R.R. Birok v. C&Md National Fertilizers Ltd & ANR

 



   
  

!"

## $%&'&( ) !*++

  ,-  .//&00$!% 1&,)2) 3$ ,4$!5(245 $!$6 !6 ,&(%,7$% !$0

&,% 0 8&,) 4 %&'$!'$!%3&, . &)/!'&!%)   *  9

 :
 :
  9

 :
:"


,&)&!%*

,:$!;&&<=24$,7'<($%&,%3&$//&00$!% ) >>>  

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

  GH %3& $4&!'4&!% ($,, &' 2% !  $) %3& ,&F2&)% ?$) 4$'& %3&,&$%&,3&$42!%?$),&(& <&'@D%3&$//0 ($!%)E$//&00$!%)73?&<&,7 (3$00&!6& ?$) 4$'& (0$ 4 !6 %3$% %3& $4&!'4&!% ($,, &' 2% 3$< !6 !% @&&!@,263%%%3&!% (&%3&$//0 ($!%)E$//&00$!%)7%3&D)320'@&/$ ' &4024&!%) !%&,4)%3&/0 (D( ,(20$%&'!3&(0$ 43$) @&&!,&;&(%&'@D%3&0&$,!&': !60&2'6&
% ) !% ! ' )/2%& %3$% ?3&! %3& ,&F2&)%  %3& $//0 ($!%)E$//&00$!%) , <02!%$,D ,&% ,&4&!% ?$) $((&/%&' $!' %3& &4024&!%)?&,&/$ ' !%&,4)%3&$4&!'&'/0 (D7%3&D)% 003$'4,& D&$,) % )&,<& @&,& $%%$ ! 6 %3& $6&  )2/&,$!!2$% ! @2% !!&  %3& $//0 ($!%)E$//&00$!%)(3)&%/%2%%3& ,<02!%$,D,&% ,&4&!%,&F2&)% !%3&6,2!'%3$%%3&$4&!'

&'%&,4)?&,&!%@,263%%%3& ,!% (&7,$%3&, %3&D$((&/%&'&4024&!%)/$ ' !%&,4)%3&,&$!' 0&'?, %/&% % !) ! %3 ) 2,% , ,&0 & ! %&,4)  %3& 2!$4&!'&' 102!%$,D &% ,&4&!% :(3&4& !(& %3& $//0 ($!%)E$//&00$!%) $((&/%&' %3& &4024&!%) ! %&,4) %3& $4&!'&' 102!%$,D &% ,&4&!% :(3&4&7 !%3 !6 0 &) !%3& , 42%3 % (!%&!' %3$% %3&D )320' @& /$ ' &4024&!%) ! %&,4)  %3& 2!$4&!'&')(3&4&)/&(  (F2&)% !?$)/2%%%3&$//0 ($!%)E$//&00$!%) $) % ?3&%3&, %3&D $,& ,&$'D $!' ? 00 !6 % ,&6 @&!& %)  102!

&% ,&4&!%:(3&4&$0%6&%3&,
!,&)/!)&7$ '$< %3$)@&&! 0&'
!%3$% % 3$) @&&! )%$%&' @D %3& $//0 ($!%)E$//&00$!%) %3$% %3&D ($!!% ,&6 %3& @&!& %)7) !(&%3&D3$'$0,&$'D$%%$ !&'%3&$6&)2/&,$!!2$% !

,%3&,&$)!)4&!% !&'$@<&7?&'!% !'$!D&,,, ! %3&,'&,/$))&'@D%3&0&$,!&': !60&2'6&

  GAH ((,' !60D7 %3& $//&$0) $,& ' )4 ))&' $!' %3& $//0 ($% !) )&&- !6(!'!$% !'&0$D$,&$0)' )4 ))&'

$;&)3 !'$0 2'6&

:"$0 $ ++  2'6& $4 % 
"3&%3&,)/&$- !6E,&$)!&' * &)E 2.
"3&%3&,,&/,%$@0& * &)E