← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/22791/2024dismissed

Santosh Gupta And Another v. Permanent Lok Adalat And Others

2024-09-24Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj19 pages



    

     

  



 !"# $%&   

'( $) *+ +$%&   

, ,

   

 



  - .

-

- -

, /, 

 ,



&  0- , /  ,       



 

 /  ,  1 

-

     

!

 "   #

  $%&&%& '

(  )*  &+%,&%&'

( )+*



- ) .

/ 0'0 1 0 

* 123    0

- 4 &%&+ !00 #

0

0    0



 &%,&%&

 



   



- &)1

5 /  

)3

 3    2,

&  0 ## 6     

     7 '

  

 - )

 7*  0 

  



  +% 0/

# 

 - &)5 / !  0

 !



 0   %+&&%8

  

  



90-  9

90

:

(

;



  0 < /

- ' 0 *  =  # 

- !

0 #

)0

  0

0 



- &)5 /  0 >  2  0

0 !

 

  #

   

  

 2 0

 !

0  $, #

0

00#   +% %,?)   0

 ! 

@,&%A

#   

 



0  + 2  

    7   

 -  !

# 

- &)5 /0

# !

"    !

#

 - +)   9

 .  

# . #   

) # ( # #  & + ,%?) !

0 0

!

0 ) 

3 # 



0  !

0

0  0 

 # 0  

 

 2



0

#!

3

 0 00  #  

- &)5 / 



- + 0

!   0



#

%$&&%8

0 !    # #   & + ,%?)   

   ,%%?)20

# !

    

! B# 

 %&&%8   0    0 !



%8&&%81

 0   7

!

#  /

%%4&%&& ! 0 # # 

  00 #

   

- 

#0

#

- & +   

  7  " # = 



  

 -:3   ;

!



# !

 

 ! 

  

 -    00

  &4%&%&& 

 - &  +  

 -    0 %%8&%&&

#

)5 /!  !



 # #!

  

%4%&&%&%  0  0  %%&&%&% !

      7       

  # 0 (#



 

   

    !

=  2  

0 #     #

# 

  #

 # 0 (#



=

  ! !



##

0 000 %%&&%&%2 

  

    .

/ 0 '0  1 0  

*  12 3   

0#      0   0

  

&&)3 .0



   8, .

/

0  

  &%,&%&+   

)5 /   "  # C2

 0 0

  !00 /  

0   0

! 

+ 



 9

0 

  C

#        &%%& '



D9C &%%&>* 4

 !  #

 # 0 0#    

 0 

&&)3 .0



   8,    

      #

 #  (

    !



&&)3',* .0



   8,  $   #



!   00  

# #

0

!  .

/0 

$%&&%& 

0



0     

?0

   

  



#

     # 2 0

 

(

     

 

    

          

 

 

               

    



     

 

   

            

  

   

 

 

  !

   "  

 

4

!           

            

  

   #$%%   

 #$%      %    

    



   







     

  

  

    &

             

    

            

       

  

                   

    

 '



(   

 -    0  0

  4%+&%&  

 9C 

B 

2  0) 3    '  

   DB2)>* !  !

 - , &%&2# !

=

B2)

# #  #

#0

0  ! # #



 

B2)  !

# 

0 

)5 /

 

   0  !    

  2  0 ;

  0

 

- !



!  !

#B2)



  %$%,&%&  0     

  



5

#

! 0!2 0

 

(

   ) )                                ' 

  

       $   *

  

#$%+

  

,)!

 &               '

           '

  

     

( ,  2  

   

    .

/ 0 

/ 

0 0

 



$%&&%& 0

!  0

/   C





 0

 # ! 0

) /

 0

&%,&%& 



   

!00  /  

0

2 .

/ 0 

&+%,&%& 

 0

 0  

 

0

 



$%&&%&2  

(

   ) % +   '     # $ %  - +

 %  .

  

              +              #$%



+

   #$%+

  

   +     %  +               

 '( 

      



 

      

     

  

    !     

   "      .    &

   +     .                     +             #$%+

  &         #$% ,

/          '

       

      '  !            + 

 

   

            

   "  $             

    %      

     " 

  



 

 01!      %    

    

       

( 8 ;

  

 % .

0

   

0   

  =# ;

>0 #3 #  

 

6

   .

/0

0



   (

  =

 !

 

&&)3',*  .0



   8, ! 0    !      .

0 0 0  

  =#  ;

>0  #3 #       

  !  "# $  %$   

   

#



   !

)!

 !

0

##

 =

0 #  

    0  #







0



;   !

 

00 !  

 =#   -  #  

 &      0

 3

0

   

   





#  0

!   

!00 =#    +    0

 0    0

 3

0

   

  =#  ;

>0  # 3     &

  # #

00

 !

 

 

  ;

>0  # 3   

!

! 

0 



   

&&)3  .0 

 

     8, !  # 

  !    .

/0

0  0

0

! 0(

  =

 !

2;

>0 #3 0



0 

 

   # 

 

 (

 =



   

 &&)3 ',*   .0 

 

    8, 

   (

  !

 

 

=

0   !

##

 ! 

 

 

&& .0



   8, !

  3 0 3  

#



   

#

!  

7!*+ #  # # 

&&)B .

/0'0 1 0 

*

 3  3 0

 C

   2#

"

! 

(#

 ! 

 =

(

 .

/0'0 1 0  

* (  ! =

#0(

  0  /  4    /

  

 0 / #  # =

0 #  .

/0>  0  .

/ 0 '0  1 0  

* !

         )0  

  !   !00  0 

#  

 0

 "  ( 

=





&&)3 '* '* .0



   8,  0# 00

# 0 0#     =

0

0 

    0 ;

#0 0#   

      

     

 #   !

 .

/0>   

#0(00  0

 

  !

0 00 ! #

 (  

    0

#

=

#0(



  !

  

0  

 # 0  =

0

#



#0( 00

0   0  0! 0

0

  

 



#0 

   00    

0 3 0 3

  0  

 



! 

 #  

) )



 0  0!    #=  

0  

#

0 /0   3 03    



= 0 # 3 0   

#   0= 0(

 

    6

 0  = 0

 

=    

#

  0!

0  (

 /   0    0  $ -

  0   

 0 

#



   ;

>0  # 3  (#  

  0 1 0  

  #  (#      .

/ 0   !

0  0

    =# #   ' !( )! & !"# *$ !  ;

>0  # 3 

  =

    .

/ 0 '0  1 0  

*

 #    = 

#0( "

0!  2 0

(

   ) --+ 2!

-33-  



456      

    

   %  

        

       

 



 

                 

       



   

      

  

  

   ,

 

      

   

       %  

 

  .       

        

   % 

                                                     .     

     

    

              

            

     

"           &   

  .    

 .      

    (   # 0 !

 !  0  (

  #   '+ ,  !  -   .!!"" *$2(



  ) / %   

   ,  )   

      .  

 /              



    ,  )      

 .     

    !

       ,  )         

  +/$*(7        (8

  9

 &                      

                       



  

 %    +/$*(   , )        .  .     + +

 , % ,  )      

  (

   

 

 .    #    ( , 2 

 =#   "

00 

0  0    .

/0>

 #

 =

#0(00

  8 0

 !   #   ;

>0  # 3  0  (# ! 

  

 .

/0>  ## 



2

    0 

     ;

>0 #3 #   '+ ,  !  ( -  . ! &*!  (

  ) :5 %            

    

      

                     

3

   *        "     

  

        +  '  , )   

          



              

        

         

    





      !       



       

    

  

            



        

     &% 2  

 

#   ' ! ( )  !  & !  " #  *$ 2 0

(

   ) -;%&  /. $      + 2!*

   

  

            



  

   



      , )                 .          ,  )     % 

  

+ 2!      

      , )                   (



&     !00  0          .

/ 0>  =

 !

 !

 



"0     ! (

3 03  0 /

 = 

#0(00  0 ;

  .

/ 0>

#

   #  

 

 

#0(

        

           =

  !  

   0   

 = 0



  = 0 !

! 

#0( = 

 

 ;

!

  0  / # 

  

 .

/0 .0



   8,

 

 00 ##    E  

#0( "

"

 



 0  0  

0   "

(#  .

/0'0 1 0  

* !

  =  #

 

  ;

>0 #3 #  & && ;

>0 #3 # 0,1!

   !  

 ! ! $*  20!  

 ## 





  -

03 # .!2  0 

48 3 #  &%+  02 0

 =# (

   "

%"   

               .         +  )  %     &  <4   +

  -3 ; 7

     -3 ;

4

(8 !

             

      .    

 

     &   0 

 *   !

7& " &  %  8$   

446 =

     &0*! 7&&%8 $   (> &  0 

* !

7,  !

% 

8$    44-=

     &0*! 7,!%8 $   (>      &   0 

 *   !

  44- 7

 &0*!(8    "  /   

  +

,

&&'  &  3  !    4!

 3'    3 ! "22# "%       .      &  <4   -3 ;   

 

             " / 

            

  

  .   $       

  .  

 "  .     .        +  )  %     &  <4        .       &  0 

* !

7

 &0*!(  * (8  

     $     &0*! 7   8     " %   & << 4<:       

   +

5

,

&&'  %         

,         & <<           & <<   

               & ;5 ;$.

    +

, .              

         %   

 

 , 

         1 +      .   %    & <4-3 ;      &

 4<:   

44:   % 

     .  

 ,    ?7&++

4--  -:-5@;

8 -:A%  "   

                  & <<     

.    B "   !

               

 

  

                

                     

 

 .             

                 

      .         

  

                   /                 .    

   %

         



   

                          

     %     ( 

  

" 

 0   

  "                 

 

  $

 A CCC -6!



"               +

   

 

$

          A% +  

            

&    .                .     

       &    

          

         +  & <<  & -7

8

& 3  + +    

 .   A*   



 

 

.   

 

 

                       

  

       * %

,  +  & <<

 &

% +

!!. ! ,!. 0 '



  !     2*  4.'

6

'3 !   6 1."" *$7""

$%*8   &

768

4<:

   +)*     



 

     "   + +         



 .    "  7   8  &+ 

0

# 

;

>0 #3

  =#

=

 !

 .

/ 0'0 1 0 

* ##   

 (

! 

  "

 & - !

   



!   00  !  0

 



(  !      F !  

 0  0 

 00   !    # # 

F !    0

##

   =

!      # # 



  

# ? /00 0 0

00#   

 #

 %&

   # # / !  #   





  0

 



 0=

#

 &4  



  



0

 

  "

#0( "

 0! "





0#

 

 

!   "

    .

/ 0

 0

 = 

    ## 

   &$  

 000   #



# )

0!  

 .

/0  

 

 

   (

    !

    0 &&$  

 

      .

/0'0 1 0  

*   #  & 

0      

 #+ 8+ #   #

 &+%,&%& '

(  )+*  $%&&%& '

(  )*

 

 - )   .

/ 0 '0  1 0  

*  12 3     0

 -  4  &%&+    '))+!8# ,9(8:!

 

'/  ,  

!';

'!$!'

 



D   ?ED

  ?ED