← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1269/2016allowed

Mukesh v. Board Of School Education Haryana Th Its Secretary And ORS

2019-03-11Mrs. Justice Rekha Mittal8 pages

 

              

                   



         



                    

   !"#$%&'

##('&&"      !""## $%"!&    "   ))))) #('&&"*$ '!## ( ! " ""# ! ) (   (  * (    )+ ! '* !)+ "+  ""##,"#((

 ! &   !( !     -% (! ( ( (  (*  )+ ! .   !# / * ( 0+  .!( ( !(!( 1+  2((+  !3   4**3! 2((+ 4**3! &+ )     !   .( (!     (#+ &  ( ( )+!"  &+)(*

!)%   5!   *" )+ ! ""## ( ! ! ( "& (    (## .   5!(#   1((  .!( (  ! ! ! ( (!+* !(# !"!! * ( &  !#(##.  5!(# 1(( .!( (0& 

()+!

!-((& ! (##("6! ! &((( ( # & !  #+ (

-% (! ( "#    .( (!  7!   ! "#((

(  

8 

9(&!( *# ( 5!& !&!(& : ( 1      ;  "   ( < " 0  *( ( )+   )+ (#( (& :( !!*(!) (!*#(&(   *# ( ( # (&"* " )#(! " !( . !# 1      .*(  &((( 1   !=&5!*(() >%(     + "( (     !#   ##,((*  5! ""##("" )+!    *  (#!*(!(!(!#+ )# 5!""### +( " & -%(! ! ! (  &(( &  <&(( &   !  *& *)&( !2((+5!

*(((&) ##!&(# & !"#(  ( (!"+  (&(# !*( 5! (# '* &  (* " *   ( " 9  %* &$    #"  (<" ?  9 :!<"(   !""##"" (! ( )< <&( : ( !&! !( (!&)   ((    *&/<?

(  ("@ !%* & (#'* 5!(# '*  (*  ; (!

,""##     A*   ! *(  (&(   6!(#

 ( ((* !'*!!# !(!  *&#( *"

3( +#(

(  .(

;

(!)* &!  *&#( *")+!"#((

((" ! !  *&  #   ! "#((

  5! &+ ) ! "&#+*3! .((!

(  )* +  ) &(&% !! &!'*  8+0  # ""#(""#( )#(!!  !## *!( (+   *&! *  ! & 

!(-%(!)*.((!5!(#'*#!# !!

! *  ( (#!*( !*(((&) ! "#((

 ! &  ! '*   + )#    (&(##+ (*9 @ (! ""# &(()(#(+ !*(

 (!"#((

(( ((*  ! ) (   !()   ""# "   )+ ! ""##,"#((

 (&(  )+ ! 1((  B*   .!( (  ! (! (!&( ""##'*!!"#((

"  ! &( *#( <&(( ( ! +

; )* ! "*((!+ ;:( 

!!!  3 # )* &(( !=&(! * (# ( (  ! (()#()#!" *# 3"&*&

 * !  # "(   *#   &3 

   ( ( (    &(3:  !

!

  )*  & !( !+! *# (  & !"#((

C ! !(# &((!(! !#  &"#( ! &( *#( <&((  ! !#  ! (##  *"  &(( & <&(( & !(#! (!(! #: ( (&"))# ! ! *#  (  &  ! !(# ""((<&(( . .7*!!# !"*#

!  *&  "(  #(&"((/< %* &/< &*( /<;

 (   /<9  &*( /<@   #   /< #!*3!!)  .((!)* (!"(( !'* !  *&*

( (!# !

! .((!  -%(!) *( (" !!  *&#!"#((

5!'*

(&

!(#'*!!&+)&!(#)+!& *3! *!   .( (!  5! &   ! (   

&(*)* (* ## ! #(&5!*(( !# ))  * #+ # ! '*#  ! ""##,"#((

*#  * ! ! " ,   (    ! *( "( *##+ !  *# +! !=&

(.((! -% (!     ( !  * (# ( (  ( & &( *#((* )+!.  !#/ * (0+ .!( (  ! & (*   )  * ! ( !    . (*  )+ !(!( 1+  2((+  !3   ( (      .*(  &(((  &   9 (*  )+ 4**3! 2((+4**3! 1     ( & )* !  ) & ! "  (  !   ! (  !##  *!( (+      (&(  *3! *#+ ) )+!&!: ( $&)  !(##5!""### " *     (  *&"!(##!  *& !(  ) .((!  -%(!:( *"(( ! )! ! '* ! !#  ! !  *& &3  

@ <!()( !(*3!!)  ) .((! &+ #  & !" *3! *!   .( (!  5!(

( '*(!*# (&(( "*&"(  % *

(!* ! )( + &(#  *)( ! (  : ! * (# ( ( *! )   #+ ( "   != & !""## !&!=&!)  #+  : (  : ( ""  ( ! ( )<  "  ! !

)* # 3 (!.((!5!& : (  ( &+ (  "((  ( ! ) (    " ! *3!  ) *   &(&+, %*# #(   : (  .((!:!(( !& (  #+)!# ! ! '*  *)   ! ""## ! ! ( *!   .( (!+!  *&" *    #! !( !   *

( & "(+  !*   ) ##   *( 5! '*!>*( !""##  !"&(  ""#   *( )( )  )+ #(&((     (  '* (!    ""# != &      -% (! ( !  !#     ! )(   ( &( "*"   ) ()+!

!5! ) (#!!  !(# 9> @+# !!  &( (! !# !"(&+ * ( (!)+!( & & )+!

! (!  ! !=&(  #+ ( )( !!(  

 (  #+     ! )(   "( &  )+ !

,""##  5!*!

 ! ""## ! 3  "# ! ! 

!! !=&(  #+  (! !# 

"()(#(+ )*# *!! &&(3!"  !#*!(( !(#  (! !=&!(& (((#  &((  ( @   ! : ( /(      ?8  ( ""##< ! & !*> D6!  " !  )+ !(  #(     &(( ((##+ * "&( !")#( !()*  *"* !)#(

(!!!( "( !## ) ##

 ( + *(  "  ( )  !(&#    * ! "  !( "(  

+!*! !!(D 5! (  (       ! 

!  ""## &  + * !  #( ((##+  "&(  ! ")#(!&+)*  *"* !)#( :!((  !& !"((  (@ !: (/(    ?8   +!!""##("" )+!   * (!"#!! !=&!) #+  (! * (# ( ( 5!('*()#((* !  !    (( &%(+  ! ""## &* ! *)&(  &(( &   <&(( &   ( ! != &  -% (! ( "#    .( (!  5! ""## *#   

   !! !=&.((!*(#!! (   (! )+ "" !( ! .   !# / * ( 0+ ! (* &( *#( (  + ( ( !*!"  ! '* (    (!# 

5!A*(! ##  ( (( !!! #(&   ! ""##  ) %    ! "&( ! ! (   "" ! ! *!((  ! '*  3(  +  ( (&& (#+((! &%(+((!+

!

)9  ??5!"#((

("? !"#( !## !!! 3 #  

  !( +  &3  !& !!( ""#+ & !( 

#( :( !! " "" (  !"#((

! !! (  !&!((##(# + *3! ""  ( ! ( )<     ( (   ! *#+   

( (   ! (&+  )(

& ! &   : (  ! &!   !(  (! &) :

*3! ( " (! 

  +  & !(! * (# ( (   &3 #+

! ! &"#  !  * ( )+ ( .   ""#(  &   ! (   ( ( (

( *#  *"!# (  '*!*( )+!""##((!) )+#(&((  * #+ # !5!(!(  *( !

  ! *  (#*   *3!  "" ! ! '*   +  ((&& (#+!(( &%(+(!+

!( "+(! *  !& *# )"%* (  (  "#

( " 5!("  *# "   ! (# "(*+*#,(* ((* )+!0+ !# / * ( .   !(!( 1+  2((+  !3 ! #+

 !+* !A*& "

  )   (!(" () "( :!(( !&

?

! '* >*(( ! "#((

 (!  ! *  ""#  A*(   #(&((  *    (     A* 

!'*(*@)(* "  ) ##   *(     (#+  (     *# ##+ (*@ ( *

,""## (!" ,   :( !!) ( * !()  !""#( ## 5!*( )+!""##,"#((

(   !

  ! != &   ! "#((

     -% (! ( ! &( *#( (  + ( ( (* )+   . !# "::::(* )+     .*( &((( !&9(* )+  ; (      &  !   ! "#((

 ( .( (! 

 ( (#      !   &  ! ( ! ) ( ( " ,   (  &3 +  ( A* !C &   "#((

  .( (! ( !  &(  ( (  ( # (*&  ( (  !"#((

*)% !"#((

 &"#( + &#((

"( A*((  ( + (!!   *!((            E1-*#(C        6!!"3(,  +, 6!!")#  +,