High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/28012/2019disposed of

Haramritpal Singh v. Punjab University Chandigarh And Others

2019-10-16Mr. Justice B.S. Walia8 pages

!" # $ % &'() *+"! ,- #.

!" # $%!%

/

$ /"&+0)

/

%) "%+0)

1 222 # $%!%& ' %( & 34

* " 5

" % 5

6%"

07% 811 6%*!"

!*() *7

* % : $ ;<< 95

+07% 8:

'*" $ "

&! "

'* "

+ 07% 8 )5""" 6% "

" " !"

+ 07% 8

" *% *=%

> !"

""' '*".! "() * 34 ?

"! "! "5 " "

" 7 ?

0!

%% % .

:"%'& @ "

!*A % :

:

= !+ "

0 *=%

> !" " "

%>") !"+5"

34 5 % " ?

0!

%% +5!"

5"" " 5 ! 5 % '* " <)!! '

' "

+ 5" % 5 '*"<)!! "* + 5"

5

' "

+ "

% %

" - " ! "

% + " 5"

5

*!

' "

"

>

*" " " <)!! 5) + "

! " + %* % 0 %

% % *!=%

> !" "'% !"

314 B"" 5% +07% 8 '*"0.! (/+ %&'+"! "

'

"

0

"

" % )

* 5 " !5"" +07% 807% 8 0 % "

+07% 8 )"

' %% 5"

"

5 %

"" "% !)! "" ;

% " " "

' %% " % ' "

"

5" !" % " ) % " *5 %5 5

!*'

"

" 7

" ) * ! 3C4 B"+

+ 07% 8+ "

'

"

" 5

"""" "

' "

>! %"

"

> " 5)

"% '

'*"<)!! ?+"

' "

5) %% !"7

314

!

%!

! 5 % '* " <)!! ") ' )

% ! " 7 B" + "

) +07% 811

!" " " % ! ! " " ' " " '6%

!*() *7

* /*+ +5 7 % .!% :

" &'() * $ ;<<9 3:4 B" "

+ 07% 8C '

" $"

+ &'() *+"! "'%" 5

&'*" $"

'*

!"

) %

" !

"() *)

:18(/ 1 5 % 34 B" " +

07% 8 5 " =%

> !" " '

! "

! /"

% C

! !

;C " &' * +$ <<+9 % % % + " %'

+ 07% 8 " .! + &' () *+ "! "

*!

'! "

! =%

> !" " " 5

%"

% %"

5 " "

% " "

%!" '

" 5 * %+ * =%

> !"

" " '

! * 5" "

"'5 %"

!"

! *() *7

*

B"

+07% 8 5

5'* +07% 8 '%" 5

&)

% +07% 8 !'* * ; >!

'* !""

) %

3C4 " !

5 %

.!% :

! !

; " &'() * $ ;<<9 394 = ) " "

%!

") ' 5"

%

5"

%

! *

%* " !

4 D %

'* *!%

" $ )**+ ,-). %/!0 1% 2 %3%

!2! 4&5%0!6%5%0 5& C :

1 "

'* " () * 5"

% !)! * 5"

% !

%* " ! !*%%' D % " %

" %052!0 #!65 2

3%

!2! 4&5%0!6%5& )++- .-+'

7( .)7 "

%% ;

"" #

$

% !

%

& '

$ ( &

(

3:4

% ) %

* $

+

'

$ ,

-" &+

.

/

( ( 0 1 1 ' ( 34 0 % " ) "

'

! "

% + *

) " " 5 @ ) "%'& "7 A'%" ! @ % ' A * " + " " 5 % ' % C % : " &' * +$ <<+9 34 -6% *

% 6%

! % '* " (/ !

% 1 &'() * $ ;<<9+ %

!

"

8() * * "

"

%"

07% 811 +"

!

>!

%"

% .!% : $ ;<< 9 "

" " * % .!% C: " &'() * $ ;<< 9

%% ; &)

$

34

$

" ./ 1

* ./

!* .

/

" 3 ! "

4

* '

$

4

$

$

$

$ ( 34 D %

"

8() * % " 5 > 5"" *" '

)

* /

"0

!

;

)% !" ) "

' "

" "5 34 0 % .!% C $ ;<<9 )" % '

% ) '%" %' " " )%*+ %" * ' '

!" % +5" % .!% :+ () *7 %

* 5"" ) " %'& " 7 + %" " ' 6%

! * () *

394 7

5 * +%!"5""" %!%* " "

7 " * +

7 +%!"5""" %!%*"

7 "5*

B"%+" '57

5 % C

: " << " &' $ ;<< 9 " )

"

%!" *' + '

! 5"""

!

'%" ' '

)+

" *

! %"

7

5 % : * $ ;<<+ 9+

! )'

") '

%

5"""

! %"

% .!% : % ") ' < " % + % )%E"* >

'*"%

! * %"

! 5"

! ")!

' "

!5"

5" 314

%'+" % % ' 5 % * % *

'* % %

' % 5 * 5) +" ' )" *0%"

>!

5"" 5 0"

%!"+ " % ") ' '* ! "

%!

! %"

5

" *% *=%

> !" "+*)5 " " "

! " ' 5""

%"

"'

+

" "

%"

* " !

" "' '* ! >!

4 5" 5 % " .!%

' 7 %*

'

'* 5" 5 5>

B"

%!

8 5

" " 5 % ' %'& " ' > '* " !

'

?

F%! "" >!8 G8

""

' G8