← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3375/2013dismissed

Estate Officer Excise Area Ambala Sadar Cum Deputy Commissioner And ANR v. Amrinder Singh And ORS

2019-11-08Ms. Justice Jaishree Thakur14 pages

  



        



  



 !

"#  $ % !# %& !

(!

))** +!, -) !  .(

(!

)

    

 

/!  ! +

 0(!'12# '





! '(, 31# '



!  4,)# '





55555555  



3( !.,*!



))*

*'

' ' (  !( **'

7( 7 8 (** . 2,'. '! " " $ )'

* 1!

,!# '!

)*  (  !( **'

7(

7 1** 2,'. '!





)'

! ))** ,! 1(! 6# ))* *'



'' *

))*#

))*

*'

8



'*6

 '6

* ))*

0!*6#  (!

%39$$9

 $$$

!)

:

(



0 ,'

  '9;1!  '#  * ''!#  * -  * 4; 4 !* ; .! ,!

6

<#  * -  (*'

  !



44 4

4 !* !'!

$

 $ "<

*'

*'

!

'

.! 16

!>'

!,

! )* !# ,(#

*'

!, )!6

?)

! '

!

(!

,'

 * 8 !*

'*!

)! 2, 

1(* *

!

)!6# ),!('

@!

@.(  A* ! 4!,'# (!

/*

6 ''

"$B#



(    *,

 , * ( '!

'6 *,'



' !

(!

'(# @ @.(  (!2 C'1  .(     *,

!

!!'

(*'

!

'

  *'





 * ,# &(, .!

' 1! 8

 '



, '

),.

* *

'*!'

**.*# !>'

 % !# %&'

!#  * '!

('

*'

!6

, # 

, )!

  !# )!

!,* !.,*

-

'# ; *'

4!  **.'

- !*

'*.'

) 1!



@!6

 44

$

"<

,( ) 1!

&!'

@!6



! 3( @!6

)!6 3(!

   )6

,))*'

 )*''

**.'

  ,.(

!*'

,)

.

(!

(!2

/*# (!

/*

!. *

! *'

(!

( .

),!) 

!>'

!,

)* !

!' 3(

-#  * '!# , )* #  * '!

 

,



1 (6   *,

!

)!6 '

**.'

4; !'

*'# ,( 

!! # (! !#

'

 *'

(!

- !*



@!6

!

,( '

!'

'

%& .!   $

,***'

@!6



B

, '

44

$

"<  0 .* !6

' ))* * -

 *



!!'

44

$

"<# * 

!,'

(!

' ),!) 

), * ),!) # ( 1 !#

,( !D,!



),.

 %

),.

#

,

!!!'

1

*

# ,(# 44

$

 $ "<

))* *

)!6 ) '

,

, 2 !

B .! !.!'

*, # ,(#  

!,'

*, < , &

!.!'

.!

(! # ' !6 )!

'

!!'

1

'

'  * 4 !*

'

(*

?

'

 

           *'

               '''

B " $$"# 

1 ') 

!' !6 !'6

 * , '

)' '

!6 .,*



44

$

"< 

,)!''

!)*'

!

!

; D,

# -

@ , 

'

 

$ -

#

$B *'

@!6 

!, .

(7

#

@!6 

)  ,( !.(

!, )!6 !!'

**.'

4; )!)!'

 * -

)*6

,)

#

2,! ,! !

6!

 *(

 * -

 )**6 '

(*'

(!

)!' !

7*'

4! 7 !

**.'

44

$

"<

 ?)

# ))!'

*'

(!

1!

 8 )!* !6

2

!.!'    *6





!#  '

  *, ,**

!

! !

** , ! 

, '

)!

 / *6   $$ !.!' , )!6# )!!6 !.(

 !

 ' *'

),.

*'# 2,'

!

6

*1#

!>'



@!6

,



'



' ('

! !!'

)!!6 !.(

*

&'

!



@!6

&

.!   $$#

(** .'

!'

&'

! '

''

*

(!

'

'' , '

)!

4;#

!()





'

,!

( *'! !.(

!''

7*'

4! 7

**.'

1! .

*6

,) 6 !.( (6

*'

!

'

.! 16

!>'

!,

! )* ! 3( 

! !!'

)* !'# 

*6 & ),!)  '



@!6





""

'.

'

% !

( ) ),!) 

,

!,)

*'

44

$

"<

!6 ,( ))* *

&'

!

 * -   )! )!*

?

' 

   !'

!,*

-

*1

(!

1!

 # , '

 ,

44

$

"<#



' !

','



1 * ) *6



$<#

1((#



' .

.,'* 

'* 

!(

'

   * ' *'

'

''

 '!'



, )* #  *

< '!

 ' ,)

( !!'

),.

*6 ,

#

'!

! !

A * 

!!6

@!6 

*!

$$$ ** .!

' 8

 *

(** . ),.

!'!

1! '

< )*

1!

 *' A!

)*' .

)!# , 1! !'

*'

)! 

))! # * 1!

,! '!'

'

,)(*'

! ))** ,!

))*

2,'. '! )'

,! *

(** .'

( !.,*!



))*



! +

 0(!'12# * ))!

(*

!., ,! * *'

))!  ,.(

!' , '

&,

'

''

''

# ,(#

*,!

(!

!()

6 ''

*'#



&

.!   $  *('

1!

!

)!6

 ''

,! * *'

))! )6

4; %&



' *

!,





"$

-

 !.,'

(!

, !6

*



,!

*'

)!  )!6 *

 ''

,! * !*'

,)

)! , *.

1

)!  )!#

*, *6

 '!1 )!,)

!.!'

!()



,!

 .!' ))*

8



'*6

* ))*#  !.,'

),!) 

* !.,*!



))*



!'!



) !6

!'!'

..

 6 * ''

'* *!8

*6 E 0(.1 1(

,**6 !!'



 ''

1

!!

'

'* *!8# ' .

!# 1! !,'

(#

,.(

1*'.

'

 

*.( 1(

, D, , 

*6 ,!  .( ; -*!8

!(   , '

),!, )! ')! * ' . .  '

'* D, )* 6

*6 E 0(.1 * -*!8 ' ,



 "

( !.,'

'*6

* ))*

 

*

,!!'

',

'

!

,(# '*6

* ))*

,.(

'

,)) !

(

 

# ( !* ,)

2,'. ! '!'

 !

 " # $%

& 

'() *+*'+),- ./0% 10  &% 20&  3  %$%4$'5)6&7* ( ,'()*+*'+)-  " /!

!#  '(, 31# '

 ))!

(*

( *6

))  !., !'

*  !.,'

,! # !

'! ** !*

!'# !.(*6 '!'



 ''

!.,

''!'

*

'*

'* ,! *

.!

'

"

,

!!

,!!  ' . !,!

( 

!

D,

'*6

* ))*

!

'# *

!.,  ))* ( )**6 !!'

)!

*

3( *'

,   , , 1!! 



& !  '*6

  '6

* ))*

 ''

(

)*'

!'

!'!

* 

))* .. * ('



*

 ''

'

 ''

'* *!8#



))*

, '

 !6 ), !(

( 

))*

8



'*6 )! ,

 1('!1

* !6

* !(

!

)!,*! *  !' !.,'

.*.

)!6

, , ,

' ))*

8



'*6

,)) !

( !., *

!* ,)

2,'. ! '!'

     *9       !   +

%0   +  '(

,)   8% $+%

+ - $%#%$ !    8   : !4 '( );8% $+%

+,(  $  3     74"7$   '( ()8% $ +%

+,  $

(!'

* )!

(!

,.(  * 2,'. !*'

,)

3( * 1!

,!# 1(* '!

(*'

),.

 $$$ %&/ 1!

.# **.*# ! !!6 * ' '# (! !#  ' 

$ (*'

!

) 

,(# !! (!

!

!!

)!6 3(  ' .

* 1!

,! 1! !'

))* ! ))** ,!

 # ),.

 $$$ %&/ (** .'

, !

.!

'

),.

 $$$ %&/#  *'

(*'

7  !



44

$

 $ "<#

*'

!,  

.

(7

)6

*,

!>'

,*' . *'

* ) *6 !,*'

'#  !6

 # ),* 

(*'

!, *  ,! , 2'

!,)

!

!, #



),.





'

% #

"

' ,!'

!()# 6 F 

  

 

            



              

         

=

)! #

*'

(* 

!

''*6# (6

) 

 1(

6

  *, ,**

!

! !

** , !   )!



'

% #

,

!

  *

(!

(!

1!

 #



('

*6

,) 6 !.( 3( *6 (!

*



%&

&! !

4 !* ; .!

B  #

'

* '* !'

,!

( *'!7 !.(

  3( !*'

,)



  $ !8# )!

)!!6 !.(

'

 !6



** )!

&'

! 1! ! !!'

@!6 )!!6 !.(

-

!'

!)

&'

! 1! ! !!'

'

! # , 2

'

 (! :)

1



  $ !8 *!

 $ !8-#

*,

$

%&! !

4 !* ; .!

%& ( *'!

,) 6 !.(



* '* !'





@!6 # ( 1 !# !

 %&

1!

.



"$84  .$  * ,7 ,'6)  <$%9   = + >    *  !$6&4  4 '?)  (*'

!



%&! !

4 !* ; ' .!



!*'

,)



** ( ,  * '(!. ,!'

*



 

!

),.

!,)

 $$$ %&/

!

'# .!

' ,  ( .

),!) # !>'

!,

!

)* ! 1(!#





','

!'

7

!

'

(!

,!

6 !) !

,)) ! (!   !.!' '

''

!8# !*'

!

'# !

**

!. *



','

!' A,!(!#

*!

!, #



 8 % % $      - =  ( ') ( )& ,! (*'

**.'

'

' !

'), ('

!'



  *

' '

8

1*'. *

# 1(

!)'*6 ! (6

!

* '  !

6 ''

"$B %&/ 9%&/G9

!* ),!('

A* ! 4!,'# (!

/* ! !

** , !  (   *,

, ( '! !

' *,'



' 

(*'

!

'

7 !

(!

'(# (!2 C'

 .(    *,

'

 ) 



2,'.  " $< %&/G9 '! %&/G9 A,!(!# !

& 

G

E 0(.1

1 

 ,)) ! 

1(!

( 

''

&

*!

!8-# @!6 

) 1!

!,)

(

7 ''

(H ( ''

'

7    ''

!.!' 0, .*

H

,(

!'!

)*'

!'

@!6

1(! 6# @!6

('

!'!'

% !#  * ''!

!, )!6 3(!

  * *

!'

,    44

 $ "< ,*.'

 '! 

0 .* !6# *

' ))* *  * -

 * -



0 .* !6 ?

( !, #

*'

 *(

!'

 

(6

!

# !., ''! *

  * ))* * *

''

B 3(! *

))*

8



'*6

 '6

* ))*# !

.*6

' 3( 8



'

'*6

.!



!'!



) !6 ('

'!'

* !.,*!



))* ( ),!) # * ''

'* *!8

*6 E 0(.1 1(

,**6 !!'



',

' .

!

,.(

1*'.

) !6 (  

*.( 1(

, D, , 

*6 ,!  .(

!(   *

!!'

))*

)! ')! * ' .

'

.  '

'* *!8

*6 E 0(.1

,



 "

( G(* !! ( # *'

'*6

* ))*

 

*

 *'

)! )* 



;

# * .(

'*6

!# ) *6

&)* 

*6 !! ,*

*



'!

!.(

)!

  3(



'*6 !

'!

,!



'#

))*

8



'*6#

! , !

'# ( 1 !# (!

, )) ''

( ))*

,)) ! ( !  3(!

!'!



)'

) !6 * *

!'# 1(! 6#

 6

!'!'

..' A,!(!# (!

, * *

!'

1  * ''

'* *!8

*6 E 0(.1

1(

( ,)!

,'

!

!

 *!*6#

,

','

!'

1(

,!  .( ; -*!8

)*

'

E 0(.1

!(   ;81#

,

','

1( ')! * ' .

'

.  '

E 0(.1

1((!

,

( 3(!

*6 *'

!

'

))*

, , !6

,)) ! (!   *'

! ' 

)'

)* !,( 3( ,!

'!'

)

(# ( !, #

, , '

,

'*6 0,

( !

2,'. ! '!'

)& ,!



 !

 " # $%

& ./0%  10  &% 20&  3  %$%4$'5)6&7*'% ) !*'

,)

* 

))*'

),*!

 !, 

   !' .*6# (!

, , '

,

'*6

 '6

* ))*

<

1

# ( ,!  '

**.*6

)!

!6

 B

,!!  ' .

!''

,! * 1  ,(#

D,

*1 !D,! '! 

!

( !.,*!



))* *'

' '

! A,!(!#

, , '

,

'*6# ))*

8



'*6

* ))*  ' *

''



'

 

  !" #$%&'(       G((!

)8 .9!

C9

G((!

!) ! * C9