Life Insurance Corp Of India And ANR v. Chanda Rani And Others
!"!
#$%&%
'$ ()'
% *+ *% ,,,,, ! "# $!"%$"&
'(")$ !
" """!"%$"&
'(" *$ +++++ + *% -%. /01 $"%%, $ ) $ )" -.-. / 01 2
34 $ 5" 6
"%" /13%(
",1)$34$"
%("*% 34$
* ," * 1"( 3* "((1 * "$ * !"
" 7 "%$"
3"%%) ""51*
-&--&---8 $"
3 3 "%,)$ 9:;"%,)$""
"%"51*
<&---8 )"
1 %*
-2- =*%4 155"> $*"( *$ ("
"$"!"
" 7 "%&)$)"
$$"
*$*"5%4*$
&$"
-)"
"% ""1$> ",*$ * 1"( "" )"
" "5 3,"
553*$ 1"(5 "4" )"
1 1 71 1"(!"
%(4 ?--@?<< * " 15 *
-&--&---8 $ 1"( 5 "41 1(
A@A-8 "15)"
$ 515*$ 5"
%(4 *5 $ (55
8(' 1 " ", %% $ B1
515 "51 )
1%4
1( *5 55
8(' * !"
" 7 "%& $)'&
$ "5& $ 3* )%"
$
"(( "(*$(%"5 )"
(%"5 $"'3*5 $"$4"-& 515 *"%% (", *3,"
553 )' ""51*
.&?@8 (%1 , 7 3("5 "4"3% "
515 * 553 * $ "5 3,"
",
A@A-8 )"
"%"
4 1( 34$ 1"( 5 "4*5$(' *$ 1 :-.-&$)'& ( $"* 515)"
' ' % --&$(&"%%$ 3,"
553 &)$$"
"'"% $*"(%4*,1 1"(' $ "3'5 %(4)5" $3"%"( 515"
$' " ($B1*$ **"%"51*
@A@8 & *"'1** "&)"
34%"!"
"7 "%&$)'&$ "5 )"
1 $1 ' 55 -- 1 "
* C 1**(*1
D5"*$ "5)"
"% ,'$ 1 " $,"%($B1)"
$" '$5)$"B1 $
-33"%"( 515"51$1,$("
$"$"% &$)'&$
"5 )"
)$ $ 0 " $" $ 5")$%& $ - $ (55
8(' * $
("
*$5$*(3&-)"
%" "
1($ 1( "% (1% 35"
*5$(55
8('*$",(&$
%(4 1''"
$ "$1 &$3* (1% 3 %"
$ ** * "5("3% %5 *"% & " "
#1 (" )"
1 "6 34 $ 5" 6
"%" /13%(
",1$ " % $
('' (" 1 ( "* $'"%( &$5"6
"%""%%) $"
%(""
( $ 1"(5 "4%"
$ 1 "51*
&-&--&---8 $
"
)$" *)5$ *5 $ " * ( * (* ( 4 * $ #1 ,58 )" & *"%, )$($ $
"
) $% % 9 :; "15$ "%% "%>"(&$ ) . " 1 % "
", 3$"%* * $ $"
'$5%4",1 $"$5"6
"%"/13%(
",1*"% "
("$"$($B1
34$ 1 ",* **"% "51 *
@A@8 *"'1 * * "
$1 "((1*C 1**(*1
D" "
1($$("(* * 1"(("
0 "
$ "* "$*$", ($
*("51)"
(&$(%"5)"
,$%4 "
-4- < $"' $" %" 1 % "
", 3$"%* * $
" $"',$1,$$ (15 "'"%"3%( @ =* ( ,*1$$5"& %'"* $ "' " * $ ")"
34 $ 5" 6
"%" )$($ 0"( "
1
!
"
# $ %
&%''(
$
!
$
&
$
)
* $ +, - $ $ $
$
(./ 0
(1 2%& $
((( (- +, - " (
!0
$$
3 (((1
45!-6 7 $$
$$ 8 9 )$ )
:
; 45!-
- 4 (((1; +, -1 (( ( 11.'1'
,
$ (
-5-
)
$
)
$
$
$
<
!
) $
$ $
$ $
$ $$
$
) $
$ $
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
= ./
$
$$ $ >
-
$
'
$ $$
$?
7 $
@ A ' $" $ 5" 6
"%" /13%(
",1
(*("%%4( $"$' *$ 515)"
(" 1 34 $ 1"( 5 "4 (3& - " " % --)"
*(551(",$ 515"51"
.&?@8
$ % 0 & $ )"% 515 * 3,"
553 )"
3 1( *5 $ 3,"
"%%)"(8 "45 6 1 $"((1 .$="($ )('$3"%"(
515"
' "/ 51531 **2*5553* ,( $ "((1$($B1(%"5 $"'
-63
)$
($ **"%"51)"
"%%, %41 34 $="6* 1**((4**1
$
8"
$"
%"( ( $ "((1 "5 0 . $), $" "
--& $)"
"3"%"(*
.A&.:<8 $"((1* ("
!"
"7 "% )$($ 5" )"
(' *5 $ ",E ", * $ *"("% 4" $* (1% 3 $" $ (' (55
* ("
)"
%*$ 5$&"
$"
3(%"5 34 1"( 5 "4 ( $ )"
1**( "51 (55
8('"((1 *"'1*$ ("
5 *$ (551("0 &$ "5)"
3 1( *5$(55
"51& $(& $ 1"( 5 "4 )"
" *"1% )$$% , $ ($B1 * 3 5 $
"% ("3% $" ' * 515 " $"' "6 %"( --)$%$($B1 " $"'31 -- '$1,$ "%%, $" ("
!"
"7 "%)"
*5 *$
$& 31 1($ ' ( $"
3 31,$ ( -$5% 1,, $"$,"( $"
"(1"%%4 (5" ! &$("
1 34$ * 1"( " %* ("
( 34 $ ( 1( (%1 , $ "51 "'"%"3% $ "((1 "
-- ", ",(4 ",)$($)"
51($5$"$ **"% 515 : *1$$ % %")$"$5"6
"%"/13%( 2 3,1 34$ ( % *"1"% #1 (&B14&*"
&3#('4" $ ( % *#1 (($
-75" "*$ 1(
34$ 1"(5 "4)"
* 1( * $ "51 *5 $ (55
8(' 1 " ", " $"
3 )%% "3% $ *5 ' ( $" $ )"
1**((55
8(' 1$"((1* ("
","
")$$ 515)"
3 &$(&$ 1"( (5 "4 (1% $"' '4 )%% " * $ "51 $"((1 ."
$(551(" 34$5$%"
$1 &)"
$
"*$ 1 ? = & )"
" 3'% ($5 5" * $ "5 3,"
", &)$1B1," 1
1" ""($B1$
(*"(%"( $"((1*!"
"7 "%&'"*("
515"51& $) $"$ 1"((5 "4)"
* $ B1 "51 $ 5 31 *"% ("4 1 " " * 48"
#1 5
"
(*( **(
$ ," $ ( B1()$*("3*"
1 $
"
%("$ 5"6
"%" ,1 34$ ( % $ 1 ( * $ ,"% 1$ (& ?:A )$($ " ( % * "1"%#1 (&B14&3#('4&*"
$ ( % *#1 (* $ 0( * #1
(
, * $ ")" )%% ,1 34 $ "3' ( % & 1($"")" )1% 3 "%4* )$ - * $"$ (0( 34$5"6
"%" /13%( ",1 (" 3 3 5
%"( 5 ((' $ ")" (" "% 3 3 %%,"%& '
1**,*5,
5
("*%")*"(
-8- , 5 $ ) & $ "5 "(( ,%4 5
$
" $")" -.-.
%(" A@ --A- % "
C$" " " " $ ' * 1"( "* "" "$E34$5" 6
"%"/13%( ",1 1 $% .+ *% 1 * ' -
$0 F$$
"6,8"
$ G 8 F$$ "3% G 8