Major Singh Sandhu v. State Of Punjab And ORS




 

    

#&'()'* + (!, ,

,

-- ,,, .- --, ,,,--   /  ,-  ,-,   /  -,- -0.0 1'+'!&

1,#1 !$'1-2#13#4$5(*#&' )(1&2'#667 *#!& #66'77#!&,

1,8161''&- !924$$ & (!#7,,48!:#;,

1, &'+2083#1#!+#74$5(*#&' )(11'+6(!$'!&(,, <<<

,-,  4,= >

2 + +#!#667 *#& (!8!$'1-'*& (! ()&2' 3 &#& (!*&)(1 *(!$(!#& (!()$'7#?()%%$#?+ !) 7 !9&2'61'+'!&66'#7,

'#1!'$-&#&'*(8!+'7+8;3 &+&2#&&2'?2#5'!((;:'*& (!)(1 *(!$(!#& (!()+# $6'1 ($()$'7#?, 2'1')(1'4&2 +#667 *#& (! +#77(@'$#!$&2'$'7#?()%%$#?+ ! ) 7 !9&2'66'#7 +*(!$(!'$,

2 + '&&'1+#&'!&66'#7 +61')'11'$#9# !+&:8$93'!&$#&'$ ,
,
6#++'$;?7'#1!'$- !97'8$9' ! A(

, 2'#66'77#!&2#$1'& 1'$#+# +&1 *&$8*#& (!)) *'1=> )1(3 +&1 *& (9#, '@#+ 36(+'$#68! +23'!&(!

,,

5 $'= >()# B$'$8*& (!)1(32 +6'!+ (!(!&2';#+ +()#1'6(1&()#!!C8 1?)) *'1 $&, ,,
4#!$&2'+# $68! +23'!&@#+ 36(+'$(! ,,

;?&2'

-'*1'&#1?&((5'1!3'!&()8!:#;4$8*#& (!'6#1&3'!&=-*2((7+>#)&'1# *(!+'!&@#+(;&# !'$)1(3&2'-'*1'&#1?48!:#;8;7 *-'15 *' (33 ++ (!4 #& #7#(! ,,

, 2'  #66'77#!&  2#$  *2#77'!9'$  !(&  (!7?  &2'  !C8 1?  1'6(1& $&, ,,
4;8&#7+(&2'(1$'1()68! +23'!&$&,

,,

4(1$'16#++'$ !&2'1'5 '@#667 *#& (!$&,

,,
(!&2'91(8!$+&2#&&2'?#1'5 (7#& 5' ()8!:#; 5 7-'15 *'=8! +23'!&#!$66'#7>87'+4 D2'1' !#)&'1 1')'11'$&(#+E&2'87'+FG,'#7+(*2#77'!9'$&2'$'$8*& (!$ 1'*&'$&(;' 3#$')1(32 +6'!+ (!#!$+(892&1')8!$()&2'+# $#3(8!&#7(!9@ &2 !&'1'+&H
B6'1#!!83,

'#1!'$- !97'8$9'$ +3 ++'$&2'A1 &'& & (!(!,
,
 2(7$ !9&2#& !C8 1?@#+)# 17?*(!$8*&'$#!$#1'#+(!'$(1$'1 +6#++'$4#!$ &2'68! +23'!& 36(+'$*#!!(&;'+# $&(;' 77'9#7,



2(8924&2'1'@#+!() !$ !9 !&2' !C8 1?1'6(1&&2#&#!? ) !#!* #77(++*#8+'$&(&2'-&#&'47'#1!'$- !97'8$9' !2 +(1$'19#5'+8*2 #) !$ !9#!$:8+& ) '$&2' 36(+ & (!()B*8& !&2'6'!+ (!, A2'!  &2 +  #66'#7  @#+  ) 7'$  ;?  &2'  #66'77#!&4  !(& *'  @#+ ++8'$(!&2'7 3 &'$'I&'!&1'9#1$ !9&2' ++8'()'I*'++ 5'68! +23'!&#!$ 61(6(1& (!#7 &?&(&2'7(++4#!$#$ 1'*& (!@#+9 5'!&(&2'1'+6(!$'!&+&() 7' &2' 11'+6(!+'1'9#1$ !9) !#!* #77(++*#8+'$&(&2'(5'1!3'!&5 $'(1$'1 $&,
, ,
, !1'+6(!+'&2'1'&(4#!#)) $#5 &@#+) 7'$(!
,,
  !&2 + #66'#7  ;?  &2'  ++ +&#!&   1'*&(14  )) *'  ()   1'*&(1  '!'1#74  -*2((7 $8*#& (!8!:#;+&#& !9*#&'9(1 *#77? !6#1# #+8!$'1 J2#& !1'+6(!+'&(&2'-6'* ) *C8'1?68&;?&2'(!F;7' (81& 5 $'(1$'1$#&'$
, ,
1'9#1$ !

9) !#!* #77(++*#8+'$&( &2'  $'6#1&3'!&4  &  +  +8;3 &&'$  &2#&  #+  6'1  1'6(1&  $#&'$ %,,
  ()  2 ')  **(8!&+  )) *'1  ()   1'*&(1  '!'1#7 -*2((7$8*#& (!!($ 1'*&) !#!* #77(++2#+;''!*#8+'$&(&2' (5'1!3'!&,K 28+4(!#)) $#5 &4&2'-&#&'2#+9(!'(!1'*(1$+#? 9&2#&&2'1' @#+!($ 1'*&) !#!* #77(++*#8+'$&(&2'-&#&', & +!(& !$ +68&'&2#&#+6'187'
,
=;>()&2'87'+1'7#& !9 &(91#!&()6'!+ (!4#!?*8& !6'!+ (!*#!;'(1$'1'$(!7? )&2'1' +# 6'*87 #17(++*#8+'$&(&2'(5'1!3'!

A2'!!(6'*87 #17(++2#+;''!*#8+'$&(&2'-&#&'4#+6'1&2' #)) $#5 &) 7'$ !&2'#66'#7(!
,,
 ;?&2'++ +&#!& 1'*&(14&2'1'

+!(:8+& ) *#& (!@#11#!& !9 36(+ & (!()B*8&& !96'!+ (!(!&2' #66'77#!&,2'7'#1!'$- !97'8$9'4 !(81(6 ! (!42#+'11'$ !9 5 !9# ) !$ !9  &2#&  7(++  2#+  ;''!  *#8+'$  &(  &2'  1'+6(!$'!&+4  @2 *2  @#+  !(& @#11#!&'$, ! 81*2#1#!  - !92  .+,  -&#&'  ()  8!:#;  #!$  (&2'1+ (1$'1 $&,%,
,

 ! 
4 !#+ 3 7#1+ &8#& (!4&2 + (81&2#+&#L'!# 5 '@&2#&(!7? )&2'1' +) !$ !9()) !#!* #77(++*#8+'$&(&2'-&#&'487'
,
=;>()&2''!+ (!87'+*#!;' !5(L'$4#!$!(1'*(5'1?)1(36'!+ (!*#! ;'(1$'1'$#+#6'!#7&?3'#+81';?&2'-&#&' !&2'#;+'!*'()#!?7(++ *#8+'$&(&2'(5'1!3'!&, !&2 +5 '@()&2'3#&&'14&2' '&&'1+#&'!&66'#7 +#77(@'$M (1$'1()&2'7'#1!'$- !97'8$9'$&,,
,
 ! A

&(&2'

'I&'!&&2'7'#1!'$8$9'2'7$&2#&&2'B*8& !6'!+ (!3#$';?&2' 1'+6(!$'!&+)1(3&2''!+ (!6#?#;7'&(&2'#66'77#!& ++'&#+ $'4#!$&2' 1'+6(!$'!&+ #1' $ 1'*&'$&( 1')8!$&( &2' #66'77#!&&2' #3(8!& () +8*2 $'$8*& (!3#$')1(32 +6'!+ (!)1(3&2'$#&')1(3@2 *2 &@#+3#$'& 77 $#&'@ &2 !%@''L+)1(3&2'1'*' 6&()#*(6?()&2 +(1$'1@ &2 !&'1'+&H

B6'1#!!83)1(31'+6'*& 5'&(&2'$#&'+()$'$8*& (!& 77&2'$#&'()#*&8#7 6#?3'!&4#!$1'+6(!$'!&+#1'$ 1'*&'$&(1')8!$B$'$8*& (!)1(36'!+ (!

3#$')(1&2'6'1 ($()?'#1+681+8#!&&(&2'(1$'1+$&, ,,

= >#!$

,,
=

>@ &2 !%@''L+@ &2 !&'1'+&H B6'1#!!83, '!$ !9#667 *#& (!=+>4 )#!?4+2#77+&#!$$ +6(+'$(), = ,-,  >  =-0.0> , ,

  61 ?#!L# A2'&2'1+6'#L !9"1'#+(!'$ '+"( A2'&2'11'6(1&#;7'

'+"(