High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/784/2018allowed

New India Assurance Company Ltd v. Savitri Devi And ORS

2018-12-03Mr. Justice B.S. Walia12 pages

!"# $$%%" & '("( ") $## "

!"# $##%%" & *) ") $$ "

!"# $##%%" & *)( ") $## "

!"# $##%%" & '

"#*) ") $## "

!"# $##%%" & % ") $## "

!"# $##%%" &

") $## " "#$# %&"'# $()*+,-#"*.',

"+ *#& ",(

"- ")%%"./# *# ),!0% %- " #1%%

# *#') '0),(

"- *#2"(,(

"- " #3 #456,457"

455 -1835, " #3"

9 #45: -1835 " #36 #459 -1835# *#))(,(

"- " #6: #456,457"

455 -1835, " #45 #45: -1835, " #97 #459 -1835# ;;; "*.',/($'

<3= ) )%% >%.## #456"

455 1835/

"@"

0%0 ( %(%% > > " #45: -1835)" "

")?"

"@"

0%0 ,")")0"

@%% ( %(# ")(@"A-

#45: -1835#

! <1= ) % * "

" % @%, % .)-"-"

B")@%C/(""3D#84#1834 0) #38 )% ") ( - ") % 0%0",

0% ,

"%0(+E *0 -1 23 -23

3# :6 -1839 .*) (#

'0) ")/

#6,9D,7:8FE# -" " - ")

" @ ")@A

"") ")--" "@A"-> "" %G @A- -35

")# 1# :: -1839 .'(" ( (#

'0)

#5,77,888FE#" "")" #3,88,888FE

- %

" @ "

" #3H #3,88,888FE

-% -% (-- " @ "

") " #1"

9) ))%%@) ?%% @ ") " - ") 0

:8I @ "

" #3, 18I

" "

" #: @0 0)" - ") 38I )@"

") " #1,6 9#98I

-") " #3:@ "

") ) 098I

- ") @ " -> " ") " %G@A- -35

") ) ") ) - 0

"@"

") )# 6# :7 -1839 .*) ( (#

'0)

")/

#9,88,888FE# )

)%%@)?%% @ ") "# "%

"@ "")@A

"# :# :4 -1839 .*) ( (#

'0)

")/

#3,63,847FE# "%

"@ ") @A

"# 9# :5 -1839 . % ( (#

'0)

")/

#75,118FE# "%

"@ ") @A

"# 7# :D -1839 .

'0) ")/

#41,8:9FE# "%

"@ ") @A

! <6= !

% - ") %%"./ J

"")"")%@%-%"

"A"

"")(

, ")@ -0 ) %0 ( - ") % @% - ")

" %"0 ") ") - )0 *% ( K ) LE7 &A ) ) 0" ") "

""%-) " ")( -")" A @%- ") ) 0%0" (0 %"0 ")

" ") ") % # (,

-")" A@0E( %"E- @ ") "F "") "" @ %%00")( -") % "

@ > %(% @% - ") ) 0%0" (0 %"0")

"")")" A?" # <:= !

%- ")%%"./J

) "A (")

"" -0) #D38 -") "" %%") E> " LE1 LE7#% -0) #38 -")(%")"")%@%)%")"")

" "

-)0%0"(0@ " #1## ") ( - ") % )% ")

("A0 ") " A -") @(")""")" -")() ("A0")

") () % "

@ " )% ("A0# (0 " " - "

% ,")%@%)%")" "*) .

LE1/) "(%%0") % "")" -

"))

E> " """)"") -") % )0)"")"

" -") ")" ") ## ") 0 ) " % ") ( . " #1/ - % "

(")() %"% ")" )-") - %% """)"")

)0%0"(0 - " #1,( - % #

! <9=

LE7,&A ) )0" "") E > " @- ") % @% ")" ") % " A ") " A -

") @ A ") 0)" " - ") " A ")" ") % @0(")0)"")" -")

"")" ")0)"

%")( -") % "

(")() %"% #% """)"")

-")) 0%0"(0 -")( -") % # <7= ( - ") " A ##

'0) LE3 @")

"%(%%0%%0" -)0%0"(0 ") " - ") ( - ") % () % % ") ) "

0) -")

"##># 3"

># :) )) ")"")" A ")

"%-") -") "") % ) ))" ") " A -

@ A 0)" ) - ") " A ")" -

") ) "

0)""")"")

-) 0%0" (0 @ " #1 ## ( - ") % # ) %@%-") @(")"") - "")" 0" 0"")( -")" A )%%@ ""0") " -- ""

) %")"")

-0%0 -") ( -")" A#)%@%% "

"")

-") "$2 4

5 50 6 % 2 51 $ +0

30 -030 / *5 21 50/ '7 %01 8% ) " )% ")" ") " ?" - A0

@"""- (

")" ") @% 0)" "

") ( % @- "# ) % @%% "

"")"")(.## " #1/ -") % ) """

")"@ >"

"")( -")

"0(@ " #3F( -")" A#)- ,(

- "597 6 40

5 4:20 *

/ ; -( ( - % %@% "

@ 0" ") ( .## " #1/ - % () %# <4= ""% , LE1 "*)) E> " "" ")" " ") ( - ") % ) (0 )% 0%0"% ")"")0"(%%0")) " ) "

(")() %% % # !A,( LE7&A ) )0" % %%") 0)-")) E> " ) """)"")

A% "

"))0%0"(0

-")" A(% ")"(")( -") % 0%0"# (") % , LE1%% LE7 ")"")

"))0%0"(0 -")" A(,) (, ") % "% 0" ") ( - ") " A %" 20 " ?""%"3D#86#1835@ 0(0")( -")" A")@-" @"# ), ") "F " )( @% ) "

% ") ( @- ") % "%%@- ")@%#")

% ",") "F "## LE1 LE7)(%%0 ")"

A% "

)0%0"(0 -")" A( )") "" ,")@%%0")"")

A% "

)0%0"(0 -")( -") % ,") 0) LE7, &A )0 "

")>"" - 0")"")

A% "

)0%0"(0 -")" A(% #") " ," )"

@ " -

") (

) > "% @%%"0")

""A0% #

! <5= !

% - ") %%"./ J

"")"""")""

"@"

0%0 # (,) > "% "-%")"

@ "-

")( " % ")@ - " 0(@ ")"@ ")"

") " -" %" #% -0) #38 -")(%")"")" A0 0 ")

"%-") ")" ")

" "

A % " ") " ) ") ( - ") % "" " "

("A ") " A -" 0""0 0% -

") " A (# <D= ""% , % - ") (% ")" ") " A % ")M

N.## )"

/")( -")" A)0( 0% "0")"")() %A0"

("A

% ("A#)

A% @ ")%-" -") % "A00"")0)" -")" -")" A#%") 0) LE7") %%) "" ")%%0)0%0"(0@ ")( -")" A % 0%0 @ ")( -") % @"")- " ")""") %-" -") % ) ))""))% -")0)" -")" A ) )0 0)#" @( ")"() %) )")

("A0 "

" - " -

") () % ) ) "

("A0#")

")( LE1%% LE7@- ") %@%")"")( -") % 0 0"-" ) "

% "

% @ ")

" - ") () % ") 0) LE7 &A )% %%0)0%0"(0@ ")( -")" A % # (,") " ")0"

)0%0"(0 -- -

@" )")"

@ "

)" ") ") ) 0 ") " -")(

! <38= ) @ @( @ (, %") 0) ") % ")

("A0-"0""00%-

")" A( ""0 ""

("A, "")%-" -") % @0"

")0)" " -")" A%"0

"#"% ,")( -") % ) ("A0 " "?"" #)- ,"

, ") 0%0 % > %(% @ ")" - ") ( - ") % #

0% , ") % @ ")

- ") @0

"@"

0%0 2 " ") 0) -" @%) ") "

@ ") "

- 0"" - @ LE7 &A %%00)0%0"(0@ ")" A(,@",) @ " @ (, ") ?" - ) 0%0" (0 "

@ ") - " - ") ) ) " "

" @0 ""@"@%"

"))0%0"(0@ ")( -") % # <33= !

%- ")%%"./J

>" 0 ")" %") 0) ") % @% ) ")

)0*%,099 " 4,888FE ")@ 0 @%")'"" - 0")%(" ##* ) 1839, "%

"")"")

)@ ") )0) 0 - ") %(" ") '"" 9531FE#, -1,98,888FE)@ ")

(" % ) .## 19,888FE"

-% >, 19,888FE "

% - "", 3,88,888FE "

% - % ( -- " 3,88,888FE

- %

" /# !

"")"")

-% -"" -%>%@%"

@ -

19,888FE"

39,888FE ) # !A, - 3,88,888FE "

") - ")

- %

" %@% "

@ "

:8,888FE#!

%-")

"")"

" @%

-% -% (-- " # <31=

",*#') '0),(

",%

%- ") "F ")% ""0")- " " ")%@ %

%- ")%%"./J

"")" " )@

--" " " ""% " "

" - 38I - ") "@%)

- ") ")">

"#," -0) #5#4 ") 92< 01,

:0 -'6 : $2 1 -5:50:$2 50 ;

- 1331;

/ ") "F " ## " #1, 6 9 ## ") %% " #:##")0)" -") % ""% "

- :8,888FE )

- % - "%

" #45: -1835# <36= -")%?-" "

," " 0 ) ")" 0) #73.(/ - ") 1 ,

:0 -23 ='

680 =*5 50 / $-$ - ;, N@%")' "))%")")") %-E % @" 98E78 - 0, ") ")" ("%" " -38I -")"@%)

-") ")">

@ ?-" "# ' ") "" , ") )0 *% ""% 99 -0%- % ,")- ,38I -")"@%)

-") ##9531FE%">

" %@

--" "#

! <3:= 0% -% (-- " ,

" @%

-") ( -") - N@%")' "

'")N .'/# <39= !A," 0) #73.(/ -") N@%")' " '")N .'/,") " ""% "

39,888FE

- % - "", 39,888FE - -% >:8,888FE

" #

0% , ") %0)" - ") " " @ (,

- 19,888FE

- -% >, 19,888FE

-% -""3,88,888FE

" "

") "

39,888FE, 39,888FE:8,888FE "(% #

"), 0) 5#4 - ") - N@% ") ' " *0 % N .'/, ) - ")

)% -") ## " #1"

9""%"

- :8,888FE

-% -"%

" # <37= ( - ") " " @ (, ") % .## #456459"

455 -1835/ ,) #45: 1835%% "

")>"" -) %0")

-") )0 *%"

@ 9531FE" - 4,888FE#!A,")

" ,-%>,% -"" ") 0) "F ")%""%"

--" " "

")>"" -38I -")"@%)

-") ,@, )

- ") "F " ## )% - ") % )% ""%"

" O:8,888FE#

! <34=

0% ,")

%%-(%.##

#456459"

455 -1835/)%@2 ""

%,- , -%@ ") "F "#"% -")

) )") "F " %@""%"

#45: -1835""% #!"#(#'("( ")+E *0 % 2:

>= 5+0 >:

1 2:

>= 5-:0 3#

4888FE 9531FE 1#

" " ! 38I -9531FEP 953FE 6# "%

4888FE .9531FEQ953FE/P 76D6FE :# *%"%% 33 33 9# " ."

% >

- / 3F6 -4888FEP 1666FE 3F6 - 76D6FEP 1363 4888FEE1666FE/ P:774F.

")/ :774FE>31P 97,88:FE 76D6FEE1363FE/P 7# .%/ :171FE.

")/ :171FE>31P 93,3::FE 4#

93,3::FE>33P 9,71,95:FE 5# !

- !

( -- " 97,88:FE>33P 7,37,8::FE 3,88,888FE ! D# !

-"" 19,888FE 39,888FE 38#

%> 19,888FE 39,888FE 33# !

- " 3,88,888FE ."

-/ :8,888FE 31# !

"% " ! :8,888FE . )"

"F " #1"

9## 0)"/ "%P //?@ 36# "" 4#9I 4#9I ++' 5,77,8::FE 0:

//?@ /;/ ?@ <35=

0% ,0"

-5,77,888FE @ ") @%, ") "F " . #45: - 1835/

! )%""%"

-4,D1,95:FE% 0")""O4#9I ")-- "-

")" "" "%%" - ", % ",- , %# <3D= % "

" , ")

)%% "

"> %@%" , - , ? -" "

") ") '")N ./# " -") ")" ") " "

)%%@") "@ ") % @% -" -" A0 "

- %

" "

) -") "F "# <18=

0% , % .## #456 459 "

455 1835/ )% #45: - 1837 "% %% @

- 0 "3D#84#1834 @ ")% @% " ") >"" "@ (# .#'#L%/ 0 86#31#1835 " 3# L)")A0F + F # 1# L)") "@% + F #