← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3369/2013dismissed

Om Parkash v. Devender And ANR

2015-10-14Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal12 pages

 

      







 !"#$

%%&&

'"( ) "

$"

%



 !"#

 "$ !"

"$ $"

*$+ )

","#$  (-+ )+

%%&&  "%# . &+ )

"%  ////  

 

         

   

   

  

     " %  !&

 %%& *  (""

 *

0(" 1&2

!&

&

 1(  4( & "&

%"  -( 

!&

&  2 "



#$2 7

+ 9$ 

("

9:7+ ) ( 2$

") ( 

)&&*  1 ! !%+ ;$&

"  %

!&

$ %("$

("

9:7   "&+ (" 1(

4 3"

)

" !" *$+ "

)&&*  1+ ;$& "  % $"(*$ "*" & 

7

!&

& 

("

43" "# &" <.0=>< 1(  =:

,(

?2 + @:

A& $": + "$:

,(

?2 ($:

,(

.  , &&* + 2$ " $ %" + 2 "

" 

("

4 3"

 ( 2$

1:$

)&&*  1 $" &23

%(

"%

-3 

12

%&



@$ 1#*"( +   1

&    (+ 3 2 "$%

%&

B &  %&

)"

%("$

4(

" !" %"

& 

7

&  &  1 &&*&+ )    

2$( "  &&*  

"

!"

" 2$ %&

&  $) %("$ %"%"3

2 "

( 2$

 

)&&*  1

;$

 %"&3

"

" & $( %"&3  &3 ) 

0 &

# %&

)&&*

3"

 7:C

(" &

%" *+ 1" && &

($"

(



  - 2  $ 

 &3 "

&

%" *+ "&&3  $( (

    23

 &3 &  1"

&& (" &

- $(  1(  >"

&"   %&

1$ %"%" * %"%" ($"   &

"# &" <9D< $2

 & 1&( &("



"

 $( (+ $& "# &" <.A,!D9<

!& "# &" < 9D?0=><

 %&

.$ $ %"%" 2" " 

  

 "&

"1( $ %"%" $

 +

 &3+

.$"+ 0$"

,"%$&

%"

"# &" <.A,?<

$2

3&&2 &("

 %&

 

,"%$&

,"%$&  (& $ 2 &  "

   



$

,"%$&

3"

 C+ $ ( .$" 0$"

*$

!"%"3 "# &" <,B0?<

$2

" &("

 %&

 

.$" %"

"# &" .0=> $2

" * &("

 

0$"

*$

&& $"    

$"

"%) $"

%("(

"& &  

 )1& %"%" (

 

2&&



1 2" )   1( 

"

$2

1)

 "

$

.$"+ ( $ 

!" $ 22 D$$ 

%"

2 %"%"+

&&

.$"  

$"

%"

"# &" <,B0?< $2

" &("

& 9&2+ 22



& "

 +C

8:

%"

&   7 )" " &  %"&3

"

$(

&& 2$

 

"  ;$" "+ %" +

 &3+ !" D$$  2" &

& "

"

%"

2 %"%" & 2" *)

.$"

"&

"+ &

 !"

)("

%&

&&*& )   

!" $

"*$+ & "

 1( " (

&& .$"+ %"": : "

!" D$$ +

$3 $ &"3 & %"

1) &  %" &3 9&2+ 22



$"

*" 

" "

*$+ 

.&-

$ %" " & 

  7C+

,"%$&+   $

"&

 *$+ & !" 0$"

)("

("- .$ :

? 9$ :

$"+  

?*   & $"

" ,"%$&  "# &"

<.A,B< $2

3&&2 &("

 %&

("- .$

  1 )   %"

& 



$ 1

%("$ !2

) "

 

?2 + 

& "



8:

"   22

!" + 9"$ 2

&&+  -3 

!" + "

)&&*  1 

  +  + 9"$  -3 & $"

$( - %"

 2"



& "



8:

?2 *$+

$"



" )" $ 2 &  

)("

!2

) "+ 2" $"

)("

?2 *$+

$"



 && $ 

0$"

"

"

23+ $ &&*

 2 %"%"+ 2" "* &&3 $&

   * $   "

$( %"%"

%

 + 9"$  -3



%"%"3

 %"

$( (

"!" 

.$" &

"*$

%"

 @$)"

*

("

$

$"

.$" & $ & $ $"

"



%" %"

 &&* 0)& 0(" $ *

-("

%"%"3+ ( 1

)&&*     

!&

& "%&

"& 0("

" 

&&2 ( :

E @$$"

%&

&

%"  -(  %"3

!!

@$$"

%&

- 2 "

&  

%" 

%& !!

 @$$"

%&

   1&

%"

!

@$$"

%&

$

(



& %" ! @$$"

%&

$

-("

"3 "

%" !

 @$$"

%&

 %"%"&3 )&(

%("%

("

 -("

! 7 & G  !" & $"

"%) )

(%%"

$"



" ( 7 ;"& 0(" # ( 

- &3 $& %&

 & "&

23

&

+ $" "+ ( 

2"  *  %&

B(   2"

 %" " *&3+ $ ( 2"  *  $ 



1

 * "" "

( 

%&

  "& 0(" ) -(*  "

7

C >& **") *  " -(*  "+

%&

2

%%&+ &   &2"

%%&& 0(" ) -(*  " 7



, + %" %%& %&

:%%&&  >" 

4(

&2



"3

&*$



" " >(&& . $

0("

H     ! " !

# $%%&' &()+ 2$"

 $& %") 



!( -1 0(" +

23

 ("&     



0!0 2+  "*(&"



%%&   1& &3 



0!0+ $" "+ (1 & 4( 

&2     

  %%&

!""

   



0!0+  %%& (& $) 1

& 1 " 0("

*"(   (

&(  



 0!0   

1 ""3 &2   (* $)

"

&2I 1 

$)

& "    "& (

&2 (* $)

"

&2  (1 & """



%"(" %") 0 $"

&2

  1

"+ 3 %1&3 $) %"( """





 (%

" 

2 "

"

 %%& (& &3 1 

(1 & 4(

&2 "

 ;$" "+ "

" 

 1 &3 1( ""

""3 &2+ 1( 2$

%( ( " (1 & 4(

&2 D  ($ %2"

%%&& ($"3 1

%(1& %&3 $) "

5 H   

        "&  %("% 1"

&3 (8&*

   %

 

*(&"

 %%&+ &"

 ( &

%%&&

" (&

&&2 (1 & 4( 

&2 :

E @$$"

&   7 (& $) 1

"& (%

2$(   1 %")

" &2

)

@$$"

(" 1&2 $) &&3 * " (  "3 ) %"( %%&&

$%

- 1   @$$"

&&* "& & ""

") ( ""+ (& $) 1

"& (%

(" 1&2 FG  $) " "*( 

1$  $) & %"( "" )

"" $2 & "&&3   

"

%"+

 &3+ *$

 "

$

.$"+ $ 

!" 22 D$$   

$"

$3 & 23 $"

)("

9&2

& "

+C

8:

%"

&   7

>(

"&

&  %&

&

%"

  %&

$ %

)& &  !"#$ )   ;$" "+ %&

&

 %&

$ 1 $ &

*"(

$ %("$

" !" *$+ $ 1

%")

"" =5!@:8.

=5!:



43" "  2  % 

(

  

=5!:

!" 2 "

 3"

 C 2" !&

:%%&& &  0(" 1&2 $)

 %%"





""

"

&   7+ $"

1#*"(

"%

)" "

$(+ (

  !& && &3 ) %%&& &  1

   %%&& + 2$& %%" !@:+ $ 5%" * " 1(  %&

=5 !@:8 .

%"%" 2$ 

,

("$"

  %"

$2

" &("

 %&

$

  &3 )

"(

$ 1

" $"

,

("$"

  $ "&"

& &  !"#$ )  

$ ":5  

 

  %&

&

)& %"  &"

" 

    1( " @$& %%" !@:+ (" %" *

(+ ) $   =5@:

%%&& 5%" $ * " 2$ 2 "

%&+ %("$ $

" !" *$

,

  $)

 %"%"  %&

%&

, &   ?2 $   $) %("$ &

"  



1(  "

%("$ $3 $ "( $"

"%) $(

%%&& $  

)"

%( )"

$( &   %"

%"%"

&&

.$"  

$"

%"

"# &" <,B0?<

 %&

$2

" &("

& 9&2

& "

 +C

8:

) &   7

 %"(&

&  $2

!" D$$  $ &"3 & $"

$" & 

)"

& %&

+ %%&& $ &"3  

)"

%"%"3+ $" "+  

1  !" $

%( "

5(

&   7

 J(



" (& $  2"

"

(& &

J(





 "

 * 1

%"%"

" %%"

) 

J(

 & 2"

*)

1

)

"&

 $" "+

(

&   7 5( !" D$$  " " 2$( "

%"%"3+ 1 &  %&

%" (

7 



=)  % %&

3

$"

"

(

 ( 

&+ "$"

$ " %1&

1 $ * &

)("

$"

%"

$ (& 1 %  ( $2 -(*  " % 0(" 1&2 "(&

"

) (

" % %")"3

""

0 4( &3+



"

%%&+     & "$'

 !($

)   *+%,-*.