High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/7374/2018dismissed

Iffco Tokio General Insurance Company Ltd v. Kulvir Singh And ANR

2018-12-07Mrs Justice Daya Chaudhary5 pages

!"# $#%&'&()

*#(#+!,('-+!(%#./!(01"$ //#,,!(" 2#+'-' *-,3&+4&(56!($!("6#+ #'/($#("'

+#'#(") +2&'6!,55!+7!,8$3%!"# +"6#!//#,,!("

6&' !//#!, 6!' 9##( &,#$ 90 "6# ('-+!(%# ./!(0 %6!,,#(5&(5 !7!+$ $!"#$

/!''#$ 90 ,#!+(#$ "+ %%&$#(" ,!&.' +&9-(!,8 -/(!5!+ :+&9-(!,; + '6+"8 3&$# 76&%6 %,!&.!(" 7!' !7!+$#$%./#('!"&( '8

<=(!%%-(" &(>-+&#''-'"!&(#$90 6&.&(!."+3#6&%,#!%%&$#("(

+&# !%"'8 (#%#''!+0 + !$>-$&%!"&( "6# %!'#8 !+# "6!" ! /#"&"&( -($#+ 4#%"&( @@ "+ 2#6&%,#' %" 7!' /+# #++#$ 90 "6# !//#,,!(" '##A&(5 %./#('!"&( ( !%%-(" "6# &(>-+&#' !($ $&'!9&,&"0 '-

#+#$906&.6#!//#,,!("7!'&(3,3#$&(!."+3#6&%,#!%%&$#("(

76#( 6# 7!' /+%##$&(5 +. 2&,,!5# 4!+6!(! "7!+$' 6!.A!-+ 4!6&9 ( 6&' ."+%0%,# 9#!+&(5

= B=?

" !9-"

/.8 76#( 6# +#!%6#$ "6# +#3#(-# ,&.&"' 3&,,!5# *!,+!( ( +&($!"6!.A!-+4!6&98"6#

#($&(54A$!!+9#!+&(5=

= @ C8 76&%6 7!' 9#&(5 $+&3#( 90 &"' $+&3#+ +#'/($#(" &( ! +!'6 !($ (#5,&5#(".!((#+8!"!6&56'/##$8%!.# +."6#//'&"#'&$#6#'!&$ 4A$! %!+ 76&,# 3#+"!A&(5 "6# 9-' !

"#+ %.&(5 ( "6# 7+(5 '&$# "6# +!$8'"+-%A!5!&('""6#."+%0%,# "6#%,!&.!(",!&.!(" #,,("6#+!$ !($+#%#&3#$.-,"&/,#&(>-+&#'&+'",086#7!'"!A#("&3&,'/&"!,8+&($!

!($ "6#+#!

"#+ +# #++#$ " 8 6!($&5!+68 76#+# 6&' +&56" " 7!' -,"&.!"#,0 !./-"!"#$ # +#.!&(#$ !$.&""#$ "6#+# +.

"7!'/,#!$#$"6!""6#%,!&.!("7!'7+A&(5!'6#!303#6&%,# $+&3#+8#!+(&(5'

<=/#+.("6./#('!"&(7!'8"6-'8/+!0#$ + 1#!+(#$+&9-(!,(%('&$#+!"&( "6# !%"'!($#3&$#(%#( +#%+$ 6#,$ "6!" "6# !%%&$#(" &( D-#'"&( "A /,!%# $-# " "6# +!'6 !($ (#5,&5#(" $+&3&(5 "6#

#($&(5 3#6&%,# 90 &"' $+&3#+ 1#!+(#$ +&9-(!, !7!+$#$!'-. '

<="7!+$'.#$&%!,#E/#('#'9#'&$#''?8

<= #!%6 "7!+$' "+!('/+"!"&( %6!+5#' !($ '/#%&!, $&#" 1#!+(#$ +&9-(!, !''#''#$"6#!((-!,&(%.# "6#!//#,,!("!''

<= 0"!A&(5&(" %('&$#+!"&( ?

F "6# #E/#%"#$ !((-!, &(%.#8 ,'' -"-+# #!+(&(5' 7!'!''#''#$!"'

<=/#+!((-.-,"&/,&#+ 7!'!//,&#$6-'8 ,'' &(%.# 7!' !''#''#$ !" '8

E '-. '?8

<=7!'!7!+$#$"7!+$'!""#($!("%6!+5#'9#'&$#''

<= + /!&( !($ '-

#+&(5' 6-'8 "6# !//#,,!(" 7!' 6#,$ #("&",#$ " ""!, %./#('!"&( '8

<=!,(57&"6&("#+#'"GCF/#+!((-. +."6# $!"# &,&(5 %,!&./#"&"&("&,,+#!,&'!"&( "&'/+&.!+&,0!+5-#$"6!""6#!%%&$#("&(D-#'"&(&'("/+3#$ "6!3#"!A#(/,!%#(

&(3,3&(5"6#

#($&(53#6&%,#76&%67!' &('-+#$ 7&"6 "6# ('-+!(%# ./!(0 " &' 3#6#.#(",0 !+5-#$ "6!" "6# !%%&$#("&(D-#'"&("A/,!%#(

876#+#!'7!'+#5&'"#+#$8 !

"#+!(-(#E/,!&(#$$#,!0 ?.("6'8( ?

"&'8"6-'8%,#!+"6!" "6#!%%&$#("&(76&%6"6#%,!&.!("&''"!"#$"6!3#+#%#&3#$&(>-+&#'8&'(" /+3#$ ( +#%+$8 (#&"6#+ (#5,&5#(%# "6# +#'/($#(" $+&3#+ &' /+3#$ +#3#+8 %./#('!"&( !7!+$#$ " "6# %,!&.!(" &' '-9.&""#$ " 9# #E%#''&3#6-'8&"&'/+!0#$"6!""6&'!//#!,9#!,,7#$

6!3# 6#!+$ ,#!+(#$ %-('#, + "6# !//#,,!(" !($ 6!3# 5(# "6+-56"6# &,# '/#+ "6# %,!&. /#"&"&( &,#$90%,!&.!("<+#'/($#("8 !( !%%&$#(" "A /,!%# (

76#( 6# ( 6&' ."+%0%,# 9#!+&(5

= B=?

7!' /+%##$&(5 +. 2&,,!5# 4!+6!(! "7!+$' 6!.A!-+ 4!6&9"!9-" <

/.876#(6#+#!%6#$"6#+#3#(-#,&.&"' 3&,,!5# *!,+!( ( +&($! " 6!.A!-+ 4!6&98 "6#

#($&(5 4A$! !+ 9#!+&(5 =

=@ C%!.# +."6#//'&"#'&$#6#%!+7!'9#&(5$+&3#(90 &"'$+&3#++#'/($#("&(!+!'6!($(#5,&5#(".!((#+8!"!6&56'/##$ 6#'!&$'A$!%!+876&,#3#+"!A&(5"6#9-'! "#+%.&(5("6#7+(5'&$# "6#+!$8'"+-%A!5!&('""6#."+%0%,# "6#%,!&.!(",!&.!(" #,,( "6# +!$ !($ +#%#&3#$ .-,"&/,# &(>-+&#' &' +&56" " 7!' -,"&.!"#,0 !./-"!"#$ !" 6!($&5!+6 &'!9&,&"0 %#+"& &%!"# E @ /+3&(5 !./-"!"&( "6# %,!&.!(";' +&56" ,7#+ ,&.98 $#%,!+&(5 $&'!9&,&"0 "6# %,!&.!(" " "6# #E"#(" ?

F 7!' /+3#$ 90 H + !6#'6 0!,8 #$&%!,

&%#+ ./-"!"&( &' !$.&""#$,0 !" "6# ,#3#, "6# !(A,# 6# %,!&.!("7!'!3#++#$"9#6#!303#6&%,#$+&3#+ &("6&'%!'#7!'+#5&'"#+#$( ?

'/#+"6# &"'#, E 8 &" &' .#("&(#$ "6!" %!'# 7!' #("+-'"#$ " 4 4!>!( 4&(568 76&(%((&3!(%#7&"6+#'/($#("<$+&3#+7!'/+#''-+&I&(5"6#%,!&.!(" "%.#""#+.'&("6&'%!'#"&'(,0!

"#+!(!//,&%!"&(7!'.3#$90"6# %./,!&(!(" '&$#" 6&56#+ !-"6+&"&#' "6!"#(D-&+0 7!'%($-%"#$!($ 7!'+#5&'"#+#$!5!&('""6#$+&3#+ "6#

#($&(53#6&%,#-($#+4#%"&(' C8 !($

( ?

H 4 4!>!( 4&(56 !$.&""#$ "6!" !( !//,&%!"&(7!'.3#$90"6#-(%,# "6#%./,!&(!("%,!&.!("9# +#"6# 8 6!.A!-+ 4!6&9 ( 76&%6 "6# 4 %($-%"#$ &(3#'"&5!"&( &(!,

+#/+"-($#+4#%"&( + 7!'-,"&.!"#,0/+#'#("#$!5!&('""6#$+&3#+ "6#

#($&(53#6&%,# ( "6&' 3&#7 "6# .!""#+8 $#,!0 &( +#5&'"+!"&( &' $-,0 #E/,!&(#$90"6#%,!&.!(""%!(("9#'!&$"6!"$-#""6#$#,!0&("6#8 !%%&$#("&(D-#'"&(&'("/+3#$6#+#&'"6-'(.#+&"&("6&'!+5-.#(" -+5#$90,#!+(#$%-('#, +"6#!//#,,!(",!&.!("6!''-%%#''

-,,0/+3#$ 6&''"!($("6#"-%6'"(# /+#/($#+!(%# /+9!9&,&"&#' -+"6#+.+#8 .#$&%!, #3&$#(%# 6!' 9##( ,#$ " /+3# "6# $&'!9&,&"0'-

#+#$90"6#%,!&.!(""6!'%.#(+#%+$"6!""6#%,!&.!(" !

"#+"6#!%%&$#("7!' &+'",0"!A#("&3&,'/&"!,!($"6#+#!

"#++# #++#$"

86!($&5!+6876#+#"6#,7#+,&.9-/",#3#, !(A,#7!'!./-"!"#$ ,!&.!("6!'#E6&9&"#$6&'$+&3&(5,&%#(%#E C"/+3#"6!"6#7!'!6#!30 3#6&%,#$+&3#+(%.# "6#%,!&.!("6!'9##(!''#''#$!''

<=/#+ !((-.!($,'' #!+(&(5!''#''#$!"?

F("6# !%"'!($%&+%-.'"!(%#' "6# %!'#8 -(%"&(!, $&'!9&,&"0 "6# %,!&.!(" %!((" 9# !''#''#$ " 9# ,#''"6!(?

F6#+#&'($&'/-"#+#5!+$&(5"6#!5# "6#%,!&.!(""&' /+3#$(+#%+$"6!""6#!%%&$#("&(D-#'"&("A/,!%#$-#""6#+!'6!($ (#5,&5#(" $+&3&(5 4A$! !+ 90 &"' $+&3#+ 6#+# +#8 !+5-.#(" "6!" D-!("-. %./#('!"&(!7!+$#$""6#%,!&.!("&'#E%#''&3#&'$#3&$ !(0.#+&"6#+#&'(5+-($ ++#$-%"&( "6#%./#('!"&(!7!+$#$" "6#%,!&.!(" "6#+!+5-.#("6!'9##(+!&'#$ 1#!+(#$ %-('#, + "6# !//#,,!(" &' -(!9,# " /&(" -" !(0 &,,#5!,&"08&( &+.&"0+/#+3#+'&"0&(!7!+$$!"#$

76&%6%!,,' +!(0 &("#+ #+#(%#&("6&'!//#!,8/+# #++#$90"6#('-+!(%#./!(0

? //#!,&'!%%+$&(5,0$&'.&''#$7&"6(+$#+!'"%'"

#%#.9#+ 8

'67!+ H6#"6#+'/#!A&(5<+#!'(#$)= #'< H6#"6#++#/+"!9,#)= #'<