High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/22411/2024dismissed

Vinod Kumar v. State Of Haryana Department Of Public Works Buildings And Roads

2026-03-13Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil10 pages

!"#$%"&"%'"(# ) )

!"#$*%(#( #+"(# , , ) ,

!"#$ *-(."(# ) , ) /"$/"%(*"%.$0'"(%1 --2 !"#$

-- "-.40#*%(#( #+"!"#$(11 --2 !"#$.#%".&(#&501.#4

6 789

: 9: 99 8 ****

!"

#

$

!%&#

!"

' !"

#

# !&#

$

( )*+

&!

%

!"

( ** :.#""*( 0-5

,*-

.#% "#' # /!0 "

112 #' 3

&

"

4 #& # *2 +5 1+1), 6 78-#6% #

( 8**# !/ # 96" !9& ,'! -/& &#"

# # #&# # 11 *+ 1+1: , 6 7)- 3

" &## ( * :" # #96" !9& ,'! -# &# " +* +;

1+11, 6 72- ,1-

<

" # / # #

= 9& ,'! - ! *2 +> 1+*+

- 2 - , 6 *- "#

& 8+? " #

/4 / !

9& ,'! -@ 9& ,'! - )? # 4

# / # # 11 *+ 1+1: , 6 )- 9& ,'! - #

"

( ** #

( 8 **

0 "# / # & # #

,:-

3"# #96" !9& &! / #

!" 9& ,$ - / " A 0 ,B & -

" 1+*+ " > # " ! /

" #/ 7"

# ! #"

# /& #& # !

"

0 # "

&

"

,)-

"# /

"# " +* +;

1+11 &

# #B"#

0 #&# # "1+*2 '

5 *# " #"# !# "

#

&/ "

/#

#& # !

"

0 "# # "

& ,8-

# +:

+> 1+18 # / /

# 9& 77'# / " A 0 ,B-

/#

( *:# !

# 7

- 3 -

!

!! # $$%& '!

'#

$ '!

( '

!

!! )!

*+ ,-

.

(

/0./0 /0.

.

.

/0 / 0

1

*+ 0(

* 0

0 2 .

.

. . " * 0 - .

.

*

0 3

/0/0 +

4

!

!!

*+ 5

3 6

,5

.

+

+

.

+ +

.

.

7

(

.

-.(.89 .

(

8 6

- 1

+- !5

" .

* ( "+ !4.

- 4 - !( "+ !% 4 . ( "+ 4 4. '( "+ ) %

, % :6

!4 3 !

!!

*+

/0

"

.

3

.

/0;

:

<

, : 6

!3!

!4

( "

/( 0 )

*+ , =

>

++

.

, &

? 5

/8

0 @

5

/8

0

'#

>

!% !

& $

! "4 4 A:

- 5 -

) ' @ @

. 51 5

/8

0

%

' " %

@-

@ .@

5

/8

0

51 5

/8

0

@

5

/8

0( : 6

) !!74$7!

+:6+=== ? !

!

( "

.-!

%. $6

1 @ @

*+ ,$ =

( "

/

2

8

51 7

51 . 0

. 8

1

.

:

.

1

"

$!

1

( "

.

B

7@

8 7(" 8 )

1

, !

51 5

/8

0( C

- 6 - ,2-

*8 +* 1+12 #

/ /

! &# %

!"

/#

( ** #"# 0 " / # '

5 * # " +* +;

1+11 "

/ "

# / 7"

# #"

/#

&/ # /#

&#

!"

# #

! # "

! "

/ '

5 *# " ,;-

3 !

# #

#

4 #

/4

#

0 !

" #

"

"

18 +:

1+11 / ( * : #

# / ! # # # /"#

0 #&# & #

0 !

" # # #&# #

/ /%"

0 " # # ,5-

" #

#% &

0

!*2 +* 1+12 ,>-

# & #

" " # # #

# / # 4 # /& #= 9& ,'! - # / !

9& ,'! -@ 9& ,'! - ! 12 +;

1+*5 &

0 !

"

! #

# "

/ " # ( * : # "

7

- 7 - *++7!

"7/ # /

" " # " +* +;

1+11 # #

96" ! 9& ,'! - # "# '"

7*7;1B "08*D;8 #"#

"" / 96" ! 9& ,'! - # # #

3 ""

# # 6 !

,;2B "0;2D*++- # "

# / E ! = &# #

# # ! / !

9& ,'! -/ && & # #

# # 96" !9& ,'! - ,*+-

.# F "

/

'

5 * # " +* +;

1+11, 6 2- #"#

# # #

&/ #

/ #& # !

"

0 # "

& " ## ##&#

" #&

9& ,'! -!7G7! ( 8** '

5 *# " 7 =

++ . (

. 7

( =

.(

C

- 8 - ,**-

'

H # "

18 +:

1+11 / #

"

/ # #& / !" #

7 /0

"

.

.

/0

<

C ,*1-

.# /! "

"

# # # /"#

0 &

0 !

" # I

J #

#&# I

<

J .# #"# "" 0# ""

/ # 4 # &

"4

" # &"

! #

"

,*:-

3#/ "0 # "

""

"#

( 8 ** #

% # # &

9& ,'! -" # !/ #96" !9& ,'! -# /"# .# ( 8**

# !/

& &

@# "

& !

"

# "

/ !" "

.# # # # 0 !

""

/

- 9 - !0& # " " # #

/ !

# 4 #

1+*5# !

" #

"

"0 # "

/ "

#

0

# 96" !9& ,'! -" "

##"

18 +:

1+11 ** +;

1+1:

.# "# #

" #&# # ( 8 ** # &

9& ,'! - / # #

" # "

"&# # #

"

# # & "

/ 7"

#&! &"

/%"# E

! /" " # &##

,*)-

.# "

" / # '

5 * # " +* +;

1+11

""! #

'

5 *& # "

#

## E "

#

&/ /"

#

"

!

" & #"# # /& "

/

I !

"J ! #&# &##

( **'

5 * # #

#

! @ " # / # "

/ "

# &# # "!

" !

# & # !

" "

0 ! # "

# #& " # # # F

"

! " "

96" !9& ,'! - # #

- 10 -

% & # & 7

0 3 # " "

"! # # # !

#

# !

/" /" # # #

# # /"

/

,*8-

# # & !

"

# # # # /I& J !

">#

!" 9& ,$ - / "A 0,B & -

" 1+*+ #"# "

/ 7"

/ 7"

## !

E"

!7G7!

/ !

"#"

# !# E

#E"

##

/ # "# #""

0 ,*2-

"" & #

/& !

,*;-

& "

,- , , ) #

:.#""*( 0-

"

1. Whether speaking/reasoned?

:

Yes/No

2. Whether reportable?

:

Yes/No