← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/821/2018disposed of

The Oriental Insurance Co Ltd v. Swaran Lata And Others

2019-10-23Mrs. Justice Lisa Gill8 pages

     

!"#"$%!& ' ()

* 

   

  + '#,#  

      %-./00/0//





 !" # 

 

 $  !" #  % & '''''

/0//) '

1 



(# () 

 *  ) 

++   %&,-.,%-!

()    

 (

!    / +    

   #   #   

 0  (

 1## 

)# $ # 

   

!   + # 

1   

#    %22#    3  !%455! 6+   # #1



!  $

()   "

 !    6  

    ,%,-.,%&  

      

 ,%,-.,%&1   



 +#     !

     /"

*.!  3

+   !  7     / +          ) !  ( +  +   / 1*2&*8*-9.2    ( %, ,,   !              3

)!   6  ( + +   /  :*2;*1*,-9,!  (+  "  ()    "    *+!

 + +  ! #(   

 #  " 6+     )   (+  "  ()  1  

!   # #  #  6 +    ) #1



   ##

  ## $ 1   

#  " : 

!  #

#  < ! + !(   + +   #    # 9& 

6  



 () 

   % .=" #  6#

$  

  + 

   6+  ) ($   +    (  )#   )  #  

  #

> 

+ +  "

      ;*  )#

  

 7

# 

  

+  $

 # >

+

 # () 

 (

#  +

* % ?   1    

    #  ("

  ,%,-.,%&@

. ?       

 + + "+#  %@

 ; ?     

        

 !# !  A  @

9 ?    

     @

& ?   

  # () 

 

   % .@ *;

2 ?    %

"+ "    "     )@ *;

-  #   (

    +    "         1

  $ "()   "  ! 6

,%,-.,%&!  

 + + "+# ##+ 6( ++ / :*2;*1*,-9,!() "+*  

  

+    #    

    (   %&!,,,=*     !



      

 ( ;9!2&!,,,=*!

 

 * 0'  2# 3,$ %

%&!,,,A%.

%!5,!,,,=* .

 #   #&,B   ##  %!5,!,,,  C  4,!,,,  D .!-,!,,,=* ;

 #  #%=9  .!-,!,,,=**2-!&,,=*D .!,.!&,,=*     #   

"+A # 

9 7) #  )+ #%2 .!,.!&,,   A  %2  D ;.!9,!,,,=* & 

" ##  %!,,!,,,=* 2 

#    %!,,!,,,=* - >

.&!,,,=*  (4)56)

7-

 :"! ( "+       +  #     #  #   +1#  :0(          

        

 

       (

  



             #  ! 

 * /  2#  1!,1 "$# %

%&!,,,A%.

%!5,!,,,=* .

 #  +%=9 

 

"+A # 

%!5,!,,,  *  %=9  D%!;&!,,,=* ; 7) #  )+ #%2 %!;&!,,,   A  %2  D .%!2,!,,,=* 9 

" ##  %!,,!,,,=* & 

 #        %!,,!,,,=* 2 >

.&!,,,=*  ()6)

7-

    

   

# ;9!2&!,,,=*(  

  # :0(    

  

!   # %,!5,!,,,=*   ##          #>7  

E( 6  # )#7  / E  # .;!5&!,,,=*

  ( (   



 

 

 (  #   ()        ) 

++    F    #     (    +      #  ( )+ +   # 

  # 

  +   



+ )

   +# 

 (;. ) 



 *

#

)   )    # ( # 



.%,-%4-& !

9%)     #    (    F  # 

 ( "

 + )  # 

  (   # 



(+ )

 #  (     



  +      #   ! #!

   # ( )+ +       

 (   !  ! )     

(

   

    

(  # 

#  )

   ## 

  ) +

?%!



   #( #  (.%,-%4-&! #!      ("

 + ):"!        ) 

 # # 

 (   #  !



+ )+  A  !



() 





+  6#  ! ! 

  

 + # 9,!,,,=*   #  (    

  !   + # 

! "   #     )  # ( ) + +   # 

 !  ! )   

( 



 "   #     "+ +   



    + + #1

!  $ "()  "  ! 6

 ,%,-.,%&!  

 + + "+# ##+ 6 ( +  +   /  :*2;*1*,-9,!  ()    "    +*   # 

  +# 

 !  #  )

 ()   # 

   



9% )    #   ,%,-.,%&

  #( 

.%,-%4-&+ )! 

   (9%)     #     ;.)

 () 

 

#    GA 9:"!

# 

 #  

 !  # )+

"   # 

# %&!,,,=* 

() 

  "

    

 A #  

  #    )   .,%%*.,%.  GA &!  

   

.!.4!%54=* # ) .,%.*.,%;GA 2! 

 9!25!&&,=*   (

 

 ( "  

     A     #  

( F  )    #1

 

 !   (    



 + 9,!,,,=*     "#  !# 



 %&!,,,=*   "

+ + 

 # 

 *

#

)  ++      #  ( F )  #

 0   

   A  # ) .,%.*.,%;GA 2  



 # 9!25!&&,=*   +"#

 

 # 

!  #

" #   # %&!,,,=* 

() 



# 

      !

 



9%)  !   #.&B #&,B!

 ( ##   #      

!"# $+ #:0(     "$ 1$#,'

$! 38 $9/"3" 2 : '

$ 90 ;" $2 ; '#) !

 " 7 # %=9  

 )## ()

     )&   



(  (9%)    #   ! #%9  #%2

 (   

 # # .&!,,,=*

     #

 A !

         # %&!,,,=*   #

(    # %&!,,,=*   

#

 # %!,,!,,,=* ()   (

  # 

#  !

 %     #   9,!,,,=*      #  

 #  

       # %!,,!,,,=*   

  # 

"

## !

. 9     # 9,!,,,=*

 # 

# 

  

 &

   

# 9,!,,,=*   

##

  #  +  + #

)(   $+ # :0(  #$%  

 &'( )*  

)+,



4":"1(((!



  %9,;.,%4 #        >*.%%,*.,%2!       )  %   



  &' -.

'

 

*

!  !     *6

 * /  2#  1!,1 "$# %

%&!,,,A%.

%!5,!,,,=* .

 #  +%=9  

 

"+A #  

%!5,!,,,  *  %=9  D %!;&!,,,=* ; 

 #      #.&B  ##   %!;&!,,, ;;!-&, %!;&!,,,A.&BD %!25!-&,=* 9 7)  #   )+ #%9 %!25!-&,  A  %9  D .;!2.!&,,=* & 

#

%&!,,,=* 2 >

%&!,,,=* - 

 #  

     

 %* 9,!,,,=* 5 

 #   

     

. 9*  9,!,,,=* 4 

 #  #

     

 &*  9,!,,,=*  6) )6

7- +    "    #   



("!  

     .&!%.!&,,=* # ;9!2&!,,,=* # .;!5&!,,,=*

)( (

  

 #   # %!.-!&,,=*

+   H-&B#  #

 =   %22#   3   

 (



  

 ?   (" #    # !



  # !& ' ()

* /0//    ?   6+=



I =/ ? 

I =/