High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1154/2016dismissed

State Of Haryana Through Collector Fatehabad And ORS v. Smt. Krishna

2016-03-15Mrs Justice Sabina3 pages

!"# $#%&'&()!*%+ !"# $#%&'&()!*%+ !"# $#%&'&()!*%+ !"# $#%&'&()!*%+ ,

"!"# !*-!(!!($"+#*'

..#//!("'

0#*'1'

2"3*&'+(!

#'.($#("

) ) ) ) 4 5 4 5 4 5 4 5

*#'#(")

*#'#(") *3!66!$,!*-!(! 77777 77777 77777 77777 ,

, #'.($#("+!$ &/#$'1&" *$#%/!*!"&(%+!//#(8&(8 "+#*$#*$!"#$

.!''#$9-$# #($!(" ,:+#*#9-, +#*'#*;&%#':#*#$&'.#('#$:&"+(+#*!//#8#$%2./#"&( -#!*' !8# +#%!'# "+#*#'.($#("<./!&("&

,&(9*&# ,:!'"+!"

'+# :!' !..&("#$ !' !( (8:!(:!*& +#/.#* ( ==> 1($#*"+#'1.#*;&'&( $# #($!(" #'.($#("<./!&("&

:!'&( *2#$9-$# #($!(">;#*9!//-"+!"+#*'#*;&%#'+!$ 9##( $&'.#('#$ :&"+ #

#%" *2

#'.($#("< ./!&("&

+!$ !/' (" 9##( .!&$ :!8#' *2 !(1!*-

(:!*$'#'.($#("<./!&("&

'#*;#$!("&%#$!"#$>

("+#$# #($!("'!($'+#:!'&( *2#$"+!"$# #($!("

+!$.!''#$!(*$#*( ?

$&'.#('&(8:&"+"+#'#*;&%#'

*#'.($#("<./!&("&

(+#*!""!&(&(8"+#!8# -#!*' # #($!("'&("+#&*:*&""#('"!"#2#("!;#**#$"+!""+# '#*;&%#' "+#*#'.($#("<./!&("&

+!$9##($&'.#('#$:&"+!'

'+#+!$!""!&(#$"+#!8# -#!*' ("+&'*#8!*$,2#$&%!/ #@!2&(!"&(:!'%($1%"#$9-2#$&%!/

&%#*!/(8:&"+"+#* %22&""##2#29#*'

("+#./#!$&(8' "+#.!*"&#', //:&(8&''1#':#*#

*!2#$9-"+#"*&!/1*")< A B+#"+#* "+# *$#* 9#!*&(8 ($'" $"

,.!''#$9-$# #($!("( !//#8#$/-( $" ?

, &' :*(8, !8!&('" !%"', !8!&('"

.*&(%&./#' (!"1*!/ C1'"&%# !($ /&!9/# " 9# '#"< !'&$#D

&''1# ( &' .*;#$, :+#"+#* "+# ./!&("&

#("&"/#$ * "+# *#/&# 2!($!"*- &(C1(%"&( !'

.*!-#$ *D

> B+#"+#*"+#./!&("&

+!'(%!1'# !%"&(*/%1'

'"!($&" &/#"+#.*#'#("'1&"D

B+#"+#* "+# C1*&'$&%"&( %&;&/ 1*" &'

9!**#$D

#/&# E

!*"&#'/#$"+#&*#;&$#(%#&('1..*" "+#&**#'.#%"&;# ./#!' *&!/ 1*" ;&$# C1$82#("F$#%*## $!"#$ >

$#%*##$"+#'1&" &/#$ 9-"+#./!&("&

<*#'.($#(" *&!/1*"

:+&/# $#%*##&(8 "+# '1&" "+# ./!&("&

<*#'.($#(" +#/$ !'

1($#*)< A'!'#G1#/"2- &($&(8'!**&;#$!":+&/#$#%&$&(8 &''1#' ( !($ , "+# '1&" "+# ./!&("&

&' $#%*##$, :&"+1"!(-*$#*!'"%'"',1($#**$#*?1/#? , 8*!("&(8!2!($!"*-&(C1(%"&(&(+#* !;1*,!8!&('""+# $# #($!("'"8#"%($1%"#$!(''& &%!"&("#'"*!*!$&< /8&%!/ "#'", !' !../&%!9/# &( "+# 8&;#( %&*%12'"!(%#', :&"+&(!.#*&$ "+*##2("+', *2"+##;#($!"# * $#"#*2&(&(8"+#!..*@&2!"#!8# ./!&("&

!($&(%!'# "+#!8# ./!&("&

%2#'1""9#9#/: -#!*',"+# $# #($!("'!*#$&*#%"#$""!6#! *#'+$#%&'&(*#8!*$&(8 +#**#"&*#2#("(%!'#,!

"#*"+#!8#$#"#*2&(!"&("#'", "+#!8# ./!&("&

%2#'1""9#9#/: -#!*',"+# &2.18(#$*$#*<'+!//'"!($!1"2!"&%!//-'#"<!'&$#!($ "+#./!&("&

'+!//9#/&!9/#"9#*#&('"!"#$&(+#*'#*;&%#' !' (8!(:!$& #/.#*, !/(8 :&"+ !// !;!&/!9/# 9#(# &"'

> :*(8/- :&"+$*!:( &( %('#G1#(%# *$#*< #%*##< '+##"9#$*!:(!%%*$&(8/-E ..#!/ &/#$9-"+#$# #($!("'<!..#//!("'!8!&('""+# C1$82#("F$#%*##.!''#$9-"+#"*&!/1*":!'$&'2&''#$9-"+# &*'" ..#//!"# 1*" ;&$# C1$82#("F$#%*## $!"#$

#(%#,"+#.*#'#("!..#!/9-"+#$# #($!("'<!..#//!("' +!;#+#!*$ /#!*(#$ "!"#%1('#/!($+!;#8(# "+*18+"+#*#%*$!;!&/!9/#("+# &/#%!*# 1//- +#1*"'9#/:!

"#*!..*#%&!"&(8"+##;&$#(%#/#!$ 9-"+#.!*"&#'(*#%*$+!;#+#/$"+!""+#*#&'($%12#("!*- .* G1!"+#!8# "+#*#'.($#("<./!&("&

+1',"+#(/- ."&(!;!&/!9/#:&"+"+#!..#//!("'<$# #($!("':!'"8#""+# *#'.($#("<./!&("&

2#$&%!//-#@!2&(#$ *!''#''2#(" +#* !8#+#1*"'9#/:+!;#+#/$"+!""+#*#:!'(2!"#*&!/( *#%*$ " #'"!9/&'+ "+!" "+# *#'.($#("<./!&("&

+!$ 9##( #@!2&(#$9-"+#2#$&%!/9!*$ **#/#;!(""#'"' *!''#''2#("

+#*!8#("+#'#%&*%12'"!(%#',"+#/#!*(#$"*&!/1*"*&8+"/- $&*#%"#$"+#!..#//!("'<$# #($!("'"8#""+#*#'.($#("<./!&("&

2#$&%!//-#@!2&(#$ *!''#''2#(" +#*!8#!($"+#*#!

"#*, "!6#! *#'+$#%&'&(*#8!*$&(8+#**#"&*#2#(" '19'"!("&!/ G1#'"&( /!: !*&'#' &( "+&' %!'# :!**!("&(8&("#* #*#(%#9-"+&'1*" &'2&''#$ !*%+ ,

!*%+ ,

2!+!;&*