High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3126/2013dismissed

Subhash Chander & ANR v. Surjit Kaur & ANR

2019-05-16Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan12 pages

!!"!#!#

$$%% &# ' #()#!#

$ *#

# '!+,- #!$$%%

# (./$,- ##$0

2#%. , ! # ! $% 3 ' #()#+%!

'#,#-%%4"!%, 5!%/#!!6#,#7!#$#! #4!4 !!"!#!

'),!+ ' (!#'#5% 4!,4 .#, # !%%8%,06#,#8%!#64

%#!0 0 #%!$%!#9#%!$$- '!#$ +!#0 #!# !%%4$

:#%4!%%4 $0 .!#-,!',$#- -'#%#,%$%. $!# .0 !'% % 5!$%#!#4!;%#% # $#'(##4!#'%'4. # #%!$ +! !# $#%%. +! #4# !# $#$##4!#%'#!##

$#!-#!$%,!%4+!!# ! ! $#'%<4%#%4'=! +!-#!.->,!..-%%4 %,5!% 06#!!! #!#!$%=!! 0 9#-#=!!.#

,#4!#->, $% !# ! !# ! 9 0 = ! ;-%!.!#-0 9#-#, +!+%$6$!$%!#! #'!#$#! !##-#4!#.>=! ;%. %#%-%$ +!+'%=!!$% !#! +#%!.##40 !##%=!!! !$%:

: <4%! .+ #4!>##'!-

-%%4"!%:

:=!!2!4#'.!! ! $%+$##'-%%4"!%

:=!#4! $#,!0 %4+!0 ,. +!!$%=!!$%+#4#!6# '%. ! !# ! = ! + - #4#4!##%=!#4!$#, 0 $#-%$!$%!.#4-%! $% .4!!!%%%!'4!# 0 !#+=!!0 $#-% $!$%$#$#''!. 44+#4#'!$%

#4!$%, ! 4%%#+'!6#!$# !'!$!#4##!% 0 =!!0 ! 4#!$% .6$4!##6!.%'! #%+#-% %0>,!##, 0 +##0>!',!'4! .#!'4 #!# #4!$%,!# +-#.%4%%.$0 !#=! !0 !''#$#!#$%. #+!!#4%44!'9 #'!# #4!$%+!!'> '! 6$##%4!$#,!0 $%.

$#%'!#!0 +!#$+!# %4%!#!.%%!0 ! 6

? $ .!#-$

#4! $%!!60 $'! #' $ +# -# $##' #%!$ $-'!#$' 4 +!$% 0 @%4 44#- . ! ! ,!$%%!;

,0 !$$#% (+#' #4$#%'#. (! !!$%!%%! $#=!!++!'=!!0 '#!#%+!0 %,+!+#!#% $#, -# # $ . ! $%, !##, ! $%4#!0 '#,!+#4 '!0 +#4+!!',!4!

4!%%!#%0 +!!'-# #'! $=!!$%!##, ! #% 4#0 4!$-'!# 5!+#4 %'!0 #4+!!',$% #4 # 5!+#4'!$% !#! .-%%4 %#06#0

,+!++#649#-#,'+!!$% !#! #4!'+!.# ::!##, !.! #4%###% +!$% !# #!# '#=!!$%##4 0 ! #!#=!!#-%$#%!$%-!

+!'=!0 -$#!%4% !% !$%!#! #7!#$#=!!$% !#! +#%,+!#!+#4! %#.!++4!#=!!$%!#! #;!+#44- #!!%#!'! 4#!!.+#+%%4$!!%=!+#4 %' ! !. %#.!!%# !#, !. ' ! #; ! $% !# !

?, 0 4- #! 0 = ! ! $% !# ! +# ( % 44 + #! 0 !.-!!(.# ! #!0 !.!+#4#%- $!!%#!'!#+=!!$%!# ! '%#!!.+%$!!%%4%%.!# #!$%+%4!A!$B ) =!!$% !#! ,!##,->#4%#%.#4! !%=!#%.!! !$%!:

# 0 % $= !#!! !# ! ,$%%!+#4!!#%! ! 9$#!##!$0 4! !!,!$%!%$!0 #!!

5!+#4%'!!#%$.#! $%+% .0 ,+!%$##'!%#=! !$%#!0 !#+ #4! +#4 , # + . ! 2!4 #'. !

! !$% :

:,#'%$#'.+ !%!/#+#! -%%4"!%,+!#0 +$ .!$%$#!%.!#/#/#!! = !!+#4#'%%.4-0 $ ! $% #4 ! , ! $% + -#. ##+%!!#! !+# '%!6#!!'$#'! !!+%%%4%+!!#%! = ;%.

:#4#$+9 +!$% +#4#4#4$0 =!! $+#4#! 4## #4 !,!$%!#+#%,#!9! $,##40 !$%=! !$%!##$##<4%=!!0 + % ! # . ! #% $# +#4 =!!$%6!$!4#$!!#$$#! '##44!$$#=!%#,!$%#' !+#4!$$#!!%+ $#$# >=!!+#4%'!$% -!#!#4!!%#4%##-%!%$ '!+#4# #4!9$# #44$!!%=! ?

:!$%!#%4 0 ')#$%4!+*!!%-%%40%, C!=!!$%4!'$$%'!# '#0 !$!#.!#4#!

D , #4%440 =!! ->!##,#4!!%=!!0 . !!%#+.#!#.#,!$%#! +#4+!#+!0 #'! !%-%%40%,#C!6$!'+!!' 06#!,!0 +.4+! 0 06#=!!$%-!#$ !%!%4'.#'49$ #44$!!%!9$ #4! +#4,!$%!#+#%# 0 $!%!$%=!.!#' $+#$##'%%4 .!$%=!.%! .#,'#$##%+$#$! $%#44$

:9 5! %' ! ! $% ! 4 ! $ ! #'! 4##,##4!! ' 5!+#4,!##,%'!$%+ +%%+#!!'!6+4%.9 ! '

5!#%"#!$$!

* * 4!,- "# /# # '# 0 , +! $$# % $#+# !%'#4! '4$+!-#%'%!$#+# . 0 !#+#'

4!#'4%%4,%%!$#.

: #'%!

5! $% ! % #$% #-#4 ! %%4 ! +# ' +!# ##4 ! -#'!$%

!$%4!$#,%%+4+# #' E!!# $

: %%4%, %% - $#--'F ** E!!#$%%#%%#$#.#F E!!#$%%#%$#'( $#.#F ** ?

E!!#$%!%%! $#F *

E!!#' %F * E!!#' ##F * E!!# $% $$ #' %4 ! $# . !+F * :

E!!#0 ! $#$#%.,, F *

E!!# $% # $# $#- ## D "*"F * % >##$#-!#,!$%' #()# !4##!#' #4#'

!!#!,!0 !!"!# 4 ! ' E ! #!# 9' ' 0##)#E,!

844!E,!

"!'C%

"!!E?,!

*#'(4!E !

+4! E

#!#4!%#%#!$#,!#% "#0 ,,-#!$%4 !,0 ? 4!-# !$% %%.,!#%"#-(4'# ?

#!+!!%4! 0 ! #%!$ $ +! ! $% $

:+%%#%.!#% %$%.$!$% .0 =+ !## 4 -, !' $#- ' !%4!!$

:!## #.$!$%0

2.+.4#4#%$#'(,! +# ## #' %'4 . # #%!$ +! ! $%#!#$#$##4!#%'#!##

@%444#- .!(4'#,! 0 !%$$% ##84, 7!#$#,+!!+4%#84 !,@5#6"#,7!#$#,+!-(4'# :

' ! $$% $!% ! '$4 (4'#$ .!#%"#

%%%4+!!(4'#

$ .!"# %+,!0 !-% !$##4%#$$% #!"#,+!! +!#$0 $% $$#!#4!

>!-!#%#%#!$# 44 !#4!!##>.'#!$$%

5!#%"#-+!%%4%$ !'!%!!#+#%!$ + !$%!#! +!0 ,# !! $%64-4-%# % '%!$%,0 !6 !# 4# $

:= !+-#, ! $%!-.4$0 , !#+!+%!-%!'>+%!-#!# 6!'%4+!!#B ) =!'#!$% !#! -#'.#$!!%#'! '! #!

?%%!! !$% :

:#!#0 # 0 !#=!#'$# $#-!- $##'=!!!%+-#! !#.!$%,!##,$$#! .$+ $

:$$#+!#.%4%

+ ! $% 0 $ $-'!#=#!#+9%!%' 0 B ) #!#!!% %!!0 +%.$ .!$% 5! 5#%"#!!!++!%',%' #6#'!0 ##4! #%!$ +!$%0 #'

:,!++!'

C#%#84 !,@5#6 "#,7!#$#!4#+!! #-' .!#% "# 7 ! #- ! ! 9' . 4+!$$#-!+9 -%%.+!.$##$!$%$ ' .E E###. !, # 4! $#'$ # # 7 $

>+#!# #-!' -%%.9,$#'$ ##!'

5! ## 4 ## . ! ! "# %+##'.##4%#.#%%4%. 5!4 ##' 0%+!!(4'# $ .!"# %+ 5!#$!% 0 %;%+#!$$%

> 4 -+ ! ## 4

## .!"# %++!+!!>.# 4#,>%!!$$%+!'#' #4%.

2#(

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#