← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/1411/2017dismissed

State Of Haryana And ANR v. K.L. Johar And Others

2017-12-11Mr. Justice Mahesh Grover,Mr. Justice Raj Shekhar Attri8 pages



     

 !""#$%$&' 

          

   

     ! "#$! !%!   ! "#$!!##$  &    '  ( )

  )   

( ) * + ,   ,-./0,&,12.034 ++'

(3 *3 35  +    *3 3(3  6 ('  3 ( ( .2..12./7  182

  292:12.0)4  3+ 

   

 +

3+3 

 +3 - 3'33 +    6337)    +          ( 3'37 3 *34 3+  47 3  ( 43  ,-./0,&,12.0;3 3   3  1 9)4 3+  ; +  ,74 , <1  3'( .2..12./4

4    '    473     7  3(  7 3+ % 

*3

--   ''  19=.1,12..  ,$$>1? 

82..12./)        *+  %     4 @ 

 33 4    3 +33    

3' 

@ '5*37+ 33 + .2..12./# + 33 + .2..12./4 +3* 3+   .A.112./ '3

 4 3   *3     ''  19=.1,12..  ,$$>1? 

282112.0

  (3    33 (#    )    *3   3     .:2112.0   3 33 3+ 33 ( 

  (  3

       *+  %  )     

3' =  *3  

2:2882.0   +3* *3+  ' 3+ %

  +4 3'' 3   7

3 (3  2:2882.0

+ 4  ' 5       3 3+    =      3+''  .22812.07   3 + ,$$     3  3+  #   3 3+  4 * '.92812.0

-.- 182812.0  

 

3  3  

192812.0)3 3 *34 3 33+ 33 (& +' 7  %*  +3 

  129>+? 4 '  (3 +

 *    3  &  #   +  4  (3

+ 822812.07 3 (3 53 *34 *3+

 47'3 ( + +  + B3 + '     73(   .2..12./'

73'' 

3 +  3+   *   2/2912.0 8 ++ ( +4 B3 +  ' ) *3 3 (3 '

202912.0  53 ( 3+ +  +73 ( 3 +3  '   #   B     *3   3 " /2=11=12.0,1B,$$=../A:

.A2912.0  *3   

  +        3        )  ++ ( +4(3    ) 2.2-12.0 3 (3 43  @    3 # ' 4 ,;'3  %)



*3+*3 '' 108:-,:/ .:2-12.0

--  

3 & .::- 12..3 3++(3  

.0..12.2  73(  3

C& .9-2012.23 #( 

   D  $ 3

&  73(   '3 &

   3  3'    4  (    (3     3  .0..12.2 9  ,+ 3   *+ %  33 (& 7  +3*

112-12.0  +3 ')   +

) D& 7

   

 

'4 7'3  *3 3+  *+ %  )   )  4 3+  4   *33 

+ +5    .92/12.0 ++ (  (3  3

    &  4  7'3  3     3+     *+  %  )       1:2/12.0 3+  4   *    1:2/12.0 #   3  & 75  

7'3

3+ % 282012.0   3  '3  ++   '     3+    % )  &  3    102012.0  $      '282012.03 1/2012.0

  4 5 ++ 

-/-  ( '' *+3 

33 ++  31/2012.0E  3 ;     +

4  *   3'( 6 (' 4 .2..12./) 3+

4      '   '     473       3(     

82..12./  

      @              3+    (*33 .:2112.0  +4 3 33 (&

 (  ' #     '3 3 3* 7'3 + 3 3+ 3    3+'' 

.22812.04 (* 33 + 3 3 *34 333+ 33 (& '' 7  %*  +3 

  129>+? 4 '

 (3 ( +  *# +4 +

3 *34  *3+)

  47'3 B3 + ' (3+ +  +

   * 3   2/2912.07 3 +  +4 B3 + ' ) 202912.053 (3+ +  +343 +3'  B3 + ' *3 3  .A2912.0 *3 



+    3 )

   +4(3  ) 2.2-12.0     3 # 3+  , ;'3 ' 



3 *3+ .:2-12.0

-0-

 

3 &3 '3 3++4 3+  7 '3

 3' 7 (      +3 3 112-12.0  ) +  3 ' )     

3+3  +

4 

7'3 ' 3+  *3 (# 3   4 * 3+  1:2/12.0 +(3 3   4  

7'3 3+ *+ % 282012.0

3   7 3

102012.043  182  !*3  3 '

( * 3+



  3 

*7 73   73 (

 ( +  *

 3 ( 3(  '3

 43+  ( 4   3'33 +  3( 4+'  ( + C+

   + + 

   3 +3  3 3   +'' 33( 4 3

3 (43 ' 3'33 (  3

( +7 * 53 ( +  +   

44 7 633 ;+ '  

33( 4 43  + 3  3 ' 4  + ( $3 7

 +   3  3  +  +

5 43 ( 4 3'33  33  ,+ 3'  82 ) + +

--  4  ( + C+

  %* '  ' 

*3+

  (  + +4  4@3

43 43+  3+    )

 33(       7  (3*  '  3

( +  3   '   ;3 7 43 '  '   +

( +'  3 +''

+

+ + @ + 3 7 F

;3  +  7 ' 3     

     (01 7 * 

<.8$  *34)33  3( 3'3  ' %* ' 7 3) 3 ( +3

 ' 33       *   7  

 ++7 ;  

 47 3  )  3   ++ ; 345

(   * ' =    +  7 (  +    ,3  +   %* '         

      +3 73(3       ' 3  343

33( +

+''3' 

3

;+3

  7  3+3 7 3  %* ' # 4  * 

  '3( 

  743    7 34  3 ( +  4   ;   7   '  

-2-

;+' 3 (* 3 )++ ()    '     '3 7  3    (3*  

++7

+(   3+3 +

+  ( ++ (  377

3'3 ( 

E 3 *34  3 )4  *34  ;        7        3    4  ++ +  3 )  4  *  7  3  '             (3      '  *  3'(  6 ('   *  7

3'3 

3'( 6 (' 3 3 3   @  3 3'3  > !%!?

"%!

...112.0>!##$?

 "%!