High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/22620/2024dismissed

Monika Chopra v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2024-12-04Mr. Justice Arun Palli,Mr. Justice Vikram Aggarwal10 pages

!"#"

$% "&"

' ()'

" *

)) ()'

" *+, ' )

! "

# $$$$ +, ' )- % &

' ( )* )+ ,),*- . /%*0 " 1 2/ # - 3 40

#5 # #1 ,*22 /% /66 0-

3 # 40 " # ( "

' 5 ( ,, )% ,),2 - . /%%0 5 " " & #

55 ( 7 6- 37640 5 , & 5( 5 " / 5 # ,) )+ ,),, - . /20 # 55 # # #

55 #

-2- ,+ %% ,),, / 55 #

8 " & / " # %2 %, ,),, &

/ ##5 # # # 9:

- . /20 # ( # 5 , ;< =))9/ >?

>2 <* >))9/ 5#( ( ( % )))9/ ( / 5 ( ( " " - . /*0 %2 %, ,),, /5# - . /;0 " 5

/ # ,) )+ ,),,

"( ( " ' 5 ' 5 %> %, ,),,

(# 5 , +% ;>)9/5# %)? '" >* %* >))9/ *

# ,) )+ ,),, %)? '5 / 76 " 5 > 6 ( 76

/ # 5 "

" (( 5

/5#,) )% ,),2- . /%)0 / ( 5 "

6 5 / /5# ,, )% ,),2 - . / %%0 " " @ # %+ A/ # 9"

-3- ;

(( " /

# " / ## ( @ " ##

5/ #9 / (( &

%, )2 ,),* - . /%20 (

( 5 5

+ %, )2 ,),* "5

,2 )* ,),*

@ 5 ( )* )+ ,),*- . /%*0#( #(

= 7 # < 6 # ( " # #

(

/ @ ( ( " ( " / 5 ## ##(# " " ' 7 #

5 # "5 / @ " ". " # 7 # "5 ". @ # #5 ( " " " @ " ( #( ( 5 #5 5- . /%>0

#9 55 # # " %2 %, ,),, " .

# 5" @ (

-4- " 5 "

# # # @(5

5 6 3

! " #$% &'

(( ) %) 7 # /

"55"# # "5 / ( ( " 5 ##@ / ##" (" 5 ## ( "( (

5 # # # 9:

"5 / ## @ ( " 6 "5 ## # " ## # . ( @ #

%% B ( ( # %, & & 5 ( ( " ' # %, )2 ,),*B 1 ,>**,),2 / ( )* )+ ,),* "@( ( ( " B #@( # " # # %+ / # ,) )+ ,),,/ .&/"0 12334$30 536 7*+ 3058033 4%%23

9%346:5 ;530 4;46 4<<302 2357 14$%35

%4%<=2 32 304$%35 -;530 $345858464 "> %2

# #55# #

( @ " " 5 ## # ( " 5 " @

-5-

(( : 5 (" " ( (( (

6 "" 5 ( ( "( " 5 ,)? "# (

# %" # #" " 5 B ##(# ( ## #%+-0 ( .

. /%> 5 # 5 " ( 5 ( " ""(# ,)? (

& @(5 A ( 8-

0 #"

5 #"

( ( " ##

" # "( 5 (

%* 1 5( # "@ " ### " # ( # ( "

5 6 #( *+, - . /0 #, '# 12 '3#

3 . / 0$ (5 67 88 6 7 ( % @ " 9 6 !# 75 # "# 6 # ( ( " # " 8 5# # ##5

#5# %)?5 " # ( " " & ##( " " #

#( 5 ## " ! C( 5 & ( ##

-6-

@(5 # 5

. #5# # 8

## # ( ( "

5 6 # #( *& -# '# ,!#& # '#$%6(9)7 & : %*;0" '#&,< '#$%6(99:7 & )% *1 . /0 #, 3 1 0 & #$% 6

97 : & (5(% *12 & / '# , . /0 / 1## 0 '#$% 6(99 7 &) *= 80# #. #. /0 #, #$%6

)7( &:9:%# >? @5A# #3 & -#B' , !#& #B'6(9)7& : # < ## 33/### A#C 0 3# / 3, 0 0 0 33 # 0 # 0 ???????? ???????? )4 ;0" B'&,< B'6(99:7 & )%# # < # # 3 30/ 3 3<# # / 33 # 3 0 3 3

0 # % #33### ???????? ???????? 9 4 1 . /0 #, 3 1 0 &B 6

97:&(5(%## < # # # #0 ;3/ 0 #0 3

# A##,## 3### ???????? ????????

3 # 3#<#/3 /3 %#<#3# ; //# 0# < 4 < 3 3 3003 < #

-7- # 9 5 3 '

, # /3 # 0 <

< ; ## 0 %<## /3 # // < ; , # 0 # #

< 3% # 0 3 # # "

% <#0## 0 +<%# # 0 <#

## 3 # 0 3" # 0 % 3 , 3 # # 0 < <# # /< 3 # A#% 30/ 330 3 ,3 #/%# 0 #" #3 3# , # /

;## 0 ##, & +, % 3# // < / #00 # /3

3A##3# ;

#/3 3## /3< 0 0

# 3 ,#/

+-. / 3# /< 3 #3 < #

3 +-.#

;0 '

, D "

/ # ;0 <# < / # <# # 3 < # 30 ,

)#//,<3003 < &3 9%C %<##3003 30/ ;%# // 3 <# 0 #

30#3 0 ,

3 % 3 0 <# /,0 3 4 < 30 / #/

/,# 03 / # ## # # # 0 8(((5 3% # , # , # // 3 A# /

3/,# 03 , # 3 #+#

3/ #3 <# <0 # 0,%/,

8 ,%#// <A# 0 3/

, # +# # # 5 ( // 34 # 3 330 3 #3%<0/ 3 8 "# #/

2/ /> "# #3$ 8 "# #&/0 0/ ,$ <# / <0 # 0 ,E %>

5# " / : 3. &" C0 '# +, &## "

-8- #" 6+&7 '#$6?(9

5? (%3 5 9 ((7 & "5 # " # 2= D ( 5 ₹% =+ << 2))9/ ! "( ( " 5 5( ( " # # A/ # # # " (

#"#( ( " 6 # ( " # ( ""#(

5" 55 & ( ( 5 ( " @ #,= # "#( @ /% " )+ ( #.5 #

# 5 (# / @( # / ,/ #?

3 / 3, <#3# < # / 33/ # ## A#< 3##<##/ A #3 ,### ,## 3 3# # /3 0 , # 00 ( 4 # 3 #3# 0 3 3 # ,3 330 3 < #/ #/ A## ### / 33 #

;0 / , ,#/; # # 3 <" #&##,<#3#3 #

& <# # 0

3 ( #

33/### 3 #0, 0 #3 #+ &/0 A 3# 1#3 & '6(95(7 & ( > 48 6(95(7 & 5

> & '+ , G< 6(957& :>48(95&()(:H - 4 ! 0& 80637%6(9:97 &( :>48 (95(&9 & - ,!#& #6(9)7&

-9-

: &0<<" ,. ! 3# # ;0 %& +, #6

97(886 7 : (:A#3 ,3 033/ 3 ### # # 3 3 3 3# 30 3 < #/ #/ # # ) #?3 / 3,% < E

"/ : 1#& #+, &##"#" 6+&7 '#% 6 7886 7((% # @) A# /; '3# 4

3F 3 6/7 ;0 # #30/ 3, #0 33/ 3# #<###< , # 3 # # # ,3 <##

3 3 # # # # 33 / 30 , % 3 # 0 0 ???????? ???????? ((4 3#330 3%#/ #" 3 3 3 #0 A# %#%// #

%# % 3 / ##0# < # / <1 , 3#/ <### %# #3# # <#3#< 0 03 #0 3

0 # 3 A# 3# ##/3 3

<0 # / %# % 3< < #"/

0 # 3## < / 3 <#3#<

3 #/3< // , ;A# / 3# #3 <#3#/##3 #

" <# /3 /3

# 0 ,

3# # , / # // ;/ #/3#### 3# A#/ # < #<## /3 # & 3# < ;0 3 3 3 < # " ## 3# "

, 3#" 3 ,<"/ 0 # /

-10- #3 / ##/ # 0" 33# 3E %;

& # # ( " #

( " " (" " 5 %+ ( (5 " # # # # # ,) )+ ,),, "

( ( 5 ( )* )+ ,),* - . /%*0 5 ( ,, )% ,),2 - . /%%0 # # "@ ## 5 ( ## ##(# # /" #

# 9"

& 5 ( #

" 5"".

( 6 5 5

"5 5 (#5 ?

))@ ?+, ' )@

$% "&"