Kala Devi v. Balbir Dass & ORS










 





 






 








 

 




 







 


   


   !"
#$%& "
"'

&%%!  


 !"  "##$$" 
"% & #" !" #  '
"'

&%%!(# & "$$(  # "##"$ " )

!  "("

 *+ (," !#" )- &+.

)-+  !$"" ""##$$"/#$"

 *  .  * #  +  ##- ,  "

0 )-""

$ (*+ (,"

1

 234#" &

$+ 

'/ 2

 234" $   '3  3

.

$  #," *+! "

" 4 ,"$ " ( ##-."

,  )-  "$&+

*+ (," 3



"!",)

, "##"$)- 

"$5  !6+ (7" (" "

) "$" 5  .

  8"$    ( "+(   *" 5"  ""

*+ (," 1

 234# ," $-

$$.

((+ 9


*"5" :!+ "- " + *"
","  " ", +$ + +

$+!" )

(




*"5"

.

+#

" ."

, +

$

 ," # , $"  "  
 ", $-$,%#$"!). "  #$"

 "  *"
", ! " # .  "  

.

*"5" 1
7" 

 "##" &+"

("("- !+$"

 !$"

,

# . !$$+ " !" "- " + # / "" ", (  "#$". & "$$( "   '3  3

." # .

"$$("  "
"," 0 " "$+!$

)$ "

+,)" ." "# (

!  "- !+,   "  " +   8"$)  5" 0

"  +$ $ ")$)"

 5 " 

 .  ", "  "

 $" 

#).

 *"5")+ ,"

"$$("     )"  .

  #$"

 !

"$$( ! " *+ (, 1

 234" "   3

 5 "    ' "  4

 *  .  ", !  (   "$$("   ""

$   "

"

!+,   $,

 /  " + $"  )"  "+"$ +!!  *"5"   "$ &+

",

$$.

+



, " 9




;

    #$"

  $  !$""  " #"- <


;

  *+ (," 1

 234

$$("$+$$"  

< 
;

    #$"

  $  #,"

*+! "#"- < 1
;

  ,"

"

")$<5 '
;

 

"!"+ "! 

$ + <5 ' ;

  "   '3  3

$$("$+$$"  

$ ")$)"

< 4

$   " )  ! )     "$ &+

,   +  "  ##$$" &+ "

,

(    "$ &+ .

+ " "! &+$  "##$$".+$ $- , ""##"$

)-   "##$$"  $    ""!%  1

 234 "  $,   "##$$"  /   "  +  ##- ) +!!   *"5" &+$    "##$$" " ""

1

 234 # ," $- )- ,"% (   +),   =  "(+  # ++ 

'/ 2

 234 ." !" .

"." "+ ", $-$,). "  "##$$" " " 4 "

"! ") "$ .  ",

#$ = + "(+ "+ ."  + 

2

 234  . ",."#+# $-

)- *"

5" 1

 234"  ", - "- ." ! .

!

!""+# !

>+"!! 1

 234 +), ,"

)-!+$  " 4

 " "- "!  $"  :  " *"5"# 

1

 234."#"  "

!!" $

$  ."   (   7 

 #+#  ! " ) ,"

  *+ (,   ?@)$   +#, &+ 

  

!"
#
$ 
!%&
'()'*
#+
"%

,*-."  *+ (,

&+
"/
$ 

0/
1&
'((*'


1%
')'" 2 !
$ 
3+/&
'((4)

1%
*.. &+$ # (   #     !"- " +## !!+

(! )- &+(" (#$" "##$$"  1

 234 +

 )-   *" 5"

" + " 4+

,"-$("$ $".,+!

$)  +$   "  + + $+! &+$ .+$  "(+  "! $ !

 !:", "  "##$$"0"$"5 +* "+0 ;

", "+

!

#  " "##$$"

"##"!

 &+ .

 !$" "  "  !"  )"  +# "$    ? .+$ + " " +"

 !" .

("  ) ()" )-$ " ""

$ !" *+ (,

1

 234 "  ", " ) ".  "("

   "##$$" )+ !+$  "##$$" ","

"-+), ""

$

(  &+

"$"#! ," = "  " !+$  #" #+ #"#9)% " ! 

'

 "##$$"/#$"

"##" .

):+##

 !   1

 234    +$  #" != !:", "  .+$ " "

%. "*"5""##"

$. ",

%. "*"5"+

"!! !+* "+;9 "$ ,"

"$ "

 #*+

!

"$    !"+   "##$$" " 

# " ."#.

*"5":!+ !=." !! !."+

)-*"5" -" 234"$" 5  ." "$ # .

 .

  ! ." +

 )- *" 5"  !."+

-+   +"4/3 5!!", :

!"

 "  *"5")+ - !, )- )+   !    "

"

"! $ !

  ! :", "  ," "$.

:",  )- "##$$"$"

"

  )$!!$+  ""$"5 %.")+ ! ! ." +

)- *"5")+ ",."!

"$$( )-

$ (

 -"

      !$" 

!  !  "  .

   *" 5" #"  "."-  ?.  .  "! $ !

  ! :", "  .

 !")  " *"5"

, , 2 2/2  *"5" !

"$$( !!

+

$

 , "##$$"

!

"$$( , "

-""

 "  *"5"  "!("$(."- . "+

)- "##$$"/#$"

)" +#!! "!

 #$"     +$    , #"  .$$9 )"  

"#" #$""

 )- "##$$"  "*" 5"

.

+#

"    " " # ,

 $"   ) "+(  &+$    "##$$"  #  " >+- .+$ $- !!   "     

! "

+!  )-  "##$$" #! *"5"

(.

 ."  !)-

"+(  !"- ")#  ! " ! "##$$"# , ," "(" "( 4.

8"$    ( 

 $$"(8 #+""("

.

 *"5" ."  "##-.

/"##$$"   "##$$" , ")$-   #   " 

,#+(    +$   , #"   ,#"  !  , "! !."#"  ", - "-.

"

 .  ", ."

# "!   +

!

  "!!# !  "##$$"   "$ " "$ " >+  ) "

" #  "% "! "$!

"( &+$  "##$$" " # +

 "-," "$ ")$ ",

"!$"

, "- #  ##-"  !$"

(  +( " *"5" ! *"5" "

 " +.

("  ", $-$,"   !$"

,   # / "    4  # + $ ("  #  "##$$"!

"$$( "  ."  ", $-$,).*"5"" " 4

 $ ( ." ( = *"5"

,$ !+$   ,#+(   ."   (  . !"  "##$$"/#$"

 !$"

(  +(    *" 5" " "- +!

! 

"#""! #! +)*!," +

  >+  (  = 

 !:  ! !" ) ,"

  *+ (,   ?A)$   +#, &+0
1
/
0!"

$ 



/
/0!"&
'((*,

1%
-(-.

") $ #""

>+ +9 B

; "$$.:",  !

8 # ( C
",  (  =
 224 & 24 ;

" ."  $  ."" !)" "

= ) !" ."" ! "!"   ! >+ #""("#  "*+ (,." 

! D=  "" !$""- #! ##-  + +$$- "

"

(  #$"

 

! "

.

$$) . # , "- $ + ""



"  "  #$"

 

 ",  )

!#" "+!

 +#"# ("

" +

"("

 "EEF    ." " !"     ) ( !"  )- 

 

  , +$ %  # !" = #""("#  6+ (, " " &+,+ >+  .

  " !+, " !  +>+"$

 " +!

"$ .    # ,       $ "

 ##-"

!+,: (+       "  %  !        >+  (  8+ .

 #!  ,+ ) #   +  " "

!  "&+ >+ (

)" "!,#,  (+ "!$"+)" ! ! 3 
( !"""! G "

!"!,#,  >+ (



"% ##-  +)*!," 

!  "&+ ,"$$-)

( .

 "#"  +$  .)-! 11 G

!! " ", .

+*+

! 

)- !$$+  " 

")$"- (+ %.$".8+ .

 #" "  ( ( )-   #$"

 $"(+"(  ! 3
( !#" !+$"$- !: +)9!$"+   +)9!   )"!%(+  $( $"

-

 !" ) "

" " ! )"   "

 >+  (    "!  " !"    "   H

# #!     )"    ."  !   "!"  $ 

 ,= ) + ."" ""!"!, (+ ! 3 " ! +( !# ! 3   !."

!+ "

$8+ "!

!"". " 

!"  "  " +  )-   !+   " !"   "

!!" 

 ,"  $  ##$"

)  # "!".

 - . #+ ."  +  "   )"   " "$ ""!  $ >+ , ", $-""(,)- .

!

- "!>+   ##-!

+$  " #$"

 &$"$-! 3 "   ""!  =

 (    "   H

# .

  *+ (,  8 #  ( ,$ 

 (+

!

  
00"/
$ 
$
!"5
$/6

"
/
"


7)88*
'
 
'*)9 )"  !" 8 # ( ."#9:

 (  ## ).   #"  )+ "   ." +(  ) !"  

  , +    !,#,    H

##!  $ "!".



 )"

  " ""!

, )  *+ (,  !"

##  "

## .+$ )!,+)*!," " "!,#,  !$" ( ##  !",.

:!# ! 3   !" +!

"!,#, 

>+ ( $- )!"+  " " +  .  ",  ""(,#$"

)-

!+$  ) $ ")- "#$"

(" .") (!" #$"

" " !)" +!

""

#$"

.+$ >+ (  H

#."

"

!

8 # ( +#" !$"$-

 (+ ")$

"!"  ! !"("

""$$ !+ "  +

."""#" " ", $-""(, " "  "$  +  $ >+

 " +  # #$"

 "

 )  "  +!

 " ", $- ""(, ") $   8 # ( +#" >+ ( F  $"$-?@)$ +#,&+  !/
/2!
$ 
:""
/2!
/
0!"

&
1%
;;%
0888)
0<
)88=&
 
0/
-)(.'(() " $ " " ! ! #"  )-   &+   >+  )(  +  #  =

"
( !

5

8!



&+ 5"1
:5"
/
/0!"
$ 
>!"
/2!
/
0!"

&
)848'

,88 " $ " " !,#,   !   >+  (   

!" $ #! ,, ")$##-  "$+ 


/9 , #

 +)*! ,"   +   7+ $ " " !,#, ! !!")("

 (+ .

!

"!"!!")"

",$-

)"

 )-I , 9 #" @  I!!

@ .

 " "

"$ (+ " +  # ++ , $ " #!: = .   ")  !  "

  )-   "##$$"  ""

$ ." ( ,  +" "!!

($- *!  ") (= 

"-"   !!+

(! )- &+ 7 ( ("

(,  "##"$ $ " "!!

($-

,  $"

( #" )" .!
  
''&
'('(









 :
>#
I5J+$" @

















 
;

 #"% (/"  -/ ;

 #")$  -/