← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1184/2016disposed of

Partibha And Another v. Nandi Devi And ORS

2018-11-27Mrs. Justice Anita Chaudhry15 pages

    !      

 "#$ %$&'(')* +



,,$--")#(  



 $(,)%$)#( * ./ /0 /    











!"

 !!  











$  

 !

 %%%%%  

    ##!!  

& 

!! &  ' &"  !

) 

"  



*  # !" '  +



! 

#     *       , 

$!

##   -&  & 

!

&!



( &

 -& !"( 

( .

 ,  

!"

'$ / #



  0 ,  # & 

&

&

! " 

*



 #



#

! " 



! # 

 & ! "     



!

'

".

!

! 

!  1"



) 



23433

5 #

 

#

& 

"( 

 



1 



"

#



#

! ##!! 

634336

&  -

"

!

33332





3636337

, 

"

&  #"



 ! ##!!  " 1"



) 

8

#

 

63733

#

!!(



 9:

9:

9:

! ## " !( #

 ' 

" /6

  

" $  

 

!"

# #

334337

!  #

3434337

+

#

!

"&

!

"   

#





 &

"

!!(



 

&  , #

 





8



63733

# #" 

! !"



!!

 8"

## #"

1 ##  -&

!

#

!(



63733

<## !#( 

& ""



 8"

= ! 

!

,

+ 



# = ! 

 "

## 

8" 

#

33

8" 

#

* 



#



#

= ! 



 !!

8" 

!!

8" 

# !

"   (

"

"! 

     ,

5 



 ! ' &"  

  

! *"



4

"( = ! 



1"  

1"

!!

=

)



"

 #

! ## " (

&

& 

! 



8" 

1"



) 



& !!(



&  )

  $

 # "  

" ! ##

&

#

" $

#

 ' 



!"

# #

" ( /6



!!(  !

# !!

!!

#

! ## !"





( (

 



"



>

!!

  )

<

?37

#





&"  "  &



  -& ! &  &  (

!

#   

       

     

   

        

    



 







 

      

          

 

      

 !""! #         

           

  

     

  

   $      

     %   &    

  



   

 

  

     '  ( )   ( !*+   ,-".!""! / ( ,.   ,,,  ,,! $     ,+,,!",.0 +

! 



&  & ! 



!(

!

& "



  "

"!

8

& 

"

"!

(



 -& ! #"

 !

&!

8



&  & $!



!

!( !!

  !

 '

!

 -&

 &

## $ 0 

& ,

  !





 -& <##

"

2 ! 

&

0

?







 "

8 !!

   8

  

    !"#$ %%&'

1,2 

  

3      

  

 

  

 

45 65#   

 5 '

3 ,  

 

  

   



  0 '

3 !   

 

 

 

 0 '

3 )  

  

    0  '

3 * 7    0 '5# 

 

5 '

3 8  

 

0 1!2 # '

3 ,   

     



         ,9 ,.  .+    

       1)2 # '

3 *   

    

       12  1

   ,.     



   1*2 (          

  &





3 



  

    



   ()* %  %%&+! , &*-  ,'

12 12 



  

   89 :



      



      )!6; 



          



    

     

  



  < 12    

  

       

 

  

      



<  12 =  

         -!   

         

          

3    

   



    1!2 6 

3    

        

   





   

#  > 

 .    *- ,& &*"$/56    

3                 

    

       

   



  0 1*  ,2# , ! 5#  

   

3



    

       



  



3<       

   

  

    

    

 

    

  



 



          ,2      -#,  /     %%&  # ,  !  5 1,2 ?

  

   

    

      

     #

 # #

 ## #

 ###  #

 # 1!2 #

 #     



   

   

 

         

 



   '

3 (  , 1)2 #

 ##      

      !,   

   

 

 

#  > 





     

  1*2 #

 ###     



   

   

     

    '

3 (  ) 

           

     



  

 1  

2 



   

        



 182 #

 #     



   

   

 

         

    '

3 (  * 1-2 @ #

    

         

  

#  > 





 0 &

! 

$ 0 " 

&

##





+ -&





 

 "

"! /& 

!

&!



#

(

 -&

 !

@

 !! 

8!

"

&

  &   8( "  ! 

&

 & 

+

!

& / "

"! 8

   

!

&!

  ! 

,

# &

!( !

$ 0

 

!(

 8 

!



37

 ?4

$ 0 @

   !! !! 

 "

 !(

 

 & 

! 

#   #

#



!

!!

#

# 

>

!!

  ( 

( &    *   34$(#') 12

      3   



      

 

            

        

  ) !  A

72



" (

6

#  !"(



#  

(

6

 8

 34( -#/", & B   

 



  

 

 

% 

  @   ,5

  

 

      

      





  

 

          

  

 

   

          

 

  @   ! 

 



    



    



 

  

       

  

<  

     

 

 

     

  

 4.  & ,#/  ", &

   

   5 1,2            

 

   < 1!2    

 

        

   



      

       1)2    

 

  

< 1*2   



   

  

 



<   

  

  

    

   

   

 0 <

# 

6

!!

" 8

 !



 !  8

" ! (



 ! !"( &  ! 8 

 #

A

" #

( 72

<

# 8" 

# 

!"(

!! !"(

" # ! 

!

)

 !

"

8

 !  !"(



!(





5 &  !"(



(

"

8"

#"

&

+#   &  !   !!

&

!



!( 

!"(

!(



!"(





( 

!   "!

"

#

!  !"( 5

*

  

# !!  34$(#')

12

      

        

=3 C

   



    A

! 

4

 

"  (



#&(

 !

 

  " 

*

"!(

5 

 

&(

"  





#"

" "   

 !  !

&!

  !!

  !



!(  "!

# +





& 

# "(

!! #"



< 8

!

&



8" 





&  ,

&(

*

   

# !!  34$(#')1 12

 

        

 

      

%    &   

 





       

 

   

 

      

                  =      A

 

,/"

& 

 ! " 

5 

#

! "  



 " #



! " 

"( 

!

'

"

"



"

 *

!!( &

! "

) 

"(

 

! "  8

# !

&(

*

0   

# !!    8"



!  8

1"



) 



63733 !



 

A

! 8" 

## #

!

8





4

A

8

 45

% %2&*  %, &*- 6*, /$#+   #,'

#   

   &                            



 

 

 

  

        =  

 

%   

   :B                     



  

     

   

 

       

 

#   6 ,+". 1,-

,+".2   

   

    

   



        ;0 +

! 

"( = ! 

!!

,?

+

##   "

8"   #



8

#  







( &

5



1"







8!

 

# !

"

"!

 !  



1"

5 # 

 # ##  -&

 !

&!

$

&

"!

 & 

"

"!  

!  -&

5

# 

#

1"



 !  * 



 

!!

!  8







1"





"

 & !!(



& 

5 # 

#

#







!

5

& 8 (

&

"!

# 

& 



( !  

  " 

+

! 



  

+

8"   #

= ! 

## *"

A



 &

  !

 "

= ! 



 

&

!

 

 "

  

1"

! " 8

= ! 

!#( 

# ;  

 "

"! /& 



$

< ( !

&



1"  

"

"$

5 !

&!

! 

 !&

"   -&

8

5



"!

  8" ## " " = ! 

8" 



 

+



! 

# 

!"

# & !!( *

# #( "$ " 



 #

( *



"

*

$  

" 

+



= ! 

$

"  

(

" 

+

8"   #







8!

1"



#

 8" 

!( $!

 #

!!

8" 

# !

"   ( (  

#

#

 

!

"



!!(



$ 

#

 "

 @

 !

 #  "

"

 # !&  "$ # " !("

#

!

1  

 

" ! 

""

 

&#

"&& 



!

"

&

!("

#  $

 " !

"

#

8 &" 

 !

 ## &

" 

(



& 7?

7 ( "

= ! 

+ 



" (

&

&

! 

 #

!

&!

! 



!! ( &

5 



" "

#

" = ! 

&

& 

"$

 # @

 !



#  "

 ! ##

!!



 

!  #

" /6

 ( !

& 

5

#  "



&

1"



& 

" +





 "

 



!!



 

8" 

 

"



(



 8" 



 / 

#"

 " 

! 

8"   #

!#( 

" $ 8

#

 

 !

! 

5



8" 

  



#

"

 $   &



"$

##  (

,

&

8 &" 





 1"

( #

#

& 

#

5



 #

& 



"

&

##

 (/&#  "&

( 

!!( 

 !  



5

 

 







&

!!(

! #"

# #

# " 







& 

!!(

+





 



"







!!(



8 ,

+ # 

 







8!

"    +

 #



' &"  !

)  



#

 

5 

! ##

"(

"



 

1"  ( 

/0



!!( # 

1" "



" 

1"  +

 

 *

&  5







## ! ##!!    8 /0



!!(

!

 /0





#

/!

" 

 @ !( ' &" 

   )



) " "$

 #

 $ 0 " 

-& <## ! 

#

2  (

"

 & / "

"!

&   !

&!



!! !(   !

"  !!

#

 

!

 &( 



 &  &  =$ 0  !   &  !! ! /0 /

+

    

=  ,  !$ &/ B / ,  -!  B /