High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3286/2013disposed of

Balkar Singh v. Raman Kumar

2016-01-27Mrs. Justice Rekha Mittal7 pages

!"#

$% "!!

!"#$%

"( ) *$%

+"" & ' '&& *,- '' ( ".#/* 0 1 - "& 0 +"" ".#/* " #'- & "/0

$% "!!& 1"& &&'"- / ".#/* 2

&-," ' 3#/$4"- (" -, &&' & -, 5'6 /" &&'' / " .#/*

7&-," '8%'3#/

% 4"-"- * " / -," '8 # % # 9&'

$"%-

* 4$ - $ " * :#* & '* / "*'

-" '& & *9* :#* 8 *& ,

'# % , "& *""&&'' 9 "

6 ' ;$2 $

$' & "&' " ' # "* # '

/(" < 2=& * " 1"&&'' '"( * $ # $ " '-', &, ,* # " & >% "" % & , # ("" & *1"- " $

*', " /"" # (" *9? !'% "

8" ? !'" " % "- " *

:#* > " ,

;$ # " /" ( ' " $" * ' /-( " /" "

*>"/"',*& --'" ** / (''&,#""#/ * # (" # / / , / #'# & # 1" &&'' % & * &, < 2=& * " " /""" # ("9? !'% "

8" * 77

;1" *# /%* # " /"" #/" # $&'1" # * '& & " /" ( #'-& #" #/" "

/""* % 1"* # '*-," & * * '&/% " /" # - 6 * -, " & * / - #* @ ,/ # - " ( - 6 & *$"* - # / ,$"&&'' ( ',# .-@""'' /* -', "#A' # " & ' " # " # - / '

% ' # 1" % ,-( "& ' * '' ( /

! "#!

!! $ %&''

(

) %&'* +

%&'* ,

) $

%&'* #

1"& ( & * #% #&&

" &%'* 1"&&'' B* "*'

+ $ " /"$" - " + "*" /"'6$4 / @ + / CB& + - ( / " #/" #' " %'

#-* *-, # "& "'/" &' / * ' $"' '8 # * #? % #

9&'

* /#( ( / " 9&&'' D# $"# ( % , $

$72

;$2 $

& &'

* # $ $72

'#'< 2=& * " * " ' '' "# *&' <= &

#* "& &'* # *" "#''

'E 4' /// % -,".#/* &-," ' # $"&&'' & &&'(""* -*-,

; " ' 3#/$4"- '' ' / $"& /#' &&'" - & -,"&&'' 8 # "'" / "8 # -' (& * ', ( # 1" #-* *-, # '" " /"$- " "' /(" *9? !'% # - 6 *"%- #-," & / '#/ "&&'' % "#/ * # '

/(" B - > $#-* "* :#* & # /" B* "* ""&&'' % - #/"" & ' *9* :#* 8 *& ,$ " $

#' & " " & ( #'% ' "&&'' # -(

"& '

; ;"&*-

;$' "&' 8 # ( #'# /"

= &

#* '' ( -, " 8 # -' ($ - , -( "& D#

-#&"'$"#'-' - # 8 # "*% *& /#" " # - 6 '#& * " , #

-# %( " '# / B* & " # $" "

*"-

/'* $ %( & % ;

"> C% 8 # "#&& ".#/* & -,"8 # -' ((""#-* ""

2 - 6* -," & * " , # -# #', /-,"&&'' (" " ' ''/ & % " (" " #' # / ,> # " /#" # - 6- /* -, *9? !'% "

" / (""-# ' / # *9*

:#* 8 *& ,$ & & "& " & / # '$ "- '' (-,"8 # & ##'& E $4"- >"%" # "& & #" 1"#- 'D# '("'' * -.$

) ) %/ -.$ 012 $) 3 4% 8 # " &#" F-"F '#& -," & - / #

/ 6 ' # " # '"

%* "-( & '

; &*-

; 1"&' &&'' " # - 6* -," *9? !'% "

8" $ & # * -,"&&'' F- " "

/" "& 77

;$"%- # "& #* % * . > &' " "% " ,' /(" *9? !'% *#"' ""% % ,* , * * -"'

" /" / , , - 6* -, *9? !'

% > - ,#"&' "( * $

#" -& " " & *#" * - 6* -, *9 ? !'% " #-* *-,"&&'' "" (

% ' ;$2 $

# -( & '

; &*-

;(" # ,/ #'# & #"% /- - #/" "8 ** / , $ "*/ ' -' %( " - 6 #',/ -,"&&'' 1"* ( #'"%-

$" " - - 6(" #/ # $ "% #',$" - , " * '$*,

'-', "#* # #& 1"&' " # - 6 *-' % "* * " , #

-# $ D# " #* ""' & / "&&'' #',/ -,"*1"&&'' $" $

( //' # " -,& / # , & "" # - 6( - /* ', , # -# C% " ($"&&'' " & # , & , - 6( #'#- "&'" "*( * " , # -# 1" # / " ( -, "8 # > &#-',$ " / * -( "&

/ ("" ( #'-" /-'1" & " '* < =&

2=& * "-,''/ /""

*& "& %' 1" & " B* ,( #- "&' " / G " #* $&& "

.# * " ( -, " 8 # -' ( D# * % # 8 # " ## '' (-,"8 # #> "%(

"* $"&&'' "''-'-' &, < =&

*" &,* & * ,-,"&&'' ''

"# #'$D# ? * / "&&'' D# ? ( % # " * 4 " / / $"&&'& ','' ( *$'% /"& - " ( 6"' 3#/

* " -*-