High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1129/2016dismissed

Manmohan Singh And ANR v. Tarsem Lal And ORS

2016-08-03Mr. Justice Amol Rattan Singh3 pages

!" #"$%&%'()* '+, '%'-, '# '!,".

//"00 '!& 1".&2& .&"+3 0 '#!,".& "&/'#"'!& ( 4 3 3 ."&"'!( . +"&,, .+ 5#1$ !"5

.!," //"00 '!& 35 . 0 ,%&%&!,"&"$'# //" 0 !,"#"

"'# '!& !".!,"&2%! %0"# 67."&/'#"'!,"."%'/0 %'!%

&""8%'-/&&"&&%' ,2&""!$5 & #"&$.%6"#%'!,"," #'!" !,"92#-+"'! !,"0" .'"###%!%' 0%1%0

2#-"5: &#"$.""#%',%& 12. '#!," %.&! //" 0 %0"#67!,"/."&"'!

//"00 '!&5 - %'&! !, ! 92#-+"'! '# #"$.""5 : & #%&+%&&"# 67 !,"

" .'"# ##%!%' 0 %&!.%$! 2#-"5 0 '#, .5 1%#" !," %+/2-'"# 92#-+"'!& '##"$.""& 3" .'"#$2'&"0 .!," //"00 '!&, & .-2"#!, !!,"$ &"&"! 2/67!,"."&/'#"'!;/0 %'!%

%'!,"&2%! %0"# ./&&"&&%'2! :,%$, !,%&&"$'# //" 0 .%&"&5: &!, !5/2.&2 '!!!,".#". ."1"'2"

2.!5: .. '!& /&&"&&%'5 !"."9"$!+"'!, #6""'.#"."#5:"."%&&2"# %' 12. ."&/'#"'!;/0 %'!%

'#!, !,", # $!2 007! 8"'

/&&"&&%'5 !".:,%$,!,"/."&"'! //"00 '!&#"

"'# '!&."/&&"&&"#!,"

&2%!/./".!7 .$%607 ) "&26+%!&!, !5 & + !!". $!5!,".": &'/. !,"

: .. '!&"1"., 1%'-6""'"<"$2!"# '#!,"0" .'"#2.!&6"0:5&%+/07 ' $$2'! !,": .. '!&, 1%'-6""'%&&2"#5/."&2+"#!, !!,"7, #6""' "<"$2!"# '#!, !!,"."

!".!,"."&/'#"'!;/0 %'!%

, #6""'#%&/&&"&&"# 67!," //"00 '!&50" #%'-!!," %0%'- !,"&2%!52! :,%$,!,%& //" 0 .%&"& = %.&!075 $2.&"5%!%&&""'!, !!,"0" .'"#2.!&6"0:, 1" /."&2+"#$.."$!07!, !/&&"&&%': &! 8"' .+!," //"00 '!&67!,"

."&/'#"'!;/0 %'!%

5/2.&2 '!!!,": .. '!& /&&"&&%'%&&2"#5 !".

"9"$!+"'!/.$""#%'-& %0"#6"

."!,&"2.!& !! %'"# %' 0%!72/!!,"

2!,.%!7 !,"%' '$% 0++%&&%'".,%&%&&6"$ 2&" !," $!!, !

!,".": &!,".:%&"'." &' .!,"."&/'#"'!;/0 %'!%

!, 1" %0"# $%1%0&2%! .! 8%'-/&&"&&%' - %'5:,"' 00!, !,", #!#: &!&""8 "<"$2!%' !,": .. '!& /&&"&&%'%&&2"#%',%& 12. > "$'#075%!%& ' #+%!!"# $!!, !!,"&2%!/./".!7$'&%&!&

."&%#"'!% 0,2&"' -.%$20!2. 00 '# '#%&&,:' & ''; -.%$20!2. 0%'!,"."1"'2"."$.#&"'$"5"1"'% %!%&/."&2+"#5 .!,"

& 8" /."&2+/!%'5 !, ! !," ."&/'#"'!;/0 %'!%

$!2 007 '"1". !8 /&&"&&%'%'!," %.&!/0 $"5 !,"&2%!/./".!75/2.&2 '!!!,": .. '!&

/&&"&&%'%&&2"#%',%& 12.5 0" .'"#$2'&"0, &'!6""' 60"! $2'!".!,"?2".7/2!!,%+5 &!,".": &'1 0%#$2'!".!!, !5!, ! 2'#26!"#07!,"&2%!/./".!7%&:'"#67!,"."&/'#"'!;/0 %'!%

2.!,".5!, !!,".#". !,"%' '$% 0++%&&%'".5.#".%'-"9"$!+"'!

) !," //"00 '!&5 : & '"1". "1".$, 00"'-"# '# , # 6"$+" %' 0 "1%#"'$":%!,."- .#! '7."'!/ %#67!," //"00 '!&!!,"."&/'#"'!; /0 %'!%

: &0"#6"

."!,"2.!&6"0:%'!,"/."&"'!0%&@ - %'61%2&07 6"$ 2&"%'!,"!,".0%&6"

."!,"."1"'2"2.!&5&2$,"1%#"'$", #6""' 0"#57"!0" #%'-! '.#". "9"$!+"'!5 &!,""1%#"'$":%!,."- .#!."'! '!, 1%'-6""'/ %#5: & $$"/!"#

"'$"5 '$" !,&" .#".& , # 6"$+" %' 0 '# !," &2%!

/./".!75%' '7$ &"5: &%'!,":'".&,%/ !,"."&/'#"'!;/0 %'!%

5&""

'." &':,7!,"&2%! ./&&"&&%'%' 12. !,"."&/'#"'!;/0 %'!%

:20#'!!,".:%&", 1"6""'#"$.""#5!,".", 1%'-6""''/0"

#1".&"/&&"&&%'"1"., 1%'-6""'&"!2/5%' '7$ &" A B%!,!," ."& %#6&".1 !%'&5 %'#%'-'+".%!%'!,"/."&"'!

//" 05!,"& +"%&#%&+%&&"#%' 562!:%!,'.#". &!$&!& )

*; * '1%": !," $!!, !!," //" 0, &6""'#%&+%&&"#5

& 61"5!,"?2"&!%' $'#' !%' !,"#"0 7 )# 7&%' %0%'- !," //" 0%&."'#"."# $ #"+%$ '#%&'!-'"%'! )*

/8C'%!%'

B,"!,".&/" 8%'-C." &'"#

"&C B,"!,"."/.! 60"

"&C