Icici Lombard General Insurance Company Ltd v. Mehrana And ORS
!""#$%$&'()(%!*+
', -.
/ //
!
"# $ # % &
'( ! )
$ # % *+ ,,, - *'.
!*-!'-/$0
% 22 (
% 1 $3 *
0
45564$( $ !78&%
% 9 $
(
" #
2( *7: ( % ; < %%
+856+
% 2
$ #
) ##2
*- 65&.&66+:
% = %% 2# =;$ ( $!
" >
%(
+856+!
" >
:
; ( 22 % % 2 ( )
5
9 *7( %(2
?
( 2%# 2
$ )(
& %!
" >
$ ( %% " @ 2
2 ( 2 2
)
% % ( ( ( *7
( ( ( ( % 1
% %
# !
" >
( %% % " @ ( !78&%
$ ( A #
% % # 22 ( A # $ ( ( 1
2 %
(
!78& (
( " 2
.B 5C.B C8(
#
C ) 2$( ( #
% % 0 011$ &2"&"3 1&%(3 &#"
45 &6.!78% %4"3/$&)9 &7 &!9"3: ; $<$1 ;:
( 1 % 8566C& $ CD (
B$ %4:
2 57
; 1 % (
D$EF$766C& % +666C& (
= %
8 =$ 5666C& =%
B= 5+66C&(
=% =( (
$ % D$FF$66C& 2(
( (
22 (
$ % 9
%-= !
!" #$
!78&
(
( % # % ( ( ( (
% ( % $ % ( $ %
% (
%
2
%
%
% ( GH=( #C ) 2- #
% % - #2
%
#( % %
2
% ( ( % ( (
% 2 % 2
% (
(
( #C ) 2
% % " 2 %1 #
D # %
&
!
"
!
" #
!
# !
#
$%
&'
! "
"
" " "
!
&
("!#
# "
) *#
#
&'
#
+
, '
+&- &!& ./ 0!
1"'
+&- &!&
& '
, '
+&- &!&./ 0!
"
# #( 2&3&
#4&" #
"
!! #
" &'"
"# "!# "
!
#
! #
"
& '"
, '
+&- &
!
"
"
!
!! &
&
"
!
&
#
#"
&# !
& '
#
, '
+&- &
&'
# "
"
&("
+
"
&
"
" !
!
"
# #"
"
&5! 6
&
!
"
6
"
"
!
& '
"
!
""
!
!
"
# !
& 3 ! ! "
!
#
"
&
&
# !
"!
"
!
!
& #5 "
"!
" "
6 ( +" /
!
&* < #
#
B% A
% " 2
5E ( B
A
% !
( ( #
) !D4% & 5 " / ( +
#"
'
+
( +
"
!
78
&'
"
" !
/ " "
!
!!
&*
57 B
#%!D4%
7 &''
6#
! 78
"
" 9 )78&.
&:$%'
"
+ #
"
:
$% "
;
$%
6
$<%:
$ %
"
/ #
"
!
!
!
;
$
%
/
!
!
!
9 !
:
$ % !
#
#
/
5 +
#=<$>=<%
#
/# :
$%
!
!
# $%
!
!
!
6
!
# $ % #
!
# $
% ! & ?
?
?
$<% / !
$%#
$%# !
# "
# :
$% ! !
$%#
;
$%
# 6
!
"
#
#
!
6
"
! & ?
?
?
$@%1"
"
#
4
"
!
&*
54 $ #( % #%!D4:+;% $ #
%
#
$( #$
(
% % 1 ( % #2
( %
% ( 2 % # $ %
( %
1
# #
& 78
!
!
"
/
"
!
!
!
!
& #'
#
/ +
, '
+&- &!&./ 0!
"
" "
"
!
#
!
#
"
&* $
% !
( ( ( ( $( ( (
( % 2 < (
2# (
($(
(
E
%
A%
%
( ) 2C #( #
#
% #
#
(
3$"&! 1 &%(3 &#" 45 &6 .$4$!"7 <% /$1=6 &7 &!9"3+56:7; :#;+ ( 2 %
22
% %
% " %% ( =(%$( (
#2 # %(
2 1 ) ( # ( 2 #
( 2%
%% " 1
!78&1 % !
% 1
%( $
$
## % )
#
(
(
1 )<&5 " !
! !#" "
!
6
" 6 ! "
&' !
" # "
/
"
& #" "
""
&
( A +
(
) * $ +,- - !"$
. /! "
0 .1&'
# "
"" !
&5 /
#""
F
#+
" ! !
!
" "
!
"
78& / "
"
78
!
!
!&1 1
" "
"
6
! "
! " & !
!
<$=%
#
9 ) !A
#
!
"
"
!
# " "
!
;* '
+
"
! !
"
!
! & #""
! "
! !
&
"
'
+
! !
$ %#
#
#
# #
"
" !
&
''
$%
/&
/ !"
/
!
'
+ &'! "
!
6
/
! "
!" !
& &'
#'
/
!
!"
!!
&
/
&* %
(
6 (
0 011$ &2 "&"3 1&%(3 &#"45 &6.$4$!"7<% %4"3/$&)9 &7 &!9"3$ : ; $<$1 ;: )&
B6&.
" "
-@CD "
!
$ % "
!& " "
& /
3
+
.'
2!34455 67 5
) * 354
$
-"
#
"
"
'
&' "
!
!"
D !# "" !
&
!# "
!
!
/ & !!
#"
!!
# # "
!
# "
" !
& <& "
!
" 3
#1' 2 !34455 67 5
) *
8 ,
29:
$
-
-"
.
#E"
!
&E
"!
6
""
& +#"!#" -<@#CCCD
7C
& &3
+
2 344 55 67 5
) * ;)<
.
!
"# "
-<@#CCCD
7C
&B!
$- 5 -; ,4+-4
- . 9#1#
+ C&<&<C<# " "
&
!
"# +
"
!
"
#"
!
" !
!
! &'
"
D ! $"
!%&'" ! !
"
!
!!
& !
! !
& +# "!# " -@C#CCCD
A A& 7& +#"!#
"
6
(
) * -< - ! "= =!
5"''
" "
"
& '
+
" &'
" '
! / &&$ % >- 4 (
.!."= =!
5" '#$
%
-
!#"= =!
5".#1/ ! #"$
. #
$
% (
$ +,- - ! " = =!
5" / 9 !$ "'" #"!#
"
!
$ %"
!& @&'
F G A $ % + </ 6+
1
A $ %
"
" ! 78
!
!
"
/
"
!
!
!
!
&' " +
F G A $ %
9 E8&'
# # "
"
! "
#
!
"
! ( +'
!#
"
& >& H "
#
"
!
!
#
#
"
" &
#"
" !
5 !
#!
!
"
!# "
& =&
"
& C&'
#
" !
!"
!!
& !#
" G
"
"
"
"
!
"
"
&' #" G "
!
! #
!
" !
# &E 8&- '
+
'''
'
B6&.
"
!&' !
/ $%"
! "
!
;$%"
!
;
$ % "
!
! !
#
"
!
.+
. #=>=#
& >& !
!
"
# !
&
B6&.
&
-@D
- @CD " "
!"
! 6 - & ! 6
#
9 !
!
! !
& !
!- A
! !
.+
. #=>=& =&'
'
D
!
+ "
8
& - '
+ " "
!
+
"
"
# !
!&5
/
!"
!#
6 !
6
#
"
!
&
!
!
!
! "
"
-C<&@<& <&' '
+
'
+
!
"
! "
-@CD
"
&' #"
!
!
!
"
&
D
!
!
"
"
"
!
A"
!A&
" "
!
"
&
"
"
& <<&'
1
A $ % "
&
" E
E
!D
& !
" !
((
"
" "
&( A +
"
" !
!
"
#
##"
"
&'!
" "!
"
#
"
!D
"
!
!
!
!
& <&H!
#'
!
"6
+
F G A $ %
A
$ %
"
( A +
1
A
A
D $ %
/
"
& # # A
"
&* %
( % ( %-= ! ( %
#C ) 2
3-*5,-
!"$
.
( # ' & #
&
! ! ! !
"
& "
!
&*
5
35, - ! #" $
# + ! B % #C ) 2 &''
!
"
#
)
!D
*"
!
& !
)
*
)
!D
*&
! !
'.0 # "
#
)
!D
* ! #
&5
"
)
*"
!
& 3#
)
!D
*# "
! & "
3
# #" 3
&5
3
'.0 # "
#
+
"
!
/ 0 ( +
"! &* #C ) 2
%
( C
# ( # -$ (
1 %
-(# $ % %
% !78&$ ! ! 2
# C8
%CD
1 @
( 57
% 2 2
# E
% 41 (
%
2 H 2C8
$ ##2 58888 :8566B5C8;% 2 %E$ % D$76$4FFC& :58888B5BE;
8E$86C&:DFF66&D764FF;
(
1 (
$
% D$46$5FFC& :D764FFI5+66I+666I5666;1 2 (
%
B %
2 267$56E : // 2 ?
! )2C 3 ?
3C*