&' 3 !8 &0'%22'%3 )).( !83/:%223 )%& ! .)!(!%& ! ('3%/ *( *6 **'( %!( .'*53&%!&3/: &0' %22'%3 . &0' .'%*!* %* .').('( %A7' * %3* ( *6 **'()*&* 

 !"#$% &  &#   '%( 

'%(  , %6 & &'+  "0'&0'.&0'.('. *.'%*!'(K*2'%E !8 + '*K  "0'&0'.&0'.('. *.'2.&%A3' + '*K