Ishwar Singh & ORS v. Nihal Singh & ORS
!"#$%&'((#"
)*+,
#- '%./.&0
1
+0 2 3+ 3 $/&-0 +$!/4." 4#$'5#67'8%#- $-4#((""#&-/ #6/4 .&'#" 4("#.&-.
/#$9 $-4./%!$-.:(! &.& -46!' :&-#&'
'%$ -4"#$&'"5$#((""#-%!$-754$9;-4#- -4-$.#"%!$- 5#/$8$/'#&'-4/!.- ."'9;-4("#.&-.
/ $($:#&&-.&6!&%-.&7 5#/'./:.//' &-4%#/.&4#&'7-4#((""#&-/ ."'/!.-/<.& $/-$#.& # #.&/-$/(&'&-='
&'#&- $:$#./.& #&;%&/-$!%-.&&-4 "#&'.&'./(!-:#/!$.& :#$"#/'(.%-'.&-4$8&!$%$'#/
4"#&'9.& 6.&-#&'5.-4!-(#$-.-.&7-4' &'#&- 5#/&-&-.-"'-$#./#&;%&/-$!%-.&$#;$5#/#"/:#' $$:8#"
-4%&/-$!%-.&#"$#';$#./'4-$.#"%!$-'%$'-4/!.-754$#/ -4"#$&'"5$#((""#-%!$-$8$/'-4 .&'.& /$%$''9;-4-$.#"
%!$-#&''./:.//'-4/!.-
3#$&'%!&/" $-4#((""#&-//!9:.--'-4#-&%.&-4 $8&!$%$'7-4($($-;4#/9&/45&-96.&-7-4' &'#&-'.'
&-4#8#&;$. 4--$#./%&/-$!%-.&-4$&5.-4!--4/#:9.& (#$-.-.&'9;:-/#&'9!&'/#/#&;%&/-$!%-.&$#./'&#(#$- -4 6.&-($($-;5!"'($6!'.%-4$. 4-/ -4#((""#&-/ -$4#$.& "#$&'%!&/" $-4#((""#&-/7'&- .&'
#&;$#/&-.&-$ $5.-4-4 .&'.& /$%$''9;-4"#$&'"5$ #((""#-%!$-4#((""#&-/#$%"#.:.& -4:/"8/-9%=5&$/
#/:#""("-:#/!$.& :#$"#/9#$.& <4#/$#>?
@$-4(!$(/7 $".#&%4#/9&("#%'!(&-4&-$./:#'.&-46#:#9#&'. $-4;#$
=
-.//! 4--9%"#.:'-4#-6.&-5&$/4.( -4("-9-5& -4(#$-././#$/!"- %&/".'#-.&.&-4;#$>@ -./&-.&'./(!- -4#--4! 4-4(#$-./5&-4$($-.&/ "#&'.&-48.""# 79!-&&
-4#-./6.&-4$./&$#/&%:.& &$%$'6!/-. ;.& 5&$/4.(
&!:9$ ($/&/&#/:#""(.% "#&':#/!$.& :#$"#/7&54.%4# 5""5#/A./-.& 4"#$&'%!$-9"54#/ !$-4$ !&'-4#-&'!9-7 -4&#:/ -4#((""#&-/4#89&/45&.&-46#:#9#&'..&%"!:& 1.&$'%"!$7458$7-4&-$;'/&-'(.%--4:#/5&$/
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
/7458$7.&8.'&% -4;#':.--'-4#-.&-4;#$>>B7-45""5#/ .""'!(5.-4/#&'#&'-4 ("-5#/"8""'+#&.& -4$9;-45""./&-.&!/ $:>>B C.-4-4# $/#.':#-$.#"&$%$'7'&- .&'#&;$$$.& -46!' :&-#&''%$(#//'9;-4"#$&'"5$#((""#-%!$-
/!9/-#&-.#" D!/-.& "#5 #$.// .& -4 ($/&- #((#" 4 /#: ./7 #%%$'.& ";7'./:.//' )#6/4 .&'#", !'
1 :<