← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1193/2016dismissed

Resham Singh v. Narinder Singh And ORS

2016-05-13Mr. Justice Arun Palli7 pages

      

 !"# $#%&'&() *

 #'+!,&(-+ ..#//!("

0' !1&($#1&(-+!($"+#1'

#'.($#("'

)2 3 4 4

1#'#(")2 1!(,56."!7$8%!"#7 1"+#!..#//!("  9#1# #11#$""+##.1"#1'1(": #'

  ;+#"+#1"+#<6$-,#("'+6/$9#1#.1"#$&("+# &-#'":

 47 +&'&'"+#'#%($!..#!/ 95"+#./!&("&

7!

"#1+&''6&"

'##=&(-!$#%/!1!"&(7!'!/'.#1,!(#("!($,!($!"15&(<6(%"&( 1#'"1!&(&(-"+#$# 1,'"..&(-"+#'6../5>6'#

!  ?!"#1  #/#%"1&%&"5  ,"1  ?+&%+  ?!'  16((&(-  (  !(  #/#%"1&%&"5 %((#%"&(&("+#(!,# "+# &1'"$# #($!("7?!'$&',&''#$95"+# /#!1(#$&8&/ 6$-# 1&8(746$+&!(!7!($"+#!..#!/!-!&('""+!" <6$-,#("!($$#%1##?!'$&',&''#$95"+#/#!1(#$ &1'"!..#//!"# 61"  

1&# /57"+#./!&("&

3' !"+#17"+#/!"#@!1!,&(-+7?!'

?(#1&(.''#''&( ',#/!($(?+&%+"+##/#%"1&%,"1&( A6#'"&(  ?!'  &('"!//#$7  95 !(  #/#%"1&%&"5 %((#%"&( .18&$#$ 952 $# #($!(" 7&#"+# 6(<!9"!"#/#%"1&%&"5 !1$+#1#&(!

"#1



1# #11#$"!'3"+# !1$3   //#-#$/57"+#91"+#1

("&,./#!$#$&( "+#'6&"7+!$ 1-#$',#$%6,#("' +&' !"+#1!($B9"!&(#$!( &//#-!/.?#1 !""1(#5C&("+#(!,# (#!1<&($#1 !/&(-+ +##,!!($'/$!96"!%1#' /!($"$#

"+16-+1#-&'"#1#$'!/#$##$' +#'!&$'!/#$##$'!($.?#1

!""1(#5?#1#%+!//#(-#$95"+#!..#//!("2./!&("&

&(!("+#1%&8&/'6&"

"&"/#$!'#'+!,&(-+0'#8&($#1&(-+7?+&%+!""+#"&,# "+#

&/&(- "+#.1#'#("'6&""+#(#6" ?+&%+"+&''#%($!..#!/ !1&'#'7?!''"&//.#($&(- "?!' 61"+#1!//#-#$&("+#./!&(""+!"$# #($!("'

!($   ?#1#  &("#1 #1&(-  &(  "+#  ./!&("&

3'  6'#    "+#  #/#%"1&%&"5 %((#%"&(!($,"1!($"+#5+!$!/'&//#-!//5-"&""1!(' #11#$&( "+#&1(!,##(%#7"+#1#9#&(-(/5(##/#%"1&%,"1"&11&-!"#"+#

&#/$'&("+#.''#''&(

7+#'6-+""+!""+# &1'""? $# #($!("'9#1#'"1!&(#$ 1,'"..&(-+&'?!"#1'6../5 1,"+# !

1#'!&$,"1!($"69#?#// D .(("&%#&''6#$""+#,7"+# &1'""?$# #($!("' &/#$ "+#&1?1&""#('"!"#,#("&(?+&%+"+#1"+!("+#6'6!/.1#/&,&(!15 9<#%"&('7"+#5!/'"=!(9<#%"&(?&"+1#-!1$""+#'6&"9#&(- 9!11#$6($#11$#1 6/# "+#  (  ,#1&"'7  "+#5  ./#!$#$  "+!"  &(  !%"7  "+#  #("&1#  /!($ +/$&(- "+#/!"#@!1!,&(-++!$("9##(,#("&(#$&("+#./!&("7 !'+#?!'"+#?(#1 

=!(!/'!($,!1/!' /!($!($("<6'"



*@!(!/'!($ !1/!'-&8#(&("+#./!&(" "?!' 61"+#1!//#-#$"+!"&

'391"+#1+!$

!91&%!"#$!($ 1-#$',#$%6,#("'&("+#(!,# +&' !"+#17" '#//!96"*!%1#' /!($""+#$# #($!("'7"+# !"+#1@!1!,&(-+ +!8&(-1#,!&(#$!/&8# 1!96" 5#!1'!

"#1"+##E#%6"&( "+#'!/# $##$7?6/$+!8#%+!//#(-#$"+#'!,#7?+&%++#(#8#1$&$ * +#1#'.($#("2 !1$$# #($!(" &("+#%&8&/'6&" !/' &/#$&"'?1&""#('"!"#,#("$#(5&(-"+!""+##/#%"1&%&"5%((#%"&( &(A6#'"&(?!'&//#-!//5"1!('

#11#$71"+!"'6%+"1!('

#1?!'"9# $#%/!1#$(6//!($8&$  #./&%!"&('""+#?1&""#('"!"#,#("+!8&(-9##( &/#$7 "+#/#!1(#$&8&/ 6$-#746$+&!(!7 1!,#$"+# //?&(-&''6#') B ;+#"+#1"+#./!&("&

&'#("&"/#$"$#%1##

$#%/!1!"&(!'.1!5#$ 1:

;+#"+#1"+#./!&("&

&'#("&"/#$"$#%1##

.#1,!(#("  &(<6(%"&(  !($  ,!($!"15 &(<6(%"&(!'.1!5#$ 1:

;+#"+#1"+#./!&("&

&'-6&/"5 '6..1#''&(  ,!"#1&!/ !%"' 1,"+#61": 2 D ;+#"+#1  "+#  .1#'#("  '6&"  &'  9!11#$  6($#1 1$#116/#   : 2

* ;+#"+#1"+#.1#'#("'6&"&'9!11#$6($#11$#1

16/#  : 2

 ;+#"+#1  .1#'#("  '6&"  &'  9!$  1 ,6/"& !1&6'(#'': 27 F ;+#"+#1"+#'6&"+!'("9##(.1.#1/58!/6#$

1"+#.61.'# %61" ##!($<61&'$&%"&(:

D  2 G ;+#"+#1  "+#  '6&"  &'  9!$  1  ,&'2<&($#1  

(#%#''!15.!1"&#': ;+#"+#1"+#.1#'#("'6&"&'?&"+6"!(5%!6'#  !%"&(:  #/&# C  "#1!..1#%&!"&(-"+##8&$#(%#&("+# 1, ?&"(#''#'

#E!,&(#$(9#+!/

7!'!/'"+#$%6,#("'"#($#1#$&( #8&$#(%#95+&,7!($"+#"#'"&,(5 "+# &1'"$# #($!("7!/(-?&"+ +&'$%6,#("!15#8&$#(%#"#($#1#$7"+#/#!1(#$&8&/ 6$-# &1'"/5

6($"+!""+#?&"(#'' ;2 !(.1##"&(-+7?+%/!&,#$"+!8# !..#!1#$!'"+#'.#%&!/!""1(#5

7!%"6!//5$&$("

.1$6%#  !(5  '6%+  '.#%&!/  .?#1    !""1(#5  &(  +&'  !861  !($ "+#1#!

"#1!$,&""#$&(%1''2#E!,&(!"&(7"+!"+#?!'%6/"&8!"&(-"+# /!($ 1,"+#'!,#,"1#8#(!

"#1"+#'!/##

#%"#$&( !861

$# 7?++!$9##(-&8&(-"+#./!&("&

!($+&,"+# ?!"#1  !%&/&"5 1  !96"   5#!1'  .1&1  "  "+#  &/&(-    "+# '6&" +#1#!

"#17+#'"!"#$ "+!""+#$# #($!("'?#1# (".#1,&""&(-"+# ./!&("&

""!=#?!"#1 1,"+#,"17"+##/#%"1&%&"5%((#%"&(

?+&%++!$9##("1!('

#11#$&("+#(!,# $# #($!(" +#  ?&"(#''  ?+  !..#!1#$  1  "+#  ./!&("&

1,  "+#

!1$7&#!(''&'"!("4&(#',!(7!/'"#'"& &#$"+!"!// 1,!/&"&#'

+!$9##(%,./&#$?&"+9# 1#"1!('

#1 "+#%((#%"&( 1,(# %('6,#1""+#"+#1 F .( 61"+#1!..1#%&!"&( "+##8&$#(%#7"+#/#!1(#$

* &8&/ 6$-# 6($"+!""+# !"+#1

7@!1!,&(-+7+!$ (#8#1%+!//#(-#$"+#'!/#$##$'$61&(-+&'/& #"&,#!($"+!""+#5+!$ (?9##(%+!//#(-#$&(!'#.!1!"#'6&"7,1#"+!( 5#!1'!

"#1"+#&1 #E#%6"&(  !($  61"+#17  "+!"  (  &//#-!/&"5  &(  "+#  "1!(' #1    "+# %((#%"&(  %6/$  9#  .18#$  95  "+#  ./!&("&

7  ?+'#  !""1(#57 +!-+69&1  &(-+  1#?!/7 !%"6!//5 (#8#1 !..#!1#$ !($ &('"#!$ !(.1##"&(-+ ;2 !..#!1#$7?&"+6"!(5.?#1 !""1(#5&(+&'

!861",!59#("&%#$+#1#"+!""+#./!&("&

&''+?("9#!

.#1,!(#("1#'&$#(" (-/!($ +#'6&"?!'7%('#A6#("/57$&',&''#$ G (  "+#  &1'"  !..#!/  &/#$  95  "+#  ./!&("&

7  "+#  /#!1(#$ $$&"&(!/&'"1&%" 6$-#7"+#1"+!(("&%&(-"+#!98#7!/'+#/$"+!" &("+#'!/#$##$7E$!"#$ *

795?+&%+"+#/!($+!$9##( '/$"$# 7"+#,"1%((#%"&(7!/(-?&"+"+# 3@"+!C7"69#?#//91#!($"1##'#"%+!$!/'9##('/$7!// 1!'6,  ' 7

>27&( !861 $# #($!(" 95@!1!,&(-+7 !"+#1 

7?+(#8#1%+!//#(-#$'6%+'!/#$##$&(+&'/& #"&,# !($&( !%"7"+#'6&"?!'&('"&"6"#$(F F

G7&#,1#"+!(* 5#!1'!

"#1"+##E#%6"&( "+#'!/#$##$ "?!' 61"+#1("&%#$"+!""+#'6&"#!1/&#1 &/#$95#'+!, &(-+7%+!//#(-&(-"+#'!/# "+#/!($&"'#/ 7+!$!/''&(%#9##( $&',&''#$!($+#+!$5#"!-!&( &/#$!("+#1'6&" #(%#7+/$&(-"+!""+#"+#1#?!'98&6'/5&("#("&(

"+#8#($1 "+#/!($7&#@!1!,&(-+7 !"+#1

7"'#//

 "+##/#%"1&%&"5%((#%"&(!($"+#1!..61"#(!(%#'("+#/!($!/(- ?&"+"+#/!($7"+#"1!('

#1 "+##/#%"1&%&"5%((#%"&("$# #($!("

7,!$#95"+#/#%"1&%&"5 !1$7?!' 6($"9#.#1 #%"/5/#-!/ !($8!/&$!($%('#A6#("/57"+#!..#!/ &/#$95"+#./!&("&

?!'!/' $&',&''#$

# 1#  "+&'  61"7  /#!1(#$  %6('#/  1  "+#  !..#//!("

'69,&"'"+!"&("+#!9'#(%# !(51#%1$.1$6%#$95"+#1#'.($#("2 /#%"1&%&"5 !1$7'+?&(-"+!""1!('

#1 "+##/#%"1&%&"5%((#%"&( &(  A6#'"&(  +!$  9##(  #

#%"#$  95  .1.#1  .1%#$61#7  95  ?!5  

(#%#''!15!../&%!"&('7(9<#%"&(%#1"& &%!"##"%7"+##/#%"1&%&"5 %((#%"&(  %6/$  ("  +!8#  9##(  "1!(' #11#$  &(  "+#  (!,#  

1#'.($#("2$# #($!(" ('.#%& &%A6#15+#!$,&"'"+!""+##/#%"1&%&"5%((#%"&( ?!'("&("+#(!,# "+#!..#//!("2./!&("&

96"&("+#(!,# +&'

/!"# !"+#1+@!1!,&(-+7?++!$'/$"+#/!($6.(?+&%+"+# #/#%"1&%&"5%((#%"&(?!'&('"!//#$"1#'.($#("'!($ 795 8&1"6# "?'!/#$##$'7&((# ?+&%+"+#1#?!'!'.#%& &%1#%&"!/

'!/# "+##/#%"1&%&"5%((#%"&(!/'"1#'.($#(" +#%("#("&("+!""+##/#%"1&%&"5%((#%"&(%6/$(" +!8#9##("1!('

#11#$'&,./595?!5 '!/#95"+# !"+#1 "+# !..#//!("7&#"+#%('6,#1 "+##/#%"1&%&"5%((#%"&(7&'%11#%"7&( 8&#? "+# !%""+!"#8#("6!//5&"&'"+##/#%"1&%&"5%,.!(5>9!1$ ?+&%+&'",!=#'6%+"1!('

#1H+?#8#17"+#1#&'($#(&!/""+# !%"

"+!""+#"1!('

#1+!'!%"6!//59##(#

#%"#$95"+#1#'.($#("2 !1$

F 1#'.($#(" "1#'.($#(" 6'"9#%!6'#1#%1$''+?&(- "+#  1,!/&"&#'    !(  !../&%!"&(  +!8&(-  9##(  ,!$#  !($  "+#  ( 9<#%"&(  %#1"& &%!"#  +!8&(-  9##(  1#%#&8#$7  ?#1# ("  .1$6%#$  &( 61"7?6/$("(#-!"#"+#"1!('

#171,!=#&"8&$1/#-!//5 6('6'"!&(!9/#7  &(  8&#?    "+#  !%"  "+!"  &1'"/57  "+#  !"+#1    "+# !..#//!(" ?+  ?!' !$,&""#$/5 "+# %('6,#17  &( ?+'# (!,# "+# #/#%"1&%&"5%((#%"&('"$7+!$(#8#19<#%"#$"'6%+"1!(' #11!"

/#!'"  (  '6%+  9<#%"&(  ?!'  #8#1  .18#$  95  "+#  !..#//!("7  !($ '#%($/57(%#"+#&("#("&( "+#%('6,#1?!',!$#%/#!195"+# '!/#$##$"+!"+#?&'+#$""1!('

#1&"7!($&(.61'6!(%#""+!""+# "1!('

#1!%"6!//5?!'#

#%"#$&( !861 1#'.($#("7!-!&(7" 1#.#!"7?&"+ (9<#%"&(95"+#%('6,#1+&,'#/ $61&(-+&'/& # "&,#7$("'##?+!"#111"+#61"'9#/?+!8#%,,&""#$?+&/# .!''&(-"+#<6$-,#("'6($#1%+!//#(-#  (!(5%!'#7"+#1#!%"6!//59#&(-('69'"!("&!/A6#'"&(

/!?&(8/8#$&("+&' ($!..#!/7!($"+#<6$-,#("' "+#61"'9#/?

("9#&(-.#18#1'#&(!(5,!((#17 &($(,#1&"&("+#!..#!/7?+&%+ &'%('#A6#("/5$&',&''#$77?&"+(1$#1!'"%'"'  *

 ,/!""!(&(-+ !(&/

6$-#