← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/725/2016dismissed

State Of Haryana Through Collector, Hisar & Others v. Sohan Lal And Another

2019-09-05Mr. Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia12 pages



      



            ! " #" #                      

   

   

 ! "     ! $" $" % #$% & '()*+ ',-%+',-(+ ',-*+  $#*-  

&  *'(+ *'*+*',+*'-+ *#(+*#*+*#,+ *#-+*%.+*%)+ *%'+*%$+*%#+ *%%+*%(+*%*+ *%,+  *%-+  ,#'

 

/012!'*-! 3!'.)( &!*'(!'.)( /012!'*(! 3!'.)( &!*'*!'.)( /012!',.! 3!'.)( &!*',!'.)( /012!',$! 3!'.)( &!*#*!'.)( /012!$),! 3!'.)( &!*#,!'.)( & )*'   % /012!',%! 3!'.)( &!*#-!'.)( /012!',*! 3!'.)( &!*%.!'.)( /012!','! 3!'.)( &!*%)!'.)( /012!$)*! 3!'.)( &!*%'!'.)( /012!',,! 3!'.)( &!*%$!'.)( /012!'-'! 3!'.)( &!*%#!'.)( /012!',)! 3!'.)( &!*%(!'.)( /012!',(! 3!'.)( &!*%*!'.)(    ! "

" % & '.).+ '.))+'.)'+ '*%,  '*%-+ '*(.+'*()+ '*('

'*($   &  &  *'%  

)*,- &  )*,,+ )*-*+)*-,+   )*-.+ )*-)+ )*-'+ )*-$+ )*-#+ )*-% 

)*--   & !'

()*+,"-./01&,2"/"/('3+1

 4 5 5 " ++ 5

6  ++  5  75 " +8+   

 5 " 2 +8 5  8 "+8 5   8  +8 5 ;   +8 5   2  +8 5 <= +8+ 5 +8+ 

  2"/"/('3+1  4-"

     "=  +   %#  > +),-#+$)

+)%

  )$ ! " + 

    '      .#.#'..,     ).)''..,               ?          

+ 8 :+   # + > + > 1    +   "=   =6        +   .%))'.)% .'))'.)(+ 8  &  

           .#.#'..,+ 

 

   ( .-.%'..,+ =  )',*    >       "8 <  6  =& 

 6  >

 +8  '.!)*))'..,+@ = 78 A,7     +).7       

)*7   +     73     ), +     +8

5  .%))'.)%+

 '. + =    =1   +@ = 78A).-%B!

 >  9%'+-,+((*B!  :6 

=         '#.-'..*+       =    '  7 +     )-+,*+...B!   + = 78   A *-+#,+...B!  

   )B$ + 8  

)-+,(+...B! = 78     & 

   #   )*  ).)''..,  (  @  ++)))''..,6     '%.''..-A,7     7  + )(( 6  >

       7   "8 6  =   +<  9 :6

 +    =    

 +          ), = 78 A ))..B! >  9%$+'#+...B!  : 6     +

  + =         .%))'.)%+  !-$! 

         == =          

 +8 +

   >   8                   %),BB'$B'B)9)!': 8  +    7 > =  #7 )#= 6 =  

= A)'C        '

$

            ,  =   (      6       >         6  =    >    D 

     8 +     

= 78 =    A))..B! >  3    

=           8 , =                        

   + 8 " 

=     @= + +  = E    '7       5   5 "      =         >   & 

    =   

  +   "=  @   ' 6789:4' 6 "9;/  "  

/&&% +  = = 78  +         8   0  #)'* +    5!(.'*! 3!'.)(

&!*'%!'.)(    ').).'..*+ =  )7 #= + = 78

  7 $#7  '#)''..*+ -7 ,= += 78

  7$+(.+...B!  ! 9

@ !$:        @=  5  7  5 " +  8+            +  =    

   7   + 8+ +  8    + = 78A))..B! >  +  

+ "   

 +    += 

=   =  "6 

    =  %(,    '#.-'..*++*=       #

  +  >   

+  +  7 @=          >  + +  "             +       

  8    =   = 8   

   

    0   

      8 +  =               '%.''..-

    "    7     + = 8     8            +      + +

   '#.-'..*9F@ !):   %(,< (    )-+,*+...B!6 ! 9F@ D$B:

           @=  6 !

     & 

    =

1  5  +

  %(-+

 @ =   !     =   %(, %(* 

 

>  =   

(%+

 

 =    & 

8    

    +   %%*+%%,+%%-+%(. %),+

    7+

  =    +   >    

    

  = + +

 

5  5 " =         =

    = 

+    = +  " %(, *  = 

 

    + 8+ +    

 =7  

== = =  ==3  + +   8   = 78 

  @ =                 

+ 

     %(*

  = 78  %(- @ =        6   + 8F@ !)+

   +   8   + +       

 ' 678 9:9 : "= +      @  

 ==    8



        +

   

   7 +   +   8

 7         %),    @ =     =        

   + =        %%*  

== = 8

=   %),F8  + +

=7 @= 9F@ !):  @      = 78    =

 +D!)+ ;0 8      8             7  =  )B$ + ="+   = 6

> )',* 

    )((      3    + +    

   = 78+ 3 0 -< "

/ .  

 /&&$+&  = ;:+ < "

+  >9     /&&5#  ?@ 09   " =< "/ A9@;   $/&$+ @         

   >      7     8     =         @=  =   8 +     ).).'..* '#)''..*+    

% 6   8  = 78  + A$#7        '= +    +A $+(.+...B! 3    0  #)'* +

  =

       

     =   = =      = 8 6  8 0  #)'* + +       = 

        7 =    E=                                 8 

  

))))'.)#  @ .-.)'.)%   + "     .'.$'.)%+  )'.$'.)%+  .,.#'.)%+  '*.%'.)%   8  +   @=  .(.*'.)% 

=  6   +       8   .%))'.)%     8        @   / ?98297  < "

/    ':      1     /&          8 0  #)'*  =      7  =     8  @   . 1 < "1;8.

  % /&& $%

     8   

#   @  = + 

  0  #)'*  @ +  

  8  >    "=     +          8   

  =    .'))'.)(+     

"         6 !

 9F@ !' !$:        8 

8  6  =  = = 

  

 =   6 +  =6  =

+ +

  = !     +%),    ==   

     >                        8 + 

>   3+ +     

        6 

8 3       8  8        = 8   = ! +       ! +  +   6  =& 

    =     5  7  5 "                = 

  + 8  8

  +     8+    E 

   7 = 8    )*7   + =    

   +  A  ).  7       +   E   

    6           7 5  = +      = 7 8     7   8 F8  = 8    1  5     >  + 

 +  = 8  3+ +      ==    >

   = 78= D!'  

 '7= = 1!  1 

) 7= = 

!(%3+   = +   

    +  "      @=  ! 9F@ !'+ !$+ !-:     8    6  = + 

>   & 

  +8  +

    8  =  +   F@!'!%

 =

  = 78    #') 7 %'-7   +  &  +'..,2 +'..,+        8 =  5 =    =       8          D

+  > 8   + " 3  D 

  =8   



 

8 

>  ). 8   =  D!$+=2  + ; =  

8   +

           +       =    8         

3      

), 8     +            7     

              +8           + =   

   398:         '%.''..- >      39:+  = 

           =  = =     

    

 

=

  !=

+  7    =  + 398:+   3    ; =  7 8   8      7   =   >  =   =@==$= +

+ ; =         >   +8    E  

8  + 6             = +        ).)''..,+

   

     =     $.C       = 7  8        8  + 8     '$    +      

    

              

8  $.C = 78    =   >  + 

   +   

 +    +  = .%.-'.)-   2"/"/('3+1    -.2,